The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
Massei let the defence have the point of the time of the phone call, because wisely, he determined it did not change the 'guilty' verdict and gave the defence one less thing to appeal against.

Nencini reinstated the correct time, which police officers Battistelli and Marsi recorded promptly the same day they arrived back at the police station, as being 12:35, and this is backed up by the CCTV time on the carpark camera, even if adjusted as being ten minutes fast or slow.

It is a fact Raff did not call the police until circa 12:47.

The phone logs and the CCTV camera are inanimate objective evidence to the fact of the matter.

Let's look at the facts, including the phone logs.

Fact: phone records show RS called his sister at 12:50 and the police at 12:51 and 12:54 (not "circa 12:46)

Fact: Officers Marzi and Battistelli claimed they arrived between 12:25 and 12:35. If this were true, they were there when Raff made the three calls yet they witnessed none of them. Nor did they say Raff was not with them at some time before Filomena and the others arrived.

Fact: Amanda also speaks on the phone with Filomena and calls her mother during the time the two cops claimed they were there. They also testified they did not witness any of these calls either. So, five phones calls go unwitnessed by the two cops when they claim to have been there. Are they blind and deaf or simply wrong?


Fact: The two officers claim they were with RS and AK for about 30 minutes before Filomena and her friend arrived. What were they talking about for a full half hour when the two officers said they only had a quick look around before the others arrived?

This is why Massei and Helllmann found the calls were made before the postales arrived. Now, let's look at Nencini's "reasoning" for reversing that.

Nencini claims that there were "six people present, not including the suspects" when the door was broken down and that this is when RS allegedly snuck off to call the carabinieri at 12:51 and 12:54. Those six people were the two policemen, Filomena Romanelli, Paola Grande, Marco Zaroli, and Luca Altieri.

However, phone records show that it was impossible for either Zaroli or Altieri to have been at the cottage at 12:51. Zaroli's phone records place him at his house at 12:46 when he called Altieri. He then explained to Altieri what Filomena had told him and that she wanted him to meet her at the cottage. Altieri then had to drive to Zaroli's place and pick him up before then driving to the cottage. All this in 5 minutes? Impossible. Filomena, Grande, Altieri and Zaroli all placed their arrival at the cottage at around 1:00, not before. So Nencini's claim that that they were all there when Kercher's door was broken down and that's when Sollecito snuck off to make the 12:51 call is contradicted by the facts. But then again, he is the same judge who wrote Raff's blood was found on the knife. Only it wasn't.
 
Knox also lied about the soft-drug use in the cottage. This particular one was the leverage Ficarra used when late on Nov 5, Ficarra said to Knox, "It's time for truth." The genius cops then proceeded to mistake complete ignorance for how the crime had been committed for lying about it.

Filomena Romanelli lied through her teeth under oath when she coyly admitted to having "sinned once" smoking weed. Once? Sheesh.
 
Sorry dude, this makes no sense. Truly, it doesn't.

But why are you even doing this on a thread which (on this topic) has declined by 88% since the 2015 acquittals, and in the English language?

Shouldn't you be emboldened by the 4th Chambers motivation report, and take all this to a Florence courtroom where the conspiracy can finally be rooted out?

Why do you even care if some random ENGLISH LANGUAGE poster to an obscure irrelevant thread may or may not be lying?

1. Quit talking about the poster.

2. You have no information about what I do in other forums or venues as a term of comparison with my posting here and you are in no position to talk about that.

3. You look annoyed that I busted your lie
 
Filomena Romanelli lied through her teeth under oath when she coyly admitted to having "sinned once" smoking weed. Once? Sheesh.

Speaking of leverage, Filomena's legal career depended on her playing ball with the prosecution. Although it's dangerous for anyone to speculate on her silence since testifying in 2009 - silence through the subsequent twists and double reversals - IMO it's clear she got out of this relatively unscathed.

She was lucky to have escaped charges for removing her own laptop from a crimescene, one that she later turned in to the Questura, lawyer in tow.

She'd told no lies about the soft drug use that both Laura and Amanda hadn't told; probably the same with the boys downstairs. It's just that the lies were leveraged differently by the cops.
 
Machiavelli,
Since you are back, could you address the following? Vixen does not seem to be able to, as we have asked her dozens of times and it is continually glossed over:

One would think that if the forensic science used to provisionally convict at the Massei level were robust and accurate, there would be several well-regarded forensic scientists, geneticists, molecular biologists, etc. (something, anything) in 2017 that would have spoken out and explained that the work done by Stefanoni et al. was correct. There are none. All of the independent forensic scientists (many of whom are regarded as the best in the field) have given talks, published papers, published book chapters that have clearly and concisely explained why the evidence was faulty and analyzed incorrectly, thus there is zero forensic evidence Amanda and Raffaele were at the murder scene. (at least, that seems to be the conclusion of a mentally sane person.)

What is your explanation for this? (....)

Sorry, the argument is idiotic.

It is an old irrational pro-Knox mantra, it is old and trite, and it is nonsensical.

It is actually nothing more than a disguised argument of extra-judicial authority based on political influence.

The so-called "well regarded" experts presented arguments only talking in the press, and they presented arguments that can be shown containing falsehoods and omissions. They are simply propaganda.
The fact that Halkides and Hampikian made wild assertions without evidence (like wild claims that Stefanoni "suppressed" e-grams or that they found "contamination"), is a fact, which talks about their neutrality, and should suffice.
The fact that Gill claims Vecchiotti as his main source and makes some proven false claims should suffice.
The fact that the "well regarded" or allegedly "independent" experts only talked in the press and were not cross questioned in the courtroom, should suffice.
The fact that defence experts such as Tagliabracci were equally qualified as the ones you quote, and the fact that all arguments presented were already identical to the ones already presented by the actual defence experts, and the fact that those were simply already found to be scientifically not convincing, should suffice.

Vecchiotti and the media guys only presented the same identical arguments that had been already presented and had already failed.

I have just not seen any convincing argument from Knox friendly experts - period.
 
Last edited:
This is an ignorant statement by someone who simply has no grasp of the basics of law.

Let's be clear.

The B/M court had no interest in contemplating decided, "done and dusted" judicial truths/facts. They were not permitted to do this by law. Given then that they were concentrating their efforts on the task at hand why would they venture down an avenue of enquiry prohibited by law?

BS.

All of this is invented.

The one who has no grasp of basic law is you.

What you are arguing is that an appeal court charged with law is sidetracked to contemplate facts for absolutely no gain and about which they can do nothing.

We know how long the court took to justifiably throw the convictions into the legal rubbish bin, and you're suggesting that the Italian Appeal Court meandered down avenues of irrelevancy.

You talk nonsense.
There is no institution called "Italian Appeal Court".
 
Sure, it's irrelevant that your highest court is inventing easily disproven transparently false evidence out of thin air not in any of the standing court rulings. You would like to believe that wouldn't you? This surely bodes well for the rest of their conclusions.

You hate Hellmann so much, he's the only judge in this entire case that doesn't make your entire country's judicial system look like a pack of morons.

The Cassazione did not invent anything. This particular point is a finding of facts by other courts.

Hellmann is a pig, nothing is honest with him, he's a filthy bastard, and a racist, but also for other reasons not just because of this case.
 
Sorry, the argument is idiotic.

It is an old irrational pro-Knox mantra, it is old and trite, and it is nonsensical.

It is actually nothing more than a disguised argument of extra-judicial authority based on political influence.

The so-called "well regarded" experts presented arguments only talking in the press, and they presented arguments that can be shown containing falsehoods and omissions. They are simply propaganda.
The fact that Halkides and Hampikian made wild assertions without evidence (like wild claims that Stefanoni "suppressed" e-grams or that they found "contamination"), is a fact, which talks about their neutrality, and should suffice.
The fact that Gill claims Vecchiotti as his main source and makes some proven false claims should suffice.
The fact that the "well regarded" or allegedly "independent" experts only talked in the press and were not cross questioned in the courtroom, should suffice.
The fact that defence experts such as Tagliabracci were equally qualified as the ones you quote, and the fact that all arguments presented were already identical to the ones already presented by the actual defence experts, and the fact that those were simply already found to be scientifically not convincing, should suffice.

Vecchiotti and the media guys only presented the same identical arguments that had been already presented and had already failed.

I have just not seen any convincing argument from Knox friendly experts - period.

We can take this response as verification that you cannot name a single forensic-DNA expert who supports Stefanoni's work. Thanks for this admission.

Would you care to comment on the technical aspects of the following link?

http://www.fsigenetics.com/article/S1872-4973(16)30033-3/abstract

Highlights
•The miscarriages of justice of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito are described.
•A knife recovered from a cutlery drawer was purported to be the murder weapon.
•A bra-clasp found in the murder room was alleged to have DNA from a defendant.
•Transfer of DNA found on the evidential material was either contamination or ‘innocent’.
•The final judgement exonerated the defendants and the reasons are explored.​
 
BS.

All of this is invented.

The one who has no grasp of basic law is you.



You talk nonsense.
There is no institution called "Italian Appeal Court".

Oh for goodness sake.

Read one of my earlier posts. In SA it's called the SCA (Supreme Court of Appeal) and matters not one iota what it's called it is still an Italian court of appeal.

Maybe if I'd written in lower case I wouldn't received another ignorant response.
 
We can take this response as verification that you cannot name a single forensic-DNA expert who supports Stefanoni's work.

Any serious expert - (by the term serious I also mean serious about the case) - would either be silent, or only talk in the courtroom in a cross questioning and in his report deposited with the court.

Those who talk in tv shows are by definition non-serious, and non-experts in the case.

Novelli, an international expert, did act seriously, and was convincing.
 
Oh for goodness sake.

Read one of my earlier posts. In SA it's called the SCA (Supreme Court of Appeal) and matters not one iota what it's called it is still an Italian court of appeal.

Maybe if I'd written in lower case I wouldn't received another ignorant response.

You have no grasp of what you are talking about. It's not my fault.
 
Any serious expert - (by the term serious I also mean serious about the case) - would either be silent, or only talk in the courtroom in a cross questioning and in his report deposited with the court.

Those who talk in tv shows are by definition non-serious, and non-experts in the case.

Novelli, an international expert, did act seriously, and was convincing.

Novelli told the court that Stefanoni had not followed international protocols with regard to multiple amplifications.

But thank you for confirming there is no forensic-DNA expert in the world willing to vouch for Stefanoni's work.
 
The Cassazione did not invent anything. This particular point is a finding of facts by other courts.

Hellmann is a pig, nothing is honest with him, he's a filthy bastard, and a racist, but also for other reasons not just because of this case.

Which standing court is it a fact from? The same ones that say the kitchen knife was the murder weapon wielded by Knox? Which were all overturned on her acquittal?

There is no way to salvage this. It's almost as if there's systemic incompetence which lead to the wrongful convictions in the first place and has appeared again in their wrongful compensation ruling :boggled: They couldn't even toe the official line (such as it is) without slipping up with this blatant mistake revealing their corruption to anyone not drowning in guilter koolaid.

Pretend I'm a third party observer Mach. I see Raff was acquitted of murder, I see he was denied compensation for the time he spent in prison, I see in the reasons they cite evidence which was was overturned as part of his acquittal.

I'm sure if the courts had a do over they would gladly go back in time and remind M&B to slip the 112 calls into the report, but they didn't. It was never part of the original findings under Massei, and the Nencini ruling was obliterated.

All these clowns needed to do was say "he lied during his interrogation" and they just couldn't manage even that simple task. Just lol.
 
Lol! Thank you for the well reasoned response, Machiavelli.

Sorry, the argument is idiotic.

What "argument"? I am asking why you don't have a single professional expert that espouses your view. Not a single one. You seem to think that isn't a problem?

It is an old irrational pro-Knox mantra, it is old and trite, and it is nonsensical.

Hang on. It is "nonsensical" to point out literally ALL of the professional forensic scientists support the fact that the forensic evidence was faulty and supports innocence of Amanda and Raffaele? So like, you are seriously saying science is nonsensical and Massei is the ultimate authority on forensic truth?

It is actually nothing more than a disguised argument of extra-judicial authority based on political influence.

No, this is where the lack of sanity starts to seep in. We say "all science supports our side". You say "it's because they are all paid off and/or influenced politically". We say "huh? that sounds like you are off your meds". Then you say "you're appealing to extra-judicial authority!!!" Like, somehow a handful of corrupt Italian judges supersedes expert forensic scientists, on uh, matters of forensic science. What planet are you from? Oh yeah Italy.

The so-called "well regarded" experts presented arguments only talking in the press, and they presented arguments that can be shown containing falsehoods and omissions. They are simply propaganda.

You are legit kinda nuts. "Only talking in the press"? They've been published in the most highly regarded forensic science journals. Peer reviewed, rubber stamped, proven correct. You literally cannot get a higher refutation of Stefanoni's DNA work. YOU are the one engaging in propaganda.

The fact that Halkides and Hampikian made wild assertions without evidence (like wild claims that Stefanoni "suppressed" e-grams or that they found "contamination"), is a fact, which talks about their neutrality, and should suffice.

This has all been proven true and documented. You are living in an alternative version of reality where proven facts are not actually facts but "wild assertions" simply because you don't like the implications. Then you accuse the professionals of propaganda. Because you know, nuts.

The fact that Gill claims Vecchiotti as his main source and makes some proven false claims should suffice.

Documentation. It's called documentation, Machiavelli. Gill referred to Stefanoni's documentation to learn what she did/didn't do. And he was able to critique that because Gill invented the technique used on the knife blade and is known as one of the founding fathers of modern forensic DNA technology. This is how science works, Machiavelli.

The fact that the "well regarded" or allegedly "independent" experts only talked in the press and were not cross questioned in the courtroom, should suffice.

Pure straight up lunacy. As I said above, they have published papers in the top peer reviewed journals and published books. This isn't "the press". They weren't cross examined in the court room because they were not invited to be expert witnesses in the court room (as they uh, are on a different continent). The independent Italian experts that DID testify supported innocence. Remember, lol?

The fact that defence experts such as Tagliabracci were equally qualified as the ones you quote, and the fact that all arguments presented were already identical to the ones already presented by the actual defence experts, and the fact that those were simply already found to be scientifically not convincing, should suffice.

A quote from Tagliabracci:

"It was moved by somebody, we don't know how, and it's possible that it was turned upside down," said Adriano Tagliabracci, a genetic expert who took the stand Tuesday for the defense. "How can we be certain that that is a reliable exhibit?"

Like, I ask you for a single expert that supports your side, and you mention a defense expert that supports innocence. You really are in a whole other reality on this aren't you?

Vecchiotti and the media guys only presented the same identical arguments that had been already presented and had already failed.

"Failed"? Amanda and Raffaele were declared innocent and are free. What the f?

I have just not seen any convincing argument from Knox friendly experts - period.

1) Luckily every sane person, including all professional forensic science experts and the Italian Supreme Court, emphatically disagree with you.

2) Have you thought about submitting your refutation of Peter Gill's work to have it peer reviewed and published in Forensic Science International: Genetics? You can present the argument here first and see how it holds up. :)
 
Last edited:
Novelli told the court that Stefanoni had not followed international protocols with regard to multiple amplifications.

But thank you for confirming there is no forensic-DNA expert in the world willing to vouch for Stefanoni's work.

Absolutely not. I do not confirm any foolish or nonsensical assertion from you.

You cannot demonstrate anything about what any other expert would say or vouch for if called to court.

On the other hand, it is proven that the theories of experts like Gill about the case are just riddled with proven falsehoods and errors. It is proven that none of those pro-Knox speakers is capable of making an argument based on actual trial facts, they all need to resort to a set of imagined data of their invention.
That the pro-Knox "esperts" behave like clowns, this is the only proven thing.
 
You are legit kinda nuts. "Only talking in the press"? They've been published in the most highly regarded forensic science journals. Peer reviewed, rubber stamped, proven correct. You literally cannot get a higher refutation of Stefanoni's DNA work. YOU are the one engaging in propaganda.

Get serious. Gill's paper is a collection of factoids that can be proven false, contrary to the trial docs. It has almost no contact with the actual trial papers.
Gill does not even cite the fundamental trial documents about DNA evidence within his source list. He does not even cite the cross-hearing of Stefanoni in 2008, nor the cross hearings of Conti & Vecchiotti.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom