The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
For newcomers to the case (!) you might link to responsible news outlets that show Hellmann was disgraced.
Or you might not.

Don't you know that Hellmann had the hots for the "acquiescent" Knox? And the fact (Ok...claim) that he was spotted driving a Ferrari..or was it a Lamborghini?...after the trial is enough proof for me! He was bought off!
 
Don't you know that Hellmann had the hots for the "acquiescent" Knox? And the fact (Ok...claim) that he was spotted driving a Ferrari..or was it a Lamborghini?...after the trial is enough proof for me! He was bought off!

Hellmann's parents were stoned hippies, and Hellmann respectfully declined when Hampikian offered to take him river rafting.
 
He married into Italian gentry. He is one of the chinless wonders who got into law because he was well-connected, but dim.

He wasn't even a criminal law judge.

Citation please. Like that will ever happen. BTW, from a source other than TJMK, TMoMK, or the last remaining PMF.

While you're at it, please provide a link to a forensic-DNA expert who agrees with Stefanoni's work.

Also, while you're at it, provide a link to the actual evidence that says Knox rubbed blood from her hands. Note, not a judicial truth about this, but the evidence which was presented in court.

If not, please also accept the judicial truth that RS and AK were acquitted in 2015.
 
When you're filling in biographies for every single living person that once did something positive for a random American girl you know your position must be one of reason :rolleyes: I'm so thankful I don't know who Mignini married or what Nencini's uncle did.
 
When you're filling in biographies for every single living person that once did something positive for a random American girl you know your position must be one of reason :rolleyes: I'm so thankful I don't know who Mignini married or what Nencini's uncle did.
Mignini's parents were stoned hippies. Nencini divorced after rafting with Stefanoni. Or was it the other way around?

It's why we have Vixen. To keep us up to date.
 
He married into Italian gentry. He is one of the chinless wonders who got into law because he was well-connected, but dim.

He wasn't even a criminal law judge.

Yea...and Nina's parents are hippie stoners just like Charles Manson and Hampikian marriage fell apart because Amanda went on a white where rafting trip with him and Noah built an Ark.

Always making crap up.
 
He married into Italian gentry. He is one of the chinless wonders who got into law because he was well-connected, but dim.

He wasn't even a criminal law judge.

Citation for these claims please? Can you mention anyone who doesn't think Knox and Sollecito are psychopathic scum without denigrating/insulting them in some way on a personal level? You sling insulting claims that you have absolutely no way of backing up with any evidence other than your own..well... I don't know exactly what to call it without breaking ISF rules.

I see good old PQ was in fine form suggesting that "big bucks and rogue masons" were somehow responsible for Hellmann's being assigned to the case. How utterly Trumpensian.

Could you please give the citation for Guede grabbing the towels out of the "bathroom closet"? After all, it's only fair since it was requested first. Not that any of us really expect you to give citations for that or for your claims above.

Have you ever thought of writing fiction? I think you may be rather good at it. You have a vivid imagination and a certain way with words. And there's always ebooks so no need for a real publisher which makes it so easy now days. Almost anyone can be published. After all, if NvdL can try and sell his "work" online, there's no reason you can't be as least as successful.
 
Last edited:
Citation for these claims please? Can you mention anyone who doesn't think Knox and Sollecito are psychopathic scum without denigrating/insulting them in some way on a personal level? You sling insulting claims that you have absolutely no way of backing up with any evidence other than your own..well... I don't know exactly what to call it without breaking ISF rules.

I see good old PQ was in fine form suggesting that "big bucks and rogue masons" were somehow responsible for Hellmann's being assigned to the case. How utterly Trumpensian.

Could you please give the citation for Guede grabbing the towels out of the "bathroom closet"? After all, it's only fair since it was requested first. Not that any of us really expect you to give citations for that or for your claims above.

Vixen said:
He wasn't even a criminal law judge.
Citation please. Like that will ever happen. BTW, from a source other than TJMK, TMoMK, or the last remaining PMF.

While you're at it, please provide a link to a forensic-DNA expert who agrees with Stefanoni's work.

Also, while you're at it, provide a link to the actual evidence that says Knox rubbed blood from her hands. Note, not a judicial truth about this, but the evidence which was presented in court.

If not, please also accept the judicial truth that RS and AK were acquitted in 2015.
 
Your ad hominems are the last logical fallacy of the scoundrel. If anyone s dishonest and disingenuous, it is you, as the most recent MR to date, 10 Feb 2017, for Florence states clearly:



This is official law court document versus the confabulations of your mind.

Don't take my word for it. Read the court documents.
I don't think there is any danger of any one taking your word on anything. The question is why oh why, assuming the court documents say what you think they do, do you take the word of the Italian judges as gospel.
 
Originally Posted by Vixen
The other wrongful act was Marasca annulling it, despite making it clear Knox was definitely there whilst Mez was murdered, did wash Mez' blood from her hands and did cover up for Rudy Guede.
Not so as posted here dozens of times. One more time, because you keep asserting something which simply is not true.
Originally Posted by Marasca-Bruno
Nevertheless, even if attribution [of rubbing blood from her hands] is certain, the trial element would not be unequivocal as a demonstration of posthumous contact with that blood, as a likely attempt to remove the most blatant traces of what had happened, perhaps to help someone or deflect suspicion from herself, without this entailing her certain direct involvement in the murder. Any further and more meaningful value would be, in fact, resisted by the fact - which is decisive - that no trace leading to her was found at the scene of the crime or on the victim’s body, so that - if all the above is accepted - her contact with the victim’s blood would have occurred after the crime and in another part of the house.
For obvious reasons you keep leaving that part out.

I have re-quoted Bill Williams' post because I think he insufficiently emphasised Vixen's inability to understand (or alternatively to deliberately misrepresent) the Marasca-Bruno ruling.

I have seen other pro-guilt posters repeat the same false fact that Marasca ruled that Knox was present when the murder occurred when in fact Marasca specifically says the opposite. Even if one accepted the evidence suggested Knox was contaminated with the victim's blood that cannot result in a conclusion that she was present at the time and place of the murder.

This is a bit like Vixen's insistence that the courts ruled that Guede did not stab the victim when the courts in fact specify they make no such ruling and Vixen has never been able to present a referenced quote.

There is something interesting about how Vixen reads something and believes it support Vixen's assumptions when in fact it does no such thing. It is as if Vixen mentally filters out what is really written and substitutes what Vixen wants to have been written. There are multiple examples of when Vixen has posted something claiming it supports Vixen's fantasies when in fact it does the opposite.
 
Last edited:
This is either a lie or a fantasy - hard to say which, really.

http://www.policecouldyou.co.uk/police-officer/am-i-eligible/

"there is no formal educational requirement, but you will have to pass written tests"
Vixen rather jumped the gun. But to defend Vixen when she is correct (or nearly so), England and Wales will be moving to a graduate police force. Like nursing this probably will mean that police officers will do a degree in policing that will be mixed theory and practical. Probably more police duties will be done by non-police officers including civilian investigators and community support officers doing low level patrolling.

https://www.derby.ac.uk/criminology-and-policing-courses/policing-ba-hons/
 
I have re-quoted Bill Williams' post because I think he insufficiently emphasised Vixen's inability to understand (or alternatively to deliberately misrepresent) the Marasca-Bruno ruling.

I cannot catch a break!

Although I do remember that I was sternly lectured by guilters for not understanding technical-legalese like "even if" or "hypothetical", when used in the Italian context.

What about Machiavelli's understanding of Italian legalese?

I'm reminded of what Machiavelli said about the use of the word "hypothetical" in the M/B report, as he was trying to argue that "hypothetical" didn't always mean "hypothetical" in Italian-legalese.

This from June 10, 2017 on this thread.... which seems decades ago at this point!

Machiavelli said:
M/B uses the word ipotizzato, which does not mean "hypothetical". The word ipotizzato is another word that doesn't exist in common language. It's legalese, it's technical jargon.

It is a neutral word, in the sense that it does not express any position on the part of the judge or lawyer within the statement in which it is used. An accusation, a charge or the evidence of a crime, if it refers to a crime which has been identified as specific or to a specific person, is called ipotesi di reato. Judges never talk about crimes, they always talk about hypotheses of crime. Like it or not, this is the talk. It does not mean that the judge agrees with the hypotheses, nor that he disagrees with it, neither that he thinks that the crime or evidence is certain, nor that he thinks that it is uncertain. It does not put any distance between the judge and the hypothesis reported. A kind of politically correct of judiciaries which is actually meant as technically correct. It is in fact meant to express the absolute neutrality of the judge within a specific phrase, his being external to it, in the sense that it expresses the point that that when a judiciary uses the terms ipotizzato or ipotesi di reato, within that phrase he is reporting something while not mentioning his own position at all. I mean, no position at all can be inferred from the word ipotizzato. Not a judge's belief, and not a doubt either. We don't know if he agrees, or if he disagrees. It is a technical word designed to avoid any possibility of inference from it regarding the person who reports. It has become a normal reporting jargon.​
Note this:

It is a neutral word, in the sense that it does not express any position on the part of the judge or lawyer within the statement in which it is used.​
This is exactly the point - M. even articulated very well what the point was. Judges Bruno and Marasca were, themselves, neither adhering nor not adhering to the hypotheticals they listed. (All the while, while folk like M. and Vixen claim they were accepting as factual those things.....)

What M/B did in their motivations report, now 2 years old - enough time for arrests to have been made if they'd sold out the country to Masonic and US Media interests!!! - what they did was list those hypotheticals to conclude:

Even if true, they still do not put either AK or RS in the murder room, therefore the Nencini court should have acquitted.

However, M. can post with a straight face:

I mean, no position at all can be inferred from the word ipotizzato. Not a judge's belief, and not a doubt either. We don't know if he agrees, or if he disagrees...​
While claiming in another post that those judges who had used ipotizzato found those things as factual.

Whose side is Machiavelli on? This is how bizarre the thread has become.
 
Last edited:
Read the following slowly and carefully, Try reading it out loud:




You'll get there in the end.

I was one of the first to point out how contradictory Appeal Courts can be to those unfamiliar with certain judicial systems. A country with such a system is Italy (and my own country South Africa which is based on Roman Dutch Law). As far as I know Scotland is the only other country in the world with similar legal heritage.

It was reported at first translation of the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA - I think ISC in Italy but it matters not) finding that Amanda was indeed in the house at the time of the murder, etc., etc.. The guilters gloated and a good many truthers were confounded.

...but it's actually rationally simple and I repeat it once again, primarily so that it might sink into Vixen's somewhat impermeable head.

The Supreme Court of Appeal is legally dispassionate and unconcerned with regard to judicial facts as found in the trial court. If the Supreme Court of Appeal repeats such facts it is because they are bound by them, regardless of the reality of truth.

Now, many expected that were the SCA finding to go in AK/RS favour it would be on the basis of a referral down to lower courts for reassessment of contradictions or inconsistencies.

The crushing blow to the prosecution, however, was the finding that EVEN TAKING ON BOARD THE ABSURDITIES (as clearly spelt out by the SCA) of the the lower convicting court it is impossible IN LAW (capitals because this is the essence of understanding) to convict on the basis of zero evidence to suggest that the accused were in the murder room AT ALL EVER...never mind not on the murder night. Therefore no referral down could possibly bridge the quantum leap required to convict where absence of presence is a fact but one ignored by the lower courts.

It is central to the understanding of the legal process to digest the difficulty of the Supreme Court of Appeal. If facts were to be reassessed this would regarded as a retrial in countries such as Italy (and I am not arguing this in relation to legal systems outside of Italy) and appeals are not going there (double jeopardy, etc.).

The reason the SCA was so easily able to trounce the prosecutions case is this. (Read carefully please Vixen and pass it on to your fellow cronies...Ergo, PQ and their horrible ilk)...

Verdicts by the lower courts have to follow logically from judicial truths. A verdict of guilty must be supported by the judicial facts. It cannot be that the link from judicial fact to verdict is illogical. This is not a dispute of fact (judicial). It is a dispute of LAW.

...and disputes of law are within the realm of the SCA finding.

Now stop repeating nonsense, Vixen. I have told you how it works. If you think I'm wrong debate the role of the SCA. Otherwise stop spreading nonsense. It's damaging to you and to those to whom your wrongful assertions are directed. It's wanton and willful slander and reflects poorly on you.
 
I was one of the first to point out how contradictory Appeal Courts can be to those unfamiliar with certain judicial systems. A country with such a system is Italy (and my own country South Africa which is based on Roman Dutch Law). As far as I know Scotland is the only other country in the world with similar legal heritage.

It was reported at first translation of the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA - I think ISC in Italy but it matters not) finding that Amanda was indeed in the house at the time of the murder, etc., etc.. The guilters gloated and a good many truthers were confounded.

...but it's actually rationally simple and I repeat it once again, primarily so that it might sink into Vixen's somewhat impermeable head.

The Supreme Court of Appeal is legally dispassionate and unconcerned with regard to judicial facts as found in the trial court. If the Supreme Court of Appeal repeats such facts it is because they are bound by them, regardless of the reality of truth.

Now, many expected that were the SCA finding to go in AK/RS favour it would be on the basis of a referral down to lower courts for reassessment of contradictions or inconsistencies.

The crushing blow to the prosecution, however, was the finding that EVEN TAKING ON BOARD THE ABSURDITIES (as clearly spelt out by the SCA) of the the lower convicting court it is impossible IN LAW (capitals because this is the essence of understanding) to convict on the basis of zero evidence to suggest that the accused were in the murder room AT ALL EVER...never mind not on the murder night. Therefore no referral down could possibly bridge the quantum leap required to convict where absence of presence is a fact but one ignored by the lower courts.

It is central to the understanding of the legal process to digest the difficulty of the Supreme Court of Appeal. If facts were to be reassessed this would regarded as a retrial in countries such as Italy (and I am not arguing this in relation to legal systems outside of Italy) and appeals are not going there (double jeopardy, etc.).

The reason the SCA was so easily able to trounce the prosecutions case is this. (Read carefully please Vixen and pass it on to your fellow cronies...Ergo, PQ and their horrible ilk)...

Verdicts by the lower courts have to follow logically from judicial truths. A verdict of guilty must be supported by the judicial facts. It cannot be that the link from judicial fact to verdict is illogical. This is not a dispute of fact (judicial). It is a dispute of LAW.

...and disputes of law are within the realm of the SCA finding.

Now stop repeating nonsense, Vixen. I have told you how it works. If you think I'm wrong debate the role of the SCA. Otherwise stop spreading nonsense. It's damaging to you and to those to whom your wrongful assertions are directed. It's wanton and willful slander and reflects poorly on you.


Look. The merits court is a fact finding court and it found various facts which were not overturned on points of law.


As an example, Pistorius in your home country, was found as a fact by the court to have done XYZ. Now the judge Maseipi inferred from these facts that it was a manslaughter. This was overturned on appeal on a point of law, because although the facts were XYZ she had applied the law wrongly and it was in fact murder.

It is an indisputable and certain fact that Knox was at the cottage, and Raff was almost certainly with her, when Mez was killed.

Yes, it is a legal/judicial fact, but those are the facts that matter.

For example, if a court decides a man is a child's father, it matters not a jot if the real truth is that a dastardly rogue swapped samples over at DNA testing, as that is the way the child will now proceed through life. (Subject to the devilish plot never coming to light.)

Lovely impassioned soliloquy, though.
 
Citation please. Like that will ever happen. BTW, from a source other than TJMK, TMoMK, or the last remaining PMF.

While you're at it, please provide a link to a forensic-DNA expert who agrees with Stefanoni's work.

Also, while you're at it, provide a link to the actual evidence that says Knox rubbed blood from her hands. Note, not a judicial truth about this, but the evidence which was presented in court.

If not, please also accept the judicial truth that RS and AK were acquitted in 2015.

Mach informed me. I had thought Hellmann was a noble family (it is in Sweden) and he put me straight.
 
Look. The merits court is a fact finding court and it found various facts which were not overturned on points of law.


As an example, Pistorius in your home country, was found as a fact by the court to have done XYZ. Now the judge Maseipi inferred from these facts that it was a manslaughter. This was overturned on appeal on a point of law, because although the facts were XYZ she had applied the law wrongly and it was in fact murder.

It is an indisputable and certain fact that Knox was at the cottage, and Raff was almost certainly with her, when Mez was killed.

Yes, it is a legal/judicial fact, but those are the facts that matter.

For example, if a court decides a man is a child's father, it matters not a jot if the real truth is that a dastardly rogue swapped samples over at DNA testing, as that is the way the child will now proceed through life. (Subject to the devilish plot never coming to light.)
Lovely impassioned soliloquy, though.

Wow!!! Just, wow!!! This is exactly why you cling to falsehoods. Incredulous statement as highlighted above.

It's fine to perpetuate a falsehood as long as it's underpinned by a legal stamp.

For you the world is still flat.
 
Wow!!! Just, wow!!! This is exactly why you cling to falsehoods. Incredulous statement as highlighted above.

It's fine to perpetuate a falsehood as long as it's underpinned by a legal stamp.

For you the world is still flat.

Apparently, Vixen is unaware of the appeal to authority fallacy.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom