The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
Nowhere in Marasca's written reason does it claim it was a 'wrongful conviction'.

You mean other than that the ISC annulled the Nencini conviction? And that Nencini had no business convicting on the evidence he'd had in front of him?

Other than those two wee things?
 
Suddenly, Bill Williams believes Rudy! There is no trace of Rudy in the small bathroom. He says he got the towels from a bathroom closet. But there is no closet of any sort inside the small bathroom. So either they were in an airing cupboard just outside, or more likely, Amanda fetched them for him.Anyway, whatever the situation, it is a fact Amanda was there with Rudy.

Both covered up for each other, as one would predict from Prisoners Dilemma.

I have just read all of Guede's statements and his diary. Doing a search for "towel" there is no mention whatsoever by him of getting them from a "closet". All he says is that he got them from the bathroom. Therefore, please provide a citation for this claim.

If you cannot provide a citation, then the speculation that followed your claim s just that; unfounded on any evidence speculation.

It is not a fact that Amanda was there with Rudy. Nencini wrote that Raff's DNA was on the knife. Is that a fact?
 
Last edited:
Vixen takes direct statements from Rudy Guede speaking in private to his friend describing going into the bathroom to get towels to use on blood. The crime scene has a male sized bloody footprint in the bathroom compatible with Rudy's foot, the bedroom has blood soaked towels from that bathroom.

This corroborated evidence-matched testimony translates in her mind to Amanda going into the bathroom to get the bloody towels.

I can't believe the PGP's evidence parsing abilities have lead to such wildly stupid conclusions I mean wow they're so strong :rolleyes:
 
Suddenly, Bill Williams believes Rudy! There is no trace of Rudy in the small bathroom. He says he got the towels from a bathroom closet. But there is no closet of any sort inside the small bathroom. So either they were in an airing cupboard just outside, or more likely, Amanda fetched them for him.

Anyway, whatever the situation, it is a fact Amanda was there with Rudy.

Both covered up for each other, as one would predict from Prisoners Dilemma.

Hmmm.... Guede says "Amanda had nothing to do with it." Then his story changes more times than Trump has changed wives. It eventually morphs into "It was Amanda". Suddenly, you believe Rudy!

I still find cleaning up all her own and Raff's DNA and fingerprints but leaving Guede's and his bloody shoeprints an odd way of "covering up" for him.

And please, learn what Prisoner's Dilemma is. You have been told umpteen times.
 
Suddenly, Bill Williams believes Rudy! There is no trace of Rudy in the small bathroom. He says he got the towels from a bathroom closet. But there is no closet of any sort inside the small bathroom. So either they were in an airing cupboard just outside, or more likely, Amanda fetched them for him.

Anyway, whatever the situation, it is a fact Amanda was there with Rudy.

Both covered up for each other, as one would predict from Prisoners Dilemma.

For your own sake, please stop with the "prisoner's dilemma" stuff. You have no idea what it refers to.

It is not a fact that Amanda was there with Rudy. If it is judicial truth you are after, the final, definitive court said that even if Knox had rubbed blood from her hands, it had to have been after the crime had been committed and in another part of the cottage - both of which fit Knox's own admission that she'd been there the morning of Nov 2 after 10:30 am.

Finally, where on earth do you just make this stuff up? The latest is you having Rudy saying he'd fetched towels "from a closet". Believing Rudy is one thing, but there is no reason to believe you on anything given your track record here.....

...... of just making stuff up. For your own sake, please stop making stuff up.
 
Vixen takes direct statements from Rudy Guede speaking in private to his friend describing going into the bathroom to get towels to use on blood. The crime scene has a male sized bloody footprint in the bathroom compatible with Rudy's foot, the bedroom has blood soaked towels from that bathroom.

This corroborated evidence-matched testimony translates in her mind to Amanda going into the bathroom to get the bloody towels.

I can't believe the PGP's evidence parsing abilities have lead to such wildly stupid conclusions I mean wow they're so strong :rolleyes:

The footprint on the bathmat is compatible with Raff.

It is not compatible with Rudy or Amanda.

Read Beomia and Rinaldi - fingerprint and footprint experts who testified to this effect in court. Don't take my word for it.

If they were at all biased, they would not have named the Italian; they would have done an 'Amanda Knox' and named the black guy.

As they have analysed over 10K samples, it is not rational to call them unobjective and 'out to get the kids'.
 
For your own sake, please stop with the "prisoner's dilemma" stuff. You have no idea what it refers to.

It is not a fact that Amanda was there with Rudy. If it is judicial truth you are after, the final, definitive court said that even if Knox had rubbed blood from her hands, it had to have been after the crime had been committed and in another part of the cottage - both of which fit Knox's own admission that she'd been there the morning of Nov 2 after 10:30 am.

Finally, where on earth do you just make this stuff up? The latest is you having Rudy saying he'd fetched towels "from a closet". Believing Rudy is one thing, but there is no reason to believe you on anything given your track record here.....

...... of just making stuff up. For your own sake, please stop making stuff up.


Read the following slowly and carefully, Try reading it out loud:

On
the other hand, given the certainty of the presence of Knox in that house, it is hardly credible that he was not with her.” (Page 49 of the decision) If therefore the fact that Knox was in the house 7 Via della Pergola at the time when young Meredith Kercher was killed constitutes a fact of absolute and indisputable certainty;


You'll get there in the end.
 
From the final Giordano-Iannelli report, which summarized what Rudy had said had happened on the night of the murder:

Guede continued his story by saying that he tried to help
the girl, staunching her wounds with a towel that he took from the bathroom, but the blood continued
to flow, so he took another towel, and managed to understand a word that Meredith pronounced “AF”,
but then he heard sounds from the floor below, panicked, and rushed out of the house, leaving the door
open and Kercher on the floor, dressed, the shutters open and Romanelli’s windowpane not smashed.​
The novelty of the third interrogation was the statement that from Romanelli’s window, he briefly saw a
female figure with loose hair which seemed to be that of Amanda Knox. Then he repeated what he had
already stated: that Meredith’s room was in order, that the girl was on the floor, dressed, that he tried to staunch the blood with two towels and then fled, terrified. On May 15th a fourth interrogation took
place, solicited by Guede, following the order issued by the Court of Cassation in the formally opened de
libertate proceeding: there, he said that he was wearing Nike shoes, corresponding to the empty shoe
box found during the search of his flat in via del Canerino, compatible with some of the shoeprints found
in the house in via della Pergola, above all with one found near Meredith Kercher’s body.​
Sorry, Vixen, no mention of a closet. You just made that up.
 
Read the following slowly and carefully, Try reading it out loud:

You'll get there in the end.

That is from a court which heard no evidence about the killing. It, like you, is reciting what it believes are "judicial facts", generated from another court.

The question for you remains - what is the evidence that supports this judicial fact?

I don't think you'll ever get to citing evidence, mainly because there is none. If there were you'd be citing it, as would have the court (which it didn't).
 
Actually, every single judge, excluding the disgraced Hellmann.

No surprise the corrupt and expunged Hellmann is a hero of the PIP.

Oh, you mean the other judges (Hellmann and Zanetti) who also acquitted RS and AK just like the Supreme Court did? Those "disgraced" judges?

Bwwwaahaaahaaaahaaahaaaa!!!
 
Actually, every single judge, excluding the disgraced Hellmann.

No surprise the corrupt and expunged Hellmann is a hero of the PIP.

The question for you remains - what is the evidence that supports this judicial fact?
 
Read the following slowly and carefully, Try reading it out loud:




You'll get there in the end.

But given that the report annulled the guilty verdict because of “contradictory” elements then it might be worth considering if the contradictory elements can be explained. On the one hand , no evidence of a clean up and no evidence of Amanda in the room where Meredith was killed, but Guede’s clearly evident. How is that explained? On the other hand, alleged presence of Amanda in the house : where does that come from- her own “confused” account later retracted and still not resolved by the ECHR.
 
The footprint on the bathmat is compatible with Raff.

It is not compatible with Rudy or Amanda.

Read Beomia and Rinaldi - fingerprint and footprint experts who testified to this effect in court. Don't take my word for it.

If they were at all biased, they would not have named the Italian; they would have done an 'Amanda Knox' and named the black guy.

As they have analysed over 10K samples, it is not rational to call them unobjective and 'out to get the kids'.

The footprint is compatible with Guede.

It is not compatible with Raff or Amanda.

Read Prof. Francesco Vinci--a forensic expert who testified to this effect in court. Don't take my word for it. Oh...and has been discussed here in great detail before, Boemia and Rinaldi are not "fingerprint and footprint experts". They are fingerprint experts. The two are not interchangeable and are not analyzed the same way as you once claimed. Unless a footprint leaves a clear image of the ridges of the toes, it cannot be analyzed like a fingerprint. And the footprint on the bathmat most certainly did not.

Notice that Marasca ruled that there was no evidence of either Knox or Sollecito in the murder room. If Marasca had accepted that the footprint was Sollecito's that would have clearly placed him in that bedroom. But, he didn't, did he?
 
Actually, every single judge, excluding the disgraced Hellmann.

No surprise the corrupt and expunged Hellmann is a hero of the PIP.

For newcomers to the case (!) you might link to responsible news outlets that show Hellmann was disgraced.
Or you might not.
 
Actually, every single judge, excluding the disgraced Hellmann.

No surprise the corrupt and expunged Hellmann is a hero of the PIP.

I've told Mach and probably you at some point as well that a better use of your time than recycling talking points with us for years on end is to go out into the open world and see if you can track down a willing victim of suitable reasoning ability and no interest in this case and have them read the Hellmann report. Prepare to be amazed as nothing jumps out at them as unreasonable or illogical.

Could every single judge involved in this case, excluding Hellmann, be so willfully ignorant or professionally deceitful and politically minded? The answer may surprise you.
 
Actually, every single judge, excluding the disgraced Hellmann.

No surprise the corrupt and expunged Hellmann is a hero of the PIP.

Proof of corruption? I am happy to read links from responsible news outlets.
 
Still waiting for that citation stating Guede got the towels from a closet in the bathroom.

(We aren't going to get it, are we?)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom