The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
What? Argumemnon has been picking up on your embarrassing mistakes in this area for several posts now (during which time you've made things far worse for yourself by doubling down in an ever more amusing exposition of ineptitude).

Has it not perhaps occurred to you, Vixen, that Argumemnon knows an awful lot more about this whole area than you do, and sought to correct you, yet was met with a rather *ahem* assertive digging in by way of "reply"?

As for the passive-aggressive "we all know whom this reflects badly on, and it's not me" schtick.....well, those three little initials Q.E.D. cover that one off quite well :D

Don't use your ridiculous Americanisms with me.
 
Don't use your ridiculous Americanisms with me.

What are you on about? Who cares if it's a regional expression? It describes what you're doing and that I've pointed out before. How about you address the points made rather than engage in this embarrassing display?
 
NHS is run by laypeople? I'll remind you that you're a layperson as well.



Please stop embarassing yourself. First you said that to qualify as a mental health issue, the sufferer has to seek medical health, which is patently false, but now you're saying that mental health issues necessarily involve drugs.

Do you know _anything_ about this topic?



Flu IS spread by germs. But you wouldn't need antibiotics for it as the germs in question are viruses.

I said nothing of the sort.

What I did say was mental illness causes the sufferer distress, whether or not they go to the doctors. Mental illnesses can be treated.

Sociopathy is considered by many to be incurable.

Sociopathic criminals (also known as Anti-Social Behaviour Disordered individuals) can respond somewhat to Behaviourist therapy, where they are rewarded for being nice and 'doing the right thing'. However, this is just a party trick, as it doesn't change the underlying personality disorder.
 
What are you on about? Who cares if it's a regional expression? It describes what you're doing and that I've pointed out before. How about you address the points made rather than engage in this embarrassing display?


OK OK Sociopaths are merely mentally ill and their illness self-limiting. With a course of prescriptions and physiotherapy they will soon feel better.
 
I said nothing of the sort.

Yes you did:

I'll try to explain one more time, then I'll give up.

I take it you have heard of 'extroversion' and 'introversion'? These are known as basic 'personality traits'.

You will have heard of 'schizophrenia', 'psychosis', 'bipolar disorder' and 'clinical depression.'

OK. You can be extrovert which describes your personality. Being extrovert or introvert is not a 'mental illness'.

'Schizophrenia', 'psychosis', 'bipolar disorder' and 'clinical depression' are mental illnesses.

A psychopath is a description of someone with a cluster of personality traits.

Psychopaths are as happy with their personalities in the same way as extroverts and introverts. They do not seek medical help. They are not in distress.

But then you already knew that, didn't you?

The above clearly implies that seeking medical help is an important part of something being an illness. Of course, that's not the case, as with everything else you've been claiming, but that's beside the point.

What I did say was mental illness causes the sufferer distress, whether or not they go to the doctors. Mental illnesses can be treated.

Oh, so now it needs to be treatable in order to qualify as an illness. Could you give us a complete list of features because you keep adding them each time you post.

Sociopathy is considered by many to be incurable.

So's AIDS so far but it's still a disease.
 
OK OK Sociopaths are merely mentally ill and their illness self-limiting. With a course of prescriptions and physiotherapy they will soon feel better.

Again, what are you on about? What is it about mental illness that has anything to do with prescriptions and physiotherapy?

Do you even know what mental illness is? For someone who claimed to have credentials in this field you sure are displaying what I can only describe as negative net knowledge on this topic, because you should know some of this stuff by simple virtue of being alive.
 
Again, what are you on about? What is it about mental illness that has anything to do with prescriptions and physiotherapy?

Do you even know what mental illness is? For someone who claimed to have credentials in this field you sure are displaying what I can only describe as negative net knowledge on this topic, because you should know some of this stuff by simple virtue of being alive.

Glad to have made you feel better.
 
OK OK Sociopaths are merely mentally ill and their illness self-limiting. With a course of prescriptions and physiotherapy they will soon feel better.


OK OK Late-stage bowel cancer sufferers are merely physiologically ill and their illness self-limiting. With a course of prescriptions and physiotherapy they will soon feel better.


Your flippant attempt at a reductio ad absurdum fails miserably. Something can be correctly defined as an illness - whether a mental health illness or physiological illness - regardless of a) whether or not it is even potentially treatable with any combination of pharmacology or other treatments, or b) whether any such combination of treatments is likely to "cure" (or even arrest or even slow the progression of) the illness.

Psychopathy - and pretty much every personality disorder - is indeed a mental health illness. Some forms of psychopathy may be treatable (to the extent of alleviating or slowing the progression of the condition) by combinations of medicinal therapy and behavioural therapy. However, in many instances of illnesses such as psychopathy, these forms of clinical intervention may potentially make the illness worse.

But, just as some forms of aggressive chemotherapy on late stage cancers may cause more suffering and an earlier death of the patient, that doesn't stop enlightened, well-informed medical professionals from terming all forms of cancer, in all stages of progression, as a form of physiological illness/disease.

And likewise, only an extremely uninformed (and unscientific) lay person would try to claim that personality disorders such as psychopathy are not mental health illnesses - especially when the "rationale" for this refusal to categorise as such seems to be largely based on whether medicinal (and/or behavioural therapy) intervention might have any efficacy in treating the condition.

Back to school. Or the British Library.
 
And likewise, only an extremely uninformed (and unscientific) lay person would try to claim that personality disorders such as psychopathy are not mental health illnesses - especially when the "rationale" for this refusal to categorise as such seems to be largely based on whether medicinal (and/or behavioural therapy) intervention might have any efficacy in treating the condition.

...or whether the person suffering from it is happy with his or her condition.
 
Don't use your ridiculous Americanisms with me.


Oooh oooooh better get in touch with Ian Fleming (from beyond the grave of course - though I understand you have associates among the pro-guilt nutters who claim some expertise in this area.....) and get him to erase the many literal and figurative times his James Bond character uses the term in the Bond books (it's a term from the card game BlackJack - or "21" as Bond would likely have referred to it more usually).

Heaven forfend that the quintessentially British Bond (especially the Bond of the original Fleming books) would have stooped to using "ridiculous Americanisms"!


And now that nonsense is out of the way, how about you address the substantial thrust of that post of mine, Vixen. I find it impossible to believe, after all, that you were attempting a little misdirection in order to avoid having to address the substance of my post :D
 

OK OK Late-stage bowel cancer sufferers are merely physiologically ill and their illness self-limiting. With a course of prescriptions and physiotherapy they will soon feel better.


Your flippant attempt at a reductio ad absurdum fails miserably. Something can be correctly defined as an illness - whether a mental health illness or physiological illness - regardless of a) whether or not it is even potentially treatable with any combination of pharmacology or other treatments, or b) whether any such combination of treatments is likely to "cure" (or even arrest or even slow the progression of) the illness.

Psychopathy - and pretty much every personality disorder - is indeed a mental health illness. Some forms of psychopathy may be treatable (to the extent of alleviating or slowing the progression of the condition) by combinations of medicinal therapy and behavioural therapy. However, in many instances of illnesses such as psychopathy, these forms of clinical intervention may potentially make the illness worse.

But, just as some forms of aggressive chemotherapy on late stage cancers may cause more suffering and an earlier death of the patient, that doesn't stop enlightened, well-informed medical professionals from terming all forms of cancer, in all stages of progression, as a form of physiological illness/disease.

And likewise, only an extremely uninformed (and unscientific) lay person would try to claim that personality disorders such as psychopathy are not mental health illnesses - especially when the "rationale" for this refusal to categorise as such seems to be largely based on whether medicinal (and/or behavioural therapy) intervention might have any efficacy in treating the condition.

Back to school. Or the British Library.


There was a programme on TV the other night, 'Horizon' about how to diagnose psychopaths at an early age (look up Uta Frith, the narrator).

She interviewed three men, each of whom had committed appalling crimes, and who she believed fit many of the criteria in the Hare's Diagnostic scale: no remorse, glib superficial, promiscous, recidivist (they committed a whole range of crimes and they never learned from their mistakes [punishment]).

They had little empathy. Were unable to identify an expression fear. One said the look of fright on a graphically reproduced face 'was just like the look' one of his victims gave him when he stabbed her. The reasons for their crimes were invariably trite. One said he 'didn't like obstacles in his way'. His murder was appalling.

None regretted their crime beyond, 'oh now I've lost my car and my home'.

The punchline?



None of them had been diagnosed as a sociopath.


When she suggested to them they might be psychopathic, they all denied it and were even offended.


Dr Frith also asked a psychopathology expert, 'But wouldn't all of us have one or two psychopathic traits?'


He responded, 'Actually, the vast majority of people would score zero.'


Brain scans showed the brains of psychopaths are different. Thus, Frith said she felt sorry for them, because they cannot help their personality.


A group of criminal sociopaths where given group therapy, including notorious killer, David Krueger.


Results? Whilst group therapy helps non-sociopath prisoners, to their shock, it was discovered Krueger and his group went on to commit even worse crimes on their release.


Lesson? Psychopathy is not caused by underlying pathology, it has had very limited success in using a basic reward-stimulus model - as one might train a dog - and as soon as the deliquent is out, no doubt quickly forgotten.

I personally know persons who have been diagnosed as bipolar, and she is on lithium for life and it has played havoc with her thyroid gland and another guy in my community, who hears voices. He is under psychiatric care and suffers terrible depression and isolation.

That is mental illness.
 
'he later told colleagues it was like a scene from Baghdad.'

How would the reporter know what the officer told his colleagues since he never contacted the officer? No one was arrested, a simple ticket was issued and a fine was paid and Amanda never set foot in court.

So Vixen does it again. First she concludes that Nina is lying and is a manipulator. Then she lies about the reporter who wrote the article and the publication it was in and then says the article was 'fine journalism'. Never mind he only got one thing going right. Amanda hosted a party.

Vixen proves again that truth is irrelevant and that she will lie about anything.

Amanda did have to show up in court, but only to pay the fine. But you are correct that she was never arrested and it is a misdemeanor equivalent to a traffic ticket in seriousness.
 
Amanda did have to show up in court, but only to pay the fine. But you are correct that she was never arrested and it is a misdemeanor equivalent to a traffic ticket in seriousness.


Are you sure? Because she didn't have to. My guess if she did go she did it to get the fine reduced. In Seattle, they have a magistrate's office where they will lower most fines automatically. You're in the court house but technically not in court.
 
I was referring to John Follain's SUNDAY TIMES article wherein he spoke to acquaintances of Knox from Seattle, who described her wild behaviour to him.?

Link to this alleged article? I've been unable to find any such article. Not that you'd make this up.:rolleyes:

Incidentally, do you have any evidence the said policeman doesn't exist?

Do you have any evidence the said policeman does exist? What we have is Officer Bender's complete report which belies Andrew Malone's (not Follain's) fabricated story. From what I have been able to find (or not find, in this case) is any other story about Knox or the murder by this Scots journalist (and I use the term very liberally). I'd bet Malone never set foot in Seattle much less interviewed anyone in/from Seattle about anything.
 
Are you sure? Because she didn't have to. My guess if she did go she did it to get the fine reduced. In Seattle, they have a magistrate's office where they will lower most fines automatically. You're in the court house but technically not in court.

I'm sure that she went to the courthouse to pay the fine with money collected from the people at the party. I will concede that I'm not sure she had to appear in court. She may have been able to mail it in just as we can mail in traffic ticket fines.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom