The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
The Motivational Report explaining the Supreme Court's upholding of Raff's denial of any compensation is now published.

http://momentolegislativo.it/ingius...a-sezione-penale-sentenza-n-42014-del-28-giu/

INJURY DETERMINATION - REPRESENTATION, MISSING AND CONTRADICTING STATEMENTS - LEGALITY OF DIFFICULT CHOICE - CASE LAW - Court of Cassation, Fourth Criminal Section, judgment no. 42014 of 28 June 2017
09/15/2017

The fourth criminal section of the Court of Cassation with judgment no. 42014 of 28 June 2017 in the case of the application for compensation for unjust imprisonment dismissed the applicant's claim on the assumption that the suspicious, lying and contradictory declarations, while being legitimate defensive choices, have a negative impact and constitute the existence of a lawsuit to the recognition of the right to repair, since with such behavior the subject contributes with serious or gross negligence upon the issue and the continuation of the maximum precautionary measure
 
Wow!!! Just, wow!!! This is exactly why you cling to falsehoods. Incredulous statement as highlighted above.

It's fine to perpetuate a falsehood as long as it's underpinned by a legal stamp.

For you the world is still flat.

I said nothing of the sort.

I was underlying the importance of the trial court.

If you fail to bring in relevant evidence at the trial stage then that is your error.

This is the stage where the facts are found and assessed.

The onus is on you to present your case and your evidence.

If you do not, you are subject to the whims of the appeal court who will almost certainly dismiss any late evidence on the grounds you should have mentioned it at the trial.

In other words, if the kids are innocent as you claim, it was up to them to successfully refute the prosecution's evidence. They did not. The evidence was deemed to show beyond a reasonable doubt that the pair were guilty as charged at a very high bar.

If anyone is blinkered by delusion, it is you.
 
I said nothing of the sort.

I was underlying the importance of the trial court.

If you fail to bring in relevant evidence at the trial stage then that is your error. This is the stage where the facts are found and assessed. The onus is on you to present your case and your evidence.

If you do not, you are subject to the whims of the appeal court who will almost certainly dismiss any late evidence on the grounds you should have mentioned it at the trial.

In other words, if the kids are innocent as you claim, it was up to them to successfully refute the prosecution's evidence. They did not. The evidence was deemed to show beyond a reasonable doubt that the pair were guilty as charged at a very high bar.

If anyone is blinkered by delusion, it is you.

I note particularly the highlighted part above, repeated here:

If you fail to bring in relevant evidence at the trial stage then that is your error.

This is the stage where the facts are found and assessed.​
Cassazione ruled in 2015 that this was exactly what the convicting judge failed to do, it had failed to bring in relevant evidence which put either Knox or Sollecito in the murder room at the time of the murder.

In fact, Cassazione ruled that what the Nencini court had proven was:

Any further and more meaningful value would be, in fact, resisted by the fact - which is decisive - that no trace leading to her was found at the scene of the crime or on the victim’s body, so that - if all the above is accepted - her contact with the victim’s blood would have occurred after the crime and in another part of the house.​
In short, both the prosecution and the convicting court, "fail(ed) to bring in relevant evidence at the trial stage". In fact, what the 2013-14 prosecution actually proved was that Knox/Sollecito were in the cottage after the crime and in other rooms, something which no one disputes.

This is why it annulled the convictions, as Cassazione in 2015 said:
9.4.3. It can easily be observed that the conclusion that there was a lack of an evidentiary framework consistent and sufficient to support the prosecution’s hypothesis regarding the more serious case of murder certainly reverberates on the residual, secondary accusations, listed here, d) theft of cellular phones and e) simulation of a crime.

10. The intrinsic contradictory nature of the evidence, emerging from the text of the appealed verdict, in essence undermines the connective tissue of the same, leading to its annulment.
In fact, in the presence of a scenario marked by many contradictions, the referral judge should not have come to a verdict of guilt, but - as previously observed – should have reached a verdict of not guilty, given Article 530, section 2, Italian Code of Criminal Procedure.​
All of this is completely in line with your claim that:

If you fail to bring in relevant evidence at the trial stage then that is your error.

This is the stage where the facts are found and assessed.​
As this was Nencini's basic error, Cassazione in 2015 corrected it.

Next.
 
Last edited:
:p
Apparently, Vixen is unaware of the appeal to authority fallacy.

Of that it is abundantly clear.

One would expect a Mensa member winning grandmaster games; who also has friends and relatives in all conceivable fields of expertise, would be able to draw on her (or his) enormous reservoir of resources to know that quoting a story such as Noah's Ark is not the truth just because it's written in the "ultimate book".

Which reminds me...who did pull the plug to let the water out? ...or did it evaporate? Mind you Mr Magic man can do anything he (or she) wants, including conjuring up a flood to kill everything when all he (or she) had to do was wave a wand. ...who on earth would believe this claptrap...Vixen??? Nah not even her.
 
I said nothing of the sort.

I was underlying the importance of the trial court.

If you fail to bring in relevant evidence at the trial stage then that is your error.

This is the stage where the facts are found and assessed. The onus is on you to present your case and your evidence. If you do not, you are subject to the whims of the appeal court who will almost certainly dismiss any late evidence on the grounds you should have mentioned it at the trial.

In other words, if the kids are innocent as you claim, it was up to them to successfully refute the prosecution's evidence. They did not. The evidence was deemed to show beyond a reasonable doubt that the pair were guilty as charged at a very high bar.

If anyone is blinkered by delusion, it is you.

Oh please! More nonsense! The most recent interchange we had is this. Judicial truth vs reality.

No court hearing alters truth. It may alter verdict but not truth. Bringing evidence to court does not alter fact.

Which is why there is such a thing as an appeal.

The facts are:-
The DNA evidence in this case is rubbish.
Selective DNA cleanup is impossible.
There is no evidence of the AK or RS being in MK's room at anytime, let alone the murder night.
There is nothing (not one thing) leading the two to being suspects, let alone being charged.

...and when you say you "said nothing of the sort" I suggest you reread what you wrote again. You said exactly what I said you did. Exactly.

...and another error (there are so many). It is certainly NOT "...up to them to successfully refute the prosecution's evidence." What drivel. The burden of proof rests with the prosecution, and the defence, if it so wishes, need say absolutely nothing in a trial. No evidence needs no refute...and there is no evidence AT ALL.

Good Day, ma'am
 
Last edited:
...and another error (there are so many). It is certainly NOT "...up to them to successfully refute the prosecution's evidence." What drivel. The burden of proof rests with the prosecution, and the defence, if it so wishes, need say absolutely nothing in a trial. No evidence needs no refute...and there is no evidence AT ALL.

Good Day, ma'am

I'm following a case in Canada where the defence took that line. The defence declined to call many exculpatory witnesses or present exculpatory evidence because it did not think that the prosecution had made a case.

Except that against all reason (IMNSHO) the judge-alone trial convicted. I'm not a lawyer, but the "Reason for Judgement" that the judge wrote, IMV, supports a scenario where the judge had cherry-picked very thin damning evidence, against all sorts of other scenarios which could have just as easily explained things.....

.... but at appeal, it was not good for the defence - at that level - to cite evidence which had been available to them at trial, but they chose not to bring it back then. Correct me if I'm wrong, but even in a case that had been thin at best for the prosecution, the defence still needs to roll the dice on how it proceeds.

IMV that had been a factor in this series of trials. The defence in 2008 often operated as if the P.M. (Mignini) would see reason and simply let them go after a year. In 2009 the defence sometimes operated as if the court (Massei) would see reason and not convict.

It was a case of actual-factual innocence working against the defence, in that the temptation was to think that eventually sober minds would end all this.

Sober minds tried ending this in Oct 2011, and then the final sober mind ended this definitively in Mar 2015. But a lot of damage had been done in the meantime - no more so than the victim's family who had to endure it all.

BTW - what do you think of TJMK writing to lawyers associations and law schools, claiming that Knox is lying when she says that she and Sollecito were definitively acquitted in 2015?

Is there anyone on the planet, other than the usual nutters, who believe that?
 
The Motivational Report explaining the Supreme Court's upholding of Raff's denial of any compensation is now published.

http://momentolegislativo.it/ingius...a-sezione-penale-sentenza-n-42014-del-28-giu/


contrary to what the Solicitation claimed, he called the Carabinieri at least ten minutes after the arrival at the crime scene by the postal police,

Lol they're inventing facts not even in any of the standing court rulings. If they were going to dig up annulled Nencini findings why not just say the kitchen knife was the murder weapon wielded by Knox. No need to be coy.

I'm not sure what the procedural rules are here. Are they allowed to use findings from annulled courts? If so how do they pick which annulled court to use? Nencini bought the postal police early arrival, Hellmann and Massei did not, they seemed to have chosen a clear loser here.

One thing however is certain, say what you will about American judges, they know how to read a clock. I believe it is taught around Kindergarten or possibly even preschool.
 
I'm following a case in Canada where the defence took that line. The defence declined to call many exculpatory witnesses or present exculpatory evidence because it did not think that the prosecution had made a case.

Except that against all reason (IMNSHO) the judge-alone trial convicted. I'm not a lawyer, but the "Reason for Judgement" that the judge wrote, IMV, supports a scenario where the judge had cherry-picked very thin damning evidence, against all sorts of other scenarios which could have just as easily explained things.....

.... but at appeal, it was not good for the defence - at that level - to cite evidence which had been available to them at trial, but they chose not to bring it back then. Correct me if I'm wrong, but even in a case that had been thin at best for the prosecution, the defence still needs to roll the dice on how it proceeds.

IMV that had been a factor in this series of trials. The defence in 2008 often operated as if the P.M. (Mignini) would see reason and simply let them go after a year. In 2009 the defence sometimes operated as if the court (Massei) would see reason and not convict.

It was a case of actual-factual innocence working against the defence, in that the temptation was to think that eventually sober minds would end all this.

Sober minds tried ending this in Oct 2011, and then the final sober mind ended this definitively in Mar 2015. But a lot of damage had been done in the meantime - no more so than the victim's family who had to endure it all.

BTW - what do you think of TJMK writing to lawyers associations and law schools, claiming that Knox is lying when she says that she and Sollecito were definitively acquitted in 2015?

Is there anyone on the planet, other than the usual nutters, who believe that?

You are absolutely right, Bill. It's bad to advise passivity as a defence. The problem with defending the innocent is that they are often the victims of being naive. Innocent people get convicted and when you're charged you better believe they're coming to get you, "I know I'm innocent so others will realize this" is often a bad strategy.

Innocent people should fight a case as though they are guilty. The problem with this is that they can appear guilty. The right to silence is a classic example. Defendants are very often advised not to take to the witness stand lest they fall prey to their naivety. They then run the risk of perception. Why wouldn't an innocent answer questions in the dock? He's hiding something, he's guilty.

It's a very bad place to be when you're innocent and charged.

In the AK/RS there are so many things that went wrong for the AK/RS. Acccess to a lawyer at the outset was the biggest mistake of all. But having read some of the trial translations it's a comedy show. Leading the witness. Answering your own questions on behalf of the accused.

Not my circus, not my clowns.
 
Yes, it is a legal/judicial fact, but those are the facts that matter.

For example, if a court decides a man is a child's father, it matters not a jot if the real truth is that a dastardly rogue swapped samples over at DNA testing, as that is the way the child will now proceed through life. (Subject to the devilish plot never coming to light.)

Lovely impassioned soliloquy, though.

I can't believe what I just read. In essence, what you are claiming is that factual truth is irrelevant and all that matters is what a court decides. In your world, once a court rules, the innocent should just sit back and shut up because their innocence is not important.

Mach informed me. I had thought Hellmann was a noble family (it is in Sweden) and he put me straight.

Ah, I see...Mach told you. And what is his source? It should be rather obvious to you (or one would think it should be) that "Mach told me" is not a credible citation. Nor is "I read somewhere". How very Trumpensian.


The onus is on you to present your case and your evidence.


I almost spit my wine out when I read that. Try and remember this statement of yours the next time you tell me, or anyone else, to "go look it up" when you are requested to provide a citation for a claim.
 
Last edited:
You are absolutely right, Bill. It's bad to advise passivity as a defence. The problem with defending the innocent is that they are often the victims of being naive. Innocent people get convicted and when you're charged you better believe they're coming to get you, "I know I'm innocent so others will realize this" is often a bad strategy.

Innocent people should fight a case as though they are guilty. The problem with this is that they can appear guilty. The right to silence is a classic example. Defendants are very often advised not to take to the witness stand lest they fall prey to their naivety. They then run the risk of perception. Why wouldn't an innocent answer questions in the dock? He's hiding something, he's guilty.

It's a very bad place to be when you're innocent and charged.

In the AK/RS there are so many things that went wrong for the AK/RS. Acccess to a lawyer at the outset was the biggest mistake of all. But having read some of the trial translations it's a comedy show. Leading the witness. Answering your own questions on behalf of the accused.

Not my circus, not my clowns.

I agree. This is exactly what happened to RS and AK.

Raff did not testify and this is seen by the PGP as a sign of guilt. Of course, the fact he has blue eyes, likes pizza, and breathes oxygen is a sign of guilt to the PGP.

Amanda has said that she always expected the first court to acquit right up to the reading of the verdict in 2009. She believed they would recognize the truth of her innocence because she was innocent. It never occurred to her that the police saw her as a suspect in the first place because she had done nothing wrong. Sweet, sweet naivete!
 
Lol they're inventing facts not even in any of the standing court rulings. If they were going to dig up annulled Nencini findings why not just say the kitchen knife was the murder weapon wielded by Knox. No need to be coy.

I'm not sure what the procedural rules are here. Are they allowed to use findings from annulled courts? If so how do they pick which annulled court to use? Nencini bought the postal police early arrival, Hellmann and Massei did not, they seemed to have chosen a clear loser here.

One thing however is certain, say what you will about American judges, they know how to read a clock. I believe it is taught around Kindergarten or possibly even preschool.

Well, if this goes to ECHR then I think the fact that the court quotes false evidence such as calling the Carabinieri after the arrival of the postal police something that has been disproven, will be important.

The Italian judicial system does seem to suffer from a mix of incompetence and corruption.
 
Yes, it is a legal/judicial fact, but those are the facts that matter.
For example, if a court decides a man is a child's father, it matters not a jot if the real truth is that a dastardly rogue swapped samples over at DNA testing, as that is the way the child will now proceed through life. (Subject to the devilish plot never coming to light.)

Lovely impassioned soliloquy, though.

I can't believe what I just read. In essence, what you are claiming is that factual truth is irrelevant and all that matters is what a court decides. In your world, once a court rules, the innocent should just sit back and shut up because their innocence is not important.

This kind of attitude isn't surprising from a devoted Christian. It's why I left the church. Unlike Vixen, I care ONLY about the ACTUAL Facts.
Court rulings don't tell us what actually happened and or th real truth. This is why Science wins over religion and it is why Amanda and Raffaele were ultimately acquitted. A court decided it couldn't justify imprisoning two young innocents to confirm some judicial truths.
 
This kind of attitude isn't surprising from a devoted Christian. It's why I left the church. Unlike Vixen, I care ONLY about the ACTUAL Facts.
Court rulings don't tell us what actually happened and or th real truth. This is why Science wins over religion and it is why Amanda and Raffaele were ultimately acquitted. A court decided it couldn't justify imprisoning two young innocents to confirm some judicial truths.

The whole reason law courts came into being is because of parties disputing the facts.

In important matters such as property and inheritance rights, the only way to settle these disputes was by arbitration.

The earliest courts as we know it, said to have been originated in Sweden, was for twelve peers of the parties to hear the dispute and come to a decision as to which party was in the right, or more in the right.

The Anglo-Saxon system on which UK/US law is predicated is one of barter. You cut off my ear in a sword fight, I take six of your sheep as compensation, an early form of personal injury claim, if you like.

If a person is murdered, the relatives were allowed to claim recompense, which could lead to quite barbaric punishment.

Deprive the crown or mutiny, and you could expect to be hanged, as were pirates routinely at Marshalsea.

A concept of habeas corpus was recognised, i.e., a right for a defendant to have a 'hearing' (to put his case in person one's own defence, before a court).

So what more can a court of law do than try to determine the facts of a case from evidence, witnesses, testimony, exhibits from all parties to the case.

People lie, deceive, commit fraud and perjury.

However, this is the whole point of cross-examination and the right to disclosure in advance of the hearing, in order to prepare a rebuttal.

By your criteria criminals are supposed to walk free in crimes which are committed under the cloak of secrecy just because no independent person witnessed it, and even if they did, how can we know the witness is reliable.

ETA In addition, it's thanks to Christianity we have a civilised justice system, based as it it on the ancient Jewish concept of there needing to be at least two witnesses before God before a thing could be a legal fact. For example in marriage or divorce.
 
Last edited:
Well, if this goes to ECHR then I think the fact that the court quotes false evidence such as calling the Carabinieri after the arrival of the postal police something that has been disproven, will be important.

The Italian judicial system does seem to suffer from a mix of incompetence and corruption.

Massei let the defence have the point of the time of the phone call, because wisely, he determined it did not change the 'guilty' verdict and gave the defence one less thing to appeal against.

Nencini reinstated the correct time, which police officers Battistelli and Marsi recorded promptly the same day they arrived back at the police station, as being 12:35, and this is backed up by the CCTV time on the carpark camera, even if adjusted as being ten minutes fast or slow.

It is a fact Raff did not call the police until circa 12:47.

The phone logs and the CCTV camera are inanimate objective evidence to the fact of the matter.
 
Massei let the defence have the point of the time of the phone call, because wisely, he determined it did not change the 'guilty' verdict and gave the defence one less thing to appeal against.

Nencini reinstated the correct time, which police officers Battistelli and Marsi recorded promptly the same day they arrived back at the police station, as being 12:35, and this is backed up by the CCTV time on the carpark camera, even if adjusted as being ten minutes fast or slow.

It is a fact Raff did not call the police until circa 12:47.

The phone logs and the CCTV camera are inanimate objective evidence to the fact of the matter.

cctv_021107_1248.png


Here's how to read a clock. The number "12:48" is a time. The "12" represents the hour. The "48" represents the minute. In this instance the clock reads "twelve forty-eight." Feel free to pass on this preschool lesson to the Italian judges.
 
[qimg]http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/cctv_021107_1248.png[/qimg]

Here's how to read a clock. The number "12:48" is a time. The "12" represents the hour. The "48" represents the minute. In this instance the clock reads "twelve forty-eight." Feel free to pass on this preschool lesson to the Italian judges.

Is that the characteristic stripe of the Carabinieri on that trouser leg?
 
By your criteria criminals are supposed to walk free in crimes which are committed under the cloak of secrecy just because no independent person witnessed it, and even if they did, how can we know the witness is reliable.

What a complete load of tripe. No one is advocating the kind of "criteria" for criminals that your skewed imagination conjures.

Your reasoning is that you deem someone a criminal first, then condemn others for pointing out the lack of evidence. Your reasoning is, why would you want a criminal to walk merely for lack of evidence.

What a waste of keystrokes.
 
Last edited:
Blah...blah....blah..

By your criteria criminals are supposed to walk free in crimes which are committed under the cloak of secrecy just because no independent person witnessed it, and even if they did, how can we know the witness is reliable.

ETA In addition, it's thanks to Christianity we have a civilised justice system, based as it it on the ancient Jewish concept of there needing to be at least two witnesses before God before a thing could be a legal fact. For example in marriage or divorce.

I can't stand reading your nonsense. There are a lot more systems of law than those. You almost never know what the hell you're talking about. And this is no exception. But I'm not going to bother correcting all these dumb remarks.

You also don't have a clue what my criteria is. No one saw Rudy commit this crime and there is more than enough evidence to convict him. I didn't see Jody Arias or Pistorius or Charles Campbell or OJ Simpson and the evidence they all committed the crime is quite compelling.

Like it or not, there simply is no credible compelling evidence against Amanda or Raffaele and they are free due to that fact. What's moronic is this tilting at windmills and you twisting the facts in a case that resulted in the kids acquittal.

No evidence means NOT GUILTY. Get use to it.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom