The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's a pity for Gill, because the things he writes are objectively false. And the negative controls are in fact in the trial.

It's a pity that a person with Gill's reputation claims things that were proven false.

Hmmmm. Who proved it false? Should be noted by you that his work is peer reviewed. Who among his peers has criticized his opinion on this case and what did they say?

Dr. Gill published his work on this case. Even the RIS quoted Dr. Gill's work.
 
It is correct to assume that they were constrained in some way.
The way is political.
But they were not constrained between the two options that you suggest. What they were constrained to do, is to acquit and end the case. They were forced to acquit them, even if they didn't want to.
It's not that Marasca is "corrupt" like in the sense that he is a guy who likes to be paid (that type of guy is Hellmann), but rather in the sense that he is a person who cannot refuse, when certain people ask him.
So Marasca appointed Bruno - who never worked as a judge, but worked at the Supreme Court archive section - to solve the problem. And they had to convince one of other three judges.
The report is simply the results that judges refused to write things like "they are innocent", they also possibly tried to write things that would have opened a possibility to review Guede's trial (which would have backfired and exposed them) as well as maybe try avoid to exposing themselves too much to an ECHR review. They only did what they were forced to do and nothing more.

And see this is why every discussion in this thread eventually resolves itself into a tautological reconstruction of our initial positions - guilty or innocent.

There are certain assumptions you're making based on your view, for example that it is self evident and incontrovertible that Knox washed blood from her hands so they couldn't avoid finding it in their report.

Obviously I disagree with the starting assumption about the blood and so wont see it that way at all.

You've claimed that I need to research more details and facts about this case. The fact is I already know more about this case than most people outside the legal profession will know about any case ever. I wish I knew less but I got a little obsessed with the PGP.

IMO guilt or innocence is something that can generally be provisionally established with a few key data points and a trial is about being careful to cross i's and dot t's and maintain integrity.

Cases are like pop songs, they have a "hook." Scott Peterson is guilty because he lied about where he was the day his pregnant wife he was cheating on disappeared while he was out in the cold bay on a boat he just bought in secret where his wife's body later drifted to shore. We can read the 10,000 case files, if we really want to.

Indeed this case started with a hook, and a very compelling one. A white girl blamed a black man for the rape and murder of her roommate who turned out to be completely innocent. And for three weeks in November 2007, that was all one needed to know. But it turned out to be a lie didn't it? The police had convinced themselves the break-in was staged and Knox's weak alibi combined with an unfortunately timed text message just before the murder lead the investigation to rounding her up in the middle of the night and aggressively persuading her to implicate their suspect Patrick through a combination of physical force (slaps), threatening language, lies, and psychological manipulation with stories about amnesia and trauma blackouts.

Then Rudy the 2-story cat burglar shows up, the break-in obviously goes from staged to real, and the story ends.

But you've convinced yourself if you dig deeper and deeper and examine each microtonality of the case you can connect Knox to this crime beyond any doubt. The secret is hidden in the blood negative smudges and lurking behind the conspirator judges and bent professors and crooked US senators. I'm sorry Mach but get a grip. You're going to have to deal with the fact that these strong emotions you feel about this random American girl are your own problem brought on by some idiot cops and their clown prosecutor and nothing to do with her. IMO you should move on.
 
And see this is why every discussion in this thread eventually resolves itself into a tautological reconstruction of our initial positions - guilty or innocent.

There are certain assumptions you're making based on your view, for example that it is self evident and incontrovertible that Knox washed blood from her hands so they couldn't avoid finding it in their report.

Obviously I disagree with the starting assumption about the blood and so wont see it that way at all.

You've claimed that I need to research more details and facts about this case. The fact is I already know more about this case than most people outside the legal profession will know about any case ever. I wish I knew less but I got a little obsessed with the PGP.

IMO guilt or innocence is something that can generally be provisionally established with a few key data points and a trial is about being careful to cross i's and dot t's and maintain integrity.

Cases are like pop songs, they have a "hook." Scott Peterson is guilty because he lied about where he was the day his pregnant wife he was cheating on disappeared while he was out in the cold bay on a boat he just bought in secret where his wife's body later drifted to shore. We can read the 10,000 case files, if we really want to.

Indeed this case started with a hook, and a very compelling one. A white girl blamed a black man for the rape and murder of her roommate who turned out to be completely innocent. And for three weeks in November 2007, that was all one needed to know. But it turned out to be a lie didn't it? The police had convinced themselves the break-in was staged and Knox's weak alibi combined with an unfortunately timed text message just before the murder lead the investigation to rounding her up in the middle of the night and aggressively persuading her to implicate their suspect Patrick through a combination of physical force (slaps), threatening language, lies, and psychological manipulation with stories about amnesia and trauma blackouts.

Then Rudy the 2-story cat burglar shows up, the break-in obviously goes from staged to real, and the story ends.

But you've convinced yourself if you dig deeper and deeper and examine each microtonality of the case you can connect Knox to this crime beyond any doubt. The secret is hidden in the blood negative smudges and lurking behind the conspirator judges and bent professors and crooked US senators. I'm sorry Mach but get a grip. You're going to have to deal with the fact that these strong emotions you feel about this random American girl are your own problem brought on by some idiot cops and their clown prosecutor and nothing to do with her. IMO you should move on.

Very well said bagels. Yes, this is the point the Perugia authorities should have released Amanda and Raffaele. But they couldn't bare it at this point. They had told the world this great story and instead of looking like heroes when they announced to the world they had closed the case and had Meredith's killers they were terrified of looking like fools.


It's really very sad. It's even sadder that people continue to push a dumb false story when the truth of this case is so so obvious.
 
Very well said bagels. Yes, this is the point the Perugia authorities should have released Amanda and Raffaele. But they couldn't bare it at this point. They had told the world this great story and instead of looking like heroes when they announced to the world they had closed the case and had Meredith's killers they were terrified of looking like fools.


It's really very sad. It's even sadder that people continue to push a dumb false story when the truth of this case is so so obvious.

The tautological reconstruction I circle back to is a rejection of the dietrology of those who claim to know what the minutiae of this "really means".

Lots of big words in that sentence and we are but humble pirates.

But here's the deal. As horrible as the crime was, it was frustratingly straightforward. A straightforward explanation never really seems adequate when compared to the enormity of the loss.

Here's another one. When a non--expert goes on and on about how an obvious expert allegedly lied, but cannot point to a single peer of that expert who agrees it was a lie....

.... who are we up in the cheap seats going to believe?

At least the pressure is off Vixen to name a single forensic-DNA expert who agrees with Stefanoni, or who calls Dr Peter Gill a clown.
 
The tautological reconstruction I circle back to is a rejection of the dietrology of those who claim to know what the minutiae of this "really means".

Lots of big words in that sentence and we are but humble pirates.

But here's the deal. As horrible as the crime was, it was frustratingly straightforward. A straightforward explanation never really seems adequate when compared to the enormity of the loss.

Here's another one. When a non--expert goes on and on about how an obvious expert allegedly lied, but cannot point to a single peer of that expert who agrees it was a lie....

.... who are we up in the cheap seats going to believe?

At least the pressure is off Vixen to name a single forensic-DNA expert who agrees with Stefanoni, or who calls Dr Peter Gill a clown.

They resort to add hominems when the facts fail. Machiavelli desperate and degrading description of Hellman just because Hellman refused to do something he knew would be horribly wrong. In Machiavelli's mind Gill should have ignored the misuse of the science he pioneered just so Mignini could look good.
 
Answer the question. Name one forensic-DNA expert who's said that Dr. Peter Gill is a clown? Name one who said he'd lied. Name one who'd said he claims things which were proven false.

You are not a forensic-DNA expert, Machiavelli. You do not get to proclaim something in that arena to be "objectively false", that is if you wish to be taken seriously.

It is not a matter of forensic science, Bill. It is a matter of facts of history. I am indeed an expert of the Meredith Kercher trials btw, and I can state based on documental proof that an assertion like that "the negative controls were not disclosed", is a false factoid.
It is objectively false because it is proven so, not proclaimed.

Also Chieffi, btw, points out that it was "superficial" on the part of Vecchiotti to assume that the negative controls were not disclosed - without even asking them, after declining to have raw data, and without checking the trial file at the preliminary Judge's court.

Can you offer one scintilla of proof that the judges "refused" to do this? In law, even in Italy, acquitting someone of a crime simply keeps their "innocent until proven guilty" status unchanged.

Don't forget that it is a proven fact that Knox was on the crime scene when the murder was committed, and it is incontrofìvertible that the crime was committed by more than one person. And that Knox is a convicted felon.
 
For example, if a court decides a man is a child's father, it matters not a jot if the real truth is that a dastardly rogue swapped samples over at DNA testing, as that is the way the child will now proceed through life. (Subject to the devilish plot never coming to light.)

...what?

By your criteria criminals are supposed to walk free in crimes which are committed under the cloak of secrecy just because no independent person witnessed it, and even if they did, how can we know the witness is reliable.

How are you supposed to determine if someone's guilty if not through evidence? Guilty until proven innocent?
 
It is not a matter of forensic science, Bill. It is a matter of facts of history. I am indeed an expert of the Meredith Kercher trials btw, and I can state based on documental proof that an assertion like that "the negative controls were not disclosed", is a false factoid.
It is objectively false because it is proven so, not proclaimed.

Also Chieffi, btw, points out that it was "superficial" on the part of Vecchiotti to assume that the negative controls were not disclosed - without even asking them, after declining to have raw data, and without checking the trial file at the preliminary Judge's court.



Don't forget that it is a proven fact that Knox was on the crime scene when the murder was committed, and it is incontrofìvertible that the crime was committed by more than one person. And that Knox is a convicted felon.

Care to cite what the evidence of this is? I'm not talking some lower court's judicial truth.. I mean real, direct, indisputable evidence.

That you feel the need to assert "Knox is a convicted felon" tells me all I need to know about your bias and MO. She's a convicted felon because the police, who did not provide her a lawyer for an interrogation they did not record, using an interpreter who worked for them and actively worked to get Knox to say things she was not willing to say on her own; police who misinterpreted the SMS message exchange between Lumumba and Amanda and concluded Amanda and Lumumba met up the night of the murder; police who slap her upside her head as they accuse her of lying and told her she would go to jail for 30 years if she didn't tell them 'that which they already know to be the truth'; THOSE police coerced a statement THEY wrote, in a language Amanda was not proficient in and got her to sign it in the wee hours of the morning on the day Amanda's mother was to arrive and start demanding her daughter's rights be honored. If I were you I wouldn't be so quick - or proud - to be calling her a convicted felon. That just happens to be the last piece of this judicial miscarriage that has yet to be corrected, but I have confidence the ECHR will make this very clear for all the world to see soon enough.
 
And see this is why every discussion in this thread eventually resolves itself into a tautological reconstruction of our initial positions - guilty or innocent.

There are certain assumptions you're making based on your view, for example that it is self evident and incontrovertible that Knox washed blood from her hands so they couldn't avoid finding it in their report.

No no no no, this is not "my view", this is something Bruno-Marasca indicates as a proven fact.
Regardless of our opinions about facts, we should at least both recognize that this is objectively something reported in the verdict.
(...)

IMO guilt or innocence is something that can generally be provisionally established with a few key data points and a trial is about being careful to cross i's and dot t's and maintain integrity.

This type of discourse is intrinsically dangerous. By a certain setting of your view, you may operate an (arbitrary or unconscious) preliminary selection of those points that you chose to believe are the "key" points, and then you may just deny, or bend, all subsequent findings in order to fit them into your provisionally established scenario.
In fact what you describe - the provisional establishment based only on few "key" factors - is called confirmation bias.

The way you chose the factors is preliminary and arbitrary, and based on some pre-existing belief.

In my opinoion instead, evidence is more like a mathematical test, a logical operation a posteriori based on comparing one hypotheses with a contrary one: which is the one that fits the details and it is consistent, versus the one where the details do not form a solid system.

Cases are like pop songs, they have a "hook." Scott Peterson is guilty because he lied about where he was the day his pregnant wife he was cheating on disappeared while he was out in the cold bay on a boat he just bought in secret where his wife's body later drifted to shore. We can read the 10,000 case files, if we really want to.

This is simplistic. Not all songs are conventional pop, music has many genres and style. Cases can be obvious, uninteresting and linear like a pop melody and have just one hook, but they can also be poliphonic or odd and have many "hooks".

Indeed this case started with a hook, and a very compelling one. A white girl blamed a black man for the rape and murder of her roommate who turned out to be completely innocent. And for three weeks in November 2007, that was all one needed to know. But it turned out to be a lie didn't it?

From my point of view, the case doesn't start there. That one is a big hook- But not the first and most impressive one.
To me, the first and biggest hook was Amanda Knox's version of facts (shower, mop, closed door, etc.), also coupled with Sollecito's non credible account.
The amount of inconsistencies in Knox's very first version is simply beyond the pole. I can't help by see it as a systematic patter nof lies.

Now, rather than the false accusation against an innocent, which is anyway extremely incriminating against Knox, what I found most incriminating against Knox is her hand written note. Because that one is another "pattern of lies", another systematic attempt of manipulation, not just a single lie.

But let's be clear: I considered those lies as evidence of Knox's lying, that is her being involved in the crime in some way - but maybe just of being involved in a cover up or of being an accessory, not necessarily of her being the murderess.

The police had convinced themselves the break-in was staged and Knox's weak alibi combined with an unfortunately timed text message just before the murder lead the investigation to rounding her up in the middle of the night and aggressively persuading her to implicate their suspect Patrick through a combination of physical force (slaps), threatening language, lies, and psychological manipulation with stories about amnesia and trauma blackouts.

Now, you are going on with a narrative but at a certain point you take a turn into fiction, as you throw in elements which are contrary to the actual facts.
Amanda Knox did not lie during a police interrogation. Her false accusation was a protracted behaviour.
When one tries to explain out the actual behaviour of Knox based on police brutality, the explanation becomes inconsistent. (and we are just talking about the false accusation - let alone the rest of her lies).
Knox laid down a false testimony against Lmumba a secont time, and this time in a way far more articulate, without being interrogated, abut just through spontaneous declarations before a magistrate.
And then presented a false testimony accusing Lumumba a third time in a hand written note, in which she lied down false evidence again but also lied down a protective life jacket in order to make such evidence ineffective and unreliable.
And then she refused to respond when she had the opportunity to clarify her testimony before a judge.
And then she lied again, she sank again into a further maelstrom of inconsistencies, and refused to respond again in the end when asked about Lumumba, as she was interrogated by the magistrate on Dec. 17.
And then she presented an inconsistent spontaneous declaration in 2008 where she failed to provide any factual detail about her interrogation and false accusation.
And then her defence failed to present any complaint about any alleged physical abuse nor unlawful interrogation.
And then the defence presented a theory of Knox suffering of a false memory syndrome.
And then after claiming a false memory syndrome, Knox claimed to remember an alibi.
And then...
it's all lies.
 
Ah, those magical "judicial facts." That have the same relationship to actual facts as...

...virtual reality does to actual reality.
...alternative medicine does to actual medicine.
...Weekly World News does to actual news.
...henna tattoos do to actual tattoos.
...Long Island iced tea does to actual iced tea.
...honorary degrees do to actual degrees.
...Papal infallibility does to actual infallibility.
 
Hmmmm. Who proved it false? Should be noted by you that his work is peer reviewed. Who among his peers has criticized his opinion on this case and what did they say?

Dr. Gill published his work on this case. Even the RIS quoted Dr. Gill's work.

Peers only review the academic outlook of an article. Not the data. Do you think the peers would actually check if the negative controls were deposited with the trial file?

The data imput in Gill's article is objectively false.

It should be enough to note that Gill does not even indicate a number of main trial documents within his list of sources. He doesn't include them. He presents a list of trial papers as the whole list of his sources. And what about the missing ones? Anyone who knows the trial can check how main data sources are missing from his list.
 
bagels said:
And see this is why every discussion in this thread eventually resolves itself into a tautological reconstruction of our initial positions - guilty or innocent.

There are certain assumptions you're making based on your view, for example that it is self evident and incontrovertible that Knox washed blood from her hands so they couldn't avoid finding it in their report.
No no no no, this is not "my view", this is something Bruno-Marasca indicates as a proven fact.

Ah, er, no. Bruno-Marasca raised the issue of the blood from the hands only to further state that even if this were true, Judge Nencini's court still should have acquitted.

Also, if it were a "proven-fact" you would have no problem supplying the proof. There is no proof. Please link to it if you know where it is. Don't just keep asserting that it has been proven - PROVIDE THE PROOF!

Judge Massei's report in 2010 even conceded that he came to that conclusion, even with no forensics supporting it. Judge Massei said he came to that (erroneous) conclusion on other grounds, other than forensic proof.

However, even if what you say is true, Machiavelli, that still does not change the "if-then" statement M/B was setting up.

Marasca-Bruno said:
Any further and more meaningful value would be, in fact, resisted by the fact - which is decisive - that no trace leading to her was found at the scene of the crime or on the victim’s body, so that - if all the above is accepted - her contact with the victim’s blood would have occurred after the crime and in another part of the house.​
Pretend for a minute that you are correct, that M-B actually believed what you say they believed.

That STILL would not change the conditional nature of it all, where the acquittal is based on the decisive fact ......

that no trace leading to her was found at the scene of the crime or on the victim’s body​

You truly do not "get" this. Even if what you say is true, M/B still would have acquitted.
 
Care to cite what the evidence of this is? I'm not talking some lower court's judicial truth.. I mean real, direct, indisputable evidence.

Rats. You beat me to it. Yes, people who assert that it is proven should at least have the decency to provide the proof.
 
Bill Williams said:
Can you offer one scintilla of proof that the judges "refused" to do this? In law, even in Italy, acquitting someone of a crime simply keeps their "innocent until proven guilty" status unchanged.
Don't forget that it is a proven fact that Knox was on the crime scene when the murder was committed, and it is incontrofìvertible that the crime was committed by more than one person. And that Knox is a convicted felon.

At some point it becomes pointless asking you to demonstrate your claims.

None of the above is anything remotely "proof" that the judges "refused" to declare her innocent. Please note, the emphasis on the word "refused".

How on earth can you know this? Did you look at a picture of the judges and see it in their eyes?
 
Peers only review the academic outlook of an article. Not the data. Do you think the peers would actually check if the negative controls were deposited with the trial file?

The data imput in Gill's article is objectively false.

It should be enough to note that Gill does not even indicate a number of main trial documents within his list of sources. He doesn't include them. He presents a list of trial papers as the whole list of his sources. And what about the missing ones? Anyone who knows the trial can check how main data sources are missing from his list.

You don't know what you're talking about. Dr. Gill's paper was about proper protocols, procedure, contamination and context. If his peers, (NOT YOU..you are not a peer) believe that his observations, logic or conclusions were wrong, they would certainly criticize it. But from the academic world there has been no such criticism. Instead it comes from TJMK, PMF, you and others who's understanding of DNA and forensics is lacking.

When you come forward with a qualified scholar that presents criticism of Dr. Gill's work, it might be worth review. But at the moment, your arguments remind me of creationists criticism of evolution. They simply are tiresome and not worth considering.
 
Peers only review the academic outlook of an article. Not the data. Do you think the peers would actually check if the negative controls were deposited with the trial file?

Sorry, with this statement you've disqualified yourself. This is not what peer review is - as anyone who has been subject to it would know.

There is no such thing as an "academic outlook of an article." Making stuff up, nonsensical stuff, does you no good.

On the other hand I am grateful you said this.
 
Last edited:
Peers only review the academic outlook of an article. Not the data. Do you think the peers would actually check if the negative controls were deposited with the trial file.

One last thing, which was just now pointed out to me that I missed.

Dr. Peter Gill is peer-reviewed in the forensic-DNA world. Which means YES they would check the interface between the way the court handled evidence and what Dr Gill said about it.

If you find yourself squirming in your seat under cross-examination by a snarly opposition lawyer, try being peer reviewed by rivals in your field just licking their lips that you may have slipped in something you wrote.

Again, it is good you wrote what you wrote. Shows readers to the thread how to assess the various views posted here.
 
Answer the question. Name one forensic-DNA expert who's said that Dr. Peter Gill is a clown? Name one who said he'd lied. Name one who'd said he claims things which were proven false.

You are not a forensic-DNA expert, Machiavelli. You do not get to proclaim something in that arena to be "objectively false", that is if you wish to be taken seriously.


Can you offer one scintilla of proof that the judges "refused" to do this? In law, even in Italy, acquitting someone of a crime simply keeps their "innocent until proven guilty" status unchanged.

It would be better if you'd not look deeply into the souls of the principles of this case and tell us what they either "refused" or "didn't refuse" to do.

What I notice is that many prominent PGP are very good at declaring what judges and others think and believe, and what their motivations are. This apparent psychic ability is strong at TJMK.

They also make accusations that these judges, experts, etc. are corrupt, unethical, paid shills, etc ...all without providing a shred of evidence. That they fail to provide any evidence of all the above is evidence in itself that they have none. If they did, they'd provide it, especially when asked to do so. Instead, it's dance around it, divert, and make ad hominem attacks.
 
:p

Of that it is abundantly clear.

One would expect a Mensa member winning grandmaster games; who also has friends and relatives in all conceivable fields of expertise, would be able to draw on her (or his) enormous reservoir of resources to know that quoting a story such as Noah's Ark is not the truth just because it's written in the "ultimate book".

Which reminds me...who did pull the plug to let the water out? ...or did it evaporate? Mind you Mr Magic man can do anything he (or she) wants, including conjuring up a flood to kill everything when all he (or she) had to do was wave a wand. ...who on earth would believe this claptrap...Vixen??? Nah not even her.

What the **** are you blathering about?
 
Yet again Vixen bangs on about Amanda and Raffaele lying and Machiavelli said Raffaele lied about everything. If someone attacked someone for lying and deliberately set out to be as hypocritical as possible, these are the things you would do :-

• Attack someone for lying whilst lying on an industrial scale yourself.
• Attack someone for lying whilst you feel it is perfectly acceptable to use lies against the person you are attacking for lying and only regard lying as a problem if lies benefit the person you are attacking but are too dishonest to admit this.
• Attack someone for lying whilst spreading lies about the person you are attacking for lying.
• Attack someone for lying while spreading nasty and malicious lies about people.
• Attack someone for lying who has been who has on numerous occasions have had had lies spread about them and lies used against them and totally ignoring this fact.
• Attack someone for lying whilst on numerous occasions defending people who have lied.
• Attack someone for lying whilst falsely accusing them of lying.
• Say that someone would not need to lie if they were innocent of a crime whilst having to resort to lying to argue for that person’s guilt.
• Attacking someone for lying whilst making excuses for other people’s lies.

The above is exactly what PGP do when they attack Amanda for lying. The below is from a previous post showing how hypocritical PGP are when they attack Amanda and Raffaele. The next time Vixen bangs on about Amanda and Raffaele telling umpteen lies, Vixen should consider Amanda and Raffaele have never done any of the things below. I have given an example below where Vixen falsely accused Amanda of lying. If Amanda and Raffaele are such prolific liars why do PGP have to resort to inventing instances where Amanda and Raffaele lied? When it comes to Vixen it is not necessary to invent instances of Vixen lying because there are plenty of genuine instances to draw on. Vixen boasts she has done a psychology degree. I wonder what people with genuine expertise in psychology would say about people who habitually lie and support liars whilst viciously attacking people for lying. Would this be regarded as a sign of mental illness.

" As can be seen from the posts below, there are numerous instances where Vixen has used falsehoods in her posts. PGP constantly bang on about Amanda and Raffaele telling umpteen lies whilst telling umpteen lies in their posts.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com...2#post11938562
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...2#post11942852
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...2#post11598412
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...1#post11427461
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...3#post11951893
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...3#post11669633

• PGP have spread lies about Amanda and Raffaele. As can be seen from the examples above, PGP have spread lies about Amanda and Raffaele eg Amanda showed no grief over the death of Meredith, Amanda was taking 300 euros daily from her bank account, Raffaele was off his head.

• There are numerous instances when PGP have lied, supported liars and ignored lies as can be seen from the post below.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com...3#post11333243

• PGP lie by giving the impression they oppose lying in general when in reality they only oppose lying when it works in Amanda and Raffaele’s favour and support lying when it works against Amanda and Raffaele. PGP feel it is perfectly acceptable to use lies against Amanda and Raffaele. This can be seen from the way PGP defend those who spread lies about Amanda and Raffaele such as the prosecution and witnesses who blatantly lied such as Quintavelle.

• There are numerous instances where people have told lies about Amanda and Raffaele and lies have been used against Amanda and Raffaele. There are several instances where witnesses have lied against Amanda and Raffaele, the prosecution fed false information to the media, Amanda was lied to she had HIV. For some reason you will never hear Vixen banging on about the umpteen occasions people have lied about Amanda and Raffaele and lies have been used against them.

• PGP have spread malicious falsehoods about people such as Hellman being bribed, defence experts have used photoshop, C&V released a DVD only available to the defence.

• PGP have falsely accused Amanda and Raffaele of lying. The post below is one example.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com...5#post11849235

• I recall Vixen saying that an innocent person would not need to lie which implied that Amanda would not need to resort to lying if she was innocent when PGP have to resort to lying to argue the case for Amanda’s guilt.

• PGP make excuses for people’s lies. When Nencini lied in his motivation report that Raffaele’s DNA was on the knife, Vixen made an excuse for this lie by saying it was a typing error.

• PGP come up with Walter Mitty stories about their intelligence and qualifications they have achieved.

Would you like to elaborate what exactly the **** you mean? Be careful.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom