The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ok.... now I'm participating in the merry-go-round.

All this was covered in June 2015 on this thread.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=10732949#post10732949

The big difference is that now the Mignini surrogates here are treating Mignini's claims in the submission as proven.

What's the statute of limitations on this defamation submission?


Convention says six years. With the exception of murder and other serious crimes, where there is no statute of limitations at all.
 
And those are only from the first 3 pages of this latest version. Unless one is a racist or bigot who dislikes someone based on their race, ethnicity, religion, etc., it's behavior that dictates if we dislike or like them.

You really don't know the difference between justice as served in a court of law (no, the kids were not prosecuted 'because Mignini didn't like them', as you claim), satire (as in wry social observation, whether it be Trump or Knox), opinion: a comment on national and global news and personal attack (ad hominem based on hatred.

In the world of Stacyhs, any criticism at all of her darlings is 'a personal attack' and this makes her very angry.
 
It is the case in all modern justice systems of either type that Appeals courts, and the Supreme Court, are purely there to oversee that the law has been applied correctly.

True, but Italy isn't a modern justice system, and it isn't true there.
 
It's kind of a joke isn't it Stacyhs? There are so many made up stretch the truths and outright lies and hatred oozing from Vixen's every sentence.

Amanda didn't write a rape murder fantasy. And what if she had? Stephen King has written countless horror stories depicting hundreds of murders. The horror genre is a popular genre. Was Mary Shelley, Bram Stoker, Edgar Allen Poe, Robert Louis Stevenson,
Peter Straub, Dean Koontz, Thomas Harris, etc and countless other writers sick? One of the most successful movie genres is horror. Hollywood makes more horror films every year than they do rom-coms. And they are especially popular among teenagers and the young.

For anyone to suggest that writing a story no matter how sick or disgusting suggests that the author is sick and disgusting really has a personal problem.

And, I'm sorry, the so called confession that links Patrick to the murder is a joke if you read it. Anyone with a brain wouldn't take it seriously. And the simple fact is that Amanda retracted it within hours.

Then Vixen says Amanda is narcissistic. I can't imagine anyone less narcissistic than Amanda. Not that she doesn't relate other people's experiences to her own. But we all do that.

Then, not showing her hatred Vixens says Amanda needed her boyfriend to correct Amanda's illiterate grammar and spelling gaffes. No, that's not hatred Vixen, That is dishonest lying nonsense. Amanda is a graduate of a prestigious prep school and university. She has written a best selling book and writes a column. She is literate in three languages. She reads and writes in Italian, English and German. It's dumb enough to believe Amanda was involved in the murder of Meredith despite all the evidence but it is a sign of pretty sick hatred to not just think, but to call Amanda illiterate despite the massive evidence to the contrary. I wonder, since you have bragged about being a Mensa member. Is there a section on logic or intellectual honesty?

Then Vixen jumps in to Amanda's op-ed about the suicide texting case as if Amanda really said anything all that controversial. There is significant question about the legality of the guilty verdict.

Then we get to Vixen being absolutely oblivious about atheism and the reasonable complaint atheists have about people discriminating against them because they don't believe in fairy tales?

This is like when Christians opine about homosexuals saying that they don't dislike the sinners, they dislike the sin. No, this is obsessive disgusting hatred. No other word for it.


It is a fact Knox wrote rape/murder fantasies before she even arrived in Italy.

It is a common observation that her grammar, syntax and spelling are appalling. You can see an alarming improvement when it is polished up - obviously by an editor when published by a glossy magazine or a proper newspaper, such as LA Times.

The stuff about philosophy, political theory and literary references obviously come from Party Rock, largely.

As an aside to your usual anti-Christian swipe, homosexuality is not considered a 'sin', it is homosexual sex that is said to be so, according to the scriptures.
 
That seems to be the gist of it. Got to channel that hate somehow. Can't really talk about the case. It's over with and Amanda was exonerated. Yes EXONERATED. Amanda is rightfully free.

But some people need a witch to burn. Maybe it makes them feel better about themselves. Me, I would be ashamed of myself. Especially, given the lessons I was taught in Sunday School. Lying and demeaning someone else aren't exactly Christian values. I was taught he without sin cast the first stone and none are without sin.

Hmmmm. It's ironic that as an atheist I'm a better Christian.


The Christian belief is that 'wrath belongs to God', so yes, it is not for us to retaliate against terrorists like-for-like, but as an advanced modern secular civilisation we are entitled to protect the community from the violent, the anti-social and the criminal. There has been much debate about prison reform and whether it should be about retribution or rehabilitation.

I am of the belief that a fair justice system is important: those guilty should be found guilty and those not, not. Once the fair and correct (as humanly possible) verdict is found, then I believe a judge should show mercy (as it did for Carter) and that the offender should show remorse (in time).

If not, we have a corrupt system whereby the guilty are set free because of the 'big money' implications (publishers, media, PR) of upholding their guilt and the truly guilty murderers prancing around the country with glee, lining their pockets with 'innocence projects' speeches with show up fees of US$5,000 (as advertised by the agency)and appropriating the projects from the genuinely wrongfully convicted.
 
And some people are having a hissy fit about Pope Francis. There are conservative Catholics stuck between their loyalty to the church and their hatred for anything liberal. And Francis seems to be taking on the conservative traditions of the church...well sort of. Still haven't heard any reforms to the laity, and letting priests marry. But he definitely is softening the position of the church on divorce.

Pope Francis, being a South American, himself, was having a dig at Trump and his wall.

Reconciling the Catholic belief in penury and fasting and the size of the Pope's waistline, does rather bring into sharp focus the need for the Reformation and protestantism.

No idolatlry, no paying priests for penitance, no fasting, no latin masses, hail marys etc., etc.
 
LOL Amazing revinvention of history. Perhaps Amanda and Raff will use this claim in their next whining 'exoneree' speech.

Perhaps crime writers can rewrite Ted Bundy: 'Ted Bundy rescued his victims from having to deal any further with the vicissitudes of life. Myra Hindley and Ian Brady brought their victims a strange kind of happiness...death.'

When Knox rang Mom, Edda, just before the door was broken down the call went like this:

'Hi Mom, just ringing up to say hello.'

'For **** sake, it's four o'clock in the morning.'

'Sorry Mom. Just wanted to let you know what a fine morning it is here in Perugia.'

'Bye'.

That you would write this shows your willingness to fabricate. Good for you.

Fact is that RS and AK spent all morning raising the alarm before the postal police arrived. Even when the postals were invited in, by AK, the postals did not suspect a major crime had taken place.

Filomena would not have been there if not summoned by Knox. Knox and Sollecito were responsible for the victim being found, otherwise it could have been another 24 or 48 hours.

But it's good you demonstrated for all to see your agenda here.
 
Clearly there is a problem. The level of cognitive dissonance is astounding. But it is the justification for turning every mundane act of Amanda's into something deviant, perverted, dirty or stupid is what I can't fathom.

Vixen's every post portrays Amanda as stupid, which clearly Amanda is not. As an oversexed slut when in reality she seems like the average woman. Or finally as a narcissist. I really don't think Vixen understands what a narcissist is because Amanda sure doesn't seem that self absorbed.

I hadn't contributed to this thread in a long time. I thought I was cured of this silliness. Anyway, hi to everyone.


I would have thought that what was done to Mez was something deviant, perverted, dirty, etc.

You have to admit Knox is not the sharpest knife in the tool box, automatically blaming 'the black man' and claiming amnesia for the night of the murder.

How dumb is it to believe the prosecutor fancies you.
 
Aside from all the nonsense in the body of this post....

Please provide credible, reliable evidence that I am "prone to hero-worship or infatuation". Or withdraw that (baseless) accusation. Thanks in advance.

I've been told but I don't know. That Knox' supporters are largely:

1. a band of white knights who want to rescue the damsel in distress (as per a well-worn Hollywood script, ever since King Kong in 1947)

2. People with a 'claim to fame', such as Stacyhs, with link's to Knox' family, friends or friends of friends.

3. paid shills and PR agents. It is a fact Curt Knox hired PR agency Gogerty-Marriott (now just Marriott) even before he got a defence lawyer.

4. Those 'bleeding hearts' who automatically support the likes of the so-called Lockerbie Bomber, Lundy, Avery, Dassey, Ferguson, Bamber: all these poor people oppressed by a Kafka-esque faceless bureaucracy.

I used to be #4 and then after the Kercher case, and the A1 murder case (Hanratty), I got wise to the tactics of the defence lawyers and subtley biased 'documentary' makers who now cynically use the documentary genre to put forward subversive propaganda in the guise of 'miscarriage of justice'.

If we have a good justice system, fair, objective and cold, we don't need all this emotional blackmail crap.
 
In the "author's notes" page in the back of "Waiting to be Heard", Amanda writes this:

" I wouldn't have been able to write this memoir without Linda Kulman. Somehow, with her Post-it Notes and questions, with her generosity, dedication, and empathy, she turned my rambling into writing, and taught me so much in the meantime. I am grateful to her family-Ralph, Sam, Julia- for sharing her with me for so long."

Amanda, who has a degree in Creative Writing, did not need Kulman to write her book for her. She needed someone to help her organize and refine it. But, of course, when one needs to disparage and belittle anything and everything Knox related, this cannot be acknowledged. No. That would just never do.


Here's what likely really happened:

CURT KNOX: Hey, I have a great idea for a book and to help my daughter get off her murder rap.

HARPER COLLINS: Yeah, wow, there could be millions in it for us! Just imagine, the public will be lapping up all her sordid details. Be sure to include lots of sex because this is what her fanboys will want to buy.

CURT: Cool. I'll get Mandy to send through the MS now.

Two days later

HC: Hello? Mr Knox? Harper Collins here. Is that all there is? just a hundred pages of unpunctuated scribble-er, ahem, I mean inner thoughts?

CURT: Well what did you expect?

HC: Can I be tactful? How about we provide a professional writer to help Amanda knock this drivel, um, I mean, amazing insights, into an acceptable conventional shape?

CURT: OK, but make it quick. We are almost bankrupt.

<brrrr>
 
Last edited:
The PGP, in their desire to denigrate Amanda, resort to deliberate ignorance or obfuscation (in some cases, they may be displaying their "actual ignorance").

Amanda acknowledged Linda Kulman's help in writing her book; Kulman was not the author, she was the author's editor.

"An author is narrowly defined as the originator of any written work and can thus also be described as a writer (with any distinction primarily being an implication that an is a writer of one or more major works, such as books or plays). More broadly defined, an author is "the person who originated or gave existence to anything" and whose authorship determines responsibility for what was created. The more specific phrase published author refers to an author (especially but not necessarily of books) whose work has been independently accepted for publication by a reputable publisher, versus a self-publishing author or an unpublished one. ...."

Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Author

Kulman is not the editor.
 
Vixen, I'm still waiting for you to provide evidence that calunnia (calumny) is equivalent to obstruction of justice which requires lying under oath. Was Amanda under oath during the interrogation? Or at any time whatsoever? Unless you can provide said evidence, may I suggest you stop repeating that falsehood?

I have sent you the law citation and the list of US states federal law in this matter on at least two previous occasions. I shall not do it again.
 
It's not exactly hero-worship but it is becoming obvious that Vixen is among a small a vocal group of Mignini advocates. These are the things Mignini would want to say, when he feels insulted that Cassation put a stop to his predatory prosecution.

Except for his submission with regard to alleging that Maori and Lanagan had defamed him, he's too cowardly to say it for himself. So he relies on surrogates.

What a ridiculous take.
 
I got wise to the tactics of the defence lawyers and subtley biased 'documentary' makers who now cynically use the documentary genre to put forward subversive propaganda in the guise of 'miscarriage of justice'.

Good news, Knox's acquittal had nothing to do with her defense lawyers. She was acquitted because the court appointed two professors to look over the forensic work, and they concluded it was irreparably flawed.

Your belief is those professors were lying frauds in on a conspiracy, backed up by no evidence but your desire for it to be true, which sounds precisely like the same desperate kind of argument we would expect from a sleazy defense lawyer.

You have nothing to offer this case. There will be no epiphanies, no revelations, no disclosures or discoveries. You are simply wrong, now and forever.

The only future development with this case will be the ECHR giving their take on the interrogation and you subsequently extending the conspiracy net to Strasbourg.
 
That you would write this shows your willingness to fabricate. Good for you.

Fact is that RS and AK spent all morning raising the alarm before the postal police arrived. Even when the postals were invited in, by AK, the postals did not suspect a major crime had taken place.

Filomena would not have been there if not summoned by Knox. Knox and Sollecito were responsible for the victim being found, otherwise it could have been another 24 or 48 hours.

But it's good you demonstrated for all to see your agenda here.


As it is an established fact (so sue me!) that Knox was present during the murder at the scene of the crime (Marasca, Florence) then she could have rung the emergency services or banged on the door of a neighbour, immediately. A good 12-15 hours earlier, when the time of death could be established exactly and the crime scene sealed off and rendered untampered with by persons galloping around the scene, as they did.
 
As it is an established fact (so sue me!) that Knox was present during the murder at the scene of the crime (Marasca, Florence) then she could have rung the emergency services or banged on the door of a neighbour, immediately. A good 12-15 hours earlier, when the time of death could be established exactly and the crime scene sealed off and rendered untampered with by persons galloping around the scene, as they did.

Repeating this canard does not make it true. One again the following is what Marasca-Bruno wrote:

Nevertheless, even if attribution (of Knox rubbing blood from her hands) is certain, the trial element would not be
unequivocal as a demonstration of posthumous contact with that blood, as a likely
attempt to remove the most blatant traces of what had happened, perhaps to help
someone or deflect suspicion from herself, without this entailing her certain direct
involvement in the murder. Any further and more meaningful value would be, in fact,
resisted by the fact - which is decisive - that no trace leading to her was found at the
scene of the crime or on the victim’s body, so that - if all the above is accepted - her contact with the victim’s blood would have occurred after the crime and in another
part of the house.​
No one disputes that Knox was there alone after the crime. What she did following that was raise the alarm by informing Raffaele, then in turn calling Filomena, Raffalele called his Carabinieri sister... etc.
 
Last edited:
Kulman is not the editor.

I don't know about "the" editor" but she clearly was an editor:

" I wouldn't have been able to write this memoir without Linda Kulman. Somehow, with her Post-it Notes and questions, with her generosity, dedication ,and empathy, she turned my ramblings into writing, and taught me so much in the meantime."

Rather a nice dedication, i think.
 
I don't know about "the" editor" but she clearly was an editor:

" I wouldn't have been able to write this memoir without Linda Kulman. Somehow, with her Post-it Notes and questions, with her generosity, dedication ,and empathy, she turned my ramblings into writing, and taught me so much in the meantime."

Rather a nice dedication, i think.

This bizarre "controversy" - staged by the PGP - of whether Knox was really the author of her own memoir, or was Kulman, acknowledged by Knox in the book for her assistance, reminds me of the "controversy" - staged by the PGP - of whether Knox had really submitted an application to the ECHR as she had written in her blog.

The PGP has as its basic assumption and method - which it cannot alter - that everything about Knox or every claim by her must be denigrated or denied.

Just as Knox's application to ECHR was real, on time, and on 29 April 2016, communicated to Italy*, contrary to the misstatements of the PGP, Knox was the author of her memoir. Kulman, as stated by Knox, helped her organize the writing, and is thus an editor. Indeed, Kulman herself, on her website, claims to be a collaborator on Knox's book and on others.

There apparently is no way that the PGP can admit, based upon known facts or evidence, that Knox's statements (excepting those obtained under coercive interrogation) are credible.

*KNOX c. ITALIE 76577/13 Communicated Case 29/04/2016

Source: http://hudoc.echr.coe.int/eng#{%22docname%22:[%22\%22KNOX%20c.%20ITALIE\%22%22],%22documentcollectionid2%22:[%22GRANDCHAMBER%22,%22CHAMBER%22,%22DECISIONS%22,%22COMMUNICATEDCASES%22],%22itemid%22:[%22001-163098%22]}
 
Adversarial (us) versus inquisitorial (Latin countries and South Africa, strangely) is simply a description of the process.

It is the case in all modern justice systems of either type that Appeals courts, and the Supreme Court, are purely there to oversee that the law has been applied correctly.

Fact finding is 100% the remit of the trial court, and in the UK/USA formula a trial verdict by a jury of defendants peers is sacrosanct and cannot be changed except on a specif point of law, which usually has five subcategories. In italy, one of these subcategories and the most common point of appeal, is that of 'internal contradiction' in the MR. UK/USA verdict rarely have written reasons at all and successful applications for an appeal are relatively rare. In Italy every defendant has an automatic two appeals, one of which is the Supreme Court, if they wish. Catch is, the prosecution can also appeal.

So, in effect, should an appeal win re 'internal contradiction', all aan appeal/Supreme Court are remitted to do is send it back to a merits court for the facts to be reassessed as prescribed by the Appeal/Supreme Court as per the point of law in (potential) error.

Mignini is correct that Marasca erred in this matter.


After all these years of "analysing" this case, you're STILL unaware of the fact that since the mid-1990s Italy has used the adversarial system of criminal justice (though some reactionary types such as Mignini and many judges still seem to wish it was the inquisitorial system, and appear to act as such)?

Oh dear.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom