The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
They resort to add hominems when the facts fail. Machiavelli desperate and degrading description of Hellman just because Hellman refused to do something he knew would be horribly wrong. In Machiavelli's mind Gill should have ignored the misuse of the science he pioneered just so Mignini could look good.

I see you beat me too it. Why is it so impossible for many PGP to believe that Hellmann really does believe that RS and AK are innocent just because they don't believe it? Instead of pointing out where they believe his mistakes lie and why, they launch into accusations of corruption and being paid off. As a PIP, I have never, ever accused Massei of being corrupt or paid off. Wrong, yes, but corrupt? No. I don't think Nencini was corrupt or paid off either. I do think he saw Chieffi as basically instructing him to convict but I also think he agreed with the guilty verdict.

They follow this same pattern with anyone who does not support guilt, whether a judge, forensic expert, or journalist. It's sad really.
 
...what?



How are you supposed to determine if someone's guilty if not through evidence? Guilty until proven innocent?

Evidence is for the defence and the prosecution to present and rebut.

Ascertaining the facts is the job of the court.

Without constructing the facts, it cannot come to a decision.

The facts show, as determined definitively by a court of law, is that Knox was definitely present at the cottage during the murder, and Raff almost certainly so (his alibi after all, is officially, fake - see latest motivations from the Supreme Court), she did wash Mez' blood from her hands and did indeed cover up for Rudy.

Whether you like it or not, those are proven facts.

The are judicial facts, because they are facts found by a court of law.

A scientific fact would be as agreed by consensus in the scientific community. Some things we can test for ourselves. Others, we have to take the 'establishment's word for.
 
I see you beat me too it. Why is it so impossible for many PGP to believe that Hellmann really does believe that RS and AK are innocent just because they don't believe it? Instead of pointing out where they believe his mistakes lie and why, they launch into accusations of corruption and being paid off. As a PIP, I have never, ever accused Massei of being corrupt or paid off. Wrong, yes, but corrupt? No. I don't think Nencini was corrupt or paid off either. I do think he saw Chieffi as basically instructing him to convict but I also think he agreed with the guilty verdict.

They follow this same pattern with anyone who does not support guilt, whether a judge, forensic expert, or journalist. It's sad really.

Now I understand how you view the process. You believe that a trial is all based on 'opnion'. Whether you like the look of the defendant or how they are dressed.

Never mind if there is solid proof they are culpable. If Judge Stacy has a gut feeling they are not guilty, who cares what was determined at trial!

Hey guys, here's a great money saving idea.

Why bother with a trial - Stacyhs, has a better idea: armchair trials.
 
The facts show, as determined definitively by a court of law, is that Knox was definitely present at the cottage during the murder, and Raff almost certainly so (his alibi after all, is officially, fake - see latest motivations from the Supreme Court), she did wash Mez' blood from her hands and did indeed cover up for Rudy.

Whether you like it or not, those are proven facts.

Or instead of repeating all this made up stuff, you can actually read what Cassazione wrote in 2015:

9.3 During the analysis of the aforementioned elements of evidence, it is certainly useful to remember that, taking for granted that the murder occurred in via della Pergola, the alleged presence at the house of the defendants cannot, in itself, be considered as proof of guilt.​
Any further and more meaningful value would be, in fact, resisted by the fact - which is decisive - that no trace leading to her was found at the scene of the crime or on the victim’s body, so that - if all the above is accepted - her contact with the victim’s blood would have occurred after the crime and in another part of the house.​
 
Evidence is for the defence and the prosecution to present and rebut.

Ascertaining the facts is the job of the court.

Without constructing the facts, it cannot come to a decision.

How can one establish facts without corroboration from witnesses and physical evidence? You said:

By your criteria criminals are supposed to walk free in crimes which are committed under the cloak of secrecy just because no independent person witnessed it, and even if they did, how can we know the witness is reliable.
 
Evidence is for the defence and the prosecution to present and rebut.

Ascertaining the facts is the job of the court.

Without constructing the facts, it cannot come to a decision.

The facts show, as determined definitively by a court of law, is that Knox was definitely present at the cottage during the murder, and Raff almost certainly so (his alibi after all, is officially, fake - see latest motivations from the Supreme Court), she did wash Mez' blood from her hands and did indeed cover up for Rudy.

Whether you like it or not, those are proven facts.

The are judicial facts, because they are facts found by a court of law.

A scientific fact would be as agreed by consensus in the scientific community. Some things we can test for ourselves. Others, we have to take the 'establishment's word for.

Right, and the scientific community says Luminol can only indicates the possibility of blood being present, with additional tests being required to prove it's blood, that it's human blood and to determine whose blood it is. On it's own it is proof of nothing. And the same scientific community also says a TMB negative test is all but definitive that blood is not present, and certainly if that sample also lacks DNA then it can be ruled out as blood. But apparently courts will sometimes disregard what the scientific community says because, after all, "what else could it be?" (this 'brilliant' reasoning was employed by both Massei and Nencini). Thus it becomes a judicial fact those TMB negative, DNA negative samples are made from Meredith's blood, which you would now call a 'proven fact'.

Except there are some of us who prefer to stick to the science, from which indisputable facts can be ascertained, and use that as evidence that trial courts erred in their reasoning, and use this as a prime example of why a judicial facts should never be confused for proven facts.

You claim Amanda being at the cottage at the time of the murder, washing Meredith's blood from her hands and covering for Guede are "proven facts". Yet when we ask you to cite what evidence led to the establishment of these proven facts you, like Machiavelli, disappear. I've offered to help you on several occasions but I assume you don't like the results. Nonetheless, I'll help you one more time;

1. Amanda is placed at the cottage based on her coerced statement which was ruled inadmissible in the criminal trial - go figure.
2. Amanda was deemed to wash Meredith's blood from her hand because her DNA was detected on her sink - go figure.
3. Amanda was deemed to cover for Guede because she names Lumumba, not Guede. Of course, it's also proof the police believed Lumumba was there because of their improper interpretation of the SMS messages and Amanda didn't name Guede because she had no idea he committed the murder - go figure.

So, you got better evidence than this? ....cause at this pace your claimed "proven facts" are factually no better than the Luminol samples being Meredith's blood. And at the end of the day this is precisely why M/B acquitted Amanda and Raffaele - because there was no evidence of their involvement in the crime.
 
It's a pity for Gill, because the things he writes are objectively false. And the negative controls are in fact in the trial.

It's a pity that a person with Gill's reputation claims things that were proven false.

Mach, you have accused Gill of claiming "thingS" that are objectively false yet have mentioned only one; the availability of the negative controls. How is this one error on Gill's part evidence that his conclusions regarding Stefanoni's analyses are, in fact, unreliable?
What are the other "false" things he writes?

Considering the notoriety of and widespread interest in this case in Italy where honor is paramount, it is surprising that no Italian (or any other) forensic expert has criticized Gill's conclusions. Why is that?
 
Now I understand how you view the process. You believe that a trial is all based on 'opnion'. Whether you like the look of the defendant or how they are dressed.

Never mind if there is solid proof they are culpable. If Judge Stacy has a gut feeling they are not guilty, who cares what was determined at trial!

Hey guys, here's a great money saving idea.

Why bother with a trial - Stacyhs, has a better idea: armchair trials.

Wow. Just wow. I'm trying to figure out how in the world you came up with that ridiculous conclusion. I'm just sitting here shaking my head.
But thank you for providing yet another example that "they follow this same pattern with anyone who does not support guilt".
 
Last edited:
Considering the notoriety of and widespread interest in this case in Italy where honor is paramount, it is surprising that no Italian (or any other) forensic expert has criticized Gill's conclusions. Why is that?

Conversely, why is it that DNA and forensic-DNA experts spontaneously criticized Stefanoni's work and none supported it. Couldn't even pay-off anyone to do this!

Both in and out of Italy.
 
I see you beat me too it. Why is it so impossible for many PGP to believe that Hellmann really does believe that RS and AK are innocent just because they don't believe it? Instead of pointing out where they believe his mistakes lie and why, they launch into accusations of corruption and being paid off. As a PIP, I have never, ever accused Massei of being corrupt or paid off. Wrong, yes, but corrupt? No. I don't think Nencini was corrupt or paid off either. I do think he saw Chieffi as basically instructing him to convict but I also think he agreed with the guilty verdict.

They follow this same pattern with anyone who does not support guilt, whether a judge, forensic expert, or journalist. It's sad really.

Nencini was being a good soldier, he wasn't being paid. But that doesn't mean his actions weren't a type of corruption. You're right on about the PGP and their attitude about Hellman. In their minds Amanda is guilty therefore corruption is the only answer. Conti, Vecchiotti, Hellman, Gill etc all most of been paid. It's the only answer.
 
Nencini was being a good soldier, he wasn't being paid. But that doesn't mean his actions weren't a type of corruption. You're right on about the PGP and their attitude about Hellman. In their minds Amanda is guilty therefore corruption is the only answer. Conti, Vecchiotti, Hellman, Gill etc all most of been paid. It's the only answer.

I don't agree that Nencini's verdict was a "type of corruption" unless you think he would have found RS and AK innocent except for Chieffi. I give him the benefit of the doubt on that.

Now, is it possible for you to explain to me just how my post regarding the PGP allegations against Hellmann had anything whatsoever to do with what Vixen wrote in response? Did I miss something? Is it just me? Or is it as off the wall as I think it is?
 
Right, and the scientific community says Luminol can only indicates the possibility of blood being present, with additional tests being required to prove it's blood, that it's human blood and to determine whose blood it is. On it's own it is proof of nothing. And the same scientific community also says a TMB negative test is all but definitive that blood is not present, and certainly if that sample also lacks DNA then it can be ruled out as blood. But apparently courts will sometimes disregard what the scientific community says because, after all, "what else could it be?" (this 'brilliant' reasoning was employed by both Massei and Nencini). Thus it becomes a judicial fact those TMB negative, DNA negative samples are made from Meredith's blood, which you would now call a 'proven fact'.

Except there are some of us who prefer to stick to the science, from which indisputable facts can be ascertained, and use that as evidence that trial courts erred in their reasoning, and use this as a prime example of why a judicial facts should never be confused for proven facts.

You claim Amanda being at the cottage at the time of the murder, washing Meredith's blood from her hands and covering for Guede are "proven facts". Yet when we ask you to cite what evidence led to the establishment of these proven facts you, like Machiavelli, disappear. I've offered to help you on several occasions but I assume you don't like the results. Nonetheless, I'll help you one more time;

1. Amanda is placed at the cottage based on her coerced statement which was ruled inadmissible in the criminal trial - go figure.
2. Amanda was deemed to wash Meredith's blood from her hand because her DNA was detected on her sink - go figure.
3. Amanda was deemed to cover for Guede because she names Lumumba, not Guede. Of course, it's also proof the police believed Lumumba was there because of their improper interpretation of the SMS messages and Amanda didn't name Guede because she had no idea he committed the murder - go figure.

So, you got better evidence than this? ....cause at this pace your claimed "proven facts" are factually no better than the Luminol samples being Meredith's blood. And at the end of the day this is precisely why M/B acquitted Amanda and Raffaele - because there was no evidence of their involvement in the crime.


Are you genuinely ignorant of the court proceedings or are you being wilfully obtuse?

Imagine you are a footballer. Your team strategy is 3-4-3 formation and the idea is for Messi to pass the ball to you on the wings from midfield and as he's running forward, you have to pass it back to him for a header, as practised all week by the team.

So Messi scores a fab goal. Would you really claim that this was a fluke incident that happened by sheer chance. You examine what each individual player was doing and have to rule each out one by one as there is nothing significant about their position of itself?

Or do you understand that hey, that goal was the result of strategy. You need to analyse the team as a whole to understand how Messi keeps scoring.

Likewise with the Knox/Raf court case. It is no good looking at each action isolation.

If you look at the bigger picture, the entire jigsaw, you can see the overall strategy of the crime.

In other words, don't just look at one tree at a time, stand back and look at the whole thing, and then you might notice the woods.
 
How can one establish facts without corroboration from witnesses and physical evidence? You said:

It's not perfect, but a good blueprint is our justice system. You only get arraigned for trial if the CPS/Attorney General/State Prosecutor weighs up there is a reasonable prospect of success (of conviction) or 'probable cause'.

Say the CPS thinks there are grounds for prosecution. So, you get a lawyer, they get a lawyer. You both bring your case to the court.

You have an alibi - good, case dismissed.

If you are prepared, and there is no conspiracy by the police or the courts to frame you, then it is unlikely you have anything to worry about.

The more serious the crime, the higher the bar to prove it. Even though Knox and Sollecito are deemed to have been present when Mez was murdered, they have 'got away with it' because this particular court claims 'more proof is needed than just being there, lying on numerous occasions to the police, washing the victim's blood from your hands and covering up for the other perp (even if you failed to report him or call an ambulance).

It's a perps' world, eh :rolleyes:

Nothing to worry about at all.
 
It's not perfect, but a good blueprint is our justice system. You only get arraigned for trial if the CPS/Attorney General/State Prosecutor weighs up their is as reasonable prospect of success (of conviction) or 'probable cause'.

Say the CPS thinks there is grounds for prosecution. So, you get a lwayer, they get a lawyer. You both bring your case to the court.

You have an alibi - good, case dismissed.

If you are prepared, and there is no conspiracy by the police or the courts to frame you, then it is unlikely you have anything to worry about.

The more serious the crime, the higher the bar to prove it. Even though Knox and Sollecito are deemed to have been present when Mez was murdered, they have 'got away with it' because this particular court claims 'more proof is needed than just being there, lying on numerous occasions to the police, washing the victim's blood from your hands and covering up for the other perp (even if you failed to report him or call an ambulance).

It's a perps' world, eh :rolleyes:

Nothing to worry about at all.

So what was the issue, then? If you can't find a credible witness or solid evidence, the defense wins.
 
From my point of view, the case doesn't start there. That one is a big hook- But not the first and most impressive one.
To me, the first and biggest hook was Amanda Knox's version of facts (shower, mop, closed door, etc.), also coupled with Sollecito's non credible account.

It's superficially suspicious to me. If we hear the words mop and crime scene together that's suspicious by itself. But there's the actual narrative we would have to construct to fit it into, and then the counter narrative that presents itself. Knox is walking around town in broad daylight awkwardly carrying a mop for the purposes of cleaning a crime scene? Pretty far fetched to me. The water pipe was proven to have issues (so need to invent Raffaele breaking it on purpose) verified by dad and maid (invent conspiracy) etc.

The counter narrative is that if you're going to stage a spectacularly theatrical break-in with a busted open window with a giant rock, and a naked rape victim sprawled on the floor with blood flooding the entire room - your story wouldn't be you casually took a shower and didn't notice a single thing. It's so idiotic it turns around into master subterfuge which I don't think these airheads had in them.

When one tries to explain out the actual behaviour of Knox based on police brutality, the explanation becomes inconsistent. (and we are just talking about the false accusation - let alone the rest of her lies).
Knox laid down a false testimony against Lmumba a secont time, and this time in a way far more articulate, without being interrogated, abut just through spontaneous declarations before a magistrate.
And then presented a false testimony accusing Lumumba a third time in a hand written note, in which she lied down false evidence again but also lied down a protective life jacket in order to make such evidence ineffective and unreliable.
And then she refused to respond when she had the opportunity to clarify her testimony before a judge.
And then she lied again, she sank again into a further maelstrom of inconsistencies, and refused to respond again in the end when asked about Lumumba, as she was interrogated by the magistrate on Dec. 17.
And then she presented an inconsistent spontaneous declaration in 2008 where she failed to provide any factual detail about her interrogation and false accusation.
And then her defence failed to present any complaint about any alleged physical abuse nor unlawful interrogation.
And then the defence presented a theory of Knox suffering of a false memory syndrome.
And then after claiming a false memory syndrome, Knox claimed to remember an alibi.
And then...
it's all lies.

First off we can't talk about what happened in the interrogation in too much detail, because despite the 10,000 wiretaps, environment taps, and transcribers and translators working round the clock following the murder, with something like 1 out of every 3 sentences Knox uttered after the murder picked up by police - all recording equipment in the interrogation room was curiously switched off. Yet In most famous cases the police are happy to publicize video of the suspects lying their asses off (just google Jodi Arias/Casey Anthony interrogation etc).

One of the notes you're referring to was written by Knox to the police shortly after the first interrogation while still in custody before she spoke to anybody. It documents their abuses quite well and explains the pressures that lead to the incriminating statements. Again we have to believe this note is some sort of master subterfuge on the part of this arrested sleep starved foreign girl because she is accusing the police that just interrogated her of behavior they would just remember doing not hours ago and surely would have video and tape on, and yet she has no fear whatsoever of putting this into writing. Either she sees into the future that they incompetently forgot to record or notate anything and she could create the only contemporary documentation of events on record, or...she's just rambling the truth in a straight forward way.

Her interview with Mignini on the 17th is when she says quite clearly she wasn't lying during the interrogation because she thought it was the truth. It is consistent with the police telling her she had trauma induced amnesia and vague images she had following proof of her presence at the crime scene and meeting with Patrick were actually real memories.

I never understood why the PGP constantly purport this very easily disproven narrative that she never clarified the statements she made in interrogation when she did so repeatedly and immediately. As far as I can tell you just wanted her to say "I lied and made it up and Patrick is actually innocent." You want this statement for two reasons, the first obviously because it shows she lied, and secondly and more importantly, because by declaring Patrick innocent, something she could only know if she witnessed the murder, she further implicates herself. Geez as long as we're wishing for things from Italy I'll take a 288 gto or Fazioli :D

IMO if you have a sociopathic killer there is usually at least one thing they said that we can point to and say, there's no getting around this, and no excuse, it is a straight up honest to god outright lie. It's curious that with one approaching the most media covered woman in criminal history we can't do that.
 
So what was the issue, then? If you can't find a credible witness or solid evidence, the defense wins.

The issue here with this case is that it was played outside of court. All kinds of people put in their oar to interfere, falsely claiming Italy was backward and it needed some kind of colonial assistance. Enter the paid sharks, the politicians and the publishers greedy for big money bucks and film rights on pushing a 'we wuz framed' line.

Marasca Supreme Court made it clear that even though they annulled the conviction the pair were not deemed 'innocent' or 'exonerated'. Raff does not qualify for any compensation and police are not looking for anybody else.

The vampire bloodsucking corporations get to hang on to their blood money.
 
Now I understand how you view the process. You believe that a trial is all based on 'opnion'. Whether you like the look of the defendant or how they are dressed.

Never mind if there is solid proof they are culpable. If Judge Stacy has a gut feeling they are not guilty, who cares what was determined at trial!

Hey guys, here's a great money saving idea.

Why bother with a trial - Stacyhs, has a better idea: armchair trials.

This isn't how I viewed what Stacyhs wrote at all. I think a judge can have an opinion either way during a trial and yet be able to separate that from the facts presented in that trial (if his opinion is different than what those facts show).

Several of the judges did insert an opinion either written in the motivations, or during interviews after the verdicts. And some of those opinions were different than the verdict which was given.

It isn't fair to allege corruption of a judge unless you offer proof of such. And so far I haven't seen it with any of the judges throughout the many years this case has been tried.
 
This isn't how I viewed what Stacyhs wrote at all. I think a judge can have an opinion either way during a trial and yet be able to separate that from the facts presented in that trial (if his opinion is different than what those facts show).

Several of the judges did insert an opinion either written in the motivations, or during interviews after the verdicts. And some of those opinions were different than the verdict which was given.

It isn't fair to allege corruption of a judge unless you offer proof of such. And so far I haven't seen it with any of the judges throughout the many years this case has been tried.

We can see Hellmann is 'bent', as he didn't follow legal protocol.

And indeed his entire motivations were struck out and he was 'let go'.

Imagine a referee who allows an offside goal or ignores a penalty. 99.99% of time it is human error and means nothing. The referee's word is final, even if wrong.

Now imagine a bent referee who deliberately swings it for one team, for whatever reason. Perhaps even a noble reason. He may privately believe one team deserves to win.

Now, that referee is bent, because it is not in his remit to 'swing it for the team he feels should win it.'

This is an exact corollary of the position a judge finds him or herself in. If they give in to non-professional feelings then they are corrupt. Full stop. Bent.

Even if it's because of a 'noble' cause, it doesn't change the nature of the unethical act.
 
Last edited:
We can see Hellmann is 'bent', as he didn't follow legal protocol.

Ah yes, the ancient revered legal protocol passed down from Rome I believe it was, Lex Bumfactia or something like. It says if you claim a heroin bum is unreliable just because he told the police one thing initially then something else later while not remembering which day it was then your career is surely over.
 
We can see Hellmann is 'bent', as he didn't follow legal protocol.

And indeed his entire motivations were struck out and he was 'let go'.

Imagine a referee who allows an offside goal or ignores a penalty. 99.99% of time it is human error and means nothing. The referee's word is final, even if wrong.

Now imagine a bent referee who deliberately swings it for one team, for whatever reason. Perhaps even a noble reason. He may privately believe one team deserves to win.

Now, that referee is bent, because it is not in his remit to 'swing it for the team he feels should win it.'

This is an exact corollary of the position a judge finds him or herself in. If they give in to non-professional feelings then they are corrupt. Full stop. Bent.

Even if it's because of a 'noble' cause, it doesn't change the nature of the unethical act.

Yes, if they give in to a feeling and rule on that feeling despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary they would be corrupt, however, I don't think that happened to any of the judges in the many trials of this case. If you have evidence to show otherwise I would be interested in those documents.

Hellmann wasn't wholeheartedly loved by innocent followers because he ruled in favor of the calunia charge. And Maresca/Bruno while giving a verdict of not guilty had included in the motivations details which made that verdict seem ambiguous (angering and confusing both sides). And even Massei's motivations was critiqued by those who thought guilt, concerning the mitigation of sentence for Amanda and Raffaele. And yet, in those three instances they ruled on what the evidence presented showed.

If there is documented evidence to support corruption I think it should be exposed. I just haven't seen it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom