The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
I guess I should have added childish in there as well.

Might I remind you that it was you who wrote;

"As for Knox' 'I cannot lie, I was there' comment, she was obviously talking about the cottage. There wouldn't be any need to lie if she was at Raff's. And in any case, he denies it. His last and definitive statement was that he has no idea where she was between 20:45 and 01:00 on the night of the murder."

Not even the courts you're so fond of quoting believed she was talking about the cottage, and not even an idiot would fail to understand the difference between a defense tactic and a definitive statement of fact.

Hey, I know... why don't you quote his "last and definitive statement" where he says he has no idea where she was between 20:45 and 01:00. Maybe that would help clear things up.


Do refer to the press conference called by him and Bongiorno during the Nencini appeal. In fact, his story remains the same since his statement to the police 5 Nov 2007.
 
The way guilters have handled this over the years is all the proof readers need of their confirmation bias.................

............... or at least that internet-guilters will continue to argue Mignini's case circa 2008-2009 as if no one in Italy had those issues in front of them in the years to come, and saw the comment for what it was. This is before considering that not even Judge Massei bought this in 2009! This is what I mean by how these people are still in a "defence of Giuliano Mignini" mode. The only things which trump defending Mignini are those slutty things they like saying about Knox.

Andrea Vogt was the first (or one of the first - Methos would know!) who wrote back to the SeattlePI paper that Knox had admitted, "I Was There." Forget for a moment that that admission was that she'd been at Raffaele's all night - such admission gleaned from a secret prison recording between she and her mom. Vogt proved herself to be Mignini's press agent by never once correcting the record on that. The important thing was getting Mignini's views out - or lose access to the police (like Nick Pisa said in the 2016 documentary).

It's not at issue what Knox had meant to the gulters, not really. Indeed, Machiavelli on this very thread eventually had to concede that in context, she'd meant she'd been at Raffaele's, but M. wanted it known that Knox and her mom had been, "speaking Mafia code".

And why not. As Mignini in the 2009-courtroom was telling the judges of the Baghdad-like destruction back in Seattle because of the noise ticket, M. revealed the reason why it had not been a story in Seattle at the time.

That was because of the Mafia code of omertà:

​
You see - the point is to incriminate Knox at all costs, just like Mignini did. Is this a childish thing to do? You decide.


Why would she need to 'admit' she was at Raff's that night. She was quite openly having sex with him. Or add, 'I cannot lie'.

She fools no-one.
 
Not childish, but definitely dishonest and disingenuous. I know damn well that Vixen knows Amanda was referring to Raffaele's apartment and that Raffaele's disassociation with Amanda was a defense tactic based on the prosecution's insistence that Amanda's signed statement was factual, and was not a 'definitive statement' that Amanda was not with him that night. If she genuinely doesn't understand this then she's got much more serious issues to deal with.

Her 'I know you are but what am I' type response... now THAT was childish.

Speaking "Mafia code"?? Don't you need to know how to speak Italian first? One month in the country and Mach's got her as a junior Mafia member. Did Mach ever indicate where Edda learned to speak "Mafia code" ?

You have some very serious issues to address and are definitely dishonest and disingenous if you cannot see that Knox has told you quite opnely she was at the cottage that night, over and over again.

Marasca and Martuscelli underline it.
 
Do refer to the press conference called by him and Bongiorno during the Nencini appeal.
Indeed. That was when the separation strategy was laid out. The PGP tried to make it sound like Raffaele was throwing Knox under a bus. Then the text of his appeal to Cassazione came out and it proved the PGP wrong.

In fact, his story remains the same since his statement to the police 5 Nov 2007.
LOL. Not even you can believe that. Read his book.
 
What I find amusing is this idea that the PIP thinks that this kind of thing DOESN'T HAPPEN in the US where the cops and prosecution lie and the courts knee jerk reaction is to defend those lies.

I've been watching a lot of YouTube lately where cops, prosecutors and judges obliterate justice, due process and act corruptly. On several videos cops are caught threatening suspects that they don't need a reason to arrest and convict someone, they'll just make up a reason. In one video during court a cop is seen rifling through a defense attorney's papers and stealing one. A judge is seen telling a defendant that he is taking away a defendants rights.

This stuff happens all the time. Whether it is noble corruption or just people on an authority trip.


US cops might be dumb, but in Europe these days, they have to be graduates (at least in the UK) and undergo ethics training.
 
Why would she need to 'admit' she was at Raff's that night. She was quite openly having sex with him. Or add, 'I cannot lie'.

She fools no-one.

Because the police slapped her and yelled at her for "lying" and threatened her with a prison sentence every time she said she was at Raff's? Try exercising some ~4th grade reading comprehension skills and you wont need to ask such a question.
 
I should repost, yet again, the 2007 Canadian wrongful conviction study, which gleans the commonalities of Canada's dozen or so notorious wrongful convictions.

These are the ones we know about, that officials and judges agree were wrongful. Heaven knows how many others are there.

Yet this 2007 study goes through the dynamics which contributed to the obvious ones. They are stunningly similar to what happened in Perugia later that year.

No, it is not an Italian problem per se; esp. when you consider that eventually Italy acquitted the pair.

There wasn't anything wrongful about the conviction. What was wrongful was Hellmann's bent acquittal based on Conti & Vecchiotti's crooked report funded by the likes of Knox fanboy Hampikian from Uni Boise grant money, which Hampikian claims is a 'trade secret', when asked to disclose his research under the Freedom of Information laws. The other wrongful act was Marasca annulling it, despite making it clear Knox was definitely there whilst Mez was murdered, did wash Mez' blood from her hands and did cover up for Rudy Guede.
 
There wasn't anything wrongful about the conviction. What was wrongful was Hellmann's bent acquittal based on Conti & Vecchiotti's crooked report funded by the likes of Knox fanboy Hampikian from Uni Boise grant money, which Hampikian claims is a 'trade secret', when asked to disclose his research under the Freedom of Information laws. The other wrongful act was Marasca annulling it, despite making it clear Knox was definitely there whilst Mez was murdered, did wash Mez' blood from her hands and did cover up for Rudy Guede.

Vixen it's rude to post Andrea Vogt's diary here without her permission.
 
Oh dear. Poor wilting wallflower.

The PGP are incapable of momentarily shifting their perspective to engage an argument from a different point of view. That's why you can't see the police slapping around and threatening a girl in the middle of the night as a big deal, because you can't see her as anything but a killer. It's argument from omniscience. But omniscience doesn't exist, so really it's argument from stupidity. A normal thinking person would go, hmmm the PIP's view is that slapping around and threatening an innocent girl in the middle of the night could have adverse effects - it sounds reasonable.

I think there probably have been PGP that were intellectually capable of analyzing different perspectives. "Wilting" is probably a good way to describe what happened to their PGP view.
 
There wasn't anything wrongful about the conviction.
Except for that the 2015 Cassazione court determined that there was no evidence.
What was wrongful was Hellmann's bent acquittal based on Conti & Vecchiotti's crooked report funded by the likes of Knox fanboy Hampikian from Uni Boise grant money, which Hampikian claims is a 'trade secret', when asked to disclose his research under the Freedom of Information laws.
Your use of ad hominem defeats your point. Besides, there is no forensic-DNA expert in the world who agrees with Stefanoni. All you have for those who trash Stefanoni's work (C&V, Gill, Hampikian, etc.) is ad hominem.
The other wrongful act was Marasca annulling it, despite making it clear Knox was definitely there whilst Mez was murdered, did wash Mez' blood from her hands and did cover up for Rudy Guede.
Not so as posted here dozens of times. One more time, because you keep asserting something which simply is not true.

Marasca-Bruno said:
Nevertheless, even if attribution [of rubbing blood from her hands] is certain, the trial element would not be unequivocal as a demonstration of posthumous contact with that blood, as a likely attempt to remove the most blatant traces of what had happened, perhaps to help someone or deflect suspicion from herself, without this entailing her certain direct involvement in the murder. Any further and more meaningful value would be, in fact, resisted by the fact - which is decisive - that no trace leading to her was found at the scene of the crime or on the victim’s body, so that - if all the above is accepted - her contact with the victim’s blood would have occurred after the crime and in another part of the house.​
For obvious reasons you keep leaving that part out.
 
There wasn't anything wrongful about the conviction. What was wrongful was Hellmann's bent acquittal based on Conti & Vecchiotti's crooked report funded by the likes of Knox fanboy Hampikian from Uni Boise grant money, which Hampikian claims is a 'trade secret', when asked to disclose his research under the Freedom of Information laws. The other wrongful act was Marasca annulling it, despite making it clear Knox was definitely there whilst Mez was murdered, did wash Mez' blood from her hands and did cover up for Rudy Guede.

More dishonesty and disingenuousness. When asked for evidence to support any of these claims you continue to come up empty. My guess is you have no clue how foolish you sound repeating unproven statements and making childish comments about numerous experts who confirm the problems with the forensic case. But it's OK because Amanda and Raffaele were acquitted and are back to enjoying their lives while you wallow in bitterness over being consistently proven wrong.
 
Vixen said:
despite making it clear Knox was definitely there whilst Mez was murdered, did wash Mez' blood from her hands and did cover up for Rudy Guede.
More dishonesty and disingenuousness. When asked for evidence to support any of these claims you continue to come up empty. My guess is you have no clue how foolish you sound repeating unproven statements and making childish comments about numerous experts who confirm the problems with the forensic case. But it's OK because Amanda and Raffaele were acquitted and are back to enjoying their lives while you wallow in bitterness over being consistently proven wrong.

It's not Vixen's fault. Judge Massei wrote in his 2010 report (perhaps six times) that this took place. Massei cited no evidence, he just asserted it as consistent with the crime as he saw it. Massei said this about Knox's trace-DNA found in her own bathroom, one that she'd used for weeks.

By definition one cannot know the origin of Knox's DNA, but even if it had come from skin exfoliation, why is any of that surprising in one's own bathroom?

Even Massei admitted this, but it did not prevent Judge Massei from continuing to "make hay" out of Knox's trace-DNA being found in her own bathroom; albeit mixed with the victim's blood, which Rudy (the killer) obviously brought with him - he admitted to going into that bathroom after the victim had been stabbed and was bleeding.

What this means is that there is no evidence that what Massei wrote or what Vixen asserts is true, and there is plenty of evidence that that scene in the bathroom was of Rudy's and only Rudy's making. (Except perhaps for the collection procedure of the crack forensic team.)

Such is the roadmap of wrongful conviction.
 
The ECHR has no clout.

ECHR rulings are binding on member states, one of which is Italy.

I suspect you know that they will rule in her favor if their past rulings in similar cases are any indication. Therefore, you must prepare for this by downplaying the importance of what you know is coming. No, they cannot force Italy to do anything but that does not minimize the legal importance of their findings. I suppose what will follow their ruling (in her favor) will be accusations against the judges of having been bought off or pressured by the US State Dept. or the Mafia or Masons. Mama mia! Can allegations of these judges having the hots for an "acquiescent" Knox be far behind?

Stay tuned, folks! It's going to be interesting watching the tap dance we all know is coming.
 
More dishonesty and disingenuousness. When asked for evidence to support any of these claims you continue to come up empty. My guess is you have no clue how foolish you sound repeating unproven statements and making childish comments about numerous experts who confirm the problems with the forensic case. But it's OK because Amanda and Raffaele were acquitted and are back to enjoying their lives while you wallow in bitterness over being consistently proven wrong.

Your ad hominems are the last logical fallacy of the scoundrel. If anyone s dishonest and disingenuous, it is you, as the most recent MR to date, 10 Feb 2017, for Florence states clearly:

In regard to Sollecito “The picture of the evidence which emerges from the
impugned judgment is marked by intrinsic unresolved contradictions...It remains,
nonetheless, a strong suspicion that he was actually present in the house at Via della Pergola on the night of the murder, but at a time, however, that cannot be determined.

On
the other hand, given the certainty of the presence of Knox in that house, it is hardly credible that he was not with her.” (Page 49 of the decision) If therefore the fact that Knox was in the house 7 Via della Pergola at the time when young Meredith Kercher was killed constitutes a fact of absolute and indisputable certainty; it is evident that the statements
made by Sollecito that she was with him all evening on 1 November 2007 are false, and
that one cannot believe his statements that he couldn't remember what he and Knox were
doing from the evening of 1 November 2007 until the following morning.


It is logical to
assume that she, returning to her boyfriend immediately after having helped someone she
knew (Guede) and others murder her flatmate, would have been greatly distraught, a
circumstance which would have allowed Sollecito to remember well what happened that
night even if he had never set foot in the house where the serious crime had happened.

This is official law court document versus the confabulations of your mind.

Don't take my word for it. Read the court documents.
 
Your ad hominems are the last logical fallacy of the scoundrel. If anyone s dishonest and disingenuous, it is you, as the most recent MR to date, 10 Feb 2017, for Florence states clearly:



This is official law court document versus the confabulations of your mind.

Don't take my word for it. Read the court documents.

Can you cite the evidence that this is true. No you cannot.

These "judicial truths" were part of the roadmap of wrongful conviction.
 
It's not Vixen's fault. Judge Massei wrote in his 2010 report (perhaps six times) that this took place. Massei cited no evidence, he just asserted it as consistent with the crime as he saw it. Massei said this about Knox's trace-DNA found in her own bathroom, one that she'd used for weeks.

By definition one cannot know the origin of Knox's DNA, but even if it had come from skin exfoliation, why is any of that surprising in one's own bathroom?

Even Massei admitted this, but it did not prevent Judge Massei from continuing to "make hay" out of Knox's trace-DNA being found in her own bathroom; albeit mixed with the victim's blood, which Rudy (the killer) obviously brought with him - he admitted to going into that bathroom after the victim had been stabbed and was bleeding.

What this means is that there is no evidence that what Massei wrote or what Vixen asserts is true, and there is plenty of evidence that that scene in the bathroom was of Rudy's and only Rudy's making. (Except perhaps for the collection procedure of the crack forensic team.)

Such is the roadmap of wrongful conviction.


Suddenly, Bill Williams believes Rudy! There is no trace of Rudy in the small bathroom. He says he got the towels from a bathroom closet. But there is no closet of any sort inside the small bathroom. So either they were in an airing cupboard just outside, or more likely, Amanda fetched them for him.

Anyway, whatever the situation, it is a fact Amanda was there with Rudy.

Both covered up for each other, as one would predict from Prisoners Dilemma.
 
You have some very serious issues to address and are definitely dishonest and disingenous if you cannot see that Knox has told you quite opnely she was at the cottage that night, over and over again.

Marasca and Martuscelli underline it.

Vixen, I know you have a huge blind spot when it comes to being able to interpret anything Knox says or does as anything other than pointing to her guilt...but...I know you are not stupid. With that understanding, can you explain to us exactly where she mentions being at the cottage and not Raff's? Can you explain how Micheli and Massei, having read the entire transcript of that recorded conversation, came to the conclusion she meant Raff's and not the cottage? Can you explain how not a single judge... not a single one...concluded otherwise? What is it you know that no one else did?

The entire quote of Amanda's is this:

It's stupid, because I cannot say anything else, I was there and I cannot lie about this. There is no reason to do so.

That last part is always left off by the PGP. Why do you think that is? Could it be because if she meant she had been at the cottage during the murder, she would have had every reason to lie about it?

Come on. As I said, you aren't stupid. So why not just admit you know she was referring to Raff's and not the cottage? Practice some common sense here.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom