The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
Massei let the defence have the point of the time of the phone call, because wisely, he determined it did not change the 'guilty' verdict and gave the defence one less thing to appeal against.

Nencini reinstated the correct time, which police officers Battistelli and Marsi recorded promptly the same day they arrived back at the police station, as being 12:35, and this is backed up by the CCTV time on the carpark camera, even if adjusted as being ten minutes fast or slow.

It is a fact Raff did not call the police until circa 12:47.

The phone logs and the CCTV camera are inanimate objective evidence to the fact of the matter.

The important issue is they failed to keep contemporaneous notes. Writing down what time they thought they arrived after the fact, particularly given all the subsequent events means this can be nothing more than a guess.

One issue raised in court was the lack of contemporaneous recording by the investigating officer. Anyone ever involved with a major incident will tell you that constructing a time line after the event is almost impossible. This is why things like radio logs, pocket books etc. are essential.

What we do know from CCTV is where the carabinieri were at 12.48 and it was not at the flat.
 
The important issue is they failed to keep contemporaneous notes. Writing down what time they thought they arrived after the fact, particularly given all the subsequent events means this can be nothing more than a guess.

One issue raised in court was the lack of contemporaneous recording by the investigating officer. Anyone ever involved with a major incident will tell you that constructing a time line after the event is almost impossible. This is why things like radio logs, pocket books etc. are essential.

What we do know from CCTV is where the carabinieri were at 12.48 and it was not at the flat.

Battistelli used the old-fashioned method...of looking at his watch.

It is no great feat of memory for a policeman to remember a key time.

They are trained to routinely note certain facts.
 
Battistelli used the old-fashioned method...of looking at his watch.

It is no great feat of memory for a policeman to remember a key time.

They are trained to routinely note certain facts.

So when he looked at his watch he was attending a routine inquiry about a lost phone. Not very important. Why should he even note the time he arrived? Other members of the household arrive he has to remember these times as well.

Then it gets all more complex, a dead body is found, suddenly he has to secure a murder scene - yet he still does not take contemporaneous notes. A whole lot more times to remember, the time of discovery of the body, who he called, when, the time of arrival of subsequent police units, the paramedics (remember he says he did not check the body for signs of life, or cannot recall doing so though eyewitnesses saw him doing so). This is a lot of times to keep straight under stress!

How many times do you think he could keep in his head until documenting them hours later? How good is his memory if he could not remember checking the body for signs of life? Is it possible he mis-remembered?

There is a reason why police are instructed to keep contemporaneous notes.
 
So when he looked at his watch he was attending a routine inquiry about a lost phone. Not very important. Why should he even note the time he arrived? Other members of the household arrive he has to remember these times as well.

Then it gets all more complex, a dead body is found, suddenly he has to secure a murder scene - yet he still does not take contemporaneous notes. A whole lot more times to remember, the time of discovery of the body, who he called, when, the time of arrival of subsequent police units, the paramedics (remember he says he did not check the body for signs of life, or cannot recall doing so though eyewitnesses saw him doing so). This is a lot of times to keep straight under stress!

How many times do you think he could keep in his head until documenting them hours later? How good is his memory if he could not remember checking the body for signs of life? Is it possible he mis-remembered?

There is a reason why police are instructed to keep contemporaneous notes.

This is because on returning to the police station he has to file a report, together with the time. This he did. He filed a report the same day.

As of that time, the kids were not under any suspicion. The cops had no motive to lie.

The kids had every motive. And they did. They lied and lied and lied, and have no alibi.
 
I note particularly the highlighted part above, repeated here:

If you fail to bring in relevant evidence at the trial stage then that is your error.

This is the stage where the facts are found and assessed.​
Cassazione ruled in 2015 that this was exactly what the convicting judge failed to do, it had failed to bring in relevant evidence which put either Knox or Sollecito in the murder room at the time of the murder.

This is false.

Bruno/Marasca did put Knox in the murder room at the time of the murder.
And you know it.
The same panel also stated that almost certainly also Sollecito was there.
The Court only alleged that they might have had a "non punishable complicity" possibly without taking "active" participation to the "killing action".

This is what B/F says.
 
This is because on returning to the police station he has to file a report, together with the time. This he did. He filed a report the same day.

As of that time, the kids were not under any suspicion. The cops had no motive to lie.

The kids had every motive. And they did. They lied and lied and lied, and have no alibi.

The time of arrival of Postal Police is irrelevant to the conclusion. It is not even worth to focus on the point.
The courts correctly pointed out that Sollecito lied on everything.

The latest motivations report also reminds that it is a judicial fact that Knox was at the scene of murder when Meredith was killed.
 
The time of arrival of Postal Police is irrelevant to the conclusion. It is not even worth to focus on the point.
The courts correctly pointed out that Sollecito lied on everything.

The latest motivations report also reminds that it is a judicial fact that Knox was at the scene of murder when Meredith was killed.

Welcome back Machiavelli.

Any court creating those kinds of "judicial facts" is completely irrelevant. No one was charged with being present while a crime was being committed.

That this is a point you hammer away at, proves the poverty of anything else you might claim.

But with you back we're guaranteed to get to Continuation 50!
 
Last edited:
This is false.

Bruno/Marasca did put Knox in the murder room at the time of the murder.
And you know it.
The same panel also stated that almost certainly also Sollecito was there.
The Court only alleged that they might have had a "non punishable complicity" possibly without taking "active" participation to the "killing action".

This is what B/F says.

LOL! The next few threads will sure be entertaining!

What I know? I know that it is sad that this sort of thing has to be argued on an English language website which (on this topic) has experienced an 88% reduction in traffic since the acquittals 2 1/2 years ago! Please answer this - WHAT POSSIBLE GOOD IS IT THAT YOU POST THESE THEORIES H-E-R-E??????

This is also what I know. People have to do contortions of language and translation to make the quotes below mean something other than their plain-text meaning:
Marasca-Bruno said:
9.3 During the analysis of the aforementioned elements of evidence, it is certainly useful to remember that, taking for granted that the murder occurred in via della Pergola, the alleged presence at the house of the defendants cannot, in itself, be considered as proof of guilt.​
Any further and more meaningful value would be, in fact, resisted by the fact - which is decisive - that no trace leading to her was found at the scene of the crime or on the victim’s body, so that - if all the above is accepted - her contact with the victim’s blood would have occurred after the crime and in another part of the house.​
I will sit in amusement resisting the urge to go through this merry-go-round again.
 
Welcome back Machiavelli.

Any court creating those kinds of "judicial facts" is completely irrelevant. No one was charged with being present while a crime was being committed.
(...)

Ok I take this as your admission that you have been caught lying.

This was wht you wrote:

[/INDENT][/I]
Cassazione ruled in 2015 that this was exactly what the convicting judge failed to do, it had failed to bring in relevant evidence which put either Knox or Sollecito in the murder room at the time of the murder.

What you wrote is a lie.

What I wrote is the truth.

You shift on presenting your own personal assessment that the fact is "irrelevant", skipping the stage of admitting the fact is true, therby implicitly you admit that what I say is the truth (and you lied)
 
This is also what I know. People have to do contortions of language and translation to make the quotes below mean something other than their plain-text meaning:

I will sit in amusement resisting the urge to go through this merry-go-round again.

The plain text meaning is fully clear by phrases such as "dato conclamato", "connivenza non punibile", etc.

Your quoted translations are inaccurate, but in addition to that you even appear to twist the meaning of your own English translation (not even your inaccurate translation disproves what I say).
 
You shift on presenting your own personal assessment that the fact is "irrelevant", skipping the stage of admitting the fact is true, therby implicitly you admit that what I say is the truth (and you lied)
Sorry dude, this makes no sense. Truly, it doesn't.

But why are you even doing this on a thread which (on this topic) has declined by 88% since the 2015 acquittals, and in the English language?

Shouldn't you be emboldened by the 4th Chambers motivation report, and take all this to a Florence courtroom where the conspiracy can finally be rooted out?

Why do you even care if some random ENGLISH LANGUAGE poster to an obscure irrelevant thread may or may not be lying?
 
The time of arrival of Postal Police is irrelevant to the conclusion. It is not even worth to focus on the point.

Sure, it's irrelevant that your highest court is inventing easily disproven transparently false evidence out of thin air not in any of the standing court rulings. You would like to believe that wouldn't you? This surely bodes well for the rest of their conclusions.

You hate Hellmann so much, he's the only judge in this entire case that doesn't make your entire country's judicial system look like a pack of morons.
 
Battistelli used the old-fashioned method...of looking at his watch.

It is no great feat of memory for a policeman to remember a key time.

They are trained to routinely note certain facts.

Total nonsense. You are simply asserting something without proving it. Very typical of you Vixen. Police are no different than anyone else where time seems to move faster and slower depending on their activity. Without viewing some kind of timepiece and logging it their perception of time becomes totally unreliable. Perhaps the average officer is better than the general public but there is no real evidence to prove this and there certainly is no way to know if the individual officers are better or worse than the average officer let alone the average citizen.
 
This is false.

Bruno/Marasca did put Knox in the murder room at the time of the murder.
And you know it.
The same panel also stated that almost certainly also Sollecito was there.
The Court only alleged that they might have had a "non punishable complicity" possibly without taking "active" participation to the "killing action".

This is what B/F says.

This is an ignorant statement by someone who simply has no grasp of the basics of law.

Let's be clear.

The B/M court had no interest in contemplating decided, "done and dusted" judicial truths/facts. They were not permitted to do this by law. Given then that they were concentrating their efforts on the task at hand why would they venture down an avenue of enquiry prohibited by law?

What you are arguing is that an appeal court charged with law is sidetracked to contemplate facts for absolutely no gain and about which they can do nothing.

We know how long the court took to justifiably throw the convictions into the legal rubbish bin, and you're suggesting that the Italian Appeal Court meandered down avenues of irrelevancy.

Puhleeezee!!
 
Sure, it's irrelevant that your highest court is inventing easily disproven transparently false evidence out of thin air not in any of the standing court rulings. You would like to believe that wouldn't you? This surely bodes well for the rest of their conclusions.

You hate Hellmann so much, he's the only judge in this entire case that doesn't make your entire country's judicial system look like a pack of morons.

You have to give the 4th Chambers of Cassazione one thing. They did not dust off the, "Raffaele's DNA was found on the knife," factoid - ah, er, judicial-factoid - that Judge Nencini included in his 2014 motivations report.

That judicial-factoid would have been far far more relevant in putting Raffaele in the room - even if no one actually proved that that knife itself had ever been in the room, much less at the cottage.

But considering that the 4th Chambers was pulling judicial-factoids out of the Cassazione toilet on the banks of the Tiber, they should have at least put Raffaele's DNA on to the knife - if for no other reason than to be consistent.
 
This is because on returning to the police station he has to file a report, together with the time. This he did. He filed a report the same day.

As of that time, the kids were not under any suspicion. The cops had no motive to lie.

The kids had every motive. And they did. They lied and lied and lied, and have no alibi.

Yet again Vixen bangs on about Amanda and Raffaele lying and Machiavelli said Raffaele lied about everything. If someone attacked someone for lying and deliberately set out to be as hypocritical as possible, these are the things you would do :-

• Attack someone for lying whilst lying on an industrial scale yourself.
• Attack someone for lying whilst you feel it is perfectly acceptable to use lies against the person you are attacking for lying and only regard lying as a problem if lies benefit the person you are attacking but are too dishonest to admit this.
• Attack someone for lying whilst spreading lies about the person you are attacking for lying.
• Attack someone for lying while spreading nasty and malicious lies about people.
• Attack someone for lying who has been who has on numerous occasions have had had lies spread about them and lies used against them and totally ignoring this fact.
• Attack someone for lying whilst on numerous occasions defending people who have lied.
• Attack someone for lying whilst falsely accusing them of lying.
• Say that someone would not need to lie if they were innocent of a crime whilst having to resort to lying to argue for that person’s guilt.
• Attacking someone for lying whilst making excuses for other people’s lies.

The above is exactly what PGP do when they attack Amanda for lying. The below is from a previous post showing how hypocritical PGP are when they attack Amanda and Raffaele. The next time Vixen bangs on about Amanda and Raffaele telling umpteen lies, Vixen should consider Amanda and Raffaele have never done any of the things below. I have given an example below where Vixen falsely accused Amanda of lying. If Amanda and Raffaele are such prolific liars why do PGP have to resort to inventing instances where Amanda and Raffaele lied? When it comes to Vixen it is not necessary to invent instances of Vixen lying because there are plenty of genuine instances to draw on. Vixen boasts she has done a psychology degree. I wonder what people with genuine expertise in psychology would say about people who habitually lie and support liars whilst viciously attacking people for lying. Would this be regarded as a sign of mental illness.

" As can be seen from the posts below, there are numerous instances where Vixen has used falsehoods in her posts. PGP constantly bang on about Amanda and Raffaele telling umpteen lies whilst telling umpteen lies in their posts.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com...2#post11938562
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...2#post11942852
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...2#post11598412
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...1#post11427461
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...3#post11951893
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...3#post11669633

• PGP have spread lies about Amanda and Raffaele. As can be seen from the examples above, PGP have spread lies about Amanda and Raffaele eg Amanda showed no grief over the death of Meredith, Amanda was taking 300 euros daily from her bank account, Raffaele was off his head.

• There are numerous instances when PGP have lied, supported liars and ignored lies as can be seen from the post below.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com...3#post11333243

• PGP lie by giving the impression they oppose lying in general when in reality they only oppose lying when it works in Amanda and Raffaele’s favour and support lying when it works against Amanda and Raffaele. PGP feel it is perfectly acceptable to use lies against Amanda and Raffaele. This can be seen from the way PGP defend those who spread lies about Amanda and Raffaele such as the prosecution and witnesses who blatantly lied such as Quintavelle.

• There are numerous instances where people have told lies about Amanda and Raffaele and lies have been used against Amanda and Raffaele. There are several instances where witnesses have lied against Amanda and Raffaele, the prosecution fed false information to the media, Amanda was lied to she had HIV. For some reason you will never hear Vixen banging on about the umpteen occasions people have lied about Amanda and Raffaele and lies have been used against them.

• PGP have spread malicious falsehoods about people such as Hellman being bribed, defence experts have used photoshop, C&V released a DVD only available to the defence.

• PGP have falsely accused Amanda and Raffaele of lying. The post below is one example.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com...5#post11849235

• I recall Vixen saying that an innocent person would not need to lie which implied that Amanda would not need to resort to lying if she was innocent when PGP have to resort to lying to argue the case for Amanda’s guilt.

• PGP make excuses for people’s lies. When Nencini lied in his motivation report that Raffaele’s DNA was on the knife, Vixen made an excuse for this lie by saying it was a typing error.

• PGP come up with Walter Mitty stories about their intelligence and qualifications they have achieved.
 
Last edited:
Machiavelli,
Since you are back, could you address the following? Vixen does not seem to be able to, as we have asked her dozens of times and it is continually glossed over:

One would think that if the forensic science used to provisionally convict at the Massei level were robust and accurate, there would be several well-regarded forensic scientists, geneticists, molecular biologists, etc. (something, anything) in 2017 that would have spoken out and explained that the work done by Stefanoni et al. was correct. There are none. All of the independent forensic scientists (many of whom are regarded as the best in the field) have given talks, published papers, published book chapters that have clearly and concisely explained why the evidence was faulty and analyzed incorrectly, thus there is zero forensic evidence Amanda and Raffaele were at the murder scene. (at least, that seems to be the conclusion of a mentally sane person.)

What is your explanation for this? Vixen has stated that all of the forensic scientists that have spoken out in favor of Amanda and Raf's case were paid off by, I think, Donald Trump (perhaps others). But, as crazy as that by itself sounds, it doesn't address the fact that no OTHER forensic scientists have spoken out in favor of the work of the Italian investigators and Stefanoni. I mean, maybe in crazy bizarro world or on some episode of the Twilight zone Donald Trump is writing checks to the likes of Bruce Budowle and Peter Gill to write false papers about DNA evidence to protect some rando from Seattle. But why has no other professional spoken out to correct this travesty? Did Donald Trump call a secret Freemason meeting, inviting all forensic geneticists in the world, and explicitly tell them no one was to correct the narrative? How much did that cost him, in your opinion?
 
Machiavelli,
Since you are back, could you address the following? Vixen does not seem to be able to, as we have asked her dozens of times and it is continually glossed over:

One would think that if the forensic science used to provisionally convict at the Massei level were robust and accurate, there would be several well-regarded forensic scientists, geneticists, molecular biologists, etc. (something, anything) in 2017 that would have spoken out and explained that the work done by Stefanoni et al. was correct. There are none. All of the independent forensic scientists (many of whom are regarded as the best in the field) have given talks, published papers, published book chapters that have clearly and concisely explained why the evidence was faulty and analyzed incorrectly, thus there is zero forensic evidence Amanda and Raffaele were at the murder scene. (at least, that seems to be the conclusion of a mentally sane person.)

What is your explanation for this? Vixen has stated that all of the forensic scientists that have spoken out in favor of Amanda and Raf's case were paid off by, I think, Donald Trump (perhaps others). But, as crazy as that by itself sounds, it doesn't address the fact that no OTHER forensic scientists have spoken out in favor of the work of the Italian investigators and Stefanoni. I mean, maybe in crazy bizarro world or on some episode of the Twilight zone Donald Trump is writing checks to the likes of Bruce Budowle and Peter Gill to write false papers about DNA evidence to protect some rando from Seattle. But why has no other professional spoken out to correct this travesty? Did Donald Trump call a secret Freemason meeting, inviting all forensic geneticists in the world, and explicitly tell them no one was to correct the narrative? How much did that cost him, in your opinion?

Machiavelli has sworn these phantom experts to secrecy, so that they can be called upon the next time someone goes in a Florence court to start the ball rolling.

That will be the beginning of the end for the Masonic-funded, American media conspiracy which bought off De Nunzio, Hellmann, Zanetti, Bruno and Marasca.

Machiavelli does not believe in prosecutorial disclosure, and he's waiting for a guarantee that these phantom experts will not even be cross examined.

Such is the length one needs to go when persecuting a Seattle language-nerd, and has to sacrifice Raffaele on the altar of necessity.
 
Yet again Vixen bangs on about Amanda and Raffaele lying and Machiavelli said Raffaele lied about everything. If someone attacked someone for lying and deliberately set out to be as hypocritical as possible, these are the things you would do :-

• Attack someone for lying whilst lying on an industrial scale yourself.
• Attack someone for lying whilst you feel it is perfectly acceptable to use lies against the person you are attacking for lying and only regard lying as a problem if lies benefit the person you are attacking but are too dishonest to admit this.
• Attack someone for lying whilst spreading lies about the person you are attacking for lying.
• Attack someone for lying while spreading nasty and malicious lies about people.
• Attack someone for lying who has been who has on numerous occasions have had had lies spread about them and lies used against them and totally ignoring this fact.
• Attack someone for lying whilst on numerous occasions defending people who have lied.
• Attack someone for lying whilst falsely accusing them of lying.
• Say that someone would not need to lie if they were innocent of a crime whilst having to resort to lying to argue for that person’s guilt.
• Attacking someone for lying whilst making excuses for other people’s lies.

The above is exactly what PGP do when they attack Amanda for lying. The below is from a previous post showing how hypocritical PGP are when they attack Amanda and Raffaele. The next time Vixen bangs on about Amanda and Raffaele telling umpteen lies, Vixen should consider Amanda and Raffaele have never done any of the things below. I have given an example below where Vixen falsely accused Amanda of lying. If Amanda and Raffaele are such prolific liars why do PGP have to resort to inventing instances where Amanda and Raffaele lied? When it comes to Vixen it is not necessary to invent instances of Vixen lying because there are plenty of genuine instances to draw on. Vixen boasts she has done a psychology degree. I wonder what people with genuine expertise in psychology would say about people who habitually lie and support liars whilst viciously attacking people for lying. Would this be regarded as a sign of mental illness.

" As can be seen from the posts below, there are numerous instances where Vixen has used falsehoods in her posts. PGP constantly bang on about Amanda and Raffaele telling umpteen lies whilst telling umpteen lies in their posts.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com...2#post11938562
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...2#post11942852
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...2#post11598412
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...1#post11427461
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...3#post11951893
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...3#post11669633

• PGP have spread lies about Amanda and Raffaele. As can be seen from the examples above, PGP have spread lies about Amanda and Raffaele eg Amanda showed no grief over the death of Meredith, Amanda was taking 300 euros daily from her bank account, Raffaele was off his head.

• There are numerous instances when PGP have lied, supported liars and ignored lies as can be seen from the post below.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com...3#post11333243

• PGP lie by giving the impression they oppose lying in general when in reality they only oppose lying when it works in Amanda and Raffaele’s favour and support lying when it works against Amanda and Raffaele. PGP feel it is perfectly acceptable to use lies against Amanda and Raffaele. This can be seen from the way PGP defend those who spread lies about Amanda and Raffaele such as the prosecution and witnesses who blatantly lied such as Quintavelle.

• There are numerous instances where people have told lies about Amanda and Raffaele and lies have been used against Amanda and Raffaele. There are several instances where witnesses have lied against Amanda and Raffaele, the prosecution fed false information to the media, Amanda was lied to she had HIV. For some reason you will never hear Vixen banging on about the umpteen occasions people have lied about Amanda and Raffaele and lies have been used against them.

• PGP have spread malicious falsehoods about people such as Hellman being bribed, defence experts have used photoshop, C&V released a DVD only available to the defence.

• PGP have falsely accused Amanda and Raffaele of lying. The post below is one example.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com...5#post11849235

• I recall Vixen saying that an innocent person would not need to lie which implied that Amanda would not need to resort to lying if she was innocent when PGP have to resort to lying to argue the case for Amanda’s guilt.

• PGP make excuses for people’s lies. When Nencini lied in his motivation report that Raffaele’s DNA was on the knife, Vixen made an excuse for this lie by saying it was a typing error.

• PGP come up with Walter Mitty stories about their intelligence and qualifications they have achieved.

Precisely Welshman. The only lies I can actually identify from Amanda are those where she falsely suggests (timidly so with no confidence) that Patrick was involved in the murder. Untruths which she rescinds almost immediately. OTOH, almost on a daily basis Vixen posts demonstrably falsehoods with impunity. And Vixen never seems to admit to these falsehoods. No, she just recycles them on a later date.
 
Precisely Welshman. The only lies I can actually identify from Amanda are those where she falsely suggests (timidly so with no confidence) that Patrick was involved in the murder. Untruths which she rescinds almost immediately. OTOH, almost on a daily basis Vixen posts demonstrably falsehoods with impunity. And Vixen never seems to admit to these falsehoods. No, she just recycles them on a later date.

Knox also lied about the soft-drug use in the cottage. This particular one was the leverage Ficarra used when late on Nov 5, Ficarra said to Knox, "It's time for truth." The genius cops then proceeded to mistake complete ignorance for how the crime had been committed for lying about it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom