The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ah, yes. I go away on vacation for few days, log in again, and see the same old tactics being trotted out by Vixen yet again. More nasty innuendo and unsubstantiated accusations against an expert who dared to support AK's and RS's innocence. A nasty, dirty old man who was willing to trade his professional reputation and career, not to mention his marriage, for a "chance" to snuggle up to "acquiescent" Knox is just the beginning! Testifying, when asked in court, that he worked on the Knox case is morphed into lying, being dishonest and claiming to have helped "free" Knox! Yep. Same-o, same-o crapola. I'd be willing to pay for it if a real psychologist would spend a few hours reading this forum and give us a professional opinion on the mind that comes up with this stuff. I really would.

Seriously, what kind of a diseased mind wants to help murderers 'get away with it'?
 
I bet your parents then became stoned hippies.

My father was a middle class snob - ex-RAF, public school and Sandhurst military academy for his sons, three times married. My mother's straitlaced bourgeoisie, very proper. My stepfather's ordinary and a Trump and Putin supporter, a compulsive cleaner and DIY fanatic, but otherwise cool. :D I can't imagine any of them as 'stoned hippies'. They would be utterly mortified.
 
Seriously, what kind of a diseased mind wants to help murderers 'get away with it'?

That would be a very disturbed individual, however, why do I feel the need to remind you this thread is a discussion of Amanda and Raffaele, so I fail to see the relevance of your comment. Actually, I fail to see the relevance of your comment based on what Stacy wrote as well, but whatever.
 
Ah, yes. I go away on vacation for few days, log in again, and see the same old tactics being trotted out by Vixen yet again. More nasty innuendo and unsubstantiated accusations against an expert who dared to support AK's and RS's innocence. A nasty, dirty old man who was willing to trade his professional reputation and career, not to mention his marriage, for a "chance" to snuggle up to "acquiescent" Knox is just the beginning! Testifying, when asked in court, that he worked on the Knox case is morphed into lying, being dishonest and claiming to have helped "free" Knox! Yep. Same-o, same-o crapola. I'd be willing to pay for it if a real psychologist would spend a few hours reading this forum and give us a professional opinion on the mind that comes up with this stuff. I really would.

Vixen is like an online petri dish, giving us bold new insight into the inner workings of a PGP mind. She's drafted a complete attack bio on Hampikian based on comments from compulsive liar/guilter corpus vile, Andrea Vogt, a powerpoint presentation she's never seen (or can prove exists) and a YouTube video she's never seen (or can prove exists). The narrative she's created is so bizarre not even Hollywood would buy it. The case is over but the few remaining PGP really are a fascinating study.
 
Have a read of this page and ask yourself, why does Andrea Vogt call it 'the secret USA defence'?

A trial is about disclosure. If Conti & Vecchiotti were being fed by Hampikian, who himself was being funded by state Uni Boise, then why the need for secrecy?

Because the whole thing was sordid, underhand, rotten and corrupt.



Good corporate governance entails transparency. If Greg is being given grants then stakeholders are entitled to know what it is spent on.

Since when was a state university a commercial enterprise with 'trade secrets'. The whole point of academia is sharing and disseminating information and knowledge, not hiding it.

So here we have a picture of a vain egotistical character who believed he could use his PhD to 'swing' the case.

Time and again we see individuals who believe they can bypass proper channels in their vainglorious self importance. They are corrupt and lack integrity.

When we consider someone like Leslie Van Houten got Life without Parole for a similar crime (she held her victim, Rosemary LaBianca down, whilst urging another perp to stab her, with poor Rosemary unable to fight back), it is deeply shocking to realise the levels of corruption certain parties in the Kercher case sunk to, to deny Meredith's family any justice.

Why not just cut to the chase... what was incorrect in Hampikian's assessment of the DNA evidence? At the end of the day you are trying to prove innocence or guilt of someone and everyone should be committed to getting it right. Now, if you can point out where Hampikian or Gil or Conti or Vecchiotti got something wrong, then that's something that should be brought front and center and discussed. But you can't seem to find anything wrong with their conclusions, so you attack the individuals. Vogt's article is over three years old - it's an old, irrelevant story. Why are you regurgitating this article now? Has your desperation reached new levels?

You're interpretation is seriously flawed. The defense turned to world renowned experts for consultation on the evidence and these unbiased, independent experts confirmed the unreliability of the DNA. They helped ensure two innocent people didn't sit rotting in jail because of a botched investigation. If you seriously were concerned about justice for Meredith and her family you should have been arguing against the reductions in the sentence of the killer of Meredith, Rudy Guede. But then, this has never been about justice for Meredith... with you, it's about attacking Amanda. Period.
 
Ah, yes. I go away on vacation for few days, log in again, and see the same old tactics being trotted out by Vixen yet again. More nasty innuendo and unsubstantiated accusations against an expert who dared to support AK's and RS's innocence. A nasty, dirty old man who was willing to trade his professional reputation and career, not to mention his marriage, for a "chance" to snuggle up to "acquiescent" Knox is just the beginning! Testifying, when asked in court, that he worked on the Knox case is morphed into lying, being dishonest and claiming to have helped "free" Knox! Yep. Same-o, same-o crapola. I'd be willing to pay for it if a real psychologist would spend a few hours reading this forum and give us a professional opinion on the mind that comes up with this stuff. I really would.

What I really love about this meme is they make Amanda a temptress able to get men to do anything for her and then in their next breath say Amanda isn't very pretty.

Koo Koo for Cocoa Puffs.
 
But you can't seem to find anything wrong with their conclusions, so you attack the individuals. Vogt's article is over three years old - it's an old, irrelevant story. Why are you regurgitating this article now? Has your desperation reached new levels?

Consider Vogt's record in covering this case.

She was more than likely the source of Peggy Ganong's often same-day tidbits from the Massei courtroom in 2009, which appeared in PMF and was discussed endlessly. Of course it was the Mingini-case they were covering, which is why (IMO) guilters have been stuck on Mignini's case ever since.

From Italy, Vogt had written an article about what is was like to be a supporter of guilt in Seattle - about the Jacksons, effectively outing them. But that pretty much confirmed that she was linked to the PMF webpage like a dirty shirt.

Vogt was one of the architects of the "Foxy Knoxy" myth. Vogt wrote the "I was there" article for a Seattle newspaper, one that falsely claimed that Knox had confessed to her mother (via secret prison recording) that she'd actually been at the cottage, when she was telling her mother she'd been at Raffaele's.

She tried to investigate Greg Hampikian, for the sole reason that he and the Idaho Innocence project took Knox's and Sollecito's side once they saw the state of the DNA evidence.

Along with Barbie Nadeau, once other news services (like the NYT and Rolling Stone) assigned their own writers to the case, and found something completely different from what Nadeau and Vogt had been pushing - Nadeau and Vogt found themselves on the outs with the US media, and complained that the US Media was becoming biased. This despite the obvious bias that both of them had been pushing virtually unopposed.

In the end, Vogt caved like a tent in Hurricane Irma. When Cassazione acquitted the pair in 2015, Vogt quoted Francesco Maresca (the Kercher's lawyer) that the case was now definitively over, and she switched her own conclusion to, "we will never know what happened." She also started outing guilters.

So it is surprising that a guilter would quote her. It invites this sort of summary - and I for one hope Vixen keeps on bring up An-DRE-a because it is such a hoot recounting her participation in it....

..... and remembering Nadeau, because Andrea did not monetize this case the way Nadeau had.
 
Last edited:
Consider Vogt's record in covering this case.

She was more than likely the source of Peggy Ganong's often same-day tidbits from the Massei courtroom in 2009, which appeared in PMF and was discussed endlessly. Of course it was the Mingini-case they were covering, which is why (IMO) guilters have been stuck on Mignini's case ever since.

From Italy, Vogt had written an article about what is was like to be a supporter of guilt in Seattle - about the Jacksons, effectively outing them. But that pretty much confirmed that she was linked to the PMF webpage like a dirty shirt.

Vogt was one of the architects of the "Foxy Knoxy" myth. Vogt wrote the "I was there" article for a Seattle newspaper, one that falsely claimed that Knox had confessed to her mother (via secret prison recording) that she'd actually been at the cottage, when she was telling her mother she'd been at Raffaele's.

She tried to investigate Greg Hampikian, for the sole reason that he and the Idaho Innocence project took Knox's and Sollecito's side once they saw the state of the DNA evidence.

Along with Barbie Nadeau, once other news services (like the NYT and Rolling Stone) assigned their own writers to the case, and found something completely different from what Nadeau and Vogt had been pushing - Nadeau and Vogt found themselves on the outs with the US media, and complained that the US Media was becoming biased. This despite the obvious bias that both of them had been pushing virtually unopposed.

In the end, Vogt caved like a tent in Hurricane Irma. When Cassazione acquitted the pair in 2015, Vogt quoted Francesco Maresca (the Kercher's lawyer) that the case was now definitively over, and she switched her own conclusion to, "we will never know what happened." She also started outing guilters.

So it is surprising that a guilter would quote her. It invites this sort of summary - and I for one hope Vixen keeps on bring up An-DRE-a because it is such a hoot recounting her participation in it....

..... and remembering Nadeau, because Andrea did not monetize this case the way Nadeau had.

I always laugh when I hear the desperate 'we will never know what happened' position. Sure ......if you have your head up your ass.

This really was maybe the easiest crime in history short of one being videotaped to figure out. We may not know exactly how the murder happened but we do know who did it' about the time he did it and that it happened in the commission of a burglary. We also KNOW that Amanda and Raffaele weren't involved.

What the hell else do we really need to know?
 
I always laugh when I hear the desperate 'we will never know what happened' position. Sure ......if you have your head up your ass.

This really was maybe the easiest crime in history short of one being videotaped to figure out.

When you think of it, it's a huge move. Vogt was also the source of AK and RS being virtually named by Cassazione as the "other assailants" at the end of the Rudy process. IMO this is proof that Vogt haf been getting her info straight fro Mignini, because that's obviously the way he interpreted tbe end of the Rudy process.

Even as Mignini was being shoved aside as the AK/RS process ground on, what Vogt reported was often pure Mignini. They both had every reason to believe that the 2015 Cassazione would simply confirm tbeir views - even if the crime Nencini had described bore little resemblance to Mignini's original prosecution.

So in 2015, where's Vogt going to go other than, "we'll now never know"? Unlike the 2015 Cassazione which knew AK/RS had not been involved, Vogt could hang on to the declaration that the investigation had hopelessly been botched.

There she sits. And so she moves on thinking she's still relevant with the last judicial truth, the only one that matters.
 
Consider Vogt's record in covering this case.

She was more than likely the source of Peggy Ganong's often same-day tidbits from the Massei courtroom in 2009, which appeared in PMF and was discussed endlessly. Of course it was the Mingini-case they were covering, which is why (IMO) guilters have been stuck on Mignini's case ever since.

From Italy, Vogt had written an article about what is was like to be a supporter of guilt in Seattle - about the Jacksons, effectively outing them. But that pretty much confirmed that she was linked to the PMF webpage like a dirty shirt.

Vogt was one of the architects of the "Foxy Knoxy" myth. Vogt wrote the "I was there" article for a Seattle newspaper, one that falsely claimed that Knox had confessed to her mother (via secret prison recording) that she'd actually been at the cottage, when she was telling her mother she'd been at Raffaele's.

She tried to investigate Greg Hampikian, for the sole reason that he and the Idaho Innocence project took Knox's and Sollecito's side once they saw the state of the DNA evidence.

Along with Barbie Nadeau, once other news services (like the NYT and Rolling Stone) assigned their own writers to the case, and found something completely different from what Nadeau and Vogt had been pushing - Nadeau and Vogt found themselves on the outs with the US media, and complained that the US Media was becoming biased. This despite the obvious bias that both of them had been pushing virtually unopposed.

In the end, Vogt caved like a tent in Hurricane Irma. When Cassazione acquitted the pair in 2015, Vogt quoted Francesco Maresca (the Kercher's lawyer) that the case was now definitively over, and she switched her own conclusion to, "we will never know what happened." She also started outing guilters.

So it is surprising that a guilter would quote her. It invites this sort of summary - and I for one hope Vixen keeps on bring up An-DRE-a because it is such a hoot recounting her participation in it....

..... and remembering Nadeau, because Andrea did not monetize this case the way Nadeau had.


Your revisionism of history would make a communist sect proud. A world in which you have the goodies (the proletariat/foakers) on one side and the baddies (the capitalist bastards/police/courts) on the other.





In fact, you are more 'Dave Spart' than Dave Spart.
 

Attachments

  • dave_spart_private_eye.jpg
    dave_spart_private_eye.jpg
    22.7 KB · Views: 1
I always laugh when I hear the desperate 'we will never know what happened' position. Sure ......if you have your head up your ass.

This really was maybe the easiest crime in history short of one being videotaped to figure out. We may not know exactly how the murder happened but we do know who did it' about the time he did it and that it happened in the commission of a burglary. We also KNOW that Amanda and Raffaele weren't involved.

What the hell else do we really need to know?

I agree. <fx faint, lie down in a darkened room>

We know exactly what happened.

As Favi-Martuscelli, Marasca-Bruno, Nencini, Micheli, Massei all point out, Rudy, Mandy and Raffy did it.

No two ways about it.
 
Your revisionism of history would make a communist sect proud. A world in which you have the goodies (the proletariat/foakers) on one side and the baddies (the capitalist bastards/police/courts) on the other.
Yet another citationless claim. You yourself have access to Vogt's blog - you have quoted from it - when it suits you.

Go to her entry following the March 2015 acquittals. It's all there. She revised her position, and started outing-guilters. Maybe you approve of that. She is also the source of the "I was there" misinformation. She has never withdrawn that claim.

http://wrongfulconvictionnews.com/how-a-grad-student-scooped-amanda-knox-trial-journalist-andrea-vogt/

For anyone knowledgeable, this “revelation” is no revelation at all. In fact, a graduate student with blog on Google had published State Department cables with the exact same information (and actually much more than Andrea Vogt provides) in June of 2010! You can visit his blog and see for yourself.

It seems in the last year Andrea Vogt can’t seem to buy a scoop. Earlier this year, Vogt wrote an article supposedly revealing that Amanda Knox was recorded saying “I was there” in reference to being at the murder scene. The truth, however, was that the statement taken in context unequivocally showed that she was not referring to the murder scene, but to her boyfriend Raffaele Sollecito’s apartment. Even the judges who presided over Knox’s case realized this. Andrea Vogt, who attended most of sessions in Amanda Knox’s trial, was either being blatantly dishonest or she was so incompetent that she didn’t even realize she was reporting old news.​
 
Last edited:
Yet another citationless claim. You yourself have access to Vogt's blog - you have quoted from it - when it suits you.

Go to her entry following the March 2015 acquittals. It's all there. She revised her position, and started outing-guilters. Maybe you approve of that. She is also the source of the "I was there" misinformation. She has never withdrawn that claim.

http://wrongfulconvictionnews.com/how-a-grad-student-scooped-amanda-knox-trial-journalist-andrea-vogt/

​

Not sure why you are quoting fanboy Brucie. Has he fallen out of favour, as he didn't bother attending the local 'innocence' event and he's always telling you guys to forget Mandy and move onto other cases.

As for Knox' 'I cannot lie, I was there' comment, she was obviously talking about the cottage. There wouldn't be any need to lie if she was at Raff's. And in any case, he denies it. His last and definitive statement was that he has no idea where she was between 20:45 and 01:00 on the night of the murder.

IMV he is simply playing Prisoners Dilemma, or rather, the Nash Equilibrium. Trying to maximise his own interests by trying to convey an impression that she's more guilty than he is, when truth is, they both switched off their phones together.

And lied about it.

Thus, when Andrea was revealed this comment (taped by the police during visiting hours with her Mom, Edda) it was reported accurately.

The reason she freaked out over the petition filed, was because she was named as a witness and she didn't want her house overturned, as happened to Nadeau.
 
[...]
The reason she freaked out over the petition filed, was because she was named as a witness and she didn't want her house overturned, as happened to Nadeau.
Not going on a snipe hunt this time... Please just tell me what the above is supposed to be about? :confused:
 
When you think of it, it's a huge move. Vogt was also the source of AK and RS being virtually named by Cassazione as the "other assailants" at the end of the Rudy process. IMO this is proof that Vogt haf been getting her info straight fro Mignini, because that's obviously the way he interpreted tbe end of the Rudy process.

Even as Mignini was being shoved aside as the AK/RS process ground on, what Vogt reported was often pure Mignini. They both had every reason to believe that the 2015 Cassazione would simply confirm tbeir views - even if the crime Nencini had described bore little resemblance to Mignini's original prosecution.

So in 2015, where's Vogt going to go other than, "we'll now never know"? Unlike the 2015 Cassazione which knew AK/RS had not been involved, Vogt could hang on to the declaration that the investigation had hopelessly been botched.

There she sits. And so she moves on thinking she's still relevant with the last judicial truth, the only one that matters.
That's what is really annoying. Just how sleazy the press was. Vogt made a hell of a lot of money from this case....or at least enough to pay for a nice vacation in Italy. There is no occupation I can think of that I admire and despise more than the press. It can be done honorably to inform us or it can be done simply to entertain us.

Let's be truthful. By far, the most entertaining theories of this crime have been proposed by Prosecutor Mignini and advanced by Vogt. A sex orgy between attractive young people gone wrong. A Satanic ritual murder of the virtuous Meredith to celebrate Halloween. A deep seeded hatred and envy of the prim and proper English girl Meredith by the hippie American girl.

When in fact, it was a boring burglary that turned into a murder.
 
I agree. <fx faint, lie down in a darkened room>

We know exactly what happened.

As Favi-Martuscelli, Marasca-Bruno, Nencini, Micheli, Massei all point out, Rudy, Mandy and Raffy did it.

No two ways about it.

No two ways about it, some people do have their head up their ass. Maybe, that's why the room appears dark?
 
Last edited:
Seriously, what kind of a diseased mind wants to help murderers 'get away with it'?

You'd have to ask the prosecution team on this case, when they made decisions like not testing the semen stain found next to a rape victim, or not getting the only known eye witness to testify.
 
I agree. <fx faint, lie down in a darkened room>

We know exactly what happened.

As Favi-Martuscelli, Marasca-Bruno, Nencini, Micheli, Massei all point out, Rudy, Mandy and Raffy did it.

No two ways about it.

The PGP know exactly what happened. That's why in 10 years they've never been able to put together a single coherent narrative of the crime lol
 
Not sure why you are quoting fanboy Brucie. Has he fallen out of favour, as he didn't bother attending the local 'innocence' event and he's always telling you guys to forget Mandy and move onto other cases.
This is where it's a reflection on me that I'd bother to respond to such childish stuff. "Fanboy"? "Brucie"? "Mandy"? Readers here can make up their own minds as to the seriousness one should take anything from this poster.

As for Knox' 'I cannot lie, I was there' comment, she was obviously talking about the cottage. There wouldn't be any need to lie if she was at Raff's. And in any case, he denies it. His last and definitive statement was that he has no idea where she was between 20:45 and 01:00 on the night of the murder.
False. Indeed if this was true, then the courts would have used the "I was there" statement to convict. The following is the sum total of what Judge Massei said about the matter in 2010, quoting Knox and then dropping the matter (unlike Vogt who turned it into a faux-confession):

Massei said:
Then, with regard to the intercepted conversation with her mother and father, in which she said ‚ I was there I have no interest in lying, I’m not afraid of the truth‛ and ‚It’s stupid, I can’t say anything but the truth, because I know I was there, I mean, I can’t lie there’s no reason to do it," she explained that the reference to the fact that ‚she was there‛ meant that she was in Raffaele’s apartment.​

IMV he is simply playing Prisoners Dilemma, or rather, the Nash Equilibrium.
As pointed out to you many times upthread, you have not got a clue about either of those dilemma's or equilibriums. It's embarrassing, please stop it.

Thus, when Andrea was revealed this comment (taped by the police during visiting hours with her Mom, Edda) it was reported accurately.
No it was not. IMV Vogt simply was told this by Mignini, before the judgement was made. So obviously unknown to them (when Massei got around to dealing with the matter months' later in his report), even one of the convicting judges (Massei) did not buy it.

Why do you?

Ok, true or false:

Did Vogt eventually (circa March 2015) declare that the case had ended with a definitive acquittal? TRUE or FALSE

Did Vogt write that her final position on this was that the truth would never be known? TRUE or FALSE

Did Vogt out guilters in that blog posting? TRUE or FALSE
 
Last edited:
You'd have to ask the prosecution team on this case, when they made decisions like not testing the semen stain found next to a rape victim, or not getting the only known eye witness to testify.

Since Rude Guede was the only known eye witness and also accused of the crime, he could not be forced to testify - at least not until he was finally convicted.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom