The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
If my aunt had balls he'd be my uncle.

Remember when Amanda was arrested and the police had her signed confession, and the murder weapon from her boyfriends kitchen with the victim's DNA on it, and they declared "Case Closed, the investigation phase is over."

And Rudy was chatting with his friend on Skype and was like "Yeah actually all of that is BS lol."

He seemed to have some inside information that an apparently ironclad case closed crime happened another way. Like, he wasn't impressed that an almost literal smoking gun, a bloody knife, was set to bring Knox down. He somehow anticipated that it would be thrown out as the murder weapon.

He must have psychic powers to look into the future and see Raff's dad bribing the local appellate council to install a crooked judge who would find two crooked professors to contest the DNA evidence in their report and eventually get appealed up to Rome with a new panel of more bent judges who finally ended the case.

Either that or he had a simple thought...well it probably wasn't the murder weapon... seeing as the murder weapon was my switchblade I dumped off Ponte Rio...

But never mind that, a recorded eyewitness unprompted candid confession is worth nothing in comparison to your own DNA being found in your own sink, so carry on :p
 
Sure. Because you said so.

The fact Linda Kulman is named as the author of Knox's pack of lies book, proves she is accredited with it and gets shared royalties.

Ghost writers are not normally named. A friend of mine in the know in the publishing world informs me Jeffrey Archer has a whole team of them.

Jeffery Archer gets the royalties.
 
The fact Linda Kulman is named as the author of Knox's pack of lies book, proves she is accredited with it and gets shared royalties.

Ghost writers are not normally named. A friend of mine in the know in the publishing world informs me Jeffrey Archer has a whole team of them.

Jeffery Archer gets the royalties.

Oh no not a ghostwriter! Finally a break in the case :rolleyes:
 
I don't have a google alert. I understand this is something the PIP has?

I think it is is important to challenge the kids false claims 'the police framed us' as it simply is not true,

I could not care less what some random woman from Seattle has to say, except when it embelishes the fake claim of being an exoneree being found innocent.

Fact is, I neither like or dislike this pair. It is their behaviour I despise.



1) Despising someone's behaviour is, de facto, disliking that person.

2) What exactly is it about Knox's/Sollecito's behaviour that you despise? (in your answer, please bear in mind that: a) Knox and Sollecito were (correctly) acquitted and exonerated by the highest court in Italy; b) there was/is zero credible, reliable evidence that Knox or Sollecito participated in the Kercher murder; c) it is, in fact, highly probable that neither Knox nor Sollecito participated in Kercher's murder; d) all of the known evidence is, in fact, entirely compatible with Guede acting alone (and there is solid, safe evidence to prove Guede's guilt beyond all reasonable doubt)).

Thanks in advance for your considered reply.
 
The fact Linda Kulman is named as the author of Knox's pack of lies book, proves she is accredited with it and gets shared royalties.

Ghost writers are not normally named. A friend of mine in the know in the publishing world informs me Jeffrey Archer has a whole team of them.

Jeffery Archer gets the royalties.


Hilariously, you've contradicted your own point. You're entirely correct that ghost writers are not named. The clue is in the word "ghost".

And you clearly have next to no idea about how large publishers choose to work with first-time authors writing autobiographies/memoirs who are somewhat outside their comfort zone (e.g, celebrities in non-writing fields, sports people, people falsely accused of serious criminal offences.....). It's in fact entirely normal (actually it's virtually a given) that publishers will provide an experienced writer to assist with structure, pacing, vocabulary, consistency and so on.
 
You don't think Linda Kulman would have any rights to the royalties if all she did was 'advise' Knox?

Come off it. Kulman wrote the whole thing and interpreted how Knox must have felt by imagining 'what-if it's true Mignini framed her'?


I'm sure you have reliable evidence to support your declarative statement that "Kulman wrote the whole thing".

Wait. What's that? You have absolutely ZERO evidence??

So I'm guessing that intellectual honesty will result in you actively withdrawing your claim?

After all, that's what intellectual honesty would require, isn't it Vixen.....?
 
You don't get Bar Standards, do you?

During a live trial all evidence relating to it must be shared by all parties, together with the judge.

Any barrister expecting to chat with the judge 'in chambers' or an independant expert witness wanting the private ear of one of the parties, is grossly negligent in their duty to the court.


Of course, you have evidence of what exactly was discussed in these (alleged) brief encounters between Conti/Vecchiotti and the defence teams? Because you're clearly claiming that what was discussed was privileged information related to the case. I'm assuming therefore that you have reliable evidence that this was what was discussed in these brief encounters (rather than, say, an exchange of pleasantries and/or a generalised chat about the anticipated length of the trial etc.....).

What's that? You have ZERO evidence of what actually was discussed in these (alleged) brief encounters between Conti/Vecchiotti and the defence teams??

Oh dear.
 
Heheh, wait until he his prison sentence is officially over (1919?) and he brings out his 'memoirs'.


Blimey, has Guede travelled back in time to the First World War era?

And what Guede does or doesn't say after he's released is totally irrelevant. Guede provably participated in Kercher's murder, and the evidence is wholly consistent with him acting alone.
 
Blimey, has Guede travelled back in time to the First World War era?

And what Guede does or doesn't say after he's released is totally irrelevant. Guede provably participated in Kercher's murder, and the evidence is wholly consistent with him acting alone.

Rudy Guede, Meredith Kercher's killer, is the best resource guilters have. Indeed the appeals court conviction in 2014 relied solely on Guede to provide motive for the wholley-invented motive/scenario which was supposed to have driven Knox.

Not a sex game, not pooh, but rent money. Yessirree Bob, we're lucky to have had Rudy to be such an impartial witness!!!!

Ultimately guilters love Rudy. He can lend an authoritative voice to the slander campaign aimed at two exonerated.
 
Last edited:
Maybe because we don't know Amanda's personal character. Or at least the vast majority of us don't.

I don't know if I would dislike or like Amanda. But if you conclude that you don't know Amanda other than what can be confirmed about Amanda I can't see how you can conclude that she is a bad person. There isn't a line of people in the Seattle area where she has lived all but 4 years of her life spouting off defaming remarks. In fact, the opposite is true. Person after person only have good things to say. Perhaps she is a closet bitch but if that were true how could I suggest something that is hidden?

The PGP has no interest in discussing the evidence as the evidence doesn't support their bias. They have made up their minds Amanda and Raffaele are sociopaths and all the facts wouldn't change that.

To this day, I wonder how Vixen, and the rest of the gang would react if Rudy admitted that he did it entirely on his own. (Not that I expect Rudy to do this. I don't.) That absolutely neither Amanda or Raffaele had anything to do with the murder. What would the PGP do. My guess, is that they wouldn't believe him.

He already did this, way back when he was on the run and thought he was talking to his friend in private. That's when he tells us Amanda had nothing to do with it and the description of the guy he claimed was there doesn't fit Raffaele, whom he doesn't even know. So yeah, they definitely would not accept it as the truth. My guess is they would claim Marriott made him an offer he couldn't refuse.
 
Heheh, wait until he his prison sentence is officially over (1919?) and he brings out his 'memoirs'.

You love to write fiction so it's no surprise you're excited at the opportunity to read more of it. Maybe he'll hire you to be his ghostwriter?
 
That's not true. The book was written whilst the process was still ongoing.
No, they had been found not guilty. They had no reason to believe that the Supreme Court would do something stupid.
But you can argue this point till you're blue in the face. It won't make a difference. It's over and Amanda and Raffaele are making a living commenting on other legal cases and you are posting here and not making a dime.
 
You don't think Linda Kulman would have any rights to the royalties if all she did was 'advise' Knox?

Come off it. Kulman wrote the whole thing and interpreted how Knox must have felt by imagining 'what-if it's true Mignini framed her'?

How do you know if she is making royalties and wasn't paid a flat fee? I didn't know that her financial arrangements with Harper Collins had been published. Care to present a cite? Or did you make this up as well?

I don't expect you to. It won't matter. You're making just another fallacious deduction. You don't even know if the original premise is true let alone the deduction. But this isn't a surprise to anyone since we've seen you do it thousands of times.
 
The fact Linda Kulman is named as the author of Knox's pack of lies book, proves she is accredited with it and gets shared royalties.

Ghost writers are not normally named. A friend of mine in the know in the publishing world informs me Jeffrey Archer has a whole team of them.

Jeffery Archer gets the royalties.

Where is she named the author? I'm looking at the book right now and the "About the Author" page is about Amanda. Actually, Linda Kulman isn't named anywhere in the book or it's jacket.
 
The fact Linda Kulman is named as the author of Knox's pack of lies book, proves she is accredited with it and gets shared royalties.

Ghost writers are not normally named. A friend of mine in the know in the publishing world informs me Jeffrey Archer has a whole team of them.

Jeffery Archer gets the royalties.

You simply do not know this. You have absolutely no knowledge of every writers financial arrangements. But that Linda was named eliminates her from being a ghost writer. She is a co-writer. Nobody questions that she was involved in writing the book only that NONE of US...you too, have a clue as to how much was written by Linda.

That's the difference between you and me Vixen. I don't mouth off pretending I know something I couldn't.
 
He already did this, way back when he was on the run and thought he was talking to his friend in private. That's when he tells us Amanda had nothing to do with it and the description of the guy he claimed was there doesn't fit Raffaele, whom he doesn't even know. So yeah, they definitely would not accept it as the truth. My guess is they would claim Marriott made him an offer he couldn't refuse.

True.
 
Where is she named the author? I'm looking at the book right now and the "About the Author" page is about Amanda. Actually, Linda Kulman isn't named anywhere in the book or it's jacket.

Thanks TC. I assumed that Vixen wouldn't make up something so easy to verify. I should know better. So, by Vixen's own words Linda probably isn't receiving royalties which makes the premise her deduction based upon false which in turn makes her deduction necessarily fallacious.

Way to go Vixen.
 
Last edited:
You simply do not know this. You have absolutely no knowledge of every writers financial arrangements. But that Linda was named eliminates her from being a ghost writer. She is a co-writer. Nobody questions that she was involved in writing the book only that NONE of US...you too, have a clue as to how much was written by Linda.

That's the difference between you and me Vixen. I don't mouth off pretending I know something I couldn't.

"Linda Kulman

I am a journalist, writer, editor, and the author, most recently, of Teaching Common Sense: The Grand Strategy Program at Yale University about one of Yale’s best-known and most sought-after courses. Based on several years of onsite reporting, archival research, interviews with students and faculty, and original survey data, Teaching Common Sense looks at “Studies in Grand Strategy,” a year-long, by-application leadership seminar. The course addresses some of higher education’s bedrock question, such as how is critical thinking taught and how will this generation learn to cope with uncertainty in a fast-changing world.

I have collaborated on seven nonfiction books, working successfully with a group of diverse, demanding personalities to tell their personal, and sometimes painful, stories. These include Amanda Knox’s New York Times bestselling memoir, Waiting to be Heard; Hillary Clinton’s Dear Socks, Dear Buddy: Kids’ Letters to the First Pets, written while she was First Lady; New York Governor Andrew Cuomo’s All Things Possible: Setbacks and Success in Politics and Life; George McGovern’s What It Means to Be a Democrat; George Foreman’s Guide to Life: How to Get Up Off the Canvas When Life Knocks You Down; and James Carville’s We’re Right, They’re Wrong. Each of these projects required me to become an expert on a nuanced topic, whether on the Italian legal system, the root causes of homelessness, heavyweight wrestling, the history of pets in the White House, or gun safety reform. ...."

Source: http://branford.yalecollege.yale.edu/linda-kulman

Collaborator: a person who works jointly on an activity or project; an associate.

Source: https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/collaborator
 
I don't have a google alert. I understand this is something the PIP has?

I think it is is important to challenge the kids false claims 'the police framed us' as it simply is not true,

I could not care less what some random woman from Seattle has to say, except when it embelishes the fake claim of being an exoneree being found innocent.

Fact is, I neither like or dislike this pair. It is their behaviour I despise.

There's a Google alert for us PIP? Darn! Why was I never informed of this? I'm sending off a letter of protest immediately to Gogerty-Marriott and cc'ing Bruce Fisher. Thanks for letting me know, Vix!

"The kids"? For someone who has a conniption fit when Amanda is referred to as a "kid" at the time of the murder, you do like to use the term yourself.

Citation please for your claim that Knox said the police "framed them". She has said they had tunnel vision, bias, and the investigation was incredibly incompetent...as did the Supreme Court... but she has never said she was "framed".

You "don't dislike the pair"? :eye-poppi The multitude of posts you have made denigrating both, but Knox especially, on a personal level very clearly show otherwise. Would you like me to quote some here?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom