The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's kind of a joke isn't it Stacyhs? There are so many made up stretch the truths and outright lies and hatred oozing from Vixen's every sentence.

Amanda didn't write a rape murder fantasy. And what if she had? Stephen King has written countless horror stories depicting hundreds of murders. The horror genre is a popular genre. Was Mary Shelley, Bram Stoker, Edgar Allen Poe, Robert Louis Stevenson,
Peter Straub, Dean Koontz, Thomas Harris, etc and countless other writers sick? One of the most successful movie genres is horror. Hollywood makes more horror films every year than they do rom-coms. And they are especially popular among teenagers and the young.

For anyone to suggest that writing a story no matter how sick or disgusting suggests that the author is sick and disgusting really has a personal problem.

And, I'm sorry, the so called confession that links Patrick to the murder is a joke if you read it. Anyone with a brain wouldn't take it seriously. And the simple fact is that Amanda retracted it within hours.

Then Vixen says Amanda is narcissistic. I can't imagine anyone less narcissistic than Amanda. Not that she doesn't relate other people's experiences to her own. But we all do that.

Then, not showing her hatred Vixens says Amanda needed her boyfriend to correct Amanda's illiterate grammar and spelling gaffes. No, that's not hatred Vixen, That is dishonest lying nonsense. Amanda is a graduate of a prestigious prep school and university. She has written a best selling book and writes a column. She is literate in three languages. She reads and writes in Italian, English and German. It's dumb enough to believe Amanda was involved in the murder of Meredith despite all the evidence but it is a sign of pretty sick hatred to not just think, but to call Amanda illiterate despite the massive evidence to the contrary. I wonder, since you have bragged about being a Mensa member. Is there a section on logic or intellectual honesty?

Then Vixen jumps in to Amanda's op-ed about the suicide texting case as if Amanda really said anything all that controversial. There is significant question about the legality of the guilty verdict.

Then we get to Vixen being absolutely oblivious about atheism and the reasonable complaint atheists have about people discriminating against them because they don't believe in fairy tales?

This is like when Christians opine about homosexuals saying that they don't dislike the sinners, they dislike the sin. No, this is obsessive disgusting hatred. No other word for it.

When a person sees someone through such a heavy fog of bias, they simply become incapable of seeing or interpreting anything related to that person in a manner other than that which fits their bias. The worst thing about such strong confirmation bias is that the person loses all ability to be objective, knee-jerk reactions become their norm, and they are blind to it all.
 
When a person sees someone through such a heavy fog of bias, they simply become incapable of seeing or interpreting anything related to that person in a manner other than that which fits their bias. The worst thing about such strong confirmation bias is that the person loses all ability to be objective, knee-jerk reactions become their norm, and they are blind to it all.

Clearly there is a problem. The level of cognitive dissonance is astounding. But it is the justification for turning every mundane act of Amanda's into something deviant, perverted, dirty or stupid is what I can't fathom.

Vixen's every post portrays Amanda as stupid, which clearly Amanda is not. As an oversexed slut when in reality she seems like the average woman. Or finally as a narcissist. I really don't think Vixen understands what a narcissist is because Amanda sure doesn't seem that self absorbed.

I hadn't contributed to this thread in a long time. I thought I was cured of this silliness. Anyway, hi to everyone.
 
Clearly there is a problem. The level of cognitive dissonance is astounding. But it is the justification for turning every mundane act of Amanda's into something deviant, perverted, dirty or stupid is what I can't fathom.

Vixen's every post portrays Amanda as stupid, which clearly Amanda is not. As an oversexed slut when in reality she seems like the average woman. Or finally as a narcissist. I really don't think Vixen understands what a narcissist is because Amanda sure doesn't seem that self absorbed.

I hadn't contributed to this thread in a long time. I thought I was cured of this silliness. Anyway, hi to everyone.

I'd gone through Mignini's submission back in June 2015, such submission meant as the groundwork for a criminal defmation charge against Mairo and Lagana.....

.... which Methos recently reposted.

I've gone through all 65 paragraphs of Mignini's submission - such submission which is stalled in Florence for what I regard as obvious reasons.

But one thing becomes clear about the content of Mignini's submission, when compared to the items that both Vixen and Machiavelli portray here on this thread as factual - their points are almost identical to what Mignini claims about the Kercher case in the submission and why he lost - illegally as he claims, but he lost nonetheless.

Those folks may be confirmation biased, but here they are surrogates for Mignini. They are posting about the Kercher murder trials in a manner that Mignini would if he were here.

I'd not made that connection two years ago. It's almost as if TJMK's webpage were the internet version of Mignini Inc. Mignini lost big in 2011, so much so that the prosecution and appeals were taken from him. In 2015 when Cassation exonerated the pair, Casssation specifically cited the "amnesiac investigation."

In his Submission with regard to the defamation claimed against Maori and Lagana, Mignini relitigates the murder trial(s) which he eventually lost. What we're getting here are the same (by now discredited) arguments by surrogates.
 
No, they had been found not guilty. They had no reason to believe that the Supreme Court would do something stupid.
But you can argue this point till you're blue in the face. It won't make a difference. It's over and Amanda and Raffaele are making a living commenting on other legal cases and you are posting here and not making a dime.

That's rubbish. It was published before the legal process was completed.

Has Raff or Amanda ever done a day's job in their lives that didn't involve sucking the death of Meredith Kercher dry?
 
How do you know if she is making royalties and wasn't paid a flat fee? I didn't know that her financial arrangements with Harper Collins had been published. Care to present a cite? Or did you make this up as well?

I don't expect you to. It won't matter. You're making just another fallacious deduction. You don't even know if the original premise is true let alone the deduction. But this isn't a surprise to anyone since we've seen you do it thousands of times.

Because Kulman is credited as the author. Ghostwriters are not, usually.
 
1) Despising someone's behaviour is, de facto, disliking that person.

2) What exactly is it about Knox's/Sollecito's behaviour that you despise? (in your answer, please bear in mind that: a) Knox and Sollecito were (correctly) acquitted and exonerated by the highest court in Italy; b) there was/is zero credible, reliable evidence that Knox or Sollecito participated in the Kercher murder; c) it is, in fact, highly probable that neither Knox nor Sollecito participated in Kercher's murder; d) all of the known evidence is, in fact, entirely compatible with Guede acting alone (and there is solid, safe evidence to prove Guede's guilt beyond all reasonable doubt)).

Thanks in advance for your considered reply.


I dislike the following conduct:

1. Accusing a completely innocent man of the rape and murder and falsely claiming to be **** scared of him.

2. Being present at the murder scene - FACT - and failing to summon any kind of help.

3. Lying and obstructing the police in their investigation.

4. Raff refusing to testify.

5. Knox' frivolous behaviour in court (cf the Manson girls).

6. Defiance.

7. Touring the country claiming to be 'exonerated' and 'wrongly imprisoned for four years' when Knox received a fair three-year sentence for no.1 above.

8. Profiting from Meredith's murder whilst Marasca clearly writes Knox had Mez' blood on her hands.

Unlike you, I am not prone to hero-worship or infatuation.
 
There's a Google alert for us PIP? Darn! Why was I never informed of this? I'm sending off a letter of protest immediately to Gogerty-Marriott and cc'ing Bruce Fisher. Thanks for letting me know, Vix!

"The kids"? For someone who has a conniption fit when Amanda is referred to as a "kid" at the time of the murder, you do like to use the term yourself.

Citation please for your claim that Knox said the police "framed them". She has said they had tunnel vision, bias, and the investigation was incredibly incompetent...as did the Supreme Court... but she has never said she was "framed".

You "don't dislike the pair"? :eye-poppi The multitude of posts you have made denigrating both, but Knox especially, on a personal level very clearly show otherwise. Would you like me to quote some here?


Unlike you, it seems, I am not governed by base instincts. I don't have any personal feelings towards the pair one way or the other. I would just like to see justice. Amanda Knox is deluding herself if she believes Mignini has any personal vendetta at all.

As for the term, 'kids' you have been told many times I am simply talking down to the PIP's level of terminology.
 
"Linda Kulman

I am a journalist, writer, editor, and the author, most recently, of Teaching Common Sense: The Grand Strategy Program at Yale University about one of Yale’s best-known and most sought-after courses. Based on several years of onsite reporting, archival research, interviews with students and faculty, and original survey data, Teaching Common Sense looks at “Studies in Grand Strategy,” a year-long, by-application leadership seminar. The course addresses some of higher education’s bedrock question, such as how is critical thinking taught and how will this generation learn to cope with uncertainty in a fast-changing world.

I have collaborated on seven nonfiction books, working successfully with a group of diverse, demanding personalities to tell their personal, and sometimes painful, stories. These include Amanda Knox’s New York Times bestselling memoir, Waiting to be Heard; Hillary Clinton’s Dear Socks, Dear Buddy: Kids’ Letters to the First Pets, written while she was First Lady; New York Governor Andrew Cuomo’s All Things Possible: Setbacks and Success in Politics and Life; George McGovern’s What It Means to Be a Democrat; George Foreman’s Guide to Life: How to Get Up Off the Canvas When Life Knocks You Down; and James Carville’s We’re Right, They’re Wrong. Each of these projects required me to become an expert on a nuanced topic, whether on the Italian legal system, the root causes of homelessness, heavyweight wrestling, the history of pets in the White House, or gun safety reform. ...."

Source: http://branford.yalecollege.yale.edu/linda-kulman

Collaborator: a person who works jointly on an activity or project; an associate.

Source: https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/collaborator

Exactly. If she was not getting paid and credited as the author, she would not be allowed to mention this at all.
 
I dislike the following conduct:

1. Accusing a completely innocent man of the rape and murder and falsely claiming to be **** scared of him.

2. Being present at the murder scene - FACT - and failing to summon any kind of help.

3. Lying and obstructing the police in their investigation.

4. Raff refusing to testify.

5. Knox' frivolous behaviour in court (cf the Manson girls).

6. Defiance.

7. Touring the country claiming to be 'exonerated' and 'wrongly imprisoned for four years' when Knox received a fair three-year sentence for no.1 above.

8. Profiting from Meredith's murder whilst Marasca clearly writes Knox had Mez' blood on her hands.

Unlike you, I am not prone to hero-worship or infatuation.



Aside from all the nonsense in the body of this post....

Please provide credible, reliable evidence that I am "prone to hero-worship or infatuation". Or withdraw that (baseless) accusation. Thanks in advance.
 
Exactly. If she was not getting paid and credited as the author, she would not be allowed to mention this at all.


Why do you appear unable to understand the difference between "the author" of a book (per your unsupported claim) and "an author" of (or "a contributor to") a book?
 
Because Kulman is credited as the author. Ghostwriters are not, usually.


You have zero understanding of how ghostwriting works. Even where a ghostwriter gets no writing credit anywhere in the published work, it's very usual that such a ghostwriter will be receiving a percentage of royalties - especially if the named author is a bankable celebrity with an agent and a publishing deal in place:


3. Do you work on a shared royalties (profit share) basis with celebrities?

Yes – particularly if a celebrity already has an agent/publisher in place. Because celebrity books are easier to sell, it’s much less risky for us to work on a shared royalties basis. However, we do ask any expenses such as hotel rooms for interviews are covered, and that a one-off payment of £2000 is made (which will be deducted from book sales) to help sustain the writer while the book is being written. The shared royalties split varies from book to book – please talk to us for an exact figure.


http://ghostwritingcompany.co.uk/ghostwriterfaq/


Please don't pretend to have knowledge of things that, in fact, you have next to no knowledge about.
 
Clearly there is a problem. The level of cognitive dissonance is astounding. But it is the justification for turning every mundane act of Amanda's into something deviant, perverted, dirty or stupid is what I can't fathom.

Vixen's every post portrays Amanda as stupid, which clearly Amanda is not. As an oversexed slut when in reality she seems like the average woman. Or finally as a narcissist. I really don't think Vixen understands what a narcissist is because Amanda sure doesn't seem that self absorbed.

I hadn't contributed to this thread in a long time. I thought I was cured of this silliness. Anyway, hi to everyone.

People who believe that someone's DNA being found in their own bathroom is incriminating are not in a position to accuse people of being stupid.
 
acbytesla;11948007[HILITE said:
]I doubt it has anything to do with ignorance.[/HILITE] I'm sure that Vixen understands what an editor does. The facts are secondary to posting an incendiary remark about Amanda. The remark about grammar and spelling is without foundation. I have yet to read anything by Amanda that would lead anyone to come to the conclusion that either pose an issue.

Now maybe the reason for this is as as a professional writer, Amanda's work is submitted to an editor that proofs her work before it is published or that she is good at what she does. The point is that there is no way for anyone other than Amanda or her editor who knows.

Which leads to the question why pretend you know something that you KNOW you DON'T?

It is, at least in part, either real or pretended ignorance. See the PGP comments that a "collaborator" on a book is necessarily an author or co-author.

There are, for example, typically several editors with different functions, for books published by established publishing companies. All the editors many be considered collaborators on the book. Authors also may hire editors or get help from friends or colleagues in shaping their works.

"The editing process often begins with the author's idea for the work itself, continuing as a collaboration between the author and the editor as the work is created. As such, editing can involve creative skills, human relations and a precise set of methods.

There are various editorial positions in publishing. Typically, one finds editorial assistants reporting to the senior-level editorial staff and directors who report to senior executive editors. Senior executive editors are responsible for developing a product for its final release. The smaller the publication, the more these roles overlap."

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Editing
 
2. Being present at the murder scene - FACT - and failing to summon any kind of help.

8. Profiting from Meredith's murder whilst Marasca clearly writes Knox had Mez' Meredith's blood on her hands.

This. Is. Not. True. And. You. Know. It's. Not. True. If it had not been for Knox and Sollecito, the victim would not have been found for days.

You. Also. Never. Cite. What. The. Court. Actually. Said. Here. It. Is. (But you did render the word "fact" in all caps, so that must have made what you said a fact):

Nevertheless, even if attribution (of Knox rubbing blood from her hands) is certain, the trial element would not be
unequivocal as a demonstration of posthumous contact with that blood, as a likely
attempt to remove the most blatant traces of what had happened, perhaps to help
someone or deflect suspicion from herself, without this entailing her certain direct
involvement in the murder. Any further and more meaningful value would be, in fact,
resisted by the fact - which is decisive - that no trace leading to her was found at the
scene of the crime or on the victim’s body, so that - if all the above is accepted - her
contact with the victim’s blood would have occurred after the crime and in another
part of the house.​
Indeed, Raffaele and Amanda actually did call around, including a call to the 112 Carabinieri - before the arrival of the postal police (as per the 2010 Massei report).

No one knew what help needed to be rendered before the door was broken down (except for the murderer Rudy Guede) who had left the victim to bleed out the night before.

You have been asked umpteen times to present the forensic-evidence behind your repetitious-claim. There is a reason why you cannot provide it - the Massei report in 2010 said there was no forensics to back the claim.
 
Last edited:
That's rubbish. It was published before the legal process was completed.

Has Raff or Amanda ever done a day's job in their lives that didn't involve sucking the death of Meredith Kercher dry?

I find it interesting that you would describe Amanda's career as a writer as sucking the death of Meredith Kercher dry since I recall you saying that you were assisting in compiling that joke of a book about the case. I also didn't see you complaining about how much all the money that other writers made from this tragedy.

Stop being a hypocrite. If anyone should profit from this tragedy, it should be the two people who WRONGLY were in prison for FOUR YEARS! And Raffaele and his family paid millions of dollars for his exoneration that will take years to get back.

But let's examine your idiotic and wrong statement. Amanda has been writing a column in Seattle that 95 percent of the time never mentions anything to do with Italy. Amanda reviews movies, plays, concerts and writes about Seattle. How is that as you said 'sucking the death of Meredith Kercher dry'?

Only someone with a sick obsessive perspective would describe that as something untoward. They really need to get help. Like it or not, Amanda and Raffaele are making lemonade out of lemons. Get over it.
 
There's a Google alert for us PIP? Darn! Why was I never informed of this? I'm sending off a letter of protest immediately to Gogerty-Marriott and cc'ing Bruce Fisher. Thanks for letting me know, Vix!

"The kids"? For someone who has a conniption fit when Amanda is referred to as a "kid" at the time of the murder, you do like to use the term yourself.

Citation please for your claim that Knox said the police "framed them". She has said they had tunnel vision, bias, and the investigation was incredibly incompetent...as did the Supreme Court... but she has never said she was "framed".

You "don't dislike the pair"? :eye-poppi The multitude of posts you have made denigrating both, but Knox especially, on a personal level very clearly show otherwise. Would you like me to quote some here?

Unlike you, it seems, I am not governed by base instincts. I don't have any personal feelings towards the pair one way or the other. I would just like to see justice. Amanda Knox is deludYing herself if she believes Mignini has any personal vendetta at all.

As for the term, 'kids' you have been told many times I am simply talking down to the PIP's level of terminology.

What I see is so many PGP motivated by intense dislike that comes dangerously close to blind hatred. To claim "I don't have any personal feelings towards the pair one way or the other" is constantly belied by your posts...a few of which I have provided. Constant personal disparaging remarks about Knox, and to a lesser extent Sollecito, do not indicate the absence of personal feelings about them. To the contrary, they are strong evidence of intense personal feelings.

The fact that some PGP are still attacking Amanda and Raffaele with insulting and disparaging remarks about anything and everything they do almost 2.5 years after they were definitively acquitted, indicates not a lust for justice but one of vengeance.

As for Amanda deluding herself about Mignini's personal motives, once again you are presuming to know what someone else thinks or feels. You have no idea what Mignini's personal feelings about Amanda are. You are not privy to his personal thoughts, are you?

Since no one here refers to Knox and Sollecito as "the kids", your excuse for continuing to refer to them as such holds no merit. I suspect you use it for the same reason you continue to refer to Meredith as "Mez".

And I'm still waiting for a citation that Amanda has ever claimed the "police framed" her. As the saying goes: put up or shut up.
 
People who believe that someone's DNA being found in their own bathroom is incriminating are not in a position to accuse people of being stupid.

Nor are people who claim TMB negative means blood is still present, that a knife could be so well cleaned that not a trace of blood remained yet the DNA of the victim survived in a scratch that could never, ever be found by any other expert, that a rock (excuse me, a "boulder" of nine lbs.) could not be thrown across a 6 foot space by a grown man, that a young, agile,athletic man could not access a second story window, and that a person who physically participates in a brutal and close-up rape/stabbing murder that left blood all over the floor could somehow leave not a trace of herself behind unlike the "other" killer.

Mind boggling, ain't it?
 
Because Kulman is credited as the author. Ghostwriters are not, usually.

Except Kulman is NOT credited as the author. Do you even have the book? Can you identify anywhere in or on the book where Kulman is even mentioned? Can you find any review of the book where Kulman is credited with anything more than "providing assistance"?

You were told this before and yet you continue to repeat this lie. Are you this dishonest in all aspects of your life or only on matters pertaining to this case?
 
In the "author's notes" page in the back of "Waiting to be Heard", Amanda writes this:

" I wouldn't have been able to write this memoir without Linda Kulman. Somehow, with her Post-it Notes and questions, with her generosity, dedication, and empathy, she turned my rambling into writing, and taught me so much in the meantime. I am grateful to her family-Ralph, Sam, Julia- for sharing her with me for so long."

Amanda, who has a degree in Creative Writing, did not need Kulman to write her book for her. She needed someone to help her organize and refine it. But, of course, when one needs to disparage and belittle anything and everything Knox related, this cannot be acknowledged. No. That would just never do.
 
I find it interesting that you would describe Amanda's career as a writer as sucking the death of Meredith Kercher dry since I recall you saying that you were assisting in compiling that joke of a book about the case. I also didn't see you complaining about how much all the money that other writers made from this tragedy.

Stop being a hypocrite. If anyone should profit from this tragedy, it should be the two people who WRONGLY were in prison for FOUR YEARS! And Raffaele and his family paid millions of dollars for his exoneration that will take years to get back.

But let's examine your idiotic and wrong statement. Amanda has been writing a column in Seattle that 95 percent of the time never mentions anything to do with Italy. Amanda reviews movies, plays, concerts and writes about Seattle. How is that as you said 'sucking the death of Meredith Kercher dry'?

Only someone with a sick obsessive perspective would describe that as something untoward. They really need to get help. Like it or not, Amanda and Raffaele are making lemonade out of lemons. Get over it.

To add to this; Amanda is investing a significant amount of her own time speaking to others about wrongful convictions in the hopes of educating people about the problem. While her background which makes her something of an expert in this area is a result of her own wrongful conviction for Meredith's murder, it is only a reference used to help educate people on how such injustices occur. She should be commended for her efforts.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom