The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
Get serious. Gill's paper is a collection of factoids that can be proven false, contrary to the trial docs. It has almost no contact with the actual trial papers.
Gill does not even cite the fundamental trial documents about DNA evidence within his source list. He does not even cite the cross-hearing of Stefanoni in 2008, nor the cross hearings of Conti & Vecchiotti.

What silliness. The world of forensic-DNA work exists outside of courtrooms.

Indeed, there have never been "trial docs" which have proven anything about Gill's analysis. It is the other way around. Indeed, In Nencini's motivations report, he cites the expert from the RIS Carabinieri who herself in her own testimony to the court, cites Gill as an expert!

1. The world of forensic-DNA analysis is universally critical of Stefanoni's work.

2. You still cannot name one forensic-DNA expert who would support Stefanoni's work, apart from Prof Novelli who confirmed, in court, that Stefanoni had not followed international protocols regarding multiple amplifications.​
It's as simple as that. It's incredible that, at this point 2 1/2 years past the exonerations with neither Hellmann, nor Zanetti, nor Maresca, nor Bruno, nor Guardiano, nor Pistorelli, nor Positabo, nor De Nunzio, nor Knox, nor Sollecito, nor Boninsegna facing any charges to do with the murder (or their rullings on the murder) that anyone would try to make it anything more than.....

...... that Stefanoni's work was junk, and was long since regarded as junk by ALL forensic-DNA experts, including experts within Italy.

Tell you what - take a printout of all that's typed into this thread and take it to a Florence courtroom. It's a mystery to me why you'd want to re-prosecute a definitively settled case like this......

...... on an obscure thread like this one (in the English language) which has seen an 88% reduction in its own activity since the 2015 acquittals. Please note, I did not claim you were not elsewhere pushing your passionately held views.....

.... it's a mystery why you're doing it here.
 
Last edited:
Will you all please remember to address arguments and not arguers. It is permissible to point out falsehoods, lies or errors but it is not permissible to turn this into a chorus of "liar, liar" when aimed at another poster.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Agatha
 
Get serious. Gill's paper is a collection of factoids that can be proven false, contrary to the trial docs. It has almost no contact with the actual trial papers.
Gill does not even cite the fundamental trial documents about DNA evidence within his source list. He does not even cite the cross-hearing of Stefanoni in 2008, nor the cross hearings of Conti & Vecchiotti.

It is published in a peer reviewed journal, the top journal in the field, Forensic Science International: Genetics.

You are spouting propaganda nonsense that anyone with a 3rd grade, non-Italian education can see through with about 5 seconds of thought.

The only people who are disagreeing with Gill and the countless other experts that support innocence are a small handful of idiotic misfits who can't reason their way out of an Italian courtroom.

So again, do you have ONE SINGLE EXPERT ON PLANET EARTH who disagrees with and refutes Dr. Peter Gill, the founding father of modern DNA forensic technology?

Did you really just start your reply with "Get serious"? LOL
 
It is published in a peer reviewed journal, the top journal in the field, Forensic Science International: Genetics.

You are spouting propaganda nonsense that anyone with a 3rd grade, non-Italian education can see through with about 5 seconds of thought.

The only people who are disagreeing with Gill and the countless other experts that support innocence are a small handful of idiotic misfits who can't reason their way out of an Italian courtroom.

So again, do you have ONE SINGLE EXPERT ON PLANET EARTH who disagrees with and refutes Dr. Peter Gill, the founding father of modern DNA forensic technology?

Did you really just start your reply with "Get serious"? LOL

It should end this topic - although I have a feeling it won't - that the RIS Carabinieri themselves cited Dr Peter Gill at the Nencini trial as an expert.

Why should that not end this discussion? What remains missing is the name of one expert who supports Stefanoni's work.
 
What silliness. The world of forensic-DNA work exists outside of courtrooms.

Indeed, there have never been "trial docs" which have proven anything about Gill's analysis. (...) [/B]

Let's be more clear.

Gill writes certain things such as:

"The knife was tested as one item in the middle of a course of 50 or 60 samples attributed to the victim; it was allegedly tested approximately seven days after the last testing of a sample belonging to Kercher."

This is absolutely false, actually before the testing of knife, the machine had tested a continuous row of 106 samples belonging to other cases (nothing to do with the Kercher case). None of such samples presented any sign of contamination from Kercher's DNA.

In the same paragraph Gill says:

"Anti-contamination procedures were not documented (or disclosed); it is unknown if or how surfaces were sterilized; what protective equipment was used; whether equipment was cleaned after each run; or how often technicians changed gloves".

This is also quite ridiculous: Gill simply omits the main sources. He completely omits hearing transcripts and preliminary hearing. In October 2008 preliminary hearing there is a document of about 180 pages mostly about laboratory procedures. Including sterilizing surfaces, etc. Also omits the testimonies of Biondo and Novelli.
Moreover, Gill omits that dr. Potenza did take part to the test sessions, that defence experts were invited to take part to all DNA laboratory tests and that under Italian procedure defence experts have a right to document whatever they want about procedures.
Make no mistake: here Gill is not talking about science. He's talking about effects and methods of legal documentation.

Then Gill even makes the claim that negative controls were missing.
While in fact, they were not missing at all. That was only Vecchiotti's lie.
Negative controls are actually available. They were in the 2008 file. And Nencini's court found them.
 
Last edited:
It is published in a peer reviewed journal, the top journal in the field, Forensic Science International: Genetics.

The problem is that Gill's paper is only a series of factoids that are proven to be factually false, this is manifest to anyone with just some direct knowledge of the trial papers.

The problem is the peer reviewers, apparently simply assumed that Gill was honest and that his data were genuine. While in fact, those are not the real trial facts but only a false narrative presented by Vecchiotti.
 
It should end this topic - although I have a feeling it won't - that the RIS Carabinieri themselves cited Dr Peter Gill at the Nencini trial as an expert.
(...)

The Carabinieri also cited Tagliabracci as a pillar of forensics. But a pillar of science can also tell lies.
It is a fact that Gill's assertions about the case are false. This can be checked against trial files.
 
The Carabinieri also cited Tagliabracci as a pillar of forensics. But a pillar of science can also tell lies.
It is a fact that Gill's assertions about the case are false. This can be checked against trial files.

Machiavelli - Major CC Dr. Andrea Berti was the expert in 2013 from the RIS Carabinieri who cited Dr. Peter Gill to the Nencini court as a world renowned expert.

Please do us all a kindness and contact her, and pass on to us her opinion of his work in this. If you need the link again I can provide it.
 
Let's be more clear.

Gill writes certain things such as:

"The knife was tested as one item in the middle of a course of 50 or 60 samples attributed to the victim; it was allegedly tested approximately seven days after the last testing of a sample belonging to Kercher."

This is absolutely false, actually before the testing of knife, the machine had tested a continuous row of 106 samples belonging to other cases (nothing to do with the Kercher case). None of such samples presented any sign of contamination from Kercher's DNA.

In the same paragraph Gill says:

"Anti-contamination procedures were not documented (or disclosed); it is unknown if or how surfaces were sterilized; what protective equipment was used; whether equipment was cleaned after each run; or how often technicians changed gloves".

This is also quite ridiculous: Gill simply omits the main sources. He completely omits hearing transcripts and preliminary hearing. In October 2008 preliminary hearing there is a document of about 180 pages mostly about laboratory procedures. Including sterilizing surfaces, etc. Also omits the testimonies of Biondo and Novelli.
Moreover, Gill omits that dr. Potenza did take part to the test sessions, that defence experts were invited to take part to all DNA laboratory tests and that under Italian procedure defence experts have a right to document whatever they want about procedures.
Make no mistake: here Gill is not talking about science. He's talking about effects and methods of legal documentation.

Then Gill even makes the claim that negative controls were missing.
While in fact, they were not missing at all. That was only Vecchiotti's lie.
Negative controls are actually available. They were in the 2008 file. And Nencini's court found them.

Machiavelli - Major CC Dr. Andrea Berti was the expert in 2013 from the RIS Carabinieri who cited Dr. Peter Gill to the Nencini court as a world renowned expert.

Please do us all a kindness and contact her, and pass on to us her opinion of what you've said about this.
 
The Cassazione did not invent anything. This particular point is a finding of facts by other courts.
Well, they did. Chieffi for example simply ruled the break in couldn't be real because Meredith Kercher would have been alerted by the noise of the breaking window, simply taking for granted that she was in the house when the break in happened, not even taking into consideration the more likely scenario: "Guede broke into the cottage before Meredith Kecher came home..."

And even Marasca and Bruno had to invent things to confirm the calunnia conviction for Knox (page 21):
Ed invero, un'eventuale pronuncia della Corte europea favorevole alla stessa Knox, nel senso auspicato del riconoscimento di un poco ortodosso trattamento degli investigatori nei suoi confronti, non potrebbe in alcun modo scalfire il giudicato interno, neppure in vista di possibile revisione della sentenza, consid,erato che le calunniose accuse che la stessa imputata rivolse al Lumumba, per effetto delle asserite coercizioni, sono state da lei confermate anche innanzi al Pm, in sede di interrogatorio, dunque in un contesto, istituzionalmente, immune da anomale pressioni psicologiche; e sono state confermate anche nel memoriale a sua firma, in un momento in cui la stessa accusatrice era sola con sé stessa e la sua coscienza, in condizioni di oggettiva tranquillità, al riparo da condizionamenti ambientali; e furono persino ribadite, dopo qualche tempo, in sede di convalida dell'arresto del Lumumba, innanzi al Gip procedente.
Too bad, that the session in front of Judge Matteini was recorded...

Hellmann is a pig, nothing is honest with him, he's a filthy bastard, and a racist, but also for other reasons not just because of this case.
I'm really interested in what those "other reasons" are...
 
What difference does the forensics surrounding the knife make at this point. It was officially not ruled the murder weapon by the Italian courts. Definitively and for all time.

The main reason the knife isn't the murder weapon anyway is because the murder weapon left clear identifiable features in the stab wounds and the bloody imprint and they were much too small to fit that gigantic cleaver.
 
Well, they did. Chieffi for example simply ruled the break in couldn't be real because Meredith Kercher would have been alerted by the noise of the breaking window, simply taking for granted that she was in the house when the break in happened, not even taking into consideration the more likely scenario: "Guede broke into the cottage before Meredith Kecher came home..."

You are mistifying, and not reporting truthfully. But above all, you are changing topic. I was talking about the panel that ruled about Sollecito.
Chieffi reports from Massei, and actually lists a number of points (so it doesn't say "because it would be alerted", but says "they found.. because of a number of reasons" and lists some).
The high Court usually makes a few material errors reporting from lower courts, this is normal; and Massei's point about the break in staging is very articulated. But the 4th does note make an error on the point reporting from lower courts about Sollecito.


Bruno and Marasca are the only ones who actually make up a real big load of things. For example they make up that the data of Meredith's and Sollecito's computer drives were destroyed (false) and that they could have been useful as evidence (false), that small amounts of DNA cannot be amplified (false), and that there are items with untested microscopic DNA samples (false) and that there are no other items to test (false), or that Knox's contact with Meredith's body would have left detectable DNA traces (false), or that scientific international protocols existed that were violated (false).
They also make up their own assessment of Quintavalle and Curatolo (delusional) and violate the points of law established by Chieffi (definitive, still valid: contamination must be proven, evidence cannot be parceled out...).
But M/B are actually not making it up themselves: they are copying and pasting them from the second Sollecito's defensive submission.
 
The main reason the knife isn't the murder weapon anyway is because the murder weapon left clear identifiable features in the stab wounds and the bloody imprint and they were much too small to fit that gigantic cleaver.

The knife matches the bloody impring perfectly. It's quite impressive actually.

On the other hand, the size of blade of bloody imprint itself does not match *one* of the wounds.

The stab wounds are inhomogeneous and indicate the use of two weapons.
 
His secret file on the mason conspiracy :D

I'm not so sure about that. The problem seems to be, that digging deeper and deeper into this case, will turn you into a conspiracy theorist.

My take is, that Hellmann and every judge after him simply turned to "damage control mode" (Nencini just followed Chieffi's order to convict). And even the final verdict and the one denying compensaton to Sollecito read like:"Yes, they aren't the murderers of Meredith Kercher BUT it's their fault that the fine, qualified and completely unbiased investigators suspected and arrested them, it's their fault that they were convicted (not the fact that the prosecution witheld vital information until way into the trial). In the end it looks like "Italy" wanted to get rid of this case, but without investigating the investigators, there are promotions and medals to keep...
 
Machiavelli - Major CC Dr. Andrea Berti was the expert in 2013 from the RIS Carabinieri who cited Dr. Peter Gill to the Nencini court as a world renowned expert.

Please do us all a kindness and contact her, and pass on to us her opinion of what you've said about this.

"he", Andrea is a man.

No, Bill. I've got nothing to say to Andrea Berti. I'm not you. I look for facts.
I talk about facts not about what people say about some other people.
The he-said authority fallacy belongs to Bill-Williams logic.

I may contact Gill instead, show him the docs that contradict his asseritions and ask him why he wrote this ******** in his article. But that would be a waste of my time, because I'm not interested in what a non-neutral expert says.
Let's just show why Gill's statements are false.
 
You involved, I guess...

No. And I don't live in his area.

And I'm also talking about his behaviour and methods, not just about his verdicts.

I also have further information on him but I don't feed the curiosity of the pro-Knoxes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom