The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
Have a read of this page and ask yourself, why does Andrea Vogt call it 'the secret USA defence'?

A trial is about disclosure. If Conti & Vecchiotti were being fed by Hampikian, who himself was being funded by state Uni Boise, then why the need for secrecy?

Because the whole thing was sordid, underhand, rotten and corrupt.



Good corporate governance entails transparency. If Greg is being given grants then stakeholders are entitled to know what it is spent on.

Since when was a state university a commercial enterprise with 'trade secrets'. The whole point of academia is sharing and disseminating information and knowledge, not hiding it.

So here we have a picture of a vain egotistical character who believed he could use his PhD to 'swing' the case.

Time and again we see individuals who believe they can bypass proper channels in their vainglorious self importance. They are corrupt and lack integrity.

When we consider someone like Leslie Van Houten got Life without Parole for a similar crime (she held her victim, Rosemary LaBianca down, whilst urging another perp to stab her, with poor Rosemary unable to fight back), it is deeply shocking to realise the levels of corruption certain parties in the Kercher case sunk to, to deny Meredith's family any justice.

PGP attack people of being corrupt whilst slavishly defending corrupt police/prosecutors who as detailed below violated the rights of Amanda and Raffaele during the interrogations, fed false information to the media, suppressed evidence, destroyed evidence, lied to Amanda she had HIV and committed perjury. Vixen argues transparency is important but PGP had no problem with lack of transparency when the prosecution engaged in the massive suppression of evidence. Another example of industrial scale hypocrisy by PGP. It is strange how PGP have no problem with corruption when it is carried out by the prosecution.

http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/raffaeles-kitchen-knife/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/contamination-labwork-coverup/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/meredith-kercher-perjury-corruption/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/evidence-destroyed/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/blood-evidence-downstairs-apartment/
https://knoxsollecito.wordpress.com...old-about-amanda-knox-and-raffaele-sollecito/
http://www.injusticeinperugia.org/myths.html
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11071314#post11071314
 
Since Rude Guede was the only known eye witness and also accused of the crime, he could not be forced to testify - at least not until he was finally convicted.

They should have tried to incentivize cooperation from him. The alternative is the crazed psycho girl who planned the whole thing and shoved a knife the size of Sicily into the victim's throat does 4 years and gets a book deal while making the prosecutor look like an idiot on Netflix. IMO they ********** up.
 
As for Knox' 'I cannot lie, I was there' comment, she was obviously talking about the cottage. There wouldn't be any need to lie if she was at Raff's. And in any case, he denies it. His last and definitive statement was that he has no idea where she was between 20:45 and 01:00 on the night of the murder.

IMV he is simply playing Prisoners Dilemma, or rather, the Nash Equilibrium. Trying to maximise his own interests by trying to convey an impression that she's more guilty than he is, when truth is, they both switched off their phones together.

I see dishonesty and disingenuousness are still primary staples of your rhetoric.

No, she was talking about being at Raffaele's apartment and anyone who reads the entire conversation can clearly see that. The prosecution never tried to argue it meant she was at the cottage and none of the judges believed it to mean anything other than being at Raffaele's. This was clarified years ago and yet here you are, once again bringing it up as if it had some relevancy.

Then you claim Raffaele denies it. He doesn't deny it - he never has. Of course, when he was asked if he could know she was there when he was asleep he had to answer no, but even then he later clarified that yes, he could know because she would not have been able to get back in if she left without waking him. And then, of course, on the appeal to Cassation his defense team decided to take a different tact and argued that if the court was going to accept Amanda's statement of being at the cottage as true then that would mean Raffaele was innocent since she never said in her statement that Raffaele was there. This is a clever legal maneuver but it was in no way Raffaele denying Amanda was with him. It's a simple, albeit obvious tactic by the defense, nothing more.

Dishonest and disingenuous. Those two words so aptly apply to you.
 
I see dishonesty and disingenuousness are still primary staples of your rhetoric.

No, she was talking about being at Raffaele's apartment and anyone who reads the entire conversation can clearly see that. The prosecution never tried to argue it meant she was at the cottage and none of the judges believed it to mean anything other than being at Raffaele's. This was clarified years ago and yet here you are, once again bringing it up as if it had some relevancy.

Then you claim Raffaele denies it. He doesn't deny it - he never has.

The Achilles Heel of the predatory prosecution and wrongful conviction has always been Raffaele and his actions. The principal action of his was aside from the non-videotaped interrogation he suffered, he was always Knox's alibi. It's why they had to arrest him and throw the same stuff at him.

He writes in his book that his comments at interrogation, unbeknownst to him, were used to entrap Knox. But since he obviously was never in a million years going to go into a courtroom and say what they claimed he'd said at his interrogation, they had to get Stefanoni to dishonestly say that whatever Sample 36B was - probably Raffaele's - that it could not have been the result of contamination.

​

Separation Strategy - One of the keys to getting the judiciary to finally see reason, was Sollecito's/Bongiorno's post-2014 re-conviction separation strategy. Of course, guilters were all over themselves claiming that Knox was being thrown under a bus.

Yet when you read the thing, Sollecito attacks his own wrongful conviction at a critical point. Nencini had written that an item of evidence which tends to condemn one, then by definition tends to condemn both. From Feb 2014 until March 2015's definitive acquittals, all Sollecito wanted to know was, "why?"

If Nencini had said "x" about Knox, what did that have to do with Sollecito? IMV it was the separation strategy that played a part in convincing Cassazione that Nencini's conviction had had no merit.

IMV even Mignini knew what all that meant for his case and reputation. When Mignini sued Sollecito/Gumbel for "Honor Bound", Mignini specifically references the defamation intended in the section where Sollecito claims he was offered a deal - early on, turn on Knox and you won't go to prison for as long.

Speaking of..... where is that predatory prosecution these days? Where is the predatory prosecution Mignini launched against Knox's parents? Where is the predatory prosecution against the West Seattle Herald? We know what happened to the defamation case against Knox, brought by 8 cops in Perugia.... Knox was definitively acquitted of that too.

Dishonesty and disingenuousness has always been part of this - so if a poster on this thread in ISF/JREF is going to rehash claims that Knox meant she'd been at the cottage when she was covertly recorded telling her mom, "I was there", that poster is only going to further reveal that she wants to advance Mignini's case of 2008-2009.

That was a case that not even the Massei court - in the main - believed, and the Massei court had to substitute its own version of the crime. Massei's court convicted mainly on stuff not brought to the trial.
 
Last edited:
I thought it was the mafia that rigged C&V. The conspiracy seems to change daily. If Amanda's defense rigged C&V, does that mean it was just a coincidence when the mafia rigged the Supreme Court verdict later? So maybe Amanda's defense wasn't coordinating well with Raff's? Or maybe it was a tag team approach? You rig Hellmann we'll rig M&B?

Or have we dropped the mafia angle altogether at this point? To rig a Supreme Court verdict, that's gotta take a lot of rafting trips.
 
Looks like the Supreme Court's motivation for upholding Raff's denial of compensation is now out.

It says he lied, made contradictions, wasn't straightforward from the beginning and gave police cause to believe he was involved in the murder.

At the initial stages of the Meredith Kercher Raffaele Sollecito murder investigation, he provided "lying and contradictory statements"; his statements have "found punctual denials in every respect". And this has reinforced in the investigators "the prospect of his involvement" by bringing him into custody in a provisional way.
- Cronaca

It 's breathtaking he had the audacity to demand €514K.

Talk about a pair of grifters.
 
Looks like the Supreme Court's motivation for upholding Raff's denial of compensation is now out.

It says he lied, made contradictions, wasn't straightforward from the beginning and gave police cause to believe he was involved in the murder.

- Cronaca

It 's breathtaking he had the audacity to demand €514K.

Talk about a pair of grifters.
First you have to convince us that your "take" on this amounts to anything. You upthread inferred to readers that a rafting trip had something to do with Hampikian's divorce.

You then posted a link to a YouTube video that showed nothing relevant.

So we should believe your take on Cassazione's bizarre action....... why?
 
Looks like the Supreme Court's motivation for upholding Raff's denial of compensation is now out.

It says he lied, made contradictions, wasn't straightforward from the beginning and gave police cause to believe he was involved in the murder.

- Cronaca

It 's breathtaking he had the audacity to demand €514K.

Talk about a pair of grifters.

As Ansa also reported " "The curtain does not fall here," replica of lawyer Giulia Bongiorno, who announced appeal to the European Court. "It has been totally overlooked - she said - the annihilation of defensive warranties in which the statements made to deny the compensation were made."

The SC refused his compensation on grounds of what RS said during an interrogation in which he was denied his rights to a lawyer...as the SC found in 2008. Once again, statements made under duress in an unrecorded interrogation without a lawyer. I can't wait for the decision on AK's claim before the ECHR. When they find in her favor, how will you spin that? They were bought off by the Mafia? The PR machine? The Masons? The Boy Scouts? The RSPCA? Maybe the RCMP?
 
As Ansa also reported " "The curtain does not fall here," replica of lawyer Giulia Bongiorno, who announced appeal to the European Court. "It has been totally overlooked - she said - the annihilation of defensive warranties in which the statements made to deny the compensation were made."

The SC refused his compensation on grounds of what RS said during an interrogation in which he was denied his rights to a lawyer...as the SC found in 2008. Once again, statements made under duress in an unrecorded interrogation without a lawyer. I can't wait for the decision on AK's claim before the ECHR. When they find in her favor, how will you spin that? They were bought off by the Mafia? The PR machine? The Masons? The Boy Scouts? The RSPCA? Maybe the RCMP?

Hey! Leave The Mounties out of this!
 
These two words apply to you, by your own standards.

I guess I should have added childish in there as well.

Might I remind you that it was you who wrote;

"As for Knox' 'I cannot lie, I was there' comment, she was obviously talking about the cottage. There wouldn't be any need to lie if she was at Raff's. And in any case, he denies it. His last and definitive statement was that he has no idea where she was between 20:45 and 01:00 on the night of the murder."

Not even the courts you're so fond of quoting believed she was talking about the cottage, and not even an idiot would fail to understand the difference between a defense tactic and a definitive statement of fact.

Hey, I know... why don't you quote his "last and definitive statement" where he says he has no idea where she was between 20:45 and 01:00. Maybe that would help clear things up.
 
I guess I should have added childish in there as well.

Might I remind you that it was you who wrote;

"As for Knox' 'I cannot lie, I was there' comment, she was obviously talking about the cottage. There wouldn't be any need to lie if she was at Raff's. And in any case, he denies it. His last and definitive statement was that he has no idea where she was between 20:45 and 01:00 on the night of the murder."

Not even the courts you're so fond of quoting believed she was talking about the cottage, and not even an idiot would fail to understand the difference between a defense tactic and a definitive statement of fact.

Hey, I know... why don't you quote his "last and definitive statement" where he says he has no idea where she was between 20:45 and 01:00. Maybe that would help clear things up.
The way guilters have handled this over the years is all the proof readers need of their confirmation bias.................

............... or at least that internet-guilters will continue to argue Mignini's case circa 2008-2009 as if no one in Italy had those issues in front of them in the years to come, and saw the comment for what it was. This is before considering that not even Judge Massei bought this in 2009! This is what I mean by how these people are still in a "defence of Giuliano Mignini" mode. The only things which trump defending Mignini are those slutty things they like saying about Knox.

Andrea Vogt was the first (or one of the first - Methos would know!) who wrote back to the SeattlePI paper that Knox had admitted, "I Was There." Forget for a moment that that admission was that she'd been at Raffaele's all night - such admission gleaned from a secret prison recording between she and her mom. Vogt proved herself to be Mignini's press agent by never once correcting the record on that. The important thing was getting Mignini's views out - or lose access to the police (like Nick Pisa said in the 2016 documentary).

It's not at issue what Knox had meant to the gulters, not really. Indeed, Machiavelli on this very thread eventually had to concede that in context, she'd meant she'd been at Raffaele's, but M. wanted it known that Knox and her mom had been, "speaking Mafia code".

And why not. As Mignini in the 2009-courtroom was telling the judges of the Baghdad-like destruction back in Seattle because of the noise ticket, M. revealed the reason why it had not been a story in Seattle at the time.

That was because of the Mafia code of omertà:

Wikipedia said:
Omertà (Italian pronunciation: [omerˈta]) is a code of honor that places importance on silence, non-cooperation with authorities, and non-interference in the illegal actions of others. It originated and remains common in Southern Italy, where banditry and the Mafia-type criminal organizations (like the Camorra, Cosa Nostra, 'Ndrangheta and Sacra Corona Unita) are strong. It is also deeply rooted in rural Crete (Greece), and Corsica.

It also exists, to a lesser extent, in certain Italian-American neighborhoods where the Italian-American Mafia has influence, as well as in Italian ethnic enclaves in countries such as Germany, Canada, and Australia, where Italian organized crime exists. Retaliation against informers is common in criminal circles, where informers are known as "rats" or "snitches"​
You see - the point is to incriminate Knox at all costs, just like Mignini did. Is this a childish thing to do? You decide.
 
Last edited:
The way guilters have handled this over the years is all the proof readers need of their confirmation bias.................

............... or at least that internet-guilters will continue to argue Mignini's case circa 2008-2009 as if no one in Italy had those issues in front of them in the years to come, and saw the comment for what it was. This is before considering that not even Judge Massei bought this in 2009! This is what I mean by how these people are still in a "defence of Giuliano Mignini" mode. The only things which trump defending Mignini are those slutty things they like saying about Knox.

Andrea Vogt was the first (or one of the first - Methos would know!) who wrote back to the SeattlePI paper that Knox had admitted, "I Was There." Forget for a moment that that admission was that she'd been at Raffaele's all night - such admission gleaned from a secret prison recording between she and her mom. Vogt proved herself to be Mignini's press agent by never once correcting the record on that. The important thing was getting Mignini's views out - or lose access to the police (like Nick Pisa said in the 2016 documentary).

It's not at issue what Knox had meant to the gulters, not really. Indeed, Machiavelli on this very thread eventually had to concede that in context, she'd meant she'd been at Raffaele's, but M. wanted it known that Knox and her mom had been, "speaking Mafia code".

And why not. As Mignini in the 2009-courtroom was telling the judges of the Baghdad-like destruction back in Seattle because of the noise ticket, M. revealed the reason why it had not been a story in Seattle at the time.

That was because of the Mafia code of omertà:

​
You see - the point is to incriminate Knox at all costs, just like Mignini did. Is this a childish thing to do? You decide.

Not childish, but definitely dishonest and disingenuous. I know damn well that Vixen knows Amanda was referring to Raffaele's apartment and that Raffaele's disassociation with Amanda was a defense tactic based on the prosecution's insistence that Amanda's signed statement was factual, and was not a 'definitive statement' that Amanda was not with him that night. If she genuinely doesn't understand this then she's got much more serious issues to deal with.

Her 'I know you are but what am I' type response... now THAT was childish.

Speaking "Mafia code"?? Don't you need to know how to speak Italian first? One month in the country and Mach's got her as a junior Mafia member. Did Mach ever indicate where Edda learned to speak "Mafia code" ?
 
Not childish, but definitely dishonest and disingenuous. I know damn well that Vixen knows Amanda was referring to Raffaele's apartment and that Raffaele's disassociation with Amanda was a defense tactic based on the prosecution's insistence that Amanda's signed statement was factual, and was not a 'definitive statement' that Amanda was not with him that night. If she genuinely doesn't understand this then she's got much more serious issues to deal with.
Not a "disassociation", but a "separation strategy". As late as the Nencini conviction in 2014, both the prosecution (Mignini, Crini) as well as the convicting courts considered that one item they deemed damning against one was to be considered damning against both.

The separation strategy following the Nencini-conviction, in the appeal document which went to Cassazione, kept asking the question - "Ok, if you say that is true about Amanda, what does that have to do with me?"

Indeed one of the tactics (as you say) was to attack the prosecution's insistence that Amanda's signed statement described the factuality of the crime - except if you consider that nothing in it (like all false confessions) actually described the crime; even as the convicting courts reconstructed it!

Be that as it may, to consider Knox's written statements as factual, that then proves that Raffaele had nothing to do with the crime.

The reason why the prosecution cannot give an inch on this? It's because Raffaele was Amanda's alibi, and he had to be part of the crime, or else Amanda is innocent too. That's the "prisoner's dilemma" that merchants of guilt face.
 
Last edited:
Not a "disassociation", but a "separation strategy". As late as the Nencini conviction in 2014, both the prosecution (Mignini, Crini) as well as the convicting courts considered that one item they deemed damning against one was to be considered damning against both.

The separation strategy following the Nencini-conviction, in the appeal document which went to Cassazione, kept asking the question - "Ok, if you say that is true about Amanda, what does that have to do with me?"

Indeed one of the tactics (as you say) was to attack the prosecution's insistence that Amanda's signed statement described the factuality of the crime - except if you consider that nothing in it (like all false confessions) actually described the crime; even as the convicting courts reconstructed it!

Be that as it may, to consider Knox's written statements as factual, that then proves that Raffaele had nothing to do with the crime.

The reason why the prosecution cannot give an inch on this? It's because Raffaele was Amanda's alibi, and he had to be part of the crime, or else Amanda is innocent too. That's the "prisoner's dilemma" that merchants of guilt face.

What I find amusing is this idea that the PIP thinks that this kind of thing DOESN'T HAPPEN in the US where the cops and prosecution lie and the courts knee jerk reaction is to defend those lies.

I've been watching a lot of YouTube lately where cops, prosecutors and judges obliterate justice, due process and act corruptly. On several videos cops are caught threatening suspects that they don't need a reason to arrest and convict someone, they'll just make up a reason. In one video during court a cop is seen rifling through a defense attorney's papers and stealing one. A judge is seen telling a defendant that he is taking away a defendants rights.

This stuff happens all the time. Whether it is noble corruption or just people on an authority trip.
 
What I find amusing is this idea that the PIP thinks that this kind of thing DOESN'T HAPPEN in the US where the cops and prosecution lie and the courts knee jerk reaction is to defend those lies.

I should repost, yet again, the 2007 Canadian wrongful conviction study, which gleans the commonalities of Canada's dozen or so notorious wrongful convictions.

These are the ones we know about, that officials and judges agree were wrongful. Heaven knows how many others are there.

Yet this 2007 study goes through the dynamics which contributed to the obvious ones. They are stunningly similar to what happened in Perugia later that year.

No, it is not an Italian problem per se; esp. when you consider that eventually Italy acquitted the pair.
 
What I find amusing is this idea that the PIP thinks that this kind of thing DOESN'T HAPPEN in the US where the cops and prosecution lie and the courts knee jerk reaction is to defend those lies.

I've been watching a lot of YouTube lately where cops, prosecutors and judges obliterate justice, due process and act corruptly. On several videos cops are caught threatening suspects that they don't need a reason to arrest and convict someone, they'll just make up a reason. In one video during court a cop is seen rifling through a defense attorney's papers and stealing one. A judge is seen telling a defendant that he is taking away a defendants rights.

This stuff happens all the time. Whether it is noble corruption or just people on an authority trip.

It certainly happens here, the difference is when it is as blatant as this case it wont survive a higher court review from our most educated and professional judges. David Camm's multiple convictions never survived appeal because by the time it got in front of somebody who studied the law for a living they realized, oh there's no case here.

This Knox case went to the highest court in the land, the Supreme Court of Cassation, and judge Chieffi said "what about these blue eyes Quintavalle saw in court" as if he was the local bumbling constable. It was judicial incompetence at a spectacularly high level. This case wouldn't have been half the spectacle if it played out normally (acquitted at appeal, appeal confirmed by Cassation).
 
It certainly happens here, the difference is when it is as blatant as this case it wont survive a higher court review from our most educated and professional judges. David Camm's multiple convictions never survived appeal because by the time it got in front of somebody who studied the law for a living they realized, oh there's no case here.

This Knox case went to the highest court in the land, the Supreme Court of Cassation, and judge Chieffi said "what about these blue eyes Quintavalle saw in court" as if he was the local bumbling constable. It was judicial incompetence at a spectacularly high level. This case wouldn't have been half the spectacle if it played out normally (acquitted at appeal, appeal confirmed by Cassation).

All true except... if the investigation had been a competent one Amanda and Raffaele would never have even stood trial, but I digress.
 
All true except... if the investigation had been a competent one Amanda and Raffaele would never have even stood trial, but I digress.

I agree but every jurisdiction in the world can have a few bad apples or compounded mistakes. It's why you need a suitably rigorous appeals process. In theory Italy has this and I suppose if you squint you could say it worked here in the end...sort of....
 
As Ansa also reported " "The curtain does not fall here," replica of lawyer Giulia Bongiorno, who announced appeal to the European Court. "It has been totally overlooked - she said - the annihilation of defensive warranties in which the statements made to deny the compensation were made."

The SC refused his compensation on grounds of what RS said during an interrogation in which he was denied his rights to a lawyer...as the SC found in 2008. Once again, statements made under duress in an unrecorded interrogation without a lawyer. I can't wait for the decision on AK's claim before the ECHR. When they find in her favor, how will you spin that? They were bought off by the Mafia? The PR machine? The Masons? The Boy Scouts? The RSPCA? Maybe the RCMP?

The ECHR has no clout.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom