The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's perhaps an exaggeration to say that this (highlighted part) was the sole purpose of the hate-sites - the PMF's (one now closed), TJMK (which regularly utters threats against all and sundry), and the fake-Wiki. They contain valuable raw-documents, but they otherwise seem to exist only to utter threats against people they disagree with.

It's not just that Conti-Vecchiotti found reason to trash Stefanoni's DNA work, in a lab not certified to do the necessary DNA work - they felt compelled to denigrate them and accuse them of being criminals.

It's not just that Dr. Peter Gill - the father of LCN DNA forensics - wrote peer-reviewed articles trashing Stefanoni's DNA work - the haters felt compelled to denigrate them and accuse him of shilling for the defence.

It's not just that Steve Moore, Saul Kassin, John Douglas, and Ron Hendry looked at the case and found that the Perugian authorities rushed into an unfounded judgment - the haters felt compelled to denigrate them and accuse them of all sorts of things, and even campaign to get one of them fired from their job. (He's now a senior justice-commentator on CNN International, so seems to have landed on his feet....)

It's not just that Judges Hellmann, Zanetti, Marasca, and Bruno deemed the case unfounded and acquitted the pair - they felt compelled to denigrate them and accuse them of a Masonic/US Media conspiracy to pervert justice in Italy. They even pull President of the Perugia Appeals Court Wladimiro De Nunzio of a "Machiavellian move" to slip Hellmann into the second trial!

It's not just that Nina Burleigh's parents raised her - they felt compelled to denigrate them and accuse them of being itinerant, "stoned hippies" which is (apparently) the reason why Nina Burleigh now "sees herself in Amanda Knox".

The whole world is corrupt, except for them - and except for Mignini.

Why is that?

Actually, those sites had two purposes. One was to pedal 'their' version of the crime, which included their spin on;

- The evidence
- How to interpret the evidence
- How people behaved
- What people said
- Why people said what they said
- What is proper procedure and protocol for the forensic investigation

The other purpose was to denigrate anyone who might otherwise call into question their version of the crime. It's not good for them when DNA experts like C & V, Gil, Hampikian, etc., all argue the DNA results are garbage. And when they can't refute what the experts are saying they are left with only one option... denigrate them.

The PIP don't need to denigrate the people involved because we can argue with facts, science and logic. That's why it's only the PGP sites that are restricted to PG posters only.
 
Actually, those sites had two purposes. One was to pedal 'their' version of the crime, which included their spin on;

- The evidence
- How to interpret the evidence
- How people behaved
- What people said
- Why people said what they said
- What is proper procedure and protocol for the forensic investigation

The other purpose was to denigrate anyone who might otherwise call into question their version of the crime. It's not good for them when DNA experts like C & V, Gil, Hampikian, etc., all argue the DNA results are garbage. And when they can't refute what the experts are saying they are left with only one option... denigrate them.


The PIP don't need to denigrate the people involved because we can argue with facts, science and logic. That's why it's only the PGP sites that are restricted to PG posters only.

They do refute what the experts are saying. The problem is that they refute the experts by misstating and misrepresenting what they say. For example, claiming that Gill said DNA is highly unlikely to transfer after 24 hours therefore contamination of the bra hook or the knife is also highly unlikely. As I quoted (with citation) Gill actually said that transfer can happen after seven days or even longer. First they denigrate the experts on a scientific basis and, when that fails, then comes the denigration on a personal level.
 
They do refute what the experts are saying. The problem is that they refute the experts by misstating and misrepresenting what they say. For example, claiming that Gill said DNA is highly unlikely to transfer after 24 hours therefore contamination of the bra hook or the knife is also highly unlikely. As I quoted (with citation) Gill actually said that transfer can happen after seven days or even longer. First they denigrate the experts on a scientific basis and, when that fails, then comes the denigration on a personal level.

Agreed, although I find it to be fairly rare. For example, they have never tried to refute anything C&V stated in their report... it's always been about attacking them, as if that made what they said in the report incorrect.
 
Nina Burleigh sees Amanda Knox in herself. That is why she fell over herself to paint Knox as innocent.

NONSENSE. It was the other way around. She saw Amanda as innocent and then saw that Amanda was very much like herself. You keep thinking that just because you are incapable of seeing the obvious that Nina should be just as blind and logically challenged.

Let's see...Hmmmm. Are all these people manipulators and untrustworthy? All must have hippie stoner parents too?

Judge Hellman
Judge Marasca
Judge Heavey
Judge Zanetti
Judge Bruno
Judge Guardiano
Judge Pistorelli
Judge Positano
Detective John Douglass
Dr Peter Gill
Dr. Hampikian
Candace Dempsey

But because Nina joked about giving Bill Clinton a blowjob her analysis must be suspect?

Get real.
 
Flippant? Common as muck.
AIUI she spent her childhood being dragged around the country freeloading with her stoned hippie parents.
So you don't mind her offering married men blow jobs 'because she thinks they are attractive', but you are happy that black men are stereotyped by her as 'drifters' and the 'obvious burglar/rapist/murderer'.



Please get your priorities right.

Wrong again. Her parents took her to San Francisco for a year. Her father was a Ph.D candidate but gave it up. They were not "stoned hippies". From her article, which I suspect is the source of your . ..ahem..."AIUI" alternative facts:

My parents didn’t do drugs and I did not recognize the smell wafting in the streets until someone lit up a joint in high school.

https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/11/travel/haight-ashbury-san-francisco.html
 
You do realise that "illness" means "unwell" which means "unhealthy", right?

A psychopath is not mentally ill. They can be mentally ill, but it is not contingent on being a psychopath.

As I said, psychopathy is a personality disorder, not a mental illness.

Anyway, I realise laymen find it a real struggle to understand the difference, so I'll let you have the last word.
 
I don't know who wrote the Daily Mail article about the party in Seattle but that was a total lie. It was clear that the reporter hadn't spoke with anyone. He just took the police report and then crafted as outrageous story he could out of it. He quotes 'un-named party goers. I know he never talked to the officer because I have.

That was the kind of journalism that was emblematic in this case. Cheap sensationalism.

AFAIAA the original article was from the SUNDAY TIMES by John Follain (for it is he), who spoke to people who knew Knox from her Seattle days.


Perfectly good journalism.
 
Wrong again. Her parents took her to San Francisco for a year. Her father was a Ph.D candidate but gave it up. They were not "stoned hippies". From her article, which I suspect is the source of your . ..ahem..."AIUI" alternative facts:



https://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/11/travel/haight-ashbury-san-francisco.html

LOL Bill Clinton never inhaled. Burleigh's parents made a bee-line for Haight-Astbury and never smoked pot or dropped acid.


Yeah, we believe you.

Well it looks like they messed up their kid.
 
A psychopath is not mentally ill. They can be mentally ill, but it is not contingent on being a psychopath.

As I said, psychopathy is a personality disorder, not a mental illness.

Anyway, I realise laymen find it a real struggle to understand the difference, so I'll let you have the last word.

Strangely there is some rarefied merit to this claim. There is a small school of thought which agrees with you.

However, your whole thesis is bogus, given that no one in the whole Perugian murder and subsequent debacle was diagnosed as either. There have been many arm-chair, internet "psychiatrists" which, ironically, Nina Burleigh exposed. One was a resident of Bath, England, who'd contributed arm-chair psychological diagnoses anonymously that people like you lapped up....

..... but when Burleigh found that this woman was:

The operator of the site turned out to be a young social media expert in Bath, working at a UK social media company, horrified that I had emailed her at work. In a pleading email, she begged me not to publish her real name, which I will not do, and wrote: “Miss Represented was only ever supposed to be a place for my own reflections, some of them I still stand by, some of them I’ve rethought as I’ve gotten a little older and bit more mature.”​
But that does not stop you, or the remaining hate-sites, from continuing as if you're on to something.

What you'd rather do is try to divert into a convo on the differences between personality disorder and mental illness, which not all professionals agree there is much difference.

It's all part of the hater-game.
 
AFAIAA the original article was from the SUNDAY TIMES by John Follain (for it is he), who spoke to people who knew Knox from her Seattle days.


Perfectly good journalism.

John Follain. Perfectly good journalism.

Right.
 
A psychopath is not mentally ill. They can be mentally ill, but it is not contingent on being a psychopath.

As I said, psychopathy is a personality disorder, not a mental illness.

And I've already explained to you that this is a distinction without a difference. Did you already forget those posts?

Anyway, I realise laymen find it a real struggle to understand the difference

What are your credentials?
 
AFAIAA the original article was from the SUNDAY TIMES by John Follain (for it is he), who spoke to people who knew Knox from her Seattle days.


Perfectly good journalism.

Um, no. It was in the DM Online and was concocted by Andrew Malone. Please do at least a bit of research before posting misinformation. Nor was it "good journalism" as the gross exaggeration and downright false information printed has been thoroughly debunked by the actual police report. I can draw of a list of proven lies in that fiction if you'd like. Of course, I understand how some would think concocting a story not based on evidence is considered "perfectly good journalism" by some.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-498853/The-wild-raunchy-past-Foxy-Knoxy.html
 
Last edited:
LOL Bill Clinton never inhaled. Burleigh's parents made a bee-line for Haight-Astbury and never smoked pot or dropped acid.


Yeah, we believe you.

Well it looks like they messed up their kid.

Of course you don't believe her. You don't believe anything except the worst from anyone who thinks Burleigh is innocent. They all lie because they are a bunch of immoral manipulators who are bought off by the PR machine or pressured by the US State Dept. Right?

Still, you have absolutely no proof that either of Burleigh's parents ever used drugs. But why let that get in the way of a good smear?
Please keep proving Burleigh's point that she made in her article about haters learning to hate her too.
 
Of course you don't believe her. You don't believe anything except the worst from anyone who thinks Burleigh is innocent. They all lie because they are a bunch of immoral manipulators who are bought off by the PR machine or pressured by the US State Dept. Right?

Still, you have absolutely no proof that either of Burleigh's parents ever used drugs. But why let that get in the way of a good smear?
Please keep proving Burleigh's point that she made in her article about haters learning to hate her too.

That Vixen doesn't see this says it all.
 
AFAIAA the original article was from the SUNDAY TIMES by John Follain (for it is he), who spoke to people who knew Knox from her Seattle days.


Perfectly good journalism.

Um, no. It was in the DM Online and was concocted by Andrew Malone. Please do at least a bit of research before posting misinformation. Nor was it "good journalism" as the gross exaggeration and downright false information printed has been thoroughly debunked by the actual police report. I can draw of a list of proven lies in that fiction if you'd like. Of course, I understand how some would think concocting a story not based on evidence is considered "perfectly good journalism" by some.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-498853/The-wild-raunchy-past-Foxy-Knoxy.html

'he later told colleagues it was like a scene from Baghdad.'

How would the reporter know what the officer told his colleagues since he never contacted the officer? No one was arrested, a simple ticket was issued and a fine was paid and Amanda never set foot in court.

So Vixen does it again. First she concludes that Nina is lying and is a manipulator. Then she lies about the reporter who wrote the article and the publication it was in and then says the article was 'fine journalism'. Never mind he only got one thing going right. Amanda hosted a party.

Vixen proves again that truth is irrelevant and that she will lie about anything.
 
Last edited:
Of course you don't believe her. You don't believe anything except the worst from anyone who thinks Burleigh is innocent. They all lie because they are a bunch of immoral manipulators who are bought off by the PR machine or pressured by the US State Dept. Right?

Still, you have absolutely no proof that either of Burleigh's parents ever used drugs. But why let that get in the way of a good smear?
Please keep proving Burleigh's point that she made in her article about haters learning to hate her too.

Sorry to disappoint you, but I don't hate Burleigh at all. I feel sorry for her and pity her conceit.
 
'he later told colleagues it was like a scene from Baghdad.'

How would the reporter know what the officer told his colleagues since he never contacted the officer? No one was arrested, a simple ticket was issued and a fine was paid and Amanda never set foot in court.

So Vixen does it again. First she concludes that Nina is lying and is a manipulator. Then she lies about the reporter who wrote the article and the publication it was in and then says the article was 'fine journalism'. Never mind he only got one thing going right. Amanda hosted a party.

Vixen proves again that truth is irrelevant and that she will lie about anything.


Has it ever crossed your mind there might be several witnesses to this party?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom