The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
Now we have an allegation of a link to neo-nazis. Can an allegation of being a Nazi be far behind?

"...one of them is a puppet, a pilots doctor whose job is to write certificates, utterly incompetent of DNA, who managed to take a post as a legal doctor thanks to the Roman sleazy environment. "

Sigh.
I'd say Conti's qualifications make him far more than a "pilots' doctor whose job it is to write certificates"! But why let facts get in the way of a good slur?

https://gomppublic.uniroma1.it/Docenti/Render.aspx?UID=a48e3958-bb61-4e3a-8769-296a177f7c25
 
So the court said that Knox was present at another time and place from the murder.

If this is a mistranslation then that is a case for you to make.

He cannot.

The Italian is as follows:

Nondimeno, anche a ritenere certa l'attribuzione, l'elemento processuale sarebbe
non univoco, siccome dimostrativo anche di un contatto postumo con quel sangue, nel probabile tentativo di rimuovere le più vistose tracce di quanto accaduto, forse per
aiutare qualcuno o per allontanare da sé i sospetti, senza che ciò possa contribuire a dare certezza del suo diretto coinvolgimento nell'azione omicidiaria. Ogni ulteriore e più pregnante valenza sarebbe, infatti, comunque resistita dalla circostanza - questa sì decisiva - che nessuna traccia a lei riferibile e stata rinvenuta nel luogo del delitto o sul corpo della vittima, di talché - a tutto concedere - il contatto con il sangue della stessa sarebbe awenuto in un momento successivo ed in altro locale della casa.​
A machine language translation of the highlighted part is:

this was the decisive thing - that no trace to her could be found in the crime scene or on the body of the victim, so that - [if all the above is accepted] to all allow - contact with the blood of her would be at a later moment and in another place in the house.​
No one have ever argued that those last two highlighted parts were not true.
 
I understand that Hellmann's third cousin, six times removed on his mother's side was connected to the Illuminati. I don't need no more stinkin' proof than that!

(This just keeps getting better and better)
 
Any serious expert - (by the term serious I also mean serious about the case) - would either be silent, or only talk in the courtroom in a cross questioning and in his report deposited with the court.

Those who talk in tv shows are by definition non-serious, and non-experts in the case.

Novelli, an international expert, did act seriously, and was convincing.

Nonsense. Serious experts shouldn't stay silent when they see a miscarriage of justice. If their expertise can correct a travesty they owe it to world to come forward.

I'm sure if you Machiavelli were in peril of being incarcerated for more than twenty years, you would be singing another tune. Or am I wrong? Would you prefer to spend your twenties, thirties and forties behind bars?
 
He cannot.

The Italian is as follows:

​
A machine language translation of the highlighted part is:

this was the decisive thing - that no trace to her could be found in the crime scene or on the body of the victim, so that - [if all the above is accepted] to all allow - contact with the blood of her would be at a later moment and in another place in the house.​
No one have ever argued that those last two highlighted parts were not true.

And yet Guede could not accomplish the same feat. Oh...right...Knox cleaned up all her invisible DNA and fingerprints but left Guede's to "cover for him". Odd way of covering for someone.
 
Mach you seem to have failed to respond to;

I am actually still waiting for Bill William's response.

B/M said:
Any further and more meaningful value would be, in fact, resisted by the fact - which is decisive - that no trace leading to her was found at the scene of the crime or on the victim’s body, so that - if all the above is accepted - her contact with the victim’s blood would have occurred after the crime and in another part of the house.

So the court said that Knox was present at another time and place from the murder.

If this is a mistranslation then that is a case for you to make.

Perhaps this is one of the three or four factual errors that Italian courts can make when justifying a verdict? Something that would not be acceptable anywhere else. Do you realise every time you say things like a few factual errors made by the court are OK you are just making the Italian judicial system look worse?


I point out as a general principle that I just do not accept any kind of judgement of the Italian Judicial System from foreigneers as an argument on a case. I consider this ans ain intrinsically arrogant and racist argument. If you want to judge a system, you need to know it and become knowladgeable of it first, and then criticize it in a way that it is specific of features not general, and certainly not as a point of discussion about the innocence or guilt of a suspect. A research about guilt or innocence takes place within a system. Foreigneers are not supposed to tell if a suspect is guilty based on how the system - of which they don't know much about - looks like to them from the outside.


*

Then to the merits.

No.
This translation, in the first place, would still not affect the fact that the court placed Knox on the scene of crime when the murder was committed, and doesn't contradict it.

Now, I'll take your post as a chance to respond, since Bill Williams doesn't want to discuss the point.

1. First, the translation error: "if all the above is accepted", this is a wrong translation. The original Italian expression is "a tutto concedere" is a colloquialism completely generic, without any reference. Whereas the presented translation is a reference, has a relation indicating something specific that was just said, "the above". In the Italian statement there is no "the above", no relation and no reference to the statement previously stated.
This is a minor point. But the English translation changes slighlty the meaning it in a way that makes the immediately previous paragraph seem depending a posteriori on some condition. In the Italian text, there isn't a relation. The truth of paragraph "above" does not depend on the one below.

2. The complete B/M paragraph here does not say only "after the crime and in another part of the house"; yes, it says that the contact with blood might have happened after the murder, but the complete statement is "subsequent contact in a probable attempt to remove the evidence of what had happened, possibly to cover up for someone or to steer away suspicion from herself". So B/M does not limit itself to saying "the contact might have occured after", it specifies the reason why this contact might have occured after. And does not present reasons of an innocent type. Note that it says that it might have occurred after the killing, but specifies "siccome anche": implies that it might as well mean during the crime - there is just reasonable doubt about that.
But "after" means, to B/M, to tamper with the evidence, with the cadaver, to stage, to cover up.

About another "part of the house", well, that's hardly "another place"; obviously "another part of the house" would include the small bathroom, and certainly the whole apartment is not "another place". It quite depends what you would mean by saying "scene of crime", and to me it is obvious that the whole apartment would be the scene of crime, it is also obvious that the murderers were in different areas of the apartment. Here anyway, we have to note that there is quite an objective contradiction in Bruno/Marasca: the text assumes as a sure fact that Knox washed herself from Meredith's blood, but at the same time suggests that she might have picked it up in "another area" of the house. This is obviously contradictory since Meredith's blood was around her body in her room, someone has to pick it up from there in some way, before washing their hands from it. B/M say there is an "eloquent proof" that Knox touched Meredith's blood and washed, also citing the fact the blood was "diluted" (or "washed away"). So, one can't deny that there is quite a contorsion of B/M in an attempt to explain that the finding is not "decisive", to the extent that it becomes contradictory.

3. All this does not effect what Bruno/Marasca stated elsewhere, that is that Meredith was killed by multiple people, and that it is a proven fact that Knox was on the scene of crime at the time of the murder. Yes possibly B/M is implying a concept of "scene of crime" that includes the whole house. But there is no doubt about the time of the murder, when Meredith was killed. B/M is so clear on this, to the extent that it even points out that Knox had a true knowledge of events like her actually hearing the scream and knowing in advance that a sexual assault had been committed.
B/M states there is no doubt about the presence of Amanda Knox in the house at the time when the murder was committed.
On the other hand, only suggests the the contact with Meredith's body might have been only after hear death, in order to clean up. One thing is Knox's presence, proven at the time of the murder, while a differet thing is her contact with Meredith's blood which might have been subsequent to the murder, and therefore concludes she might have not participated actively to the killing action.
Therefore suggests that there is an option of "non punishable complicity", rather than guilt.
 
Last edited:
Make an effort and try to see things as they are. The aggressors did not operate with considerable force. You cannot describe events with such a narrative. Instead, the aggression was protracted, and there was a gradual escalation. There are other wounds, and they are not blown with considerable force, they are superficial, and they are on a different side. And there are also many other wounds of different types and there are also ripped clothes. And the person was also immobilized in the meanwhile. You need a dynamic that describes the whole course of events.
If you describe it as a man grabbing a girl and cutting her throat with force you are mystifying, that was not the story. Something else went on.

By the way, tell me what are those points sheet imprint that allegedly don't match the knife.

His foot is not compatible with that imprint. Which instead matches Sollecito.
Come on step out of your prejudice and take a ruler. Take a few measurements. Not from Vinci if possible, I mean true measurements.

I really think you should take your own advice. We're not the ones tilting at windmills. The imprints are not as you claim. It is pure desperation and myopia to believe that one could match the bathmat print to an individual. The knife is worse. It was the most unlikely of weapons and it certainly didn't match the bedsheet.

But Machiavelli, you go on living in fantasy land if it floats your boat. Amanda and Raffaele were justifiably acquitted. All you can do is rant. In the meantime, Amanda is working with the Innocence Project here in the US and is paid to give speeches to American lawyers.
 
Last edited:
Therefore suggests that there is an option of "non punishable complicity", rather than guilt.


Aiding, abetting, assisting with, evidence tampering, concealing, and conspiring are all crimes. Knox wasn't convicted of any of these crimes. Which means they didn't have evidence Knox washed blood from her hands during a crime. They mentioned it in their silly report because they were constrained by the wacky Italian legal procedures attached to this case from previous inept courts. If they thought she washed blood from her hands, clearly they would have found her guilty of the various crimes such damning evidence implicates.

Your theory is they went out of their way to implicate their own incompetence and corruption by highlighting her "non punishable complicity" whatever that means. Rofl.
 
Last edited:
Nonsense. Serious experts shouldn't stay silent when they see a miscarriage of justice. If their expertise can correct a travesty they owe it to world to come forward.

Yours is nonsense. Serious experts would not declare "miscariage of justice" while being uninvolved and staying outside from a trial - and especially not reporting a series of false factoids such as Gill in his article - if serious experts decide they want to look into the facts of a trial and have important information, they get involved into the trial and they testify.
If you are serious you testify. If you want to claim that there are no negative controls, you actually check if that's true file and you get challeged in cross-questioning to maintain that yuor claim is a true fact.
If you claim "there are no negative controls" and you say that to the media, and you don't bring evidence while avoid to have your statement challenged in court, you are a clown.

I'm sure if you Machiavelli were in peril of being incarcerated for more than twenty years, you would be singing another tune. Or am I wrong? Would you prefer to spend your twenties, thirties and forties behind bars?

If I were incarcerated maybe I would be ready to lie and cheat in order to get out. I would maybe pay experts shills in order to influence the court.
And the point is, in fact, exaclty that a neutral observer is someone who has nothing at stake, he/she is neutral precisely because he/she is not connected to the position of a suspect, does not identify with his/her interests.
 
Yours is nonsense. Serious experts would not declare "miscariage of justice" while being uninvolved and staying outside from a trial - and especially not reporting a series of false factoids such as Gill in his article - if serious experts decide they want to look into the facts of a trial and have important information, they get involved into the trial and they testify.
If you are serious you testify.

This is nonsense. Nobody can just decide to testify, they have to be called.
 
And the point is, in fact, exaclty that a neutral observer is someone who has nothing at stake, he/she is neutral precisely because he/she is not connected to the position of a suspect, does not identify with his/her interests.

Please read this again.

This assumes that 100% of the time that "a suspect" is guilty. If only 0.005% of suspects were, in fact innocent, then you would forbid neutral observers from expressing a neutral point of view that the suspect is innocent.

I've never understood why in this case the ones who clam neutrality for themselves are the ones who peddle guilt. It's the race to define terms like "neutrality" itself, in such a way as to predetermine the outcome.

Neutral people are those who eventually deem the suspect guilty. If a neutral observer actually moves towards identifying with an innocent suspect, but suspect nonetheless, that neutral observer loses the right to even comment.

This is biasing the outcome simply by controling the definition of terms.

However, let's keep this honest. Here it is, once again, a neutral forensic-DNA expert's assessment of the DNA evidence used against Sollecito and Knox in this case:

http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1872497316300333

"Neutral" means something other than that they've decided on the quality of the evidence.
 
Aiding, abetting, assisting with, evidence tampering, concealing, and conspiring are all crimes. Knox wasn't convicted of any of these crimes. Which means they didn't have evidence Knox washed blood from her hands during a crime. They mentioned it in their silly report because they were constrained by the wacky Italian legal procedures attached to this case from previous inept courts. If they thought she washed blood from her hands, clearly they would have found her guilty of the various crimes such damning evidence implicates.
(...)

Now, you are replacing again facts, with your own deductions. You think that they were constrained by "the wacky legal Italian legal procedures", but this is precisely one of your rationalizations, guesses, based on your generic prejudicial worldview. In reality, you know basically nothing about those legal procedures that you call "wacky". The idea that B/M would be constrained by some wacky procedure is a rationalization grown from your ingorance and your general scathing of something you are not interested in, you don't understand and so maybe you unconsciously see as shapeless, you can project anything on it.
In reality, B/M were not constrained to draw such conclusion by any procedure nor legal principle at all. This scenario all belongs entirely to your own invention, it's against the law and the procedure.
The contrary is true, B/M were not constrained. They should have respected the procedure code, but on completely different points: that is, they should not have contradicted Chieffi's points of law.
And, there were no findings at all which they would have been bound to adhere to. Not legally, but not even logically. They could have contradicted previous findings of Guede's trial, if they thought that was the conclusion.

The fact is, and it is explicit in what they wrote, that instead what they did was to add their unnecessary, further opinion expressing agreement with some findings of the lower courts.
They wrote, in their opinion about Nencini's conclusion, that they have found some further valid evidence that Meredith was killed by mutiple persons, that in the Sollecito-Knox independent finding emerged of this, and also B/M unnecessarily emphasize their agreement with Nencini on the finding that Knox heared Meredith's scream, and explain again why they are sure she committed a calunnia even if nobody asked them to express themselves on a point already decided. If B/M wrote these things, the only reasonable explanation is that they believe them.
 
Last edited:
I really think you should take your own advice. We're not the ones tilting at windmills. The imprints are not as you claim. It is pure desperation and myopia to believe that one could match the bathmat print to an individual. The knife is worse. It was the most unlikely of weapons and it certainly didn't match the bedsheet.

But Machiavelli, you go on living in fantasy land if it floats your boat. Amanda and Raffaele were justifiably acquitted. All you can do is rant. In the meantime, Amanda is working with the Innocence Project here in the US and is paid to give speeches to American lawyers.

Yours is nonsense. Serious experts would not declare "miscariage of justice" while being uninvolved and staying outside from a trial - and especially not reporting a series of false factoids such as Gill in his article - if serious experts decide they want to look into the facts of a trial and have important information, they get involved into the trial and they testify.
If you are serious you testify. If you want to claim that there are no negative controls, you actually check if that's true file and you get challeged in cross-questioning to maintain that yuor claim is a true fact.
If you claim "there are no negative controls" and you say that to the media, and you don't bring evidence while avoid to have your statement challenged in court, you are a clown.
Apparently not Machiavelli. I challenge you to find any credentialed Forensics DNA experts that have said Dr. Gill is a clown. No, just uneducated fools on the Internet say that.
Let us know when you get a degree in Forensics.
 
This just keeps getting better and better. There is truth in the old saying that
"give them more rope and they'll hang themselves"! ROTFLMAO!
 
Now, you are replacing again facts, with your own decutions. You think that they were constrained by "the wacky legal Italian legal procedures", but this is precisely one of your rationalizations, guesses, based on your generic prejudicial worldview. In reality, you know basically nothing about those legal procedures that you call "wacky". The idea that B/M would be constrained by some wacky procedure is a rationalization grown from your ingorance and your general scathing of something you are not interested in, you don't understand and so maybe you unconsciously see as shapeless, you can project anything on it.
In reality, B/M were not constrained to draw such conclusion by any procedure nor legal principle at all. This scenario all belongs entirely to your own invention, it's against the law and the procedure.
The contrary is true, B/M were not constrained. They should have respected the procedure code, but on completely different points: that is, they should not have contradicted Chieffi's points of law.
And, there were no findings at all which they would have been bound to adhere to. Not legally, but not even logically. They could have contradicted previous findings of Guede's trial, if they thought that was the conclusion.

The fact is, and it is explicit in what they wrote, that instead what they did was to add their unnecessary, further opinion expressing agreement with some findings of the lower courts.
They wrote, in their opinion about Nencini's conclusion, that they have found some further valid evidence that Meredith was killed by mutiple persons, that in the Sollecito-Knox independent finding emerged of this, and also B/M unnecessarily emphasize their agreement with Nencini on the finding that Knox heared Meredith's scream, and explain again why they are sure she committed a calunnia even if nobody asked them to express themselves on a point already decided. If B/M wrote these things, the only reasonable explanation is that they believe them.

It doesn't matter how ignorant I am of the Italian judiciary (thankfully very). It's about the actual logical outcome.

In your view M&B had two options:

1. Amanda Knox did not necessarily wash blood from her hands just because her own DNA was found in her own sink, the defense cited forensic experts that demonstrated the strong possibility swabbing a sink region and collecting separately deposited DNA from normal sink use is very possible, especially since she used the sink every day and was the last person to use it that very morning.

2. Amanda Knox washed blood from her hands in connection with some aspect of the crime but we wont find her guilty of any crime because we're corrupt.

And you believe given this choice, they went with option 2.

I am simply pointing out that's really stupid and probably not what happened based on the simple logic that people in general, and I presume even some Italian judges, do not like to make complete fools of themselves and implicate themselves in corruption.

I then conceived of the only logically remaining plausible explanation for their finding, which is they were constrained in some way. Maybe procedurally, politically, or some combination of both.

Or maybe they are just really stupid? TBH I don't care that much.
 
This is nonsense. Nobody can just decide to testify, they have to be called.

Obviously you need an agreement with one party. If one wants to help the defence, offers his/her testimony to the defence.
It is also possible to seek contact with the prosecution office, actually.

Gill did this in the Yara Gambirasio murder case in Italy. His point was defeated, however.
 
Wow, I'm sure the eminent Doctor is devastated. ROFLMAO. Good one.
I'm sure if you Machiavelli were in peril of being incarcerated for more than twenty years, you would be singing another tune. Or am I wrong? Would you prefer to spend your twenties, thirties and forties behind bars?

If I were incarcerated maybe I would be ready to lie and cheat in order to get out. I would maybe pay experts shills in order to influence the court.
And the point is, in fact, exaclty that a neutral observer is someone who has nothing at stake, he/she is neutral precisely because he/she is not connected to the position of a suspect, does not identify with his/her interests.

So, that would be a no then.

We live in a free market world and Dr. Gill's opinion is valued because he has worked hard and became an expert in his field. But it wouldn't be valued if he was willing to destroy his own credibility by putting forth an obvious dishonest opinion simply for a check. Others in his field would loudly criticize his actions and his opinion. Especially when Dr. Gill submitted his work for peer review. Are we seeing an outcry from his colleagues? Where are the published criticisms of his work?

All I see is blue sky and all I hear are crickets. Except from the uneducated.
 
It doesn't matter how ignorant I am of the Italian judiciary (thankfully very). It's about the actual logical outcome.

In your view M&B had two options:

1. Amanda Knox did not necessarily wash blood from her hands just because her own DNA was found in her own sink, the defense cited forensic experts that demonstrated the strong possibility swabbing a sink region and collecting separately deposited DNA from normal sink use is very possible, especially since she used the sink every day and was the last person to use it that very morning.

2. Amanda Knox washed blood from her hands in connection with some aspect of the crime but we wont find her guilty of any crime because we're corrupt.

And you believe given this choice, they went with option 2.

I am simply pointing out that's really stupid and probably not what happened based on the simple logic that people in general, and I presume even some Italian judges, do not like to make complete fools of themselves and implicate themselves in corruption.

I then conceived of the only logically remaining plausible explanation for their finding, which is they were constrained in some way. Maybe procedurally, politically, or some combination of both.

Or maybe they are just really stupid? TBH I don't care that much.

It is correct to assume that they were constrained in some way.
The way is political.
But they were not constrained between the two options that you suggest. What they were constrained to do, is to acquit and end the case. They were forced to acquit them, even if they didn't want to.
It's not that Marasca is "corrupt" like in the sense that he is a guy who likes to be paid (that type of guy is Hellmann), but rather in the sense that he is a person who cannot refuse, when certain people ask him.
So Marasca appointed Bruno - who never worked as a judge, but worked at the Supreme Court archive section - to solve the problem. And they had to convince one of other three judges.
The report is simply the results that judges refused to write things like "they are innocent", they also possibly tried to write things that would have opened a possibility to review Guede's trial (which would have backfired and exposed them) as well as maybe try avoid to exposing themselves too much to an ECHR review. They only did what they were forced to do and nothing more.
 
Apparently not Machiavelli. I challenge you to find any credentialed Forensics DNA experts that have said Dr. Gill is a clown. (..)

It's a pity for Gill, because the things he writes are objectively false. And the negative controls are in fact in the trial.

It's a pity that a person with Gill's reputation claims things that were proven false.
 
acbytelsa said:
Apparently not Machiavelli. I challenge you to find any credentialed Forensics DNA experts that have said Dr. Gill is a clown. (..)
It's a pity for Gill, because the things he writes are objectively false. And the negative controls are in fact in the trial.

It's a pity that a person with Gill's reputation claims things that were proven false.

Answer the question. Name one forensic-DNA expert who's said that Dr. Peter Gill is a clown? Name one who said he'd lied. Name one who'd said he claims things which were proven false.

You are not a forensic-DNA expert, Machiavelli. You do not get to proclaim something in that arena to be "objectively false", that is if you wish to be taken seriously.

Machiavelli said:
So Marasca appointed Bruno - who never worked as a judge, but worked at the Supreme Court archive section - to solve the problem. And they had to convince one of other three judges.
The report is simply the results that judges refused to write things like "they are innocent"
Can you offer one scintilla of proof that the judges "refused" to do this? In law, even in Italy, acquitting someone of a crime simply keeps their "innocent until proven guilty" status unchanged.

It would be better if you'd not look deeply into the souls of the principles of this case and tell us what they either "refused" or "didn't refuse" to do.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom