Read the following slowly and carefully, Try reading it out loud:
You'll get there in the end.
I was one of the first to point out how contradictory Appeal Courts can be to those unfamiliar with certain judicial systems. A country with such a system is Italy (and my own country South Africa which is based on Roman Dutch Law). As far as I know Scotland is the only other country in the world with similar legal heritage.
It was reported at first translation of the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA - I think ISC in Italy but it matters not) finding that Amanda was indeed in the house at the time of the murder, etc., etc.. The guilters gloated and a good many truthers were confounded.
...but it's actually rationally simple and I repeat it once again, primarily so that it might sink into Vixen's somewhat impermeable head.
The Supreme Court of Appeal is legally dispassionate and unconcerned with regard to judicial facts as found in the trial court. If the Supreme Court of Appeal repeats such facts it is because they are bound by them, regardless of the reality of truth.
Now, many expected that were the SCA finding to go in AK/RS favour it would be on the basis of a referral down to lower courts for reassessment of contradictions or inconsistencies.
The crushing blow to the prosecution, however, was the finding that EVEN TAKING ON BOARD THE ABSURDITIES (as clearly spelt out by the SCA) of the the lower convicting court it is impossible IN LAW (capitals because this is the essence of understanding) to convict on the basis of zero evidence to suggest that the accused were in the murder room AT ALL EVER...never mind not on the murder night. Therefore no referral down could possibly bridge the quantum leap required to convict where absence of presence is a fact but one ignored by the lower courts.
It is central to the understanding of the legal process to digest the difficulty of the Supreme Court of Appeal. If facts were to be reassessed this would regarded as a retrial in countries such as Italy (and I am not arguing this in relation to legal systems outside of Italy) and appeals are not going there (double jeopardy, etc.).
The reason the SCA was so easily able to trounce the prosecutions case is this. (Read carefully please Vixen and pass it on to your fellow cronies...Ergo, PQ and their horrible ilk)...
Verdicts by the lower courts have to follow logically from judicial truths. A verdict of guilty must be supported by the judicial facts. It cannot be that the link from judicial fact to verdict is illogical. This is not a dispute of fact (judicial). It is a dispute of LAW.
...and disputes of law are within the realm of the SCA finding.
Now stop repeating nonsense, Vixen. I have told you how it works. If you think I'm wrong debate the role of the SCA. Otherwise stop spreading nonsense. It's damaging to you and to those to whom your wrongful assertions are directed. It's wanton and willful slander and reflects poorly on you.