The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
This one? The one that has the lie about Matteini-Chiari being the president of the criminal appeals court in it?
The one that the prosecution in Florence asked to be dismissed in May last year?

I still love to re-read that one, because it makes clear that for Mignini it's not about justice, but his very own "bella figura"... :(

Dismissed was it? ROTFLMAO! I noticed it also contained the lie that there was Knox's and Kercher's "mixed blood". My favorite however, was the assertion that the fact Curatolo had been a prosecution witness a few times before in other cases was evidence of his credibility! :jaw-dropp

Mignini files lawsuits more often than Trump lies. Well....maybe not quite as often as that would be almost impossible.
 
Dismissed was it? ROTFLMAO! I noticed it also contained the lie that there was Knox's and Kercher's "mixed blood". My favorite however, was the assertion that the fact Curatolo had been a prosecution witness a few times before in other cases was evidence of his credibility! :jaw-dropp

Mignini files lawsuits more often than Trump lies. Well....maybe not quite as often as that would be almost impossible.

What is clear from reading the English translation of Mignini's own "Submission of Criminal Complaint," is that the remaining guilters are simply, unquestioningly singing off of Mignini's songsheet. For instance, the only source I've seen (if there are others I hope someone would provide the link) that the 2015 ISC acquittals should not have used the second paragraph of Section 530 to accomplish it, is in this submission. Oh, and then there's Mignini's assertion of "mixed blood" as Stacyhs has pointed out. Hoots!

The continual trashing of Knox on this thread is, functionally, from surrogates of Giuliano Mignini. And he lost.

And once again, here is yet another newspiece, this one Umbria24 from May 2016 which makes mention that the Supreme Court in 2015 had definitively acquitted the pair. Definitively. Acquitted.

Sheesh.
 
Last edited:
I find it interesting, and telling, that PIP tend to discuss the evidence rather than Knox's personal character whereas PGP revel in attacking her on a personal level. We have seen this excessive need to demonize and disparage Knox at every opportunity, even going so far as to claim knowledge of what she feels and thinks on this very site. I have to wonder just what psychological need manifests itself in this online spewing of venom and hatred toward Knox? That there is a profound, disturbing, and unbalanced psychology at play here, there is no doubt.
 
I find it interesting, and telling, that PIP tend to discuss the evidence rather than Knox's personal character whereas PGP revel in attacking her on a personal level. We have seen this excessive need to demonize and disparage Knox at every opportunity, even going so far as to claim knowledge of what she feels and thinks on this very site. I have to wonder just what psychological need manifests itself in this online spewing of venom and hatred toward Knox? That there is a profound, disturbing, and unbalanced psychology at play here, there is no doubt.

Maybe because we don't know Amanda's personal character. Or at least the vast majority of us don't.

I don't know if I would dislike or like Amanda. But if you conclude that you don't know Amanda other than what can be confirmed about Amanda I can't see how you can conclude that she is a bad person. There isn't a line of people in the Seattle area where she has lived all but 4 years of her life spouting off defaming remarks. In fact, the opposite is true. Person after person only have good things to say. Perhaps she is a closet bitch but if that were true how could I suggest something that is hidden?

The PGP has no interest in discussing the evidence as the evidence doesn't support their bias. They have made up their minds Amanda and Raffaele are sociopaths and all the facts wouldn't change that.

To this day, I wonder how Vixen, and the rest of the gang would react if Rudy admitted that he did it entirely on his own. (Not that I expect Rudy to do this. I don't.) That absolutely neither Amanda or Raffaele had anything to do with the murder. What would the PGP do. My guess, is that they wouldn't believe him.
 
Maybe because we don't know Amanda's personal character. Or at least the vast majority of us don't.

I don't know if I would dislike or like Amanda. But if you conclude that you don't know Amanda other than what can be confirmed about Amanda I can't see how you can conclude that she is a bad person. There isn't a line of people in the Seattle area where she has lived all but 4 years of her life spouting off defaming remarks. In fact, the opposite is true. Person after person only have good things to say. Perhaps she is a closet bitch but if that were true how could I suggest something that is hidden?

The PGP has no interest in discussing the evidence as the evidence doesn't support their bias. They have made up their minds Amanda and Raffaele are sociopaths and all the facts wouldn't change that.

To this day, I wonder how Vixen, and the rest of the gang would react if Rudy admitted that he did it entirely on his own. (Not that I expect Rudy to do this. I don't.) That absolutely neither Amanda or Raffaele had anything to do with the murder. What would the PGP do. My guess, is that they wouldn't believe him.

I agree; they wouldn't. I don't think if a video tape emerged showing Guede climbing in through Filomena's window that they'd believe it. It would mean they'd have to admit they were wrong...and that is not their strong point.
 
How can a post be obsessed?

You're on to something. That should be "posts", plural. The continual citationless claims banged out by the dozen demonstrate a bizarre obsession. The advice upthread is sound, delete the term "Amanda Knox" from your google alerts "and stop worrying about what some random woman from Seattle has to say", and quit with the creepy use of the familiar term for the victim of this now decade-old, albeit still horrible crime.

Quit obsessively accusing someone of a crime they did not commit.

The creepy references to Knox actually creates her noteworthiness, the very thing you say she does not deserve. So quit with the multiple, creepy references and the whole thing will disappear.

ETA - you barely ever mention Rudy Guede and he's now virtually forgotten. See how it works?


I don't have a google alert. I understand this is something the PIP has?

I think it is is important to challenge the kids false claims 'the police framed us' as it simply is not true,

I could not care less what some random woman from Seattle has to say, except when it embelishes the fake claim of being an exoneree being found innocent.

Fact is, I neither like or dislike this pair. It is their behaviour I despise.
 
As has been pointed out. The book was released after Amanda was acquitted and exonerated. And again, you only know that Amanda had help writing the book. Not that it was ghost written. Amanda is as innocent of murder and a sex crime as you are.
So? Some of our lives are thrust upon us.

What message is that? That 2 people who were wrongfully incarcerated and ground up by the legal system might have a perspective worth hearing?

I think it is a great message and am glad some feel sick by it. I love that it bothers the disgusting obscene morons who feel the need to continue to post their vile lies on the Internet. I love that Amanda and Raffaele are paid for their opinions by the LA Times, Salon, the New York Times etc while the unpaid sickos whine on social media.

I wrote many posts that Amanda and Raffaele had no choice but to do this. People were not going to leave them alone so they might as well use their fame to help others and make a living from it. You have only yourself to blame. If it wasn't the interest from fangirls like yourself that click on every article this wouldn't have happened.


That's not true. The book was written whilst the process was still ongoing.


So you like fake news. Welcome to the world of the doped-up masses.
 
And another post which you have absolutely zero evidence for. No question Amanda had help writing the book never having penned one.

But you have absolutely no idea whatsoever how much was written by Linda and how much was written by Amanda. It only fits your sick and twisted narrative that Amanda couldn't have wrote it.

Here's a riddle for you. What do you call someone who doesn't have clue about what is true and what is false, but nevertheless says it anyway?


President

You are Donald Trump :confused:
 
Once again you resort to telling us things you cannot possibly know. But that's pretty much par for the course now.

"The only explanation Knox can offer for her prosecution"? Really? You really wrote that? Knox has given many reasons as to why she was prosecuted: tunnel vision by the police and prosecution, media sensationalism,
pressure to find and arrest the killer, suspect-centered investigation, etc. I suggest you read the Supreme Court's criticism again as they saw many of the same reasons.

Please stop falsely claiming calunnia equals obstruction of justice in the US. It does not. There is NO equivalent to Italy's calunnia in the US. The closest equivalent is defamation (slander and libel). We've been over this before and you could never provide any evidence of your claim so please, just stop.

Calumny:
•a false and malicious statement meant to hurt someone's reputation
• the uttering of such a statement; slander

(Webster Legal Law Dictionary)

Lying/making false statements can ONLY be prosecuted as obstruction in the US if it is done UNDER OATH. Amanda was never under oath.


http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/recycled/2007/03/how_many_ways_can_you_say_lie.html



It is a class example of confirmation bias when someone continues to make a claim that has been repeatedly proved false but cannot provide any evidence of that claim being true.

Stop talking rubbish. Slander and libel are merely civil matters. Obstruction of justice includes exactly what Amanda was convicted of, aiming to pervert the course of [FBI] investigators and is a federal felony which attracts on average five year's jail in most US states.
 
Last edited:
I don't have a google alert. I understand this is something the PIP has?

I think it is is important to challenge the kids false claims 'the police framed us' as it simply is not true,

I could not care less what some random woman from Seattle has to say, except when it embelishes the fake claim of being an exoneree being found innocent.

Fact is, I neither like or dislike this pair. It is their behaviour I despise.

There's nothing in any of their behavior since arrested that is inconsistent with their own claims of being innocent. Your interpretation of their behavior is something entirely predicated on your own personal opinion about what you believe happened in the cottage on the evening of the 1st. It is something you project onto them, not something that is objectively projected by them.

So when Amanda Knox says something like "I am innocent, the police misbehaved." It is neither new, nor interesting, nor helpful that you remind us "I believe she is lying and those statements are false." I think we all get that.
 
This thread is treated to the factors which go into wrongful convictions. One is making claims which have not been demonstrated.

Another is continual character assassination, which is justified by assuming the conclusion to begin with.

You need to first demonstrate the conviction was 'wrongful'. The Supreme Court never said that.
 
Heheh, wait until he his prison sentence is officially over (1919?) and he brings out his 'memoirs'.

I'm available to ghostwrite them. I already thought of the perfect ending...

"So next time, when I'm invited into somebody's home, I definitely will remember to flush."
 
Last edited:
Regarding Maori's "wining and dining" (according to Vixen) of Conti and Vecchiotti from Mignini's deposition:



So, they were being "wined and dined" standing in front of the courthouse and in a bar in full public view and where anyone nearby could have heard what was being said. This is absolute evidence of collusion in the PGP version of reality. Sheesh.

You don't get Bar Standards, do you?

During a live trial all evidence relating to it must be shared by all parties, together with the judge.

Any barrister expecting to chat with the judge 'in chambers' or an independant expert witness wanting the private ear of one of the parties, is grossly negligent in their duty to the court.
 
Of course this is true. Linda says that Amanda wrote the book and she did very little. But who's to say?

I KNOW that I don't know. What makes Vixen so sure of something she has ABSOLUTELY no way of knowing? Did Linda call her personally and tell her Amanda wrote none of it? Somehow, I doubt it.

But guess what Vixen? Amanda has written countless columns and more and more of them have been picked up by major publications. Seems as if she is making a living as a writer.

You don't think Linda Kulman would have any rights to the royalties if all she did was 'advise' Knox?

Come off it. Kulman wrote the whole thing and interpreted how Knox must have felt by imagining 'what-if it's true Mignini framed her'?
 
You don't think Linda Kulman would have any rights to the royalties if all she did was 'advise' Knox?

Come off it. Kulman wrote the whole thing and interpreted how Knox must have felt by imagining 'what-if it's true Mignini framed her'?

Sure. Because you said so.
 
Dismissed was it? ROTFLMAO! I noticed it also contained the lie that there was Knox's and Kercher's "mixed blood". My favorite however, was the assertion that the fact Curatolo had been a prosecution witness a few times before in other cases was evidence of his credibility! :jaw-dropp

Mignini files lawsuits more often than Trump lies. Well....maybe not quite as often as that would be almost impossible.

Yes, in mafia-ridden Italy, libelling the prosecutor, sadly is common practice.

Perhaps now you understand why Raff's book was a seen as a criminal attempt to do exactly that.

(Although I doubt it.)
 
Yes, in mafia-ridden Italy, libelling the prosecutor, sadly is common practice.

Perhaps now you understand why Raff's book was a seen as a criminal attempt to do exactly that.

(Although I doubt it.)

If Raff's family can make a phone call to Rome and have a sex murder conviction go away I think he can handle an idiot blowhard like Mignini. It will be taken care of ;)
 
Maybe because we don't know Amanda's personal character. Or at least the vast majority of us don't.

I don't know if I would dislike or like Amanda. But if you conclude that you don't know Amanda other than what can be confirmed about Amanda I can't see how you can conclude that she is a bad person. There isn't a line of people in the Seattle area where she has lived all but 4 years of her life spouting off defaming remarks. In fact, the opposite is true. Person after person only have good things to say. Perhaps she is a closet bitch but if that were true how could I suggest something that is hidden?

The PGP has no interest in discussing the evidence as the evidence doesn't support their bias. They have made up their minds Amanda and Raffaele are sociopaths and all the facts wouldn't change that.

To this day, I wonder how Vixen, and the rest of the gang would react if Rudy admitted that he did it entirely on his own. (Not that I expect Rudy to do this. I don't.) That absolutely neither Amanda or Raffaele had anything to do with the murder. What would the PGP do. My guess, is that they wouldn't believe him.

If my aunt had balls he'd be my uncle.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom