The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
Link to this alleged article? I've been unable to find any such article. Not that you'd make this up.:rolleyes:
No, she'd DEFINITELY make it up.

Do you have any evidence the said policeman does exist? What we have is Officer Bender's complete report which belies Andrew Malone's (not Follain's) fabricated story. From what I have been able to find (or not find, in this case) is any other story about Knox or the murder by this Scots journalist (and I use the term very liberally). I'd bet Malone never set foot in Seattle much less interviewed anyone in/from Seattle about anything.

Exactly. I couldn't find an article by Follain about the party either.

I'm 100 percent convinced that Malone never interviewed anyone for his story, but simply embellished the police report. I know Malone NEVER talked to Officer Bender so I highly doubt he spoke with anyone on the force. And given the article is contradicted by the police report and Malone didn't provide any names of the party goers or Bender's colleagues, it's damn clear that this was just an exercise in creative writing. I mean the only person who could sue Malone was in prison in Perugia so as long as it was anonymous sources, he could write just about anything.
 
No, she'd DEFINITELY make it up.



Exactly. I couldn't find an article by Follain about the party either.

I'm 100 percent convinced that Malone never interviewed anyone for his story, but simply embellished the police report. I know Malone NEVER talked to Officer Bender so I highly doubt he spoke with anyone on the force. And given the article is contradicted by the police report and Malone didn't provide any names of the party goers or Bender's colleagues, it's damn clear that this was just an exercise in creative writing. I mean the only person who could sue Malone was in prison in Perugia so as long as it was anonymous sources, he could write just about anything.

Follain and Malone; two of a kind. Just make crap up and print it.
 
A personality disorder is not a mental illness. Full stop.

If it causes problems, they will be social and criminal problems.

Incidentally, extroversion and introversion are both 'clusters of traits'. Not all extroverts will show all extrovert traits.

Likewise, psychopaths differ from one another according to range of psychopathic personality traits.

I have to agree with Vixen on this. Personality disorders are regarded as distinct from mental illnesses. Psychopathy / sociopathy is not treatable by medicine, psychological techniques may alter behaviour. The law may define psychopathy as a mental illness but this is a legal fact not a scientific one.
 
Oooh, are you listening, NHS England?!! Online self-appointed "expert" Vixen is telling you that you're wrong to state that a personality disorder is a mental health condition (AKA "mental illness"):

Personality disorders are common mental health problems

http://www.nhs.uk/conditions/personality-disorder/Pages/Definition.aspx


And that's before we even start with the piles of credible academic literature which state that personality disorders such as psychopathy absolutely ARE a category of mental health illness (and that pretty much the only reason why there have been historic attempts to deny them that categorisation has everything to do with funding and outcome measurement issues, rather than a cold, objective assessment on its own terms).

But hey, who doesn't love a good old-fashioned digging-in-ever-deeper embarrassment of a Thursday evening! Pass the popcorn :D

So obesity is a physical health problem it is not an illness. There is a difference between health issues and illness. Poor diet, lack of exercise, stress are all health problems but not illnesses.
 
Link to this alleged article? I've been unable to find any such article. Not that you'd make this up.:rolleyes:



Do you have any evidence the said policeman does exist? What we have is Officer Bender's complete report which belies Andrew Malone's (not Follain's) fabricated story. From what I have been able to find (or not find, in this case) is any other story about Knox or the murder by this Scots journalist (and I use the term very liberally). I'd bet Malone never set foot in Seattle much less interviewed anyone in/from Seattle about anything.

If you use 'search' you will be able to find the article, as I have linked to it and quoted from it several times before.


Or google it. (NB The TIMES is behind a pay wall.)
 
I have to agree with Vixen on this. Personality disorders are regarded as distinct from mental illnesses. Psychopathy / sociopathy is not treatable by medicine, psychological techniques may alter behaviour. The law may define psychopathy as a mental illness but this is a legal fact not a scientific one.

Thank you.

ETA In fact, the legal definition does not include sociopathy. Whoever wrote that spiel was using technical inexactitude,. Psychopathy is only defined as a 'mental health' problem if a criminal is so insane and dangerous, he or she has to be locked up in a secure prison hospital such as Rampton or Broadstairs.

The vast majority of psychopaths in prison, such as Ian Huntley (Soham murders), Sutcliffe (Yorkshire Ripper), Rose West and Charles Bronson are all held in ordinary prisons. Sutcliffe did fool the prison authorities for a long time by claiming to hear voices and getting a 'paranoid schizophrenic' label and thus enjoying a cushy hospital life. Recently, his time was up and he was moved to an ordinary prison much to his great anger.

As for Bronson, he is diagnosed as Borderline Criminal Personality Disorder. He is in prison for life for intimidating prison staff. 'Borderline' does not mean 'slight'. It means 'extremely dangerous' and is a euphemism for 'insane psychopath', albeit one not treatable by medicine. The label has now changed to something similar.
 
Last edited:
How nice that you found someone to agree with you.

But the argument is still bonkers. Something doesn't have to be treatable to be an illness.

Think about your personality. You might be extrovert. You could be introvert.

Would you go to the doctor and plead, 'Please can you refer me to a hospital consultant as I am too extrovert'.

An ultra sensitive introvert might well ask for help with shyness and there are groups to help overcome social anxiety, blushing and fear of public speaking.

You'll find generally extroverts and sociopaths are quite happy with themselves and in no worse health than anybody else.
 
Last edited:
Think about your personality. You might be extrovert. You could be introvert.

Would you go to the doctor and plead, 'Please can you refer me to a hospital consultant as I am too extrovert'.

An ultra sensitive introvert might well ask for help with shyness and there are groups to help overcome social anxiety, blushing and fear of public speaking.

You'll find generally extroverts and sociopaths are quite happy with themselves and in no worse health than anybody else.

Amazing. I've already told you that being unhappy with your condition is not a necessary component of illness, and you come back with exactly the same argument, namely that people with personality disorders are happy with their condition. Don't you understand that that is irrelevant?

And didn't you understand the first time around that "extrovert" is not a disorder, unlike psychopathy? Your comparison is nonsensical.

Here's how the dictionary defines "disorder": a disturbance in physical or mental health or functions; malady or dysfunction.

In short, an illness! It's even in the synonyms!

Give it up. You made a mistake. Admit it, and let's move on.
 
Amazing. I've already told you that being unhappy with your condition is not a necessary component of illness, and you come back with exactly the same argument, namely that people with personality disorders are happy with their condition. Don't you understand that that is irrelevant?

And didn't you understand the first time around that "extrovert" is not a disorder, unlike psychopathy? Your comparison is nonsensical.

Here's how the dictionary defines "disorder": a disturbance in physical or mental health or functions; malady or dysfunction.

In short, an illness! It's even in the synonyms!

Give it up. You made a mistake. Admit it, and let's move on.

You have made the classic mistake of taking colloquial vernacular and confusing it with specialist definition. For example, a layperson might call a pea a vegetable, when in fact, it is strictly speaking a fruit. (The entire pod, that is.)

Dr Hare's definition of personality disorder is as follows:

DSM Classification
(The psychiatry bible)

Personality disorder

An enduring pattern of inner experience and behavior that deviates markedly from the expectations of the culture of the individual who exhibits it.

Note the terms deviant, behaviour and culture. Now do you get it?
 
Last edited:
You have made the classic mistake of taking colloquial vernacular and confusing it with specialist definition.

Stop trying to sound knowledgeable about this issue when it's clear you're not. May I remind you that this all started when you said this:

Psychopathy is a personality disorder and nothing to do with 'mental health'.

And now you're trying real hard to convince us that a disorder is not an illness. Now even the actual definition of the word isn't good enough. :rolleyes:
 
Stop trying to sound knowledgeable about this issue when it's clear you're not. May I remind you that this all started when you said this:



And now you're trying real hard to convince us that a disorder is not an illness. Now even the actual definition of the word isn't good enough. :rolleyes:

So, moving forward, what is your contribution to this thread?
 
Last edited:
Yeah, I got handed my degree by Albert Einstein, President Kennedy and Miley Cyrus, dontcha know?!


(BTW Stanley Milgram -"Stan" to his friends HAHAHAHAHA - taught at City University New York from 1967 to 1984, in which year he died of a heart attack. So it was indeed extraordinarily munificent of him to fly across the Atlantic during that period of his career, in order to hand out degrees at a tertiary academic institution in the UK! Surely only a storied institution such as Oxford or Cambridge University would earn such a visit from the great Milgram?! Obviously he wouldn't, for example, make the journey to hand out degrees at a crappy polytechnic......)
 
I have to agree with Vixen on this. Personality disorders are regarded as distinct from mental illnesses. Psychopathy / sociopathy is not treatable by medicine, psychological techniques may alter behaviour. The law may define psychopathy as a mental illness but this is a legal fact not a scientific one.



The distinction between personality disorder and mental illness
R. E. Kendell
The British Journal of Psychiatry Feb 2002


The historical reasons for regarding personality disorders as fundamentally different from mental illnesses are being undermined by both clinical and genetic evidence.

http://bjp.rcpsych.org/content/180/2/110




Neuroscience and Legal Responsibility
Nicole A. Vincent, 2003


This illuminating research enables us to argue that psychopathy counts as a mental disease on any plausible account of mental disease. In particular, Szasz's and Pickard's eliminativist views and Sedgwick's social constructivist account of mental illness that might exclude psychopathy are not plausible, and there is no reason to exclude psychopathy under Boorse's and Scadding's biomedical accounts, Wakefield's harmful dysfunction account, and the DSM-IV-TR objective harm account of mental disease.

http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/vi...5605.001.0001/acprof-9780199925605-chapter-10



(inter alia....)
 
So, moving forward, what is your contribution to this thread?

BTW I was handed my degree by the late great Stan Milgram, with whom I shook hands, at the award ceremony. So guess the subject.

Besides boasting about imaginary qualifications, PGP are now coming up with stories about famous people who handed out these qualifications. PGP come up with Walter Mitty fantasies about their academic achievements and they have the cheek to call Amanda a pathological liar.
 
So, moving forward, what is your contribution to this thread?

Well at first I was correcting your claim that psychopathy had nothing to do with mental heatlh, then I corrected your claim that psychopathy had nothing to do with mental illness, and now I'm trying to underline the fact that you simply generally don't know what you're talking about.

You?

BTW I was handed my degree by the late great Stan Milgram, with whom I shook hands, at the award ceremony. So guess the subject.

I got my degree from Alan Turing!
 
Last edited:
Well at first I was correcting your claim that psychopathy had nothing to do with mental heatlh, then I corrected your claim that psychopathy had nothing to do with mental illness, and now I'm trying to underline the fact that you simply generally don't know what you're talking about.

You?



I got my degree from Alan Turing!

There seems to be colossal ignorance on this forum, with some comments better suited to the DAILY MAIL. It is quite normal to have an eminent person at a graduation ceremony. A relative had the Queen Mother (London), and a close relative Bill Bryson (Durham) and some minor royal at Edinburgh.

Perhaps some posters come from backgrounds where this is considered unusual in some way.

Nothing I can do about it. <shrug>
 
Last edited:
There seems to be colossal ignorance on this forum

Yes, I said that in the post you quoted.

It is quite normal to have an eminent person at a graduation ceremony.

Of course! Just like it's entirely normal for someone to have a doctorate. So if I tell you that I have one, you have to believe me.

Perhaps some posters come from backgrounds where this is considered unusual in some way.

No one said that. We just said that we don't believe you. Body of work and all.
 
Yes, I said that in the post you quoted.



Of course! Just like it's entirely normal for someone to have a doctorate. So if I tell you that I have one, you have to believe me.



No one said that. We just said that we don't believe you. Body of work and all.

If you have a need to bully and defame another poster, then that reflects on you.

I note you say 'we', so you are the type of person who will join in a brawl in a street even if you don't know what it is about.

Lovely.
 
If you have a need to bully and defame another poster, then that reflects on you.

Here you are again with "bully" and such words.

Do you have a persecution complex? I ask because you would be, according to yourself, qualified to answer that question.

I note you say 'we', so you are the type of person who will join in a brawl in a street even if you don't know what it is about.

Again, what are you talking about? "We" is a word in English denoting several people. Several people, including myself, said we don't believe you. So "we" is the proper word to use.

You have a serious problem.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom