The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
The knife matches the bloody impring perfectly. It's quite impressive actually.

Are you talking about your photoshop where you line up a couple points arbitrarily while a bunch of others dont fit including the obvious lower section lol

The stab wounds are inhomogeneous and indicate the use of two weapons.

Every wound on the body and the imprint could all have been perfectly and easily made by a smallish switchblade-type knife which is the same type of weapon an eyewitness spotted Guede wielding during a previous break-in. Because guess what, the guy with blood all over his hands feet and pants and knife cuts on his hand is the guy who butchered Meredith like a Christmas hog. Shocker.

The Italian police had to work overtime to twist the forensics at the scene into being able to say, if you squint and make certain implausible assumptions about the stabbing motion you might be able to say it's theoretically possible this kitchen knife isn't totally excluded from being capable of making the fatal wound (or any sharp edged object in the world).

But I'm not really interested in discussing the forensics of this pedestrian smash and grab rape murder anymore. I'm more interested in why the highest court in Italy has the audacity to cite false made up evidence not found in any of the official court rulings against Raffaele in his compensation claim. Can you explain that to me?
 
I'm not so sure about that. The problem seems to be, that digging deeper and deeper into this case, will turn you into a conspiracy theorist.

It is interesting that all pro-Knoxes are in fact conspiracy theorists, who only explain things through an alternative conspiracy, where in general terms "Italy" is a kind of corrupt or backward system concerned of protecting itself from being shamed by the brave, enlightened and honest pro-Knox and pro-science Americans - coupled with their natural assumption that the black guy is guilty just based of its profiling. This is the racist presumptuous bias at the core of the belief, and this is fed by the utter ignorance around the law, the people, the foreign justice system and the context, and also fed by the US media coverage of the case, which was designed as a pro-Knox narrative in assonance with the pre-existing worldviews.
 
Are you talking about your photoshop where you line up a couple points arbitrarily while a bunch of others dont fit including the obvious lower section

Which ones "don't fit"?

Every wound on the body and the imprint could all have been perfectly and easily made by a smallish switchblade-type knife which is the same type of weapon an eyewitness spotted Guede wielding during a previous break-in.

No. Not so easilly.
It is theoretically possible to make a large wound with a small knife. But to make a large wound with clear margins using a small knife, a wound with that triangular section, it is quite difficult. You need a lot force, and you are more likely to have it with a longer leverage. The wound is 8.5 cm deep and with such depth the tissues oppose a huge resistance. By using a smaller knife, it is just more likely that one would only manage to cause a smaller wound, or a longer but superficial cut or at best a large wound with a much more irregular shape.

Because guess what, the guy with blood all over his hands feet and pants and knife cuts on his hand is the guy who butchered Meredith like a Christmas hog. Shocker.

One of the persons with blood on themselves (as footprints show). And he killed together with other people.
And by the way, think about that not even a single trace of Gude's blood or DNA was found in the bathroom where some murderer apparently washed their hands: it's a bit strange if you consider that he had numerous cuts on his hands.
Maybe the person who washed himself, it was not him.

The Italian police had to work overtime to twist the forensics at the scene into being able to say, if you squint and make certain implausible assumptions about the stabbing motion you might be able to say it's theoretically possible this kitchen knife isn't totally excluded from being capable of making the fatal wound (or any sharp edged object in the world).

Come on this is just rhetoric.

But I'm not really interested in discussing the forensics of this pedestrian smash and grab rape murder anymore. I'm more interested in why the highest court in Italy has the audacity to cite false made up evidence not found in any of the official court rulings against Raffaele in his compensation claim. Can you explain that to me?

The Court does not make up anything, it cites findings that are reported in the Courts of Florence ruling of Jan. 2017 (pages 7-8).
 
It is interesting that all pro-Knoxes are in fact conspiracy theorists, who only explain things through an alternative conspiracy, where in general terms "Italy" is a kind of corrupt or backward system concerned of protecting itself from being shamed by the brave, enlightened and honest pro-Knox and pro-science Americans - coupled with their natural assumption that the black guy is guilty just based of its profiling. This is the racist presumptuous bias at the core of the belief, and this is fed by the utter ignorance around the law, the people, the foreign justice system and the context, and also fed by the US media coverage of the case, which was designed as a pro-Knox narrative in assonance with the pre-existing worldviews.


Conspiracy theorists hold minority viewpoints not shared by the general esteemed consensus.

The official ruling of the highest court in Italy is Knox and Raffaele are not guilty of murdering Meredith Kercher because the evidence is lacking and insufficient, and the investigation was of poor quality. The DNA forensics were trashed by an official report produced by two professors appointed by the court.

Esteemed outside commenters have all trashed the case, including some of the top forensic experts in history. None have support the prosecution, that I'm aware of. Alan Dershowitz, who detests Knox, says there's some evidence of innocence and sufficient reasonable doubt to acquit.

Meanwhile you believe the forensic report and second level verdict was part of a masonic plot/bribe and that the final acquittal was a carefully orchestrated back channel coordination from top US government sources to help a convicted murderer get away with it because of vague incoherent reasons like their lawyer went on TV and said she's like totally innocent trust me I'm her lawyer.

Lastly the Italian courts continue to go out of their way to document their incompetence/corruption with this matter by citing ridiculous and objectively false evidence that's not even part of their own rulings in their latest report.

Stop pretending your view isn't one of a raving conspiracy theorist.
 
You are mistifying, and not reporting truthfully. But above all, you are changing topic. I was talking about the panel that ruled about Sollecito.
Now, that's lame...
[...]
The high Court usually makes a few material errors reporting from lower courts, this is normal; and Massei's point about the break in staging is very articulated. But the 4th does note make an error on the point reporting from lower courts about Sollecito.
Wait a second, IIRC Cassazzione isn't up to deal with the facts, so how can it be "normal" that they make "material errors" ?

Bruno and Marasca are the only ones who actually make up a real big load of things. For example they make up that the data of Meredith's and Sollecito's computer drives were destroyed (false) and that they could have been useful as evidence (false), that small amounts of DNA cannot be amplified (false), and that there are items with untested microscopic DNA samples (false) and that there are no other items to test (false), or that Knox's contact with Meredith's body would have left detectable DNA traces (false), or that scientific international protocols existed that were violated (false).
Quotes for that please, i.e. page numbers from the MR in Italian...

They also make up their own assessment of Quintavalle and Curatolo (delusional) and violate the points of law established by Chieffi (definitive, still valid: contamination must be proven, evidence cannot be parceled out...).
But M/B are actually not making it up themselves: they are copying and pasting them from the second Sollecito's defensive submission.
Yepp, Drug addict Curatolo and attention whore Quintavalle are relyable, as established as fact by Chieffi to make sure that Nencini got the message,...
ETA: it's getting late here... Good N8... ;)
 
Last edited:
No. Not so easilly.
It is theoretically possible to make a large wound with a small knife. But to make a large wound with clear margins using a small knife, a wound with that triangular section, it is quite difficult. You need a lot force, and you are more likely to have it with a longer leverage. The wound is 8.5 cm deep and with such depth the tissues oppose a huge resistance. By using a smaller knife, it is just more likely that one would only manage to cause a smaller wound, or a longer but superficial cut or at best a large wound with a much more irregular shape.

Lol @ you taking a wound even the state's own medical examiner concluded was initially made by a "small pen knife" (before he got the memo they had pulled a broadsword out of Raffs apartment and needed to make it the murder weapon) and heaping reams of sophist nonsense about what was a simple case where a strong young guy grabbed a girl, and, with considerable force, sliced her neck open to brutally murder her, so she would stop resisting his assault and leave him free to dig through her purse for cash and phones. The giant kitchen knife would have made a deeper and even more aggressive wound.


One of the persons with blood on themselves (as footprints show). And he killed together with other people.
And by the way, think about that not even a single trace of Gude's blood or DNA was found in the bathroom where some murderer apparently washed their hands: it's a bit strange if you consider that he had numerous cuts on his hands.
Maybe the person who washed himself, it was not him.

We've been over this ridiculousness with Vixen. Maybe the guy who confessed to his friend and put in writing that he went into the bathroom because of the mess of blood, and who left a bloody footprint on the mat in the same bathroom, is the guy who was in there while Meredith was gurgling and spewing blood during her final moments?

The Court does not make up anything, it cites findings that are reported in the Courts of Florence ruling of Jan. 2017 (pages 7-8).

Which presumably Raffaele appealed and contested that claim since the evidence does not exist and was never established by any official ruling. Which means the supreme court ignored the appeal and then knowingly repeated the false evidence in their final ruling, bringing us back to my original question, which is what gives them the audacity to so boldly invent false claims?
 
Conspiracy theorists hold minority viewpoints not shared by the general esteemed consensus.

Let's not build ludicrous circular definitions.
The concept of "esteemed consensus" is something very different in different pats of the world. In most of the world - including Europe - the majority consensus is that 9.11 included a conspiracy by the government of the USA.
Mainstream beliefs of majorities may be quite different from the mainstream American ones. And in 2009 still something like 40% of Americans believed that 9-11 was committed by Saddam Hussein.
There is nothing inherently reliable nor esteemed in mainstream views, and they change over time. And mainstream views may well by conspiracy theories or utterly racist prejudices (in fact, they always are so to some extent).

The official ruling of the highest court in Italy is Knox and Raffaele are not guilty of murdering Meredith Kercher because the evidence is lacking and insufficient, and the investigation was of poor quality. The DNA forensics were trashed by an official report produced by two professors appointed by the court.

The official ruling says that Knox was on the scene of murder when Meredith was killed and that she washed her hands from her blood, and also that Meredith was physically killed by multiple perpetrators.
The two "professors": one of them is a puppet, a pilots doctor whose job is to write certificates, utterly incompetent of DNA, who managed to take a post as a legal doctor thanks to the Roman sleazy environment. Vecchiotti is the protagonist of what lawyer Marazzita called "the worst DNA investigation in the history of Italy", for which she was found guilty of "gross incompetence"; and she is the professor who worked at an institute that was shut down entirely by a judge's order because it was so filthy, rotten and poorly-run that all autopsy reports would be "unreliable".

The two professors were caught lying and cheating on the Kercher case, and their lies can be proven.

Esteemed outside commenters have all trashed the case, including some of the top forensic experts in history. None have support the prosecution, that I'm aware of. Alan Dershowitz, who detests Knox, says there's some evidence of innocence and sufficient reasonable doubt to acquit.

The esteemed commenters like Gill can be shown to report a series of false factoids. Sorry, this is just the facts. He just reports false data.
Halkides and Hampikian are kid of guys who made press conferences claiming that "new evidence emerged" that Stefanoni suppressed data and that they had found contamination. And it was all false.
Btw, esteemed Halkides apparently loves to quote neo-Nazi sites.

Meanwhile you believe the forensic report and second level verdict was part of a masonic plot/bribe and that the final acquittal was a carefully orchestrated back channel coordination from top US government sources to help a convicted murderer get away with it because of vague incoherent reasons like their lawyer went on TV and said she's like totally innocent trust me I'm her lawyer.

No, it's quite simple corruption, aided by convergence with foreign political pressure. It's not something new or unseen.
It is a matter of fact that political charachters like senator Cantwell campaigned in favour of a murder (it's not the first time that Cantwell defends a murder calling out a police conspiracy, actually the first time was in the murder case where the suspect was her brother).

Lastly the Italian courts continue to go out of their way to document their incompetence/corruption with this matter by citing ridiculous and objectively false evidence that's not even part of their own rulings in their latest report.

It is, it's in the Florence ruling of Jan. 2017.

Stop pretending your view isn't one of a raving conspiracy theorist.

Your view is that of a racist theorist. I mean a conspiracy theorist who doesn't need specific facts and doesn't invstigate or check details, is only based on general view of the world and prejudice.
There was recently a case of two american young women who were raped by two Carabinieri in Florence. There are some people who believe the cops and not the girls, saying things like "they were drunk and junkies, they only wanted to f***, they were not clear cops didn't understand...", they would see those scenarios based on their worldview as the reasonable ones. They think their view is esteemed and not conspiracy-based. I'm sorry but I think you are like those people. You have your worldview, in which the world revolves around your own prejudice and your own perception of "common sense".
 
It is interesting that all pro-Knoxes are in fact conspiracy theorists, who only explain things through an alternative conspiracy, where in general terms "Italy" is a kind of corrupt or backward system concerned of protecting itself from being shamed by the brave, enlightened and honest pro-Knox and pro-science Americans - coupled with their natural assumption that the black guy is guilty just based of its profiling. This is the racist presumptuous bias at the core of the belief, and this is fed by the utter ignorance around the law, the people, the foreign justice system and the context, and also fed by the US media coverage of the case, which was designed as a pro-Knox narrative in assonance with the pre-existing worldviews.

"Italy" acquitted the pair.
 
I was going to respond to some posts here but, after reading all of them first, I decided it would be futile. When a poster has to resort to slinging personal insults at judges and world-respected experts including racism, name calling, allegations of professional dishonesty, unethical behavior and intentional lying, it signals that said poster is irretrievably chin deep in the muck of confirmation bias. So why bother?

The psychology of it all fascinates me.
 
Last edited:
I was going to respond to some posts here but, after reading all of them first, I decided it would be futile. When a poster has to resort to slinging personal insults at judges and world-respected experts including racism, name calling, allegations of professional dishonesty, unethical behavior and intentional lying, it signals that said poster is irretrievably chin deep in the muck of confirmation bias. So why bother?

The psychology if it all fascinates me.

Major CC Dr. Andrea Berti was the expert in 2013 from the RIS Carabinieri who cited Dr. Peter Gill to the Nencini court as a world renowned expert. (I've been informed that it is my error to denote Major Berti as female. Major Berti is, in fact, male. My bad.)

I was going to ask - why would Major Berti cite Dr. Peter Gill as a world renowned forensic-DNA expert in his testimony to to the Nencini court if.....

...... it had been proven that Dr. Gill had lied about Stefanoni?

I was going to ask this, but there is actually no point. Suffice it to say that the RIS Carabinieri had opportunity to correct the record at the Nencini trial if need be - all Prosecutor Crini had to do was ask.

But never mind. From the "other side of the fence" it's all a conspiracy anyway.

Even this post!
 
It is interesting that all pro-Knoxes are in fact conspiracy theorists, who only explain things through an alternative conspiracy, where in general terms "Italy" is a kind of corrupt or backward system concerned of protecting itself from being shamed by the brave, enlightened and honest pro-Knox and pro-science Americans - coupled with their natural assumption that the black guy is guilty just based of its profiling. This is the racist presumptuous bias at the core of the belief, and this is fed by the utter ignorance around the law, the people, the foreign justice system and the context, and also fed by the US media coverage of the case, which was designed as a pro-Knox narrative in assonance with the pre-existing worldviews.

In general most of the claims about corruption are targeted at the judges finding innocence. Hellman and Marasca. Being Italian you may not realise that judges in other jurisdictions are virtually never accused of corruption (biased yes, corrupt no). That you can believe these judges are corrupt shows a problem with the Italian judicial system. Even the Italian government knows the Italian judicial system needs changing. Cases drag on so long that many are lost under the statutes of limitation. Do not pretend that the Italian judicial system is anywhere near perfect.
 
"he", Andrea is a man.

No, Bill. I've got nothing to say to Andrea Berti. I'm not you. I look for facts.
I talk about facts not about what people say about some other people.
The he-said authority fallacy belongs to Bill-Williams logic.

I may contact Gill instead, show him the docs that contradict his asseritions and ask him why he wrote this ******** in his article. But that would be a waste of my time, because I'm not interested in what a non-neutral expert says.
Let's just show why Gill's statements are false.

So, you are not interested in what one expert says about another expert, in a case which both of them have some familiarity?

And you call this a "he-said authority fallacy"? I had thought there was a procedure in court to have someone designated as an "expert witness"? I regard Andrea Berti as an expert witness, but more importantly apparently the Nencini court did, too.

Neither you nor I have the expertise to show why Gill's stuff is true or false. Peer review handles that. Neither you nor I are peers of Gill's.

But thanks with the heads up about Berti's gender.
 
Let's not build ludicrous circular definitions.
The concept of "esteemed consensus" is something very different in different pats of the world. In most of the world - including Europe - the majority consensus is that 9.11 included a conspiracy by the government of the USA.
Mainstream beliefs of majorities may be quite different from the mainstream American ones. And in 2009 still something like 40% of Americans believed that 9-11 was committed by Saddam Hussein.
There is nothing inherently reliable nor esteemed in mainstream views, and they change over time. And mainstream views may well by conspiracy theories or utterly racist prejudices (in fact, they always are so to some extent).



The official ruling says that Knox was on the scene of murder when Meredith was killed and that she washed her hands from her blood, and also that Meredith was physically killed by multiple perpetrators.
The two "professors": one of them is a puppet, a pilots doctor whose job is to write certificates, utterly incompetent of DNA, who managed to take a post as a legal doctor thanks to the Roman sleazy environment. Vecchiotti is the protagonist of what lawyer Marazzita called "the worst DNA investigation in the history of Italy", for which she was found guilty of "gross incompetence"; and she is the professor who worked at an institute that was shut down entirely by a judge's order because it was so filthy, rotten and poorly-run that all autopsy reports would be "unreliable".

The two professors were caught lying and cheating on the Kercher case, and their lies can be proven.



The esteemed commenters like Gill can be shown to report a series of false factoids. Sorry, this is just the facts. He just reports false data.
Halkides and Hampikian are kid of guys who made press conferences claiming that "new evidence emerged" that Stefanoni suppressed data and that they had found contamination. And it was all false.
Btw, esteemed Halkides apparently loves to quote neo-Nazi sites.


No, it's quite simple corruption, aided by convergence with foreign political pressure. It's not something new or unseen.
It is a matter of fact that political charachters like senator Cantwell campaigned in favour of a murder (it's not the first time that Cantwell defends a murder calling out a police conspiracy, actually the first time was in the murder case where the suspect was her brother).



It is, it's in the Florence ruling of Jan. 2017.



Your view is that of a racist theorist. I mean a conspiracy theorist who doesn't need specific facts and doesn't invstigate or check details, is only based on general view of the world and prejudice.
There was recently a case of two american young women who were raped by two Carabinieri in Florence. There are some people who believe the cops and not the girls, saying things like "they were drunk and junkies, they only wanted to f***, they were not clear cops didn't understand...", they would see those scenarios based on their worldview as the reasonable ones. They think their view is esteemed and not conspiracy-based. I'm sorry but I think you are like those people. You have your worldview, in which the world revolves around your own prejudice and your own perception of "common sense".

This seems to be an ad hominem attack of a member of ISF address the argument.

ETA
Certainly only a mad minority in the UK think that the twin towers disaster on 11/9 was anything other than terrorism. Even most muslim people I know accept that this was terrorism.
 
Last edited:
Lol @ you taking a wound even the state's own medical examiner concluded was initially made by a "small pen knife" (before he got the memo they had pulled a broadsword out of Raffs apartment and needed to make it the murder weapon) and heaping reams of sophist nonsense about what was a simple case where a strong young guy grabbed a girl, and, with considerable force, sliced her neck open to brutally murder her, so she would stop resisting his assault and leave him free to dig through her purse for cash and phones. The giant kitchen knife would have made a deeper and even more aggressive wound.

Make an effort and try to see things as they are.
The aggressors did not operate with considerable force. You cannot describe events with such a narrative. Instead, the aggression was protracted, and there was a gradual escalation. There are other wounds, and they are not blown with considerable force, they are superficial, and they are on a different side. And there are also many other wounds of different types and there are also ripped clothes. And the person was also immobilized in the meanwhile. You need a dynamic that describes the whole course of events.
If you describe it as a man grabbing a girl and cutting her throat with force you are mystifying, that was not the story. Something else went on.

By the way, tell me what are those points sheet imprint that allegedly don't match the knife.

We've been over this ridiculousness with Vixen. Maybe the guy who confessed to his friend and put in writing that he went into the bathroom because of the mess of blood, and who left a bloody footprint on the mat in the same bathroom, is the guy who was in there while Meredith was gurgling and spewing blood during her final moments?

His foot is not compatible with that imprint. Which instead matches Sollecito.
Come on step out of your prejudice and take a ruler. Take a few measurements. Not from Vinci if possible, I mean true measurements.

Which presumably Raffaele appealed and contested that claim since the evidence does not exist and was never established by any official ruling. Which means the supreme court ignored the appeal and then knowingly repeated the false evidence in their final ruling, bringing us back to my original question, which is what gives them the audacity to so boldly invent false claims?

I don't understand what you are talking about. I've already answered. The Supreme Court does not invent false claims. The evidence exist in an official ruling. The Jan. 2017 ruling is an official ruling. That is the ruling the Cassazione has to decide about.
If the datum was false (but it isn't) then it would be Florence court's mistake. The Cassazione's job is not to correct or re-interpret factual findings of another court. And in fact they didn't. Their only job was to find out if the Florence court was illogical or in contradiction with other documents from courts of merits.
There is no evidence that the Florence court is in contradiction with Nencini, neither were Nencini's findings annulled on this specific point.

So you are not making a question, but rather a false assertion: you assert that the Court invented non-existing findings. It didn't. There is no evidence of that.

But the main point is, that whether this is an error or not, it matters little, because this is not ther reason why Sollecito is denied damages. The reasons are overwhelmingly wider, the point is that he *always* lied, all his versions were lies, his entire narrative is false, in addition he even refused to answer when he was interrogated, his alibi was contradicted by multiple factual elements (phone records, computer records, telephone conversation), and also, the same ruling well reminds it was a proven fact that Knox was on the scene of crime at the time of the murder and he was almost certainly there as well.... Why is it that you decide to focus on the timing of his police call? There is no need to single out this specific point. It's a pattern not a point.
 
Last edited:
The two "professors": one of them is a puppet, a pilots doctor whose job is to write certificates, utterly incompetent of DNA, who managed to take a post as a legal doctor thanks to the Roman sleazy environment.

Thankfully none of this nation's pervasive systemic incompetence and corruption ever makes it way to the local investigators or courts ;)

Your view is that of a racist theorist. I mean a conspiracy theorist who doesn't need specific facts and doesn't invstigate or check details, is only based on general view of the world and prejudice. You have your worldview, in which the world revolves around your own prejudice and your own perception of "common sense".

It was a simple case Mach. I didn't create it. Nobody told Guede to go slaughter a girl in her own home who was only trying to get some rest and study for a test. I'm sorry it completely ********** with your mind.

The case against Guede isn't really a theory or world view or whatever. You can basically list out the raw evidence in its linear sequence and the case unveils itself.

Evidence from mid October
- Guede is arrested in connection with a break-in at a law office blocks from the Kercher cottage involving what was described by the victim as an "absolutely not easy climb" up to a second story balcony window and bashing it open with a large heavy rock.
- An eyewitness says someone he later believed to be Rudy Guede broke into his apartment and pulled a switchblade-type knife on him in the dark

Evidence from the evening of the murder
- Guede is picked up on CCTV snooping around the cottage
- Meredith is picked up on CCTV a while later, returning home alone
- The cottage was found with an apparent break-in on the second story window, a large heavy rock was used to bash open the window from outside
- Meredith is found stabbed to death, every wound and the bloody imprint from the knife is compatible with a switchblade-type knife
- Meredith's body is surrounded by Rudy Guede's bloody hand and footprints
- Meredith's vagina has Rudy Guede's DNA in it
- Meredith's purse has Rudy Guede's DNA on it.
- Rudy Guede confessed to a friend in a private conversation he was there with Meredith alone and he was alone with her as she died and nobody he knew was ever there with them
- In addition to this primary evidence the Italian police had a collection of incidental findings (blood negative DNA negative luminol stains, DNA from the sink matching another roommate that lived there, witnesses that initially said they saw nothing but were later brought to trial anyway, etc).

This is literally just an evidence list that spells out what happened. I'm sorry Mignini is a dumbass and thought the break-in staged and illegally interrogated three people because of it. Get over it.
 
Major CC Dr. Andrea Berti was the expert in 2013 from the RIS Carabinieri who cited Dr. Peter Gill to the Nencini court as a world renowned expert. (I've been informed that it is my error to denote Major Berti as female. Major Berti is, in fact, male. My bad.)

I was going to ask - why would Major Berti cite Dr. Peter Gill as a world renowned forensic-DNA expert in his testimony to to the Nencini court if.....

...... it had been proven that Dr. Gill had lied about Stefanoni?

I was going to ask this, but there is actually no point. Suffice it to say that the RIS Carabinieri had opportunity to correct the record at the Nencini trial if need be - all Prosecutor Crini had to do was ask.

But never mind. From the "other side of the fence" it's all a conspiracy anyway.

Even this post!

You can be forgiven for assuming Andrea Berti is a woman as Andrea is exclusively a woman's name in the US (and I believe in the English speaking world). Andrea Doria was the famous 16th century Genoan admiral for whom the Italian liner was named.

Yes, it is a wonder that Gill was not exposed for the lying, unprofessional, unethical, incompetent snake he is by Crini during the Nencini trial. I'm shocked that his peer reviewed paper and book have not been refuted by a horde of other experts! Not a single one! They must all have been bought off by the Great PR Machine. Or the Masons. Or the Illuminati. Or the Mafia. I'd include the RCMP but I learned my lesson.
 
Ok I take this as your admission that you have been caught lying.

This was wht you wrote:



What you wrote is a lie.

What I wrote is the truth.

You shift on presenting your own personal assessment that the fact is "irrelevant", skipping the stage of admitting the fact is true, therby implicitly you admit that what I say is the truth (and you lied)

Mach you seem to have failed to respond to;
In fact, Cassazione ruled:

Any further and more meaningful value would be, in fact, resisted by the fact - which is decisive - that no trace leading to her was found at the scene of the crime or on the victim’s body, so that - if all the above is accepted - her contact with the victim’s blood would have occurred after the crime and in another part of the house.

So the court said that Knox was present at another time and place from the murder.

If this is a mistranslation then that is a case for you to make.

Perhaps this is one of the three or four factual errors that Italian courts can make when justifying a verdict? Something that would not be acceptable anywhere else. Do you realise every time you say things like a few factual errors made by the court are OK you are just making the Italian judicial system look worse?
 
Sorry, the argument is idiotic.

It is an old irrational pro-Knox mantra, it is old and trite, and it is nonsensical.

It is actually nothing more than a disguised argument of extra-judicial authority based on political influence.

The so-called "well regarded" experts presented arguments only talking in the press, and they presented arguments that can be shown containing falsehoods and omissions. They are simply propaganda.
The fact that Halkides and Hampikian made wild assertions without evidence (like wild claims that Stefanoni "suppressed" e-grams or that they found "contamination"), is a fact, which talks about their neutrality, and should suffice.
The fact that Gill claims Vecchiotti as his main source and makes some proven false claims should suffice.
The fact that the "well regarded" or allegedly "independent" experts only talked in the press and were not cross questioned in the courtroom, should suffice.
The fact that defence experts such as Tagliabracci were equally qualified as the ones you quote, and the fact that all arguments presented were already identical to the ones already presented by the actual defence experts, and the fact that those were simply already found to be scientifically not convincing, should suffice.

Vecchiotti and the media guys only presented the same identical arguments that had been already presented and had already failed.

I have just not seen any convincing argument from Knox friendly experts - period.

Sorry, the argument is idiotic.

It is an old irrational pro-Knox mantra, it is old and trite, and it is nonsensical.

It is actually nothing more than a disguised argument of extra-judicial authority based on political influence.

The so-called "well regarded" experts presented arguments only talking in the press, and they presented arguments that can be shown containing falsehoods and omissions. They are simply propaganda.
The fact that Halkides and Hampikian made wild assertions without evidence (like wild claims that Stefanoni "suppressed" e-grams or that they found "contamination"), is a fact, which talks about their neutrality, and should suffice.
The fact that Gill claims Vecchiotti as his main source and makes some proven false claims should suffice.
The fact that the "well regarded" or allegedly "independent" experts only talked in the press and were not cross questioned in the courtroom, should suffice.
The fact that defence experts such as Tagliabracci were equally qualified as the ones you quote, and the fact that all arguments presented were already identical to the ones already presented by the actual defence experts, and the fact that those were simply already found to be scientifically not convincing, should suffice.

Vecchiotti and the media guys only presented the same identical arguments that had been already presented and had already failed.

I have just not seen any convincing argument from Knox friendly experts - period.

You so funny Machiavelli. Who cares about your opinion anyway? The Italian courts obviously don't. Dr. Gill is maybe the world's most renowned DNA forensics expert and we don't see any similarly credentialed DNA experts questioning his findings. Note* his work is peer reviewed. Why do you think that you have any expertise that would make you qualified to suggest that Dr. Halkides or Dr. Hampikian or Dr. Conti or Dr. Vecchiotti? Seriously, tell us about your advanced degrees in Genetics, Forensics, Biology or any science. We'd love to know your qualifications.
 
Last edited:
In general most of the claims about corruption are targeted at the judges finding innocence. Hellman and Marasca. Being Italian you may not realise that judges in other jurisdictions are virtually never accused of corruption (biased yes, corrupt no). That you can believe these judges are corrupt shows a problem with the Italian judicial system. Even the Italian government knows the Italian judicial system needs changing. Cases drag on so long that many are lost under the statutes of limitation. Do not pretend that the Italian judicial system is anywhere near perfect.

And so what?

Btw yes, verdicts commonly believed as corrupt in Italy are most typically acquittals, that's a fact.

However, Hellmann and Marasca are two diferent persons. The terms "corrupt" would have two very different meanings in the two cases.
Hellmann could resemble the typical "corrupt" character in a rather marginal position, but linked to some specific environments. Hellmann was born in Padua and the Hellmann family in Padua are the decendants of one of the founders of the first lodge of the Italian Masonry (the Renier-Hellmann house), in Venice. Hellmann steps into the story following a very unusual event, that is the replacement of the originally appointed President of the Appeals Court, Judge Matteini Chiari.
Marasca instead is a former politician, who, like all people in a position of power, would have to give back some political favours. Marasca represents a typical Italian problem of mingeling between some magistrates and politics which is a toxic factor, because it damages the credibility of innocent magistrates.
It's not that I believe that those people are "corrupt", it's that there is evidence. But in the case of Hellmann and Zanetti there is even stronger evidence of their racist stance, which they openly manifested during the trial and expressed in their verdict.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom