The distinction between personality disorder and mental illness
R. E. Kendell
The British Journal of Psychiatry Feb 2002
The historical reasons for regarding personality disorders as fundamentally different from mental illnesses are being undermined by both clinical and genetic evidence.
http://bjp.rcpsych.org/content/180/2/110
Neuroscience and Legal Responsibility
Nicole A. Vincent, 2003
This illuminating research enables us to argue that psychopathy counts as a mental disease on any plausible account of mental disease. In particular, Szasz's and Pickard's eliminativist views and Sedgwick's social constructivist account of mental illness that might exclude psychopathy are not plausible, and there is no reason to exclude psychopathy under Boorse's and Scadding's biomedical accounts, Wakefield's harmful dysfunction account, and the DSM-IV-TR objective harm account of mental disease.
http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/vi...5605.001.0001/acprof-9780199925605-chapter-10
(
inter alia....)
I'd posted upthread that Vixen was not entirely incorrect in her claims. However, to add to that observation two things:
- the debate is not reflected in this thread - it is as you imply in your post, LondonJohn, professionals are still sorting out their definitions
- none of this has anything to do with the subject matter, as advertised by the title of this thread.
At his closing in 2009, Prosecutor Mignini waded into the pop-psychological. This was because the "sex-game gone wrong" and the "Rite associated with Hallowe'en" motives that Mignini had previously tossed (evidenceless) into the case had fallen on deaf ears - even to the courts that eventually convicted (cf. Massei's court and Nencini's court).
So in the 2009 closing Mignini had to do something else to maintain that Knox was somehow "weird", he went all pop-psychological about how much Knox must have been jealous of Meredith. Once again, though, he'd tossed this in with no evidence at all that Knox had been jealous of Kercher. So what did Judge Massei do with that claim?
Massei ignored it. Whereas for Mignini, Knox had brought the knife from Raffaele's where (as Mignini said in court in a faux-Knox voice) "We will make you have sex", Massei ended up saying that Knox had brought the knife completely by accident.
Nencini then said at the 2013 trial that Knox had brought the knife because there was common sharing of cooking utensils between the two abodes - something no one had claimed, much less proved.All psychology was now missing.
All to distance themselves from Mignini's occult claims, then his sex-game claims, then his psychological claims.
Given that no court - none of them bought this - did that deter the haters? No.
What we see in this thread almost a decade after Rudy Guede robbed a beautiful young woman of her life, is long discussions of psychopathology - as if it had ever had anything to do with this case - which it never had.
In trying to track down those haters online who pushed this, Nina Burleigh found out who Miss Represented was - indeed, at the time Peter Quennell blabbed about all sorts of things, thinking Burleigh was onside.
Fortunately for people like Miss Represented, once Burleigh found out she'd been a complete fraud, Burleigh had enough journalistic ethics not to expose this person.
But here we are, those obsessed with Vixen's inanities, arguing if psychopathology and mental illness have links.
That's how much PGP still control the agenda - in far off corners of cyberspace like here.