The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
In the "author's notes" page in the back of "Waiting to be Heard", Amanda writes this:

" I wouldn't have been able to write this memoir without Linda Kulman. Somehow, with her Post-it Notes and questions, with her generosity, dedication, and empathy, she turned my rambling into writing, and taught me so much in the meantime. I am grateful to her family-Ralph, Sam, Julia- for sharing her with me for so long."

Amanda, who has a degree in Creative Writing, did not need Kulman to write her book for her. She needed someone to help her organize and refine it. But, of course, when one needs to disparage and belittle anything and everything Knox related, this cannot be acknowledged. No. That would just never do.

Thanks Stacy, I stand corrected - Linda Kulman is mentioned - but is once again credited for assisting, not authoring. It lends nothing to Vixen's LIE about Kulman being credited as the author, but maybe Vixen might learn from this how to admit when you have something wrong.

....bwa ha ha ha.. yeah, right.
 
I dislike the following conduct:

1. Accusing a completely innocent man of the rape and murder and falsely claiming to be **** scared of him.

2. Being present at the murder scene - FACT - and failing to summon any kind of help.

3. Lying and obstructing the police in their investigation.

4. Raff refusing to testify.

5. Knox' frivolous behaviour in court (cf the Manson girls).

6. Defiance.

7. Touring the country claiming to be 'exonerated' and 'wrongly imprisoned for four years' when Knox received a fair three-year sentence for no.1 above.

8. Profiting from Meredith's murder whilst Marasca clearly writes Knox had Mez' blood on her hands.

Unlike you, I am not prone to hero-worship or infatuation.

http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/raffaeles-kitchen-knife/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/contamination-labwork-coverup/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/meredith-kercher-perjury-corruption/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/evidence-destroyed/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/blood-evidence-downstairs-apartment/
https://knoxsollecito.wordpress.com...old-about-amanda-knox-and-raffaele-sollecito/

As can be seen from the posts above the police/prosecution lied on numerous occasions. They fed false information to the media, lied in court, committed perjury, lied in documentation and worst of all lied to Amanda she had HIV. PGP bang on about Amanda and Raffaele telling umpteen lies whilst slavishly defending corrupt prosecutors who lied on a massive scale. One of numerous instances where PGP have supported liars whilst attacking Amanda and Raffaele for lying. PGP complain about Amanda and Raffaele lying to the police but feel it is perfectly acceptable for the police/prosecution to spread lies about Amanda and Raffaele and use lies against Amanda and Raffaele.

PGP complain that Amanda and Raffaele obstructed justice when defending corrupt police/prosecutors who obstructed justice by denying Amanda and Raffaele access to lawyers, not taping the interrogations, not telling them their rights during the interrogations, suppressing evidence, destroying evidence and telling numerous lies. As it was the police who bullied and manipulated Amanda into naming Lumumba, it was the police who obstructed justice.

It seems the PGP are deliberately trying to be as vile as possible in their hypocrisy.

As my post show below Raffaele did not lie to the police

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11944311#post11944311
 
Last edited:
In the "author's notes" page in the back of "Waiting to be Heard", Amanda writes this:

" I wouldn't have been able to write this memoir without Linda Kulman. Somehow, with her Post-it Notes and questions, with her generosity, dedication, and empathy, she turned my rambling into writing, and taught me so much in the meantime. I am grateful to her family-Ralph, Sam, Julia- for sharing her with me for so long."

Amanda, who has a degree in Creative Writing, did not need Kulman to write her book for her. She needed someone to help her organize and refine it. But, of course, when one needs to disparage and belittle anything and everything Knox related, this cannot be acknowledged. No. That would just never do.

The PGP, in their desire to denigrate Amanda, resort to deliberate ignorance or obfuscation (in some cases, they may be displaying their "actual ignorance").

Amanda acknowledged Linda Kulman's help in writing her book; Kulman was not the author, she was the author's editor.

"An author is narrowly defined as the originator of any written work and can thus also be described as a writer (with any distinction primarily being an implication that an is a writer of one or more major works, such as books or plays). More broadly defined, an author is "the person who originated or gave existence to anything" and whose authorship determines responsibility for what was created. The more specific phrase published author refers to an author (especially but not necessarily of books) whose work has been independently accepted for publication by a reputable publisher, versus a self-publishing author or an unpublished one. ...."

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Author
 
Vixen, I'm still waiting for you to provide evidence that calunnia (calumny) is equivalent to obstruction of justice which requires lying under oath. Was Amanda under oath during the interrogation? Or at any time whatsoever? Unless you can provide said evidence, may I suggest you stop repeating that falsehood?
 
I dislike the following conduct:

1. Accusing a completely innocent man of the rape and murder and falsely claiming to be **** scared of him.

2. Being present at the murder scene - FACT - and failing to summon any kind of help.

3. Lying and obstructing the police in their investigation.

4. Raff refusing to testify.

5. Knox' frivolous behaviour in court (cf the Manson girls).

6. Defiance.

7. Touring the country claiming to be 'exonerated' and 'wrongly imprisoned for four years' when Knox received a fair three-year sentence for no.1 above.

8. Profiting from Meredith's murder whilst Marasca clearly writes Knox had Mez' blood on her hands.

Unlike you, I am not prone to hero-worship or infatuation.

1. Being scared ****less, being smacked on the head by a policewoman when you don't tell them what they want to hear (a la what they "already knew"), being told there is strong evidence against you including that you were at the scene of the murder when you weren't, being told you just have "amnesia", and being told you met up with your boss so he could rape and kill your roommate would tend to make you ****** scared of him.

2. There is no evidence whatsoever that she was at the cottage at the time of the murder. FACT. Only a judicial fact exists based solely on her recanted memorial.

3. Anything Amanda said that did not include admitting she was at the cottage at the time of the murder, had a meeting set up with Lumumba, and did not have anything to do with the murder was a "lie" according to the police. She did not lie or obstruct justice (nice touch there) when she finally succumbed to the police's and "interpreter's" insistence she had arranged to take Lumumba to the cottage. She finally just gave in to the pressure, exhaustion, and fear. Typical of false confessions as Saul Kassin points out. And nothing she says in that "confession" turned out to be true. Shall I explain why? Because she wasn't there and didn't know the truth...other than what the police were telling her was "the truth".

4. Raff exercised his right not to testify. It is common for even innocent people not to testify. Most defense attorneys do not want to put their clients on the stand because they understand how they can so easily be manipulated by prosecutors. "Have you stopped beating your wife? Yes or no? YES OR NO?"

5. Frivolous behavior in court a la Manson girls? Darn..I must have missed the X carved into her forehead. Since when is wearing a T-shirt that was a gift from family "frivolous"? Oh, wait....do you mean smiling at her family? Now, that's frivolous.

6. Defiance? Such as in daring to maintain your innocence?

7. Touring the country? I think you mean being invited to speak at law universities, legal associations and Innocence Project conferences. I suggest you take up the "exoneration" denial with Italian judges who have also said she was exonerated and with Italian media which also uses that word. Go make your objections with them.

8. Amanda has every right to be paid when she is invited to speak. She had every right to tell her side of the story in her book both morally and legally and to be paid for it. After all, she and her family incurred huge debts defending her against charges for which she was eventually definitively acquitted. No, Marasca writes that IF she had blood on her hand, it had to have gotten there AFTER the murder, not during.

You may not be prone to hero-worship or infatuation but you are most certainly prone to a very severe case of confirmation bias.
 
I dislike the following conduct:

1. Accusing a completely innocent man of the rape and murder and falsely claiming to be **** scared of him.

2. Being present at the murder scene - FACT - and failing to summon any kind of help.

3. Lying and obstructing the police in their investigation.

4. Raff refusing to testify.

5. Knox' frivolous behaviour in court (cf the Manson girls).

6. Defiance.

7. Touring the country claiming to be 'exonerated' and 'wrongly imprisoned for four years' when Knox received a fair three-year sentence for no.1 above.

8. Profiting from Meredith's murder whilst Marasca clearly writes Knox had Mez' blood on her hands.

Unlike you, I am not prone to hero-worship or infatuation.

None of this behavior is objectively objectionable in an of itself. It's all dependent on your starting assumption about their guilt (which wasn't even proven in the corrupt Italian courts desperate to prove it, let alone in a first world court, let alone in actual reality).

If we're just going to beg the question for the rest of the thread I might as well just spam "The Italians gave the man who raped Meredith in her own home, and cut her open for her money phones and silence, an easy 10 year sentence and pat on the back on his way out."
 
Last edited:
You may not be prone to hero-worship or infatuation but you are most certainly prone to a very severe case of confirmation bias.

It's not exactly hero-worship but it is becoming obvious that Vixen is among a small a vocal group of Mignini advocates. These are the things Mignini would want to say, when he feels insulted that Cassation put a stop to his predatory prosecution.

Except for his submission with regard to alleging that Maori and Lanagan had defamed him, he's too cowardly to say it for himself. So he relies on surrogates.
 
It's not exactly hero-worship but it is becoming obvious that Vixen is among a small a vocal group of Mignini advocates. These are the things Mignini would want to say, when he feels insulted that Cassation put a stop to his predatory prosecution.

Except for his submission with regard to alleging that Maori and Lanagan had defamed him, he's too cowardly to say it for himself. So he relies on surrogates.

I have always been puzzled how could the members TJMK have such high regard for an odious scumbag like Mignini. On TJMK they think the sun shines out of Mignini's backside and go to great lengths to defend Mignini regardless of what he does. I wonder if Mignini has a connection with the people behind TJMK and is contact with TJMK members.I find it hard to believe that TJMK would go to such lengths to defend someone like Mignini if they have no connection with him.
 
It's not exactly hero-worship but it is becoming obvious that Vixen is among a small a vocal group of Mignini advocates. These are the things Mignini would want to say, when he feels insulted that Cassation put a stop to his predatory prosecution.

Except for his submission with regard to alleging that Maori and Lanagan had defamed him, he's too cowardly to say it for himself. So he relies on surrogates.

The obvious answer is Mignini is still trying the case that made him a National fool. Desperately trying to save face, he whines to the court that the opposing attorneys that kicked his ass were mean to him. And naturally his pathetic arguments have migrated via Ergon and Machiavelli to the sickos over here who can't let go.
 
I have always been puzzled how could the members TJMK have such high regard for an odious scumbag like Mignini. On TJMK they think the sun shines out of Mignini's backside and go to great lengths to defend Mignini regardless of what he does. I wonder if Mignini has a connection with the people behind TJMK and is contact with TJMK members.I find it hard to believe that TJMK would go to such lengths to defend someone like Mignini if they have no connection with him.

Welshman and Acbytesla:

This is the only explanation for something you notice if you hang around long enough.

Those folk, and particularly TJMK, rarely defend Massei's compatibilities or Nencini's speculations, and never mention the second prosecutor at all - Crini.

They defend Mignini, or more precisely Mignini's bizarre theories. Remember that thosr theories are unrecognizable by the time of Nencini's court.

No one can ever know, really, if there's some link other than that they parrot his theories. But my word, the submission against Maori and Lagana is a template for what the surrogates repeat ad naseam.
 
You have zero understanding of how ghostwriting works. Even where a ghostwriter gets no writing credit anywhere in the published work, it's very usual that such a ghostwriter will be receiving a percentage of royalties - especially if the named author is a bankable celebrity with an agent and a publishing deal in place:


3. Do you work on a shared royalties (profit share) basis with celebrities?

Yes – particularly if a celebrity already has an agent/publisher in place. Because celebrity books are easier to sell, it’s much less risky for us to work on a shared royalties basis. However, we do ask any expenses such as hotel rooms for interviews are covered, and that a one-off payment of £2000 is made (which will be deducted from book sales) to help sustain the writer while the book is being written. The shared royalties split varies from book to book – please talk to us for an exact figure.


http://ghostwritingcompany.co.uk/ghostwriterfaq/


Please don't pretend to have knowledge of things that, in fact, you have next to no knowledge about.



Is Knox an author or a writer? Also keep in mind publishing houses also have editors who help put it together, without acknowledgment so it looks like Kulman did help the 'creative writing major' more than let on:

[T]he author of a book is the person who supplies the ideas, plan, theory, stories, etc. The person who helps the author arrange everything on paper in a marketable form is the writer. (Usually the author is also the writer.) The person who makes sure the manuscript conforms to commercial standards is the editor. Individuals who bring material, research and/​or story ideas to the project are co-authors or collaborators.
http://www.writersandeditors.com/book_collaboration__ghostwriting_57408.htm

So whether Kulman 'brings material, research and/or story ideas', or simply writes it, means there is no way Amanda was the author and writer of her own book, if she did not bring any originality to it, except to supply Kulman with answers to her prejudiced (pre-judged) questions.
 
It is, at least in part, either real or pretended ignorance. See the PGP comments that a "collaborator" on a book is necessarily an author or co-author.

There are, for example, typically several editors with different functions, for books published by established publishing companies. All the editors many be considered collaborators on the book. Authors also may hire editors or get help from friends or colleagues in shaping their works.

"The editing process often begins with the author's idea for the work itself, continuing as a collaboration between the author and the editor as the work is created. As such, editing can involve creative skills, human relations and a precise set of methods.

There are various editorial positions in publishing. Typically, one finds editorial assistants reporting to the senior-level editorial staff and directors who report to senior executive editors. Senior executive editors are responsible for developing a product for its final release. The smaller the publication, the more these roles overlap."

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Editing


Wrong, Numbers. An editor's function is quite different. (See above.)
 
This. Is. Not. True. And. You. Know. It's. Not. True. If it had not been for Knox and Sollecito, the victim would not have been found for days.

You. Also. Never. Cite. What. The. Court. Actually. Said. Here. It. Is. (But you did render the word "fact" in all caps, so that must have made what you said a fact):

​
Indeed, Raffaele and Amanda actually did call around, including a call to the 112 Carabinieri - before the arrival of the postal police (as per the 2010 Massei report).

No one knew what help needed to be rendered before the door was broken down (except for the murderer Rudy Guede) who had left the victim to bleed out the night before.

You have been asked umpteen times to present the forensic-evidence behind your repetitious-claim. There is a reason why you cannot provide it - the Massei report in 2010 said there was no forensics to back the claim.


LOL Amazing revinvention of history. Perhaps Amanda and Raff will use this claim in their next whining 'exoneree' speech.

Perhaps crime writers can rewrite Ted Bundy: 'Ted Bundy rescued his victims from having to deal any further with the vicissitudes of life. Myra Hindley and Ian Brady brought their victims a strange kind of happiness...death.'

When Knox rang Mom, Edda, just before the door was broken down the call went like this:

'Hi Mom, just ringing up to say hello.'

'For **** sake, it's four o'clock in the morning.'

'Sorry Mom. Just wanted to let you know what a fine morning it is here in Perugia.'

'Bye'.
 
I find it interesting that you would describe Amanda's career as a writer as sucking the death of Meredith Kercher dry since I recall you saying that you were assisting in compiling that joke of a book about the case. I also didn't see you complaining about how much all the money that other writers made from this tragedy.

Stop being a hypocrite. If anyone should profit from this tragedy, it should be the two people who WRONGLY were in prison for FOUR YEARS! And Raffaele and his family paid millions of dollars for his exoneration that will take years to get back.

But let's examine your idiotic and wrong statement. Amanda has been writing a column in Seattle that 95 percent of the time never mentions anything to do with Italy. Amanda reviews movies, plays, concerts and writes about Seattle. How is that as you said 'sucking the death of Meredith Kercher dry'?

Only someone with a sick obsessive perspective would describe that as something untoward. They really need to get help. Like it or not, Amanda and Raffaele are making lemonade out of lemons. Get over it.

Millions of dollars of other people's money. When will the obknoxious Knox pay Patrick his €42K as ordered by the court?


I note she never mentions her conviction and rightful four year's in prison concerning this big gentle Congolese man who was like an uncle to her and never hurt a fly.

She only got a column in West Seattle Herald because of the 'novelty value' in having a mu notorious criminal from Seattle writing for them, and the newspaper owner's son got to get his leg over.
 
Last edited:
ROFLMAO

This is the epitome of ignorance of how forensics can help crime investigators.

What's there to laugh at. This is the only case in history where someone's DNA being found in their own sink they were the last person to use was considered incriminating by the prosecution.

1-800 Devry Institute certificate receiver Stefanoni is not pioneering forensic work.

I could go to the 9/11 section of this forum and get better arguments from truthers who think the gov blew up a few buildings to destroy a dozen paper documents.
 
Vixen doesn't understand what is or isn't an ex-parte conversation. It wouldn't matter if they were having a private conversation about the case which clearly they weren't. Conti and Vechiotti are not judges. They are simply expert witnesses. In fact disclosure laws would require them to provide all the information about their tests to both the prosecution and defense and maybe answer questions prior to their testimony.

The point is, they were not going to. Ask yourself why the Carabinieri were sent out to arrest them. Because Vecchiotti & Conti corruptly produced a DVD which they prepared to help the defence .

Vecchiotti was later convicted of gross negligence in another murder case where she refused to test the DNA of the murderer for 19 years until ordered to. She and Pascali were ordered to pay €150,000 each to the murder victim's husband.

This is a woman who abuses her office to help murderers avoid prison.
 
Ho. Lee. Cow.

Just finished reading Mignini's "Submission of Criminal Complaint", written in support of charging Luca Maori (Sollecito's criminal lawyer), Alberto Lagana and Bruno Brunori, for defamatory comments Maori had made in 2015 in an interview with Lagana. Named as complainants in this submission are also Monica Napoleoni and Lorena Zugarini, who (it is claimed) were defamed by inference.

Thank you to Methos for pointing to the submission, available in translation from TJMK.

The rumour is - this complaint is being held up in Florence because the prosecutor there does not want to proceed with it. And if that is true, repeat "if", the submission itself contains the reasons why.

It is clear that Mignini deems it essential to relitigate the murder trial(s) which eventually cleared Knox and Sollecito. It's clear he's a sore loser.
He lays out his own reasons why the legal-legalities of that process (from 2009-2015) stopped with the Nencini trial. He regards the Fifth Chambers annulment of the Nencini convictions to be illegitimate - and here's the thing.....

...... for all the reasons that Vixen and Machiavelli have laid out in this thread, as well as those who post to TJMK.

However, I'd challenge anyone to cite an Italian legal source, other than Mignini, who agrees with his views on the Kercher murder trial processes. These are Mignini's whines, as well as his surrogates who repeat them almost verbatim.

But here's the deal - and these are the reasons IMO that the Florence prosecutor is not going to go ahead with the prosecution of defamation against Maori and Lagana.....

Mignini is signalling that essential to understanding that defamation are the facts of the Kercher murder trials as Mignini sees them. That means - probably - that those facts will be relitigated in the Florence court after the Fifth Chamber of Cassation has definitively put an end to it.

Two last things, the last of which is where even Mignini undercuts himself.

In the submission Mignini lists people "informed of the facts". They are Insp Armando Finzi, of the Perugia Flying Squad, Dr Daniela Severi, Advocate Carlo Pacelli, Giuseppe Castellini, Dr Manuela Comodi, and Dr Patrizia Stefanoni who Mignini claims are in a position to buttress his views on both the defamation statements, as well as the facts/evidence of the Kercher murder trials.

Do these people, particularly Stefanoni, want to be cross-examined on their conduct in the murder trials? Has the Florence prosecutor phoned Stefanoni only to be told that Stefanoni is washing her hair that month? Are all these people who are "informed of the facts" going to be forced to defame the Fifth Chambers the same way Mignini defames them in his submission? Do they really want that sort of trouble?

Besides, Napoleoni and Zugarini have unrelated legal problems of their own right now.

But then there's the second thing. In the submission, Mignini admits that as of the Fifth Chambers annulments, this annuls everything from Massei's court all the way to the Nencini court - with the exception (from Mignini's point of view) of what the First Chambers had found as factual in 2013. That set of stuff stands, even though Mignini counterintuitively says that both Massei and Hellmann are now gone.

How's that for logic.

Which prosecutor in their right mind wants to engage all this? Which prosecutor in their right mind wants to relitigate the Kercher trials, when those trials ended in acquittals - definitive at that! - for Knox and Sollecito?

All because Mignini lost?

When even Mignini conceeds, in writing in his submission, that all the lower court trials from the Kercher process now are annulled and without effect!?

Mignini probably DOES have a case of defamation, given the words Maori and Lagana used to describe him, and by extension Napoleoni and Zugarini. I agreed with that part in Mignini's submission that both Maori and Lagana could have made the same points about incompetence without becoming inflammatory.

But........

By trying to relitigate the Kercher process by claiming that he was right, even though he lost, is a whine. Nothing more. Nothing less.

But we now know who Machiavelli and Vixen are surrogates for in this thread. Everything they've claimed about the Fifth Chambers is in the submission Methos pointed to.

But none of it is factual - it is all Mignini's legal opinion, about a series of trials in which he eventually lost.

And we can gauge the size of the loss, but the size of his whine.

I should point out that Mignini is the attorney prosecutor for the region. It is his job to prepare cases for prosecution. These will be literally thousands per annum. He is highly legally qualified enough to know the criteria for bringing a case to trial, and in any case, he has to get past the preliminary judges first, who always hear both sides of a case.


After Massei, he was no involved in the case at all.


Thirdly, the prosecutor doesn't decide the case, the court does, after hearing all of the evidence presented during a fair and balanced trial, which is publicly seen to be so. The ultimate motivations rest with the judges after the verdict, and the prosecutor's case has no higher merit than the defence's.

The final point you must understand is that Italy has been riddled with Mafia corruption, which includes intimidating prosecutors and judges (one was kidnapped and murdered) who live in daily fear of Mafia retribution, hence the importance of coming down hard on any whiff of witness intimidation or prosecutor libel and defamation.
 
Mignini in his submission says that Marasca/Bruno's use of Section 530.2 to annul the Nencini conviction represents a "“weakened” and “doubtful” formula"....

​
I have one source which says that this understanding changed in 1989 during the partial reform intended to move from an inquisitorial system to an adversarial system.

After 1989 "there is plenty of Cassation rulings stating the perfect legal equivalence of the acquittals issued under the two sections of Article 530." I do not have any to link to, so am just putting it out there.

In any event, since Mignini wrote his submission well before the publication of the Marasca-Bruno motivation report, not even M/B thought it important enough to deal with.

In short, they ignored Mignini. And from this distance, there was no hue and cry of protest in reply from any Italian legal source, except for Mignini's on-line surrogates.

Adversarial (us) versus inquisitorial (Latin countries and South Africa, strangely) is simply a description of the process.

It is the case in all modern justice systems of either type that Appeals courts, and the Supreme Court, are purely there to oversee that the law has been applied correctly.

Fact finding is 100% the remit of the trial court, and in the UK/USA formula a trial verdict by a jury of defendants peers is sacrosanct and cannot be changed except on a specif point of law, which usually has five subcategories. In italy, one of these subcategories and the most common point of appeal, is that of 'internal contradiction' in the MR. UK/USA verdict rarely have written reasons at all and successful applications for an appeal are relatively rare. In Italy every defendant has an automatic two appeals, one of which is the Supreme Court, if they wish. Catch is, the prosecution can also appeal.

So, in effect, should an appeal win re 'internal contradiction', all aan appeal/Supreme Court are remitted to do is send it back to a merits court for the facts to be reassessed as prescribed by the Appeal/Supreme Court as per the point of law in (potential) error.

Mignini is correct that Marasca erred in this matter.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom