The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
You don't get Bar Standards, do you?

During a live trial all evidence relating to it must be shared by all parties, together with the judge.

Any barrister expecting to chat with the judge 'in chambers' or an independant expert witness wanting the private ear of one of the parties, is grossly negligent in their duty to the court.

You don't get that there is no evidence whatsoever that Maori or any other defense lawyer "colluded" with Conti and Vecchiotti, do you? There is no evidence they were, in your words, "wined and dined". Speaking to them in public in full view of Stefanoni, journalists, etc is not exactly the best way to get "the private ear" of someone, is it?

I'm still waiting for you to provide evidence that Vecchiotti was "almost arrested" or that she had made the DVD for "the defence's eyes only".
 
"Linda Kulman

I am a journalist, writer, editor, and the author, most recently, of Teaching Common Sense: The Grand Strategy Program at Yale University about one of Yale’s best-known and most sought-after courses. Based on several years of onsite reporting, archival research, interviews with students and faculty, and original survey data, Teaching Common Sense looks at “Studies in Grand Strategy,” a year-long, by-application leadership seminar. The course addresses some of higher education’s bedrock question, such as how is critical thinking taught and how will this generation learn to cope with uncertainty in a fast-changing world.

I have collaborated on seven nonfiction books, working successfully with a group of diverse, demanding personalities to tell their personal, and sometimes painful, stories. These include Amanda Knox’s New York Times bestselling memoir, Waiting to be Heard; Hillary Clinton’s Dear Socks, Dear Buddy: Kids’ Letters to the First Pets, written while she was First Lady; New York Governor Andrew Cuomo’s All Things Possible: Setbacks and Success in Politics and Life; George McGovern’s What It Means to Be a Democrat; George Foreman’s Guide to Life: How to Get Up Off the Canvas When Life Knocks You Down; and James Carville’s We’re Right, They’re Wrong. Each of these projects required me to become an expert on a nuanced topic, whether on the Italian legal system, the root causes of homelessness, heavyweight wrestling, the history of pets in the White House, or gun safety reform. ...."

Source: http://branford.yalecollege.yale.edu/linda-kulman

Collaborator: a person who works jointly on an activity or project; an associate.

Source: https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/collaborator

Thanks Numbers. This tangent arose from Vixen's suggestion that Amanda required the assistance of her boyfriend Chris to help with the spelling and grammar in her latest op-ed in the LA Times. I just pointed out that Amanda didn't seem to need his help having penned her own best selling book as well as hundreds of columns not to mention she graduated from a prestigious prep school and university. Vixen of course jumped in insisting it was Linda who wrote the book in its entirety.
 
Stop talking rubbish. Slander and libel are merely civil matters. Obstruction of justice includes exactly what Amanda was convicted of, aiming to pervert the course of [FBI] investigators and is a federal felony which attracts on average five year's jail in most US states.

Rubbish is being talked here, but not by me.

Slander and libel are merely civil matters.

EXACTLY! Which is why it is not a CRIMINAL offense as is calunnia. Which is why the US has no equivalent to calunnia.

What part of obstruction of justice requires lying UNDER OATH are you not understanding? Amanda was never under oath.

And for the umpteenth time (I know you love that term), if calunnia were recognized as an equivalent crime in the US, Amanda would have a criminal record in the US. She does not as TJMK's and your failure to ever produce one proves.
 
The fact Linda Kulman is named as the author of Knox's pack of lies book, proves she is accredited with it and gets shared royalties.

Ghost writers are not normally named. A friend of mine in the know in the publishing world informs me Jeffrey Archer has a whole team of them.

Jeffery Archer gets the royalties.

My post below shows the numerous instances where PGP have ignored or defended books, films and documentaries with faslehoods which makes it hypocritical for PGP to attack Amanda for lying in her book.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=11333243#post11333243
 
You don't get that there is no evidence whatsoever that Maori or any other defense lawyer "colluded" with Conti and Vecchiotti, do you? There is no evidence they were, in your words, "wined and dined". Speaking to them in public in full view of Stefanoni, journalists, etc is not exactly the best way to get "the private ear" of someone, is it?

I'm still waiting for you to provide evidence that Vecchiotti was "almost arrested" or that she had made the DVD for "the defence's eyes only".

Vixen doesn't understand what is or isn't an ex-parte conversation. It wouldn't matter if they were having a private conversation about the case which clearly they weren't. Conti and Vechiotti are not judges. They are simply expert witnesses. In fact disclosure laws would require them to provide all the information about their tests to both the prosecution and defense and maybe answer questions prior to their testimony.
 
Thanks Numbers. This tangent arose from Vixen's suggestion that Amanda required the assistance of her boyfriend Chris to help with the spelling and grammar in her latest op-ed in the LA Times. I just pointed out that Amanda didn't seem to need his help having penned her own best selling book as well as hundreds of columns not to mention she graduated from a prestigious prep school and university. Vixen of course jumped in insisting it was Linda who wrote the book in its entirety.

Perhaps part of the issue is that the PGP are ignorant of the role of editors in producing books and other written materials.

"Editing is the process of selecting and preparing written, visual, audible, and film media used to convey information. The editing process can involve correction, condensation, organization, and many other modifications performed with an intention of producing a correct, consistent, accurate and complete work.

The editing process often begins with the author's idea for the work itself, continuing as a collaboration between the author and the editor as the work is created. As such, editing can involve creative skills, human relations and a precise set of methods.
....
Self-employed editors work directly for clients (e.g., authors, publishers) or offer their services through editing firms, or both. They may specialize in a type of editing (e.g., copy editing) and in a particular subject area. Those who work directly for authors and develop professional relationships with them are called authors' editors."

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Editing
 
Thanks Numbers. This tangent arose from Vixen's suggestion that Amanda required the assistance of her boyfriend Chris to help with the spelling and grammar in her latest op-ed in the LA Times. I just pointed out that Amanda didn't seem to need his help having penned her own best selling book as well as hundreds of columns not to mention she graduated from a prestigious prep school and university. Vixen of course jumped in insisting it was Linda who wrote the book in its entirety.

In other words, the poster posted a lie to shield another lie.
 
Perhaps part of the issue is that the PGP are ignorant of the role of editors in producing books and other written materials.
"Editing is the process of selecting and preparing written, visual, audible, and film media used to convey information. The editing process can involve correction, condensation, organization, and many other modifications performed with an intention of producing a correct, consistent, accurate and complete work.

The editing process often begins with the author's idea for the work itself, continuing as a collaboration between the author and the editor as the work is created. As such, editing can involve creative skills, human relations and a precise set of methods.
....
Self-employed editors work directly for clients (e.g., authors, publishers) or offer their services through editing firms, or both. They may specialize in a type of editing (e.g., copy editing) and in a particular subject area. Those who work directly for authors and develop professional relationships with them are called authors' editors."

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Editing

I doubt it has anything to do with ignorance. I'm sure that Vixen understands what an editor does. The facts are secondary to posting an incendiary remark about Amanda. The remark about grammar and spelling is without foundation. I have yet to read anything by Amanda that would lead anyone to come to the conclusion that either pose an issue.

Now maybe the reason for this is as as a professional writer, Amanda's work is submitted to an editor that proofs her work before it is published or that she is good at what she does. The point is that there is no way for anyone other than Amanda or her editor who knows.

Which leads to the question why pretend you know something that you KNOW you DON'T?
 
SOME CHEESE WITH THAT WHINE!

Ho. Lee. Cow.

Just finished reading Mignini's "Submission of Criminal Complaint", written in support of charging Luca Maori (Sollecito's criminal lawyer), Alberto Lagana and Bruno Brunori, for defamatory comments Maori had made in 2015 in an interview with Lagana. Named as complainants in this submission are also Monica Napoleoni and Lorena Zugarini, who (it is claimed) were defamed by inference.

Thank you to Methos for pointing to the submission, available in translation from TJMK.

The rumour is - this complaint is being held up in Florence because the prosecutor there does not want to proceed with it. And if that is true, repeat "if", the submission itself contains the reasons why.

It is clear that Mignini deems it essential to relitigate the murder trial(s) which eventually cleared Knox and Sollecito. It's clear he's a sore loser.
He lays out his own reasons why the legal-legalities of that process (from 2009-2015) stopped with the Nencini trial. He regards the Fifth Chambers annulment of the Nencini convictions to be illegitimate - and here's the thing.....

...... for all the reasons that Vixen and Machiavelli have laid out in this thread, as well as those who post to TJMK.

However, I'd challenge anyone to cite an Italian legal source, other than Mignini, who agrees with his views on the Kercher murder trial processes. These are Mignini's whines, as well as his surrogates who repeat them almost verbatim.

But here's the deal - and these are the reasons IMO that the Florence prosecutor is not going to go ahead with the prosecution of defamation against Maori and Lagana.....

Mignini is signalling that essential to understanding that defamation are the facts of the Kercher murder trials as Mignini sees them. That means - probably - that those facts will be relitigated in the Florence court after the Fifth Chamber of Cassation has definitively put an end to it.

Two last things, the last of which is where even Mignini undercuts himself.

In the submission Mignini lists people "informed of the facts". They are Insp Armando Finzi, of the Perugia Flying Squad, Dr Daniela Severi, Advocate Carlo Pacelli, Giuseppe Castellini, Dr Manuela Comodi, and Dr Patrizia Stefanoni who Mignini claims are in a position to buttress his views on both the defamation statements, as well as the facts/evidence of the Kercher murder trials.

Do these people, particularly Stefanoni, want to be cross-examined on their conduct in the murder trials? Has the Florence prosecutor phoned Stefanoni only to be told that Stefanoni is washing her hair that month? Are all these people who are "informed of the facts" going to be forced to defame the Fifth Chambers the same way Mignini defames them in his submission? Do they really want that sort of trouble?

Besides, Napoleoni and Zugarini have unrelated legal problems of their own right now.

But then there's the second thing. In the submission, Mignini admits that as of the Fifth Chambers annulments, this annuls everything from Massei's court all the way to the Nencini court - with the exception (from Mignini's point of view) of what the First Chambers had found as factual in 2013. That set of stuff stands, even though Mignini counterintuitively says that both Massei and Hellmann are now gone.

How's that for logic.

Which prosecutor in their right mind wants to engage all this? Which prosecutor in their right mind wants to relitigate the Kercher trials, when those trials ended in acquittals - definitive at that! - for Knox and Sollecito?

All because Mignini lost?

When even Mignini conceeds, in writing in his submission, that all the lower court trials from the Kercher process now are annulled and without effect!?

Mignini probably DOES have a case of defamation, given the words Maori and Lagana used to describe him, and by extension Napoleoni and Zugarini. I agreed with that part in Mignini's submission that both Maori and Lagana could have made the same points about incompetence without becoming inflammatory.

But........

By trying to relitigate the Kercher process by claiming that he was right, even though he lost, is a whine. Nothing more. Nothing less.

But we now know who Machiavelli and Vixen are surrogates for in this thread. Everything they've claimed about the Fifth Chambers is in the submission Methos pointed to.

But none of it is factual - it is all Mignini's legal opinion, about a series of trials in which he eventually lost.

And we can gauge the size of the loss, but the size of his whine.
 
Last edited:
Mignini in his submission says that Marasca/Bruno's use of Section 530.2 to annul the Nencini conviction represents a "“weakened” and “doubtful” formula"....

"in open violation of
Articles 609 and 628, paragraph two Criminal Procedure Code
and with inadmissible re-evaluation of the merits of the case.
An annulment without remittance, according to what has been
given to be known, not requested by the appellants-accused
who had reiterated their usual objections to the decision but
had asked for annulment with remittance."​
I have one source which says that this understanding changed in 1989 during the partial reform intended to move from an inquisitorial system to an adversarial system.

After 1989 "there is plenty of Cassation rulings stating the perfect legal equivalence of the acquittals issued under the two sections of Article 530." I do not have any to link to, so am just putting it out there.

In any event, since Mignini wrote his submission well before the publication of the Marasca-Bruno motivation report, not even M/B thought it important enough to deal with.

In short, they ignored Mignini. And from this distance, there was no hue and cry of protest in reply from any Italian legal source, except for Mignini's on-line surrogates.
 
Last edited:
How sick is it for someone who wrote sick rape/murder fantasies and convicted of falsely accusing Patrick Lumumba of the rape and murder she and Raff were found guilty of in the merits trial and appeal (annulled by the Supreme Court on non-legal grounds) to get to write for the LA TIMES about other sick criminals.As per usual Knox turns the story round to one about herself, so no change to the narcissism there, then.Interestingly, she also championed the cause of swimmer Brock Turner found 'dry humping' a woman in a coma on public ground.

I suspect Party Rock boyfriend, Chris Robinson, had a hand in helping her to write it and iron out the illiterate grammatical errors and spelling gaffes.Pretentiously, she writes that whilst Michelle Carter - who urged her boyfriend to kill himself, which he then did - whilst 'morally and philosophically wrong' was 'unlawfully convicted'.

Really?

In which way is it 'philosophically' wrong? Just big words for form over substance. In fact there is plenty of philosophical literature on suicide: Hamlet, The Savage God; The Myth of Sisyphus, and so on and so forth. Who is Amanda Knox to say it is 'philosophically wrong' but not illegal? Someone who writes about her 'best truth' and things her 'head' is 'confusedly' telling her 'in blurry images'.

Fact is, it might be considered 'morally wrong' for someone who is a Christian, but Knox is a rabid atheist who frets she may never become President as she would be unable to swear on the Bible at the inauguration. What planet is this being on?

Legally: unfortunately for Knox suicide or aiding suicide was illegal in many western countries even up until the sixties, with 'assisted suicide' still being unlawful, with some countries, such as Switzerland allowing it for medical reasons in special clinics.

The fact the prosecutor in Carter's case had a criminal statute against her and there was jurisdiction to hear her case, means it cannot have been 'unlawful' to convict her, whether or not you agree with the charge.

How much was Knox paid for leeching off the murder of her roommate? Enquiring minds need to know.What was LA TIMES thinking?

.
Fact is, I neither like or dislike this pair. It is their behaviour I despise.

You disprove yourself with your own words.
 
She should grow up. Since when was a 20-year old a 'kid'? As for, 'the Black guys call me their "little baby girl"' - snorts of scepticism - and prancing about in a little red riding hood outfit, who is she kidding?
Mind you, they do say psychopaths are arrested at a young emotional age, usually because of a traumatic incident. For example, Mary Bell, child killer aged 8, was used by her prostitute mum as a toddler prostitute.

Why are you telling me? It is absolute rubbish to say a twenty-year old adult is 'just a child'.

They were not juveniles, they are not 'kids', they were not 'kidnapped'; none of the Black ex-cons call her 'our little baby girl' . (If they do it was probably a tactful response to her flirting with them).
The person who caused pain to her family was Amanda herself. When will this emotionally retarded person take responsibiltiy for her own actions instead of blaming innocent prison doctors, her age, the drugs, sexism, Italy, catholics, the victim's family and Uncle Tom Cobbley and all.

I don't 'slut shame'. I couldn't give a toss about the pair's personal details.

Knox herself keeps portraying herself as a rampant nymphomaniac who invented sex. <fx YAWN>

Fact is, I neither like or dislike this pair. It is their behaviour I despise.

And those are only from the first 3 pages of this latest version. Unless one is a racist or bigot who dislikes someone based on their race, ethnicity, religion, etc., it's behavior that dictates if we dislike or like them.
 
How sick is it for someone who wrote sick rape/murder fantasies and convicted of falsely accusing Patrick Lumumba of the rape and murder she and Raff were found guilty of in the merits trial and appeal (annulled by the Supreme Court on non-legal grounds) to get to write for the LA TIMES about other sick criminals.

As per usual Knox turns the story round to one about herself, so no change to the narcissism there, then.

Interestingly, she also championed the cause of swimmer Brock Turner found 'dry humping' a woman in a coma on public ground.

I suspect Party Rock boyfriend, Chris Robinson, had a hand in helping her to write it and iron out the illiterate grammatical errors and spelling gaffes.

Pretentiously, she writes that whilst Michelle Carter - who urged her boyfriend to kill himself, which he then did - whilst 'morally and philosophically wrong' was 'unlawfully convicted'.

Really?

In which way is it 'philosophically' wrong? Just big words for form over substance. In fact there is plenty of philosophical literature on suicide: Hamlet, The Savage God; The Myth of Sisyphus, and so on and so forth. Who is Amanda Knox to say it is 'philosophically wrong' but not illegal? Someone who writes about her 'best truth' and things her 'head' is 'confusedly' telling her 'in blurry images'.

Fact is, it might be considered 'morally wrong' for someone who is a Christian, but Knox is a rabid atheist who frets she may never become President as she would be unable to swear on the Bible at the inauguration. What planet is this being on?

Legally: unfortunately for Knox suicide or aiding suicide was illegal in many western countries even up until the sixties, with 'assisted suicide' still being unlawful, with some countries, such as Switzerland allowing it for medical reasons in special clinics.

The fact the prosecutor in Carter's case had a criminal statute against her and there was jurisdiction to hear her case, means it cannot have been 'unlawful' to convict her, whether or not you agree with the charge.

How much was Knox paid for leeching off the murder of her roommate? Enquiring minds need to know.

What was LA TIMES thinking?

Fact is, I neither like or dislike this pair. It is their behaviour I despise.

You disprove yourself with your own words.

It's kind of a joke isn't it Stacyhs? There are so many made up stretch the truths and outright lies and hatred oozing from Vixen's every sentence.

Amanda didn't write a rape murder fantasy. And what if she had? Stephen King has written countless horror stories depicting hundreds of murders. The horror genre is a popular genre. Was Mary Shelley, Bram Stoker, Edgar Allen Poe, Robert Louis Stevenson,
Peter Straub, Dean Koontz, Thomas Harris, etc and countless other writers sick? One of the most successful movie genres is horror. Hollywood makes more horror films every year than they do rom-coms. And they are especially popular among teenagers and the young.

For anyone to suggest that writing a story no matter how sick or disgusting suggests that the author is sick and disgusting really has a personal problem.

And, I'm sorry, the so called confession that links Patrick to the murder is a joke if you read it. Anyone with a brain wouldn't take it seriously. And the simple fact is that Amanda retracted it within hours.

Then Vixen says Amanda is narcissistic. I can't imagine anyone less narcissistic than Amanda. Not that she doesn't relate other people's experiences to her own. But we all do that.

Then, not showing her hatred Vixens says Amanda needed her boyfriend to correct Amanda's illiterate grammar and spelling gaffes. No, that's not hatred Vixen, That is dishonest lying nonsense. Amanda is a graduate of a prestigious prep school and university. She has written a best selling book and writes a column. She is literate in three languages. She reads and writes in Italian, English and German. It's dumb enough to believe Amanda was involved in the murder of Meredith despite all the evidence but it is a sign of pretty sick hatred to not just think, but to call Amanda illiterate despite the massive evidence to the contrary. I wonder, since you have bragged about being a Mensa member. Is there a section on logic or intellectual honesty?

Then Vixen jumps in to Amanda's op-ed about the suicide texting case as if Amanda really said anything all that controversial. There is significant question about the legality of the guilty verdict.

Then we get to Vixen being absolutely oblivious about atheism and the reasonable complaint atheists have about people discriminating against them because they don't believe in fairy tales?

This is like when Christians opine about homosexuals saying that they don't dislike the sinners, they dislike the sin. No, this is obsessive disgusting hatred. No other word for it.
 
Last edited:
Then Vixen jumps in to Amanda's op-ed about the suicide texting case as if Amanda really said anything all that controversial. There is significant question about the legality of the guilty verdict.

..... which even the convicting judge conceded when granting the stay of sentence.

But why bother with the nuances of the texting/suicide case when it gives an opportunity to say something awful about a random Seattleite author who has an opinion.
 
..... which even the convicting judge conceded when granting the stay of sentence.

But why bother with the nuances of the texting/suicide case when it gives an opportunity to say something awful about a random Seattleite author who has an opinion.

That seems to be the gist of it. Got to channel that hate somehow. Can't really talk about the case. It's over with and Amanda was exonerated. Yes EXONERATED. Amanda is rightfully free.

But some people need a witch to burn. Maybe it makes them feel better about themselves. Me, I would be ashamed of myself. Especially, given the lessons I was taught in Sunday School. Lying and demeaning someone else aren't exactly Christian values. I was taught he without sin cast the first stone and none are without sin.

Hmmmm. It's ironic that as an atheist I'm a better Christian.
 
That seems to be the gist of it. Got to channel that hate somehow. Can't really talk about the case. It's over with and Amanda was exonerated. Yes EXONERATED. Amanda is rightfully free.

But some people need a witch to burn. Maybe it makes them feel better about themselves. Me, I would be ashamed of myself. Especially, given the lessons I was taught in Sunday School. Lying and demeaning someone else aren't exactly Christian values. I was taught he without sin cast the first stone and none are without sin.

Hmmmm. It's ironic that as an atheist I'm a better Christian.

So far you and Pope Francis are on the same page. He's said something akin to, it's better to be a moral atheist than an immoral Christian.
 
So far you and Pope Francis are on the same page. He's said something akin to, it's better to be a moral atheist than an immoral Christian.

And some people are having a hissy fit about Pope Francis. There are conservative Catholics stuck between their loyalty to the church and their hatred for anything liberal. And Francis seems to be taking on the conservative traditions of the church...well sort of. Still haven't heard any reforms to the laity, and letting priests marry. But he definitely is softening the position of the church on divorce.
 
And some people are having a hissy fit about Pope Francis. There are conservative Catholics stuck between their loyalty to the church and their hatred for anything liberal. And Francis seems to be taking on the conservative traditions of the church...well sort of. Still haven't heard any reforms to the laity, and letting priests marry. But he definitely is softening the position of the church on divorce.

He got an Australian Bishop to attempt to clean up Vatican finances......... that one got interrupted.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom