Stacyhs
Penultimate Amazing
Massei let the defence have the point of the time of the phone call, because wisely, he determined it did not change the 'guilty' verdict and gave the defence one less thing to appeal against.
Nencini reinstated the correct time, which police officers Battistelli and Marsi recorded promptly the same day they arrived back at the police station, as being 12:35, and this is backed up by the CCTV time on the carpark camera, even if adjusted as being ten minutes fast or slow.
It is a fact Raff did not call the police until circa 12:47.
The phone logs and the CCTV camera are inanimate objective evidence to the fact of the matter.
Let's look at the facts, including the phone logs.
Fact: phone records show RS called his sister at 12:50 and the police at 12:51 and 12:54 (not "circa 12:46)
Fact: Officers Marzi and Battistelli claimed they arrived between 12:25 and 12:35. If this were true, they were there when Raff made the three calls yet they witnessed none of them. Nor did they say Raff was not with them at some time before Filomena and the others arrived.
Fact: Amanda also speaks on the phone with Filomena and calls her mother during the time the two cops claimed they were there. They also testified they did not witness any of these calls either. So, five phones calls go unwitnessed by the two cops when they claim to have been there. Are they blind and deaf or simply wrong?
Fact: The two officers claim they were with RS and AK for about 30 minutes before Filomena and her friend arrived. What were they talking about for a full half hour when the two officers said they only had a quick look around before the others arrived?
This is why Massei and Helllmann found the calls were made before the postales arrived. Now, let's look at Nencini's "reasoning" for reversing that.
Nencini claims that there were "six people present, not including the suspects" when the door was broken down and that this is when RS allegedly snuck off to call the carabinieri at 12:51 and 12:54. Those six people were the two policemen, Filomena Romanelli, Paola Grande, Marco Zaroli, and Luca Altieri.
However, phone records show that it was impossible for either Zaroli or Altieri to have been at the cottage at 12:51. Zaroli's phone records place him at his house at 12:46 when he called Altieri. He then explained to Altieri what Filomena had told him and that she wanted him to meet her at the cottage. Altieri then had to drive to Zaroli's place and pick him up before then driving to the cottage. All this in 5 minutes? Impossible. Filomena, Grande, Altieri and Zaroli all placed their arrival at the cottage at around 1:00, not before. So Nencini's claim that that they were all there when Kercher's door was broken down and that's when Sollecito snuck off to make the 12:51 call is contradicted by the facts. But then again, he is the same judge who wrote Raff's blood was found on the knife. Only it wasn't.
They couldn't even toe the official line (such as it is) without slipping up with this blatant mistake revealing their corruption to anyone not drowning in guilter koolaid.