The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
I had better not tell you as it might trigger a fit of envy in one or two posters.

In other words, none whatsoever.

You're pulling these "facts" out of your behind. Now, I haven't followed this thread (who could?) but it seems to be a theme.

Of course personality disorders have something to do with mental health.
 
Sorry to disappoint you, but I don't hate Burleigh at all. I feel sorry for her and pity her conceit.

After saying that Burleigh doesn't rate even a passing mention, you've gone on a three-day insult spree about her on this thread, and have even speculated that Burleigh is such a bad character because she'd been raised (your words) "by stoned hippies"!

And we're supposed to believe you when you say you don't hate her?

Right.
 
Last edited:
In other words, none whatsoever.

You're pulling these "facts" out of your behind. Now, I haven't followed this thread (who could?) but it seems to be a theme.

Of course personality disorders have something to do with mental health.

I'll try to explain one more time, then I'll give up.

I take it you have heard of 'extroversion' and 'introversion'? These are known as basic 'personality traits'.

You will have heard of 'schizophrenia', 'psychosis', 'bipolar disorder' and 'clinical depression.'


OK. You can be extrovert which describes your personality. Being extrovert or introvert is not a 'mental illness'.

'Schizophrenia', 'psychosis', 'bipolar disorder' and 'clinical depression' are mental illnesses.

A psychopath is a description of someone with a cluster of personality traits.

Psychopaths are as happy with their personalities in the same way as extroverts and introverts. They do not seek medical help. They are not in distress.

But then you already knew that, didn't you?
 
In other words, none whatsoever.

You're pulling these "facts" out of your behind. Now, I haven't followed this thread (who could?) but it seems to be a theme.

Of course personality disorders have something to do with mental health.

If you've followed the thread, Vixen said both. She settled back on her first position after consulting Wikipedia and abandoned that she briefly claimed they were one and the same.

More to the point, it is on such things that haters call Knox a liar. First she'd said she'd been at Raffaele's, then at unrecorded interrogation said she imagined herself at the cottage, then reverted back to version 1.

So by PGP's own standards we're witnessing a psychopath at work in this thread in the past three days. Whether or not that is also a mental illness means consulting Wikipedia.
 
Last edited:
Has it ever crossed your mind there might be several witnesses to this party?

So? Who was there? Why isn't any of their names in the article?

Has it ever crossed your mind that the reporter wrote the article from the perspective of a police officer? And QUOTED supposedly his 'colleagues'. HOW DID HE DO THAT? Seriously? I spoke directly with the officer. And no reporter EVER contacted him about the incident. So how does he know who his colleagues are? What does that tell you Vixen? And that the details in the officer's incident report don't match the story. The article says Knox was arrested. The incident report says a noise infraction was issued.

You really have to start using some critical thinking skills.
 
I'll try to explain one more time, then I'll give up.

I take it you have heard of 'extroversion' and 'introversion'? These are known as basic 'personality traits'.

You will have heard of 'schizophrenia', 'psychosis', 'bipolar disorder' and 'clinical depression.'

OK. You can be extrovert which describes your personality. Being extrovert or introvert is not a 'mental illness'.

'Schizophrenia', 'psychosis', 'bipolar disorder' and 'clinical depression' are mental illnesses.

A psychopath is a description of someone with a cluster of personality traits.

Psychopaths are as happy with their personalities in the same way as extroverts and introverts. They do not seek medical help. They are not in distress.

But then you already knew that, didn't you?

Yeah but you made a mistake in your explanation. Shall I tell you?

A trait is not a disorder. That's why an extrovert is not mentally ill. You said yourself that psychopaths have a personality disorder. I have explained to you already why such a disorder is a mental health issue. And in response you post irrelevancies about things that are not disorders.

Furthermore, you've just shown that you, in fact, have no mental health qualification when you essentially claimed that people with mental heath issues seek medical help as a matter of course. They often don't, and that's one of many problems they have to face.

Seriously, you proudly broadcast your ignorance with every post you make, because you refuse to ever admit to making a mistake, and double down instead.
 
Has it ever crossed your mind there might be several witnesses to this party?

Here's what responding officer Jason Bender wrote:

I was on uniformed patrol in the marked unit as 3U5. At approximately 0028 hours, I responded to the report of a loud party in the listed location. The complainant relayed to dispatch that participants from the party were throwing rocks at his house and at passing cars. The complainant requested officer not contact him. Upon arrival, I noted loud amplified music coming from the listed address. The music could be heard from a distance greater than 75 ft from the source. I also noted several rocks in the street. I did not locate any damage at that time. I contacted a party participant and had them retrieve a resident.

S1/Knox contacted me (in front of the house). She stated that she was one of the current residents. She stated that she was the one who was hosting the party (as she was moving out). She stated that she was not aware of any rock throwers at the gathering.

I issued S1/Knox this infraction for the noise violation and a warning for the rock throwing. I explained how dangerous and juvenile that action was.

See Cad event 264012 for further.

No further action taken at this time.

A loud party... now that's something that never happens with college kids. Several rocks in the road but he did not witness anyone throwing any so they could have been there prior to the party or could have been thrown by people not attending the party. Regardless, it was hardly a scene out of Baghdad. If it was it would have been reflected in the responding officer's report.

Why is it I'm not surprised you find this to be perfectly good journalism. You embrace a few websites that also write extensive fiction on the case and we know you think very highly of them.
 
If a journalist ever deserved to be called "dishonest" and a "manipulator", it's Nick Pisa. Do I have evidence of this? Yes: his completely fake "GUILTY!" article for the DM in 2011 which was full of made up quotes, reactions, and incidents. None of which ever happened. Yet where is the PGP criticism of him?

Here: (It shows up first under "Great reporting" in the sidebar of TJMK)
TJMK: Netflixhoax 16: Omitted - How Netflix Maliciously Depicted Good Reporting As Fictitious Hype

[...]
4. Nick Pisa’s Real Reports On The Case

Fortunately for the hard truth, what we often called the “Rome pool” of foreign correspondents included nearly a dozen exceptionally talented reporters (those posted in other countries usually are the cream of the crop).

Thanks to their very hard work and their incessant costly travel to Perugia, we were able to repost on the 2008 and 2009 developments with a scope far beyond what any one “man on the spot” could do (we did have several of those too).

Free-lancer Nick Pisa in fact reported from the court for a lot of media outlets in the UK, not simply one. He was the only non-Italian reporter to pretty consistently have a cameraman along, for his reports for Sky News, and some of his good video reports still show.

This kind of fast, comprehensive coverage badly rattled the Knoxes and Mellases and their camps and especially diminished their PR, and they openly displayed angry aggression at times.

We’ll describe in the next post their desperate attempts to demonize all of the few reporters they did not have on a chain as coming straight from hell.

We have carried a total of 35 of Nick Pisa’s reports, in whole or in part. Check them all out below. Do you see ANY bias here?
[...]
It's interesting that the above post was originally headlined:
Netflixhoax: Omitted - How Netflix Depicted Media Coverage 180 Degrees Away From The Truth #1...
 
Yeah but you made a mistake in your explanation. Shall I tell you?

A trait is not a disorder. That's why an extrovert is not mentally ill. You said yourself that psychopaths have a personality disorder. I have explained to you already why such a disorder is a mental health issue. And in response you post irrelevancies about things that are not disorders.

Furthermore, you've just shown that you, in fact, have no mental health qualification when you essentially claimed that people with mental heath issues seek medical help as a matter of course. They often don't, and that's one of many problems they have to face.

Seriously, you proudly broadcast your ignorance with every post you make, because you refuse to ever admit to making a mistake, and double down instead.


A personality disorder is not a mental illness. Full stop.

If it causes problems, they will be social and criminal problems.

Incidentally, extroversion and introversion are both 'clusters of traits'. Not all extroverts will show all extrovert traits.

Likewise, psychopaths differ from one another according to range of psychopathic personality traits.
 
Last edited:
Here's what responding officer Jason Bender wrote:



A loud party... now that's something that never happens with college kids. Several rocks in the road but he did not witness anyone throwing any so they could have been there prior to the party or could have been thrown by people not attending the party. Regardless, it was hardly a scene out of Baghdad. If it was it would have been reflected in the responding officer's report.

Why is it I'm not surprised you find this to be perfectly good journalism. You embrace a few websites that also write extensive fiction on the case and we know you think very highly of them.


I was referring to John Follain's SUNDAY TIMES article wherein he spoke to acquaintances of Knox from Seattle, who described her wild behaviour to him.


Incidentally, do you have any evidence the said policeman doesn't exist?
 
A personality disorder is not a mental illness. Full stop.



Oooh, are you listening, NHS England?!! Online self-appointed "expert" Vixen is telling you that you're wrong to state that a personality disorder is a mental health condition (AKA "mental illness"):

Personality disorders are common mental health problems

http://www.nhs.uk/conditions/personality-disorder/Pages/Definition.aspx


And that's before we even start with the piles of credible academic literature which state that personality disorders such as psychopathy absolutely ARE a category of mental health illness (and that pretty much the only reason why there have been historic attempts to deny them that categorisation has everything to do with funding and outcome measurement issues, rather than a cold, objective assessment on its own terms).

But hey, who doesn't love a good old-fashioned digging-in-ever-deeper embarrassment of a Thursday evening! Pass the popcorn :D
 
Contrary to what you might think, bullying and mobbing reflects on you, not me.

Playing the victim card reflects on you, however.

Seriously, I'm the only one discussing this specific thing with you. How is that mobbing? (ETA: ok, LondonJohn jumped in now, but two is not a mob.)

And if you feel that everybody disagrees with you, maybe you should ask yourself if that means you're wrong and too proud to admit it.

Now, how about you address what I said?
 
Last edited:
I was referring to John Follain's SUNDAY TIMES article wherein he spoke to acquaintances of Knox from Seattle, who described her wild behaviour to him.

Incidentally, do you have any evidence the said policeman doesn't exist?

Excuse me? I was the one who brought up the party. I am unaware of Follain writing said article. I know of the original article published in the Daily Mail. Care to provide a citation? BECAUSE THIS IS ANOTHER LIE. This is the problem with discussing this case with you. YOU LIE. OVER and OVER and OVER.

I'll issue an apology if you can provide a citation where Follain writes in the Times and quotes named individuals who were at the party. In the MEAN TIME.. YOU'RE A LIAR.

No one said the officer doesn't exist. Just that neither Follain or any reporter EVER contacted the officer. The STORY is a TOTAL EMBELLISHMENT of the Police report and you have to be GULLIBLE...GULLIBLE..GULLIBLE not to see it.
 
Oooh, are you listening, NHS England?!! Online self-appointed "expert" Vixen is telling you that you're wrong to state that a personality disorder is a mental health condition (AKA "mental illness"):

Personality disorders are common mental health problems

http://www.nhs.uk/conditions/personality-disorder/Pages/Definition.aspx


And that's before we even start with the piles of credible academic literature which state that personality disorders such as psychopathy absolutely ARE a category of mental health illness (and that pretty much the only reason why there have been historic attempts to deny them that categorisation has everything to do with funding and outcome measurement issues, rather than a cold, objective assessment on its own terms).

But hey, who doesn't love a good old-fashioned digging-in-ever-deeper embarrassment of a Thursday evening! Pass the popcorn :D

Big deal. So a lay person calls a sociopath 'mentally ill'.

Perhaps you'd like to tell us what drugs will be prescribed for it.

You remind me of people who describe flu as being spread by 'germs' and demanding antibiotics for it.
 
Last edited:
Contrary to what you might think, bullying and mobbing reflects on you, not me. So you thought you'd join in.


What? Argumemnon has been picking up on your embarrassing mistakes in this area for several posts now (during which time you've made things far worse for yourself by doubling down in an ever more amusing exposition of ineptitude).

Has it not perhaps occurred to you, Vixen, that Argumemnon knows an awful lot more about this whole area than you do, and sought to correct you, yet was met with a rather *ahem* assertive digging in by way of "reply"?

As for the passive-aggressive "we all know whom this reflects badly on, and it's not me" schtick.....well, those three little initials Q.E.D. cover that one off quite well :D
 
Big deal. So a lay person calls a sociopath 'mentally ill'.

Perhaps you'd like to tell us what drugs will be prescribed for it.



AHHHHHH! So

1) The curators of the NHS website are "lay person(s)", are they...?

2) You're NOT a "lay person", are you...? (AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!)

3) You think that an illness only meets that definition if "drugs (can) be prescribed for it", do you...?

You have so little idea of what you're talking about, it's beneath contempt. Particularly in the sensitive - and much stigmatised - area of mental health illnessess. You should be ashamed.
 
Big deal. So a lay person calls a sociopath 'mentally ill'.

NHS is run by laypeople? I'll remind you that you're a layperson as well.

Perhaps you'd like to tell us what drugs will be prescribed for it.

Please stop embarassing yourself. First you said that to qualify as a mental health issue, the sufferer has to seek medical health, which is patently false, but now you're saying that mental health issues necessarily involve drugs.

Do you know _anything_ about this topic?

You remind me of people who describe flu as being spread by 'germs' and demanding antibiotics for it.

Flu IS spread by germs. But you wouldn't need antibiotics for it as the germs in question are viruses.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom