Ho. Lee. Cow.
Just finished reading Mignini's "Submission of Criminal Complaint", written in support of charging Luca Maori (Sollecito's criminal lawyer), Alberto Lagana and Bruno Brunori, for defamatory comments Maori had made in 2015 in an interview with Lagana. Named as complainants in this submission are also Monica Napoleoni and Lorena Zugarini, who (it is claimed) were defamed by inference.
Thank you to Methos for pointing to the submission, available in translation from TJMK.
The rumour is - this complaint is being held up in Florence because the prosecutor there does not want to proceed with it. And if that is true, repeat "if", the submission itself contains the reasons why.
It is clear that Mignini deems it essential to relitigate the murder trial(s) which eventually cleared Knox and Sollecito. It's clear he's a sore loser.
He lays out his own reasons why the legal-legalities of that process (from 2009-2015) stopped with the Nencini trial. He regards the Fifth Chambers annulment of the Nencini convictions to be illegitimate - and here's the thing.....
...... for all the reasons that Vixen and Machiavelli have laid out in this thread, as well as those who post to TJMK.
However, I'd challenge anyone to cite an Italian legal source, other than Mignini, who agrees with his views on the Kercher murder trial processes. These are Mignini's whines, as well as his surrogates who repeat them almost verbatim.
But here's the deal - and these are the reasons IMO that the Florence prosecutor is not going to go ahead with the prosecution of defamation against Maori and Lagana.....
Mignini is signalling that essential to understanding that defamation are the facts of the Kercher murder trials as Mignini sees them. That means - probably - that those facts will be relitigated in the Florence court after the Fifth Chamber of Cassation has definitively put an end to it.
Two last things, the last of which is where even Mignini undercuts himself.
In the submission Mignini lists people "informed of the facts". They are Insp Armando Finzi, of the Perugia Flying Squad, Dr Daniela Severi, Advocate Carlo Pacelli, Giuseppe Castellini, Dr Manuela Comodi, and Dr Patrizia Stefanoni who Mignini claims are in a position to buttress his views on both the defamation statements, as well as the facts/evidence of the Kercher murder trials.
Do these people, particularly Stefanoni, want to be cross-examined on their conduct in the murder trials? Has the Florence prosecutor phoned Stefanoni only to be told that Stefanoni is washing her hair that month? Are all these people who are "informed of the facts" going to be forced to defame the Fifth Chambers the same way Mignini defames them in his submission? Do they really want that sort of trouble?
Besides, Napoleoni and Zugarini have unrelated legal problems of their own right now.
But then there's the second thing. In the submission, Mignini admits that as of the Fifth Chambers annulments, this annuls everything from Massei's court all the way to the Nencini court - with the exception (from Mignini's point of view) of what the First Chambers had found as factual in 2013. That set of stuff stands, even though Mignini counterintuitively says that both Massei and Hellmann are now gone.
How's that for logic.
Which prosecutor in their right mind wants to engage all this? Which prosecutor in their right mind wants to relitigate the Kercher trials, when those trials ended in acquittals - definitive at that! - for Knox and Sollecito?
All because Mignini lost?
When even Mignini conceeds, in writing in his submission, that all the lower court trials from the Kercher process now are annulled and without effect!?
Mignini probably DOES have a case of defamation, given the words Maori and Lagana used to describe him, and by extension Napoleoni and Zugarini. I agreed with that part in Mignini's submission that both Maori and Lagana could have made the same points about incompetence without becoming inflammatory.
But........
By trying to relitigate the Kercher process by claiming that he was right, even though he lost, is a whine. Nothing more. Nothing less.
But we now know who Machiavelli and Vixen are surrogates for in this thread. Everything they've claimed about the Fifth Chambers is in the submission Methos pointed to.
But none of it is factual - it is all Mignini's legal opinion, about a series of trials in which he eventually lost.
And we can gauge the size of the loss, but the size of his whine.