Bill Williams
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Nov 10, 2011
- Messages
- 15,715
Get serious. Gill's paper is a collection of factoids that can be proven false, contrary to the trial docs. It has almost no contact with the actual trial papers.
Gill does not even cite the fundamental trial documents about DNA evidence within his source list. He does not even cite the cross-hearing of Stefanoni in 2008, nor the cross hearings of Conti & Vecchiotti.
What silliness. The world of forensic-DNA work exists outside of courtrooms.
Indeed, there have never been "trial docs" which have proven anything about Gill's analysis. It is the other way around. Indeed, In Nencini's motivations report, he cites the expert from the RIS Carabinieri who herself in her own testimony to the court, cites Gill as an expert!
1. The world of forensic-DNA analysis is universally critical of Stefanoni's work.
2. You still cannot name one forensic-DNA expert who would support Stefanoni's work, apart from Prof Novelli who confirmed, in court, that Stefanoni had not followed international protocols regarding multiple amplifications.
It's as simple as that. It's incredible that, at this point 2 1/2 years past the exonerations with neither Hellmann, nor Zanetti, nor Maresca, nor Bruno, nor Guardiano, nor Pistorelli, nor Positabo, nor De Nunzio, nor Knox, nor Sollecito, nor Boninsegna facing any charges to do with the murder (or their rullings on the murder) that anyone would try to make it anything more than.....2. You still cannot name one forensic-DNA expert who would support Stefanoni's work, apart from Prof Novelli who confirmed, in court, that Stefanoni had not followed international protocols regarding multiple amplifications.
...... that Stefanoni's work was junk, and was long since regarded as junk by ALL forensic-DNA experts, including experts within Italy.
Tell you what - take a printout of all that's typed into this thread and take it to a Florence courtroom. It's a mystery to me why you'd want to re-prosecute a definitively settled case like this......
...... on an obscure thread like this one (in the English language) which has seen an 88% reduction in its own activity since the 2015 acquittals. Please note, I did not claim you were not elsewhere pushing your passionately held views.....
.... it's a mystery why you're doing it here.
Last edited: