And see this is why every discussion in this thread eventually resolves itself into a tautological reconstruction of our initial positions - guilty or innocent.
There are certain assumptions you're making based on your view, for example that it is self evident and incontrovertible that Knox washed blood from her hands so they couldn't avoid finding it in their report.
No no no no, this is not "my view", this is something Bruno-Marasca indicates as a proven fact.
Regardless of our opinions about facts, we should at least both recognize that this is objectively something reported in the verdict.
(...)
IMO guilt or innocence is something that can generally be provisionally established with a few key data points and a trial is about being careful to cross i's and dot t's and maintain integrity.
This type of discourse is intrinsically dangerous. By a certain setting of your view, you may operate an (arbitrary or unconscious) preliminary selection of those points that you chose to believe are the "key" points, and then you may just deny, or bend, all subsequent findings in order to fit them into your provisionally established scenario.
In fact what you describe - the provisional establishment based only on few "key" factors - is called confirmation bias.
The way you chose the factors is preliminary and arbitrary, and based on some pre-existing belief.
In my opinoion instead, evidence is more like a mathematical test, a logical operation
a posteriori based on comparing one hypotheses with a contrary one: which is the one that fits the details and it is consistent, versus the one where the details do not form a solid system.
Cases are like pop songs, they have a "hook." Scott Peterson is guilty because he lied about where he was the day his pregnant wife he was cheating on disappeared while he was out in the cold bay on a boat he just bought in secret where his wife's body later drifted to shore. We can read the 10,000 case files, if we really want to.
This is simplistic. Not all songs are conventional pop, music has many genres and style. Cases can be obvious, uninteresting and linear like a pop melody and have just one hook, but they can also be poliphonic or odd and have many "hooks".
Indeed this case started with a hook, and a very compelling one. A white girl blamed a black man for the rape and murder of her roommate who turned out to be completely innocent. And for three weeks in November 2007, that was all one needed to know. But it turned out to be a lie didn't it?
From my point of view, the case doesn't start there. That one is a big hook- But not the first and most impressive one.
To me, the first and biggest hook was Amanda Knox's version of facts (shower, mop, closed door, etc.), also coupled with Sollecito's non credible account.
The amount of inconsistencies in Knox's very first version is simply beyond the pole. I can't help by see it as a systematic patter nof lies.
Now, rather than the false accusation against an innocent, which is anyway extremely incriminating against Knox, what I found most incriminating against Knox is her hand written note. Because that one is another "pattern of lies", another systematic attempt of manipulation, not just a single lie.
But let's be clear: I considered those lies as evidence of Knox's lying, that is her being involved in the crime in some way - but maybe just of being involved in a cover up or of being an accessory, not necessarily of her being the murderess.
The police had convinced themselves the break-in was staged and Knox's weak alibi combined with an unfortunately timed text message just before the murder lead the investigation to rounding her up in the middle of the night and aggressively persuading her to implicate their suspect Patrick through a combination of physical force (slaps), threatening language, lies, and psychological manipulation with stories about amnesia and trauma blackouts.
Now, you are going on with a narrative but at a certain point you take a turn into fiction, as you throw in elements which are contrary to the actual facts.
Amanda Knox did not lie during a police interrogation. Her false accusation was a protracted behaviour.
When one tries to explain out the actual behaviour of Knox based on police brutality, the explanation becomes inconsistent. (and we are just talking about the false accusation - let alone the rest of her lies).
Knox laid down a false testimony against Lmumba a secont time, and this time in a way far more articulate, without being interrogated, abut just through spontaneous declarations before a magistrate.
And then presented a false testimony accusing Lumumba a third time in a hand written note, in which she lied down false evidence again but also lied down a protective life jacket in order to make such evidence ineffective and unreliable.
And then she refused to respond when she had the opportunity to clarify her testimony before a judge.
And then she lied again, she sank again into a further maelstrom of inconsistencies, and refused to respond again in the end when asked about Lumumba, as she was interrogated by the magistrate on Dec. 17.
And then she presented an inconsistent spontaneous declaration in 2008 where she failed to provide any factual detail about her interrogation and false accusation.
And then her defence failed to present any complaint about any alleged physical abuse nor unlawful interrogation.
And then the defence presented a theory of Knox suffering of a false memory syndrome.
And then after claiming a false memory syndrome, Knox claimed to remember an alibi.
And then...
it's all lies.