The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
For heavens' sake, Vixen, your urge to spread bile about Amanda Knox clouds your postings. It is clear you have not followed the text-suicide case in Massachusetts.

Do you know who agrees with Knox that this might be a case of an "unlawful conviction"? Wait for it, and I can put it in large red letters if you need it presented that way.....

The convicting judge. Read that again, Vixen, "the convicting judge".

In a rare judicial move, the convicting judge (did I mention that he'd been the convicting judge!?) granted a stay on the implementation of the 2 1/2 year sentence because he considered it reasonable that.....

..... his own conviction of the woman could be reasonably heard by an appellate court on 1st Amendment grounds. Obviously the convicting (did I mention he'd been the convicting?) judge acknowledged that the appeal grounds were so reasonable that the woman could have served the full term of her sentence before the appeals process had played out. So in a rare move he granted the defence motion for a stay on sentence.

Of course, the convicting judge would disagree with Amanda Knox's LATimes OpEd. Of course he would. But he would also agree that it was a reasonable opinion to hold, that down the road his decision might be rendered "unlawful", and reversed.

Unfortunately your venom aimed at some random Seattleite who (through her own experience) has an opinion, blinds you to say silly things. You claim to know the inner thoughts and motives of people. You claim to know that Knox's sig-oth actually penned the LATimes OpEd, with nothing other than your own vindictiveness as "proof".

Do you believe that you are converting reasonable people to your view of things by doing this?

AIUI She is appealing under Amendment 1: freedom of speech.

I might be missing something, but how is urging someone who trusts you and hangs onto your every word, to top themselves, 'freedom of speech'?

It's telling that Knox always takes the side of the criminal with faux sympathies for their victims.
 
Ummmm

Well, the matter of suicide (and whether it's morally correct, or anti-Christian, or whatever) was not the matter at hand. The matter at hand was the persuasion of a third party for a person to kill himself, and whether THAT was morally correct (or anti-Christian, or whatever). So at a stroke, this renders what you've written above totally moot and irrelevant anyhow.

So, with that in mind, pray tell us again why you think Knox is not "authorised" to comment on the moral and legal issues around one person urging another person to kill himself. And this time, please stick to the matter at hand. Thanks in advance.

Her ghostwritten book was only written by dint of her being a convicted murderer/sex criminal ATT as an attempt to influence public opinion and the courts.

IOW her claim to fame is not through any talent, but because of the vicious slaying of her roommate, a lovely popular intelligent young woman with her life ahead of her.

It is sickening that the media now see Amanda and Raff as expert crime commentators. It sends the wrong message.
 
Her ghostwritten book was only written by dint of her being a convicted murderer/sex criminal ATT as an attempt to influence public opinion and the courts.

It was written after she was acquitted. It influenced nothing.

IOW her claim to fame is not through any talent, but because of the vicious slaying of her roommate, a lovely popular intelligent young woman with her life ahead of her.

Her claim to fame is she happened to live in a house where a burglar broke in and slaughtered the woman that happened to be home at the time and used her body as his own personal sex toy and dug through per purse for cash before hitting up his favorite night club that lead to an incompetent investigation where a couple fat oafs went "no human being would climb in through a window so it must have been the ditsy coed."

It is sickening that the media now see Amanda and Raff as expert crime commentators. It sends the wrong message.

Who cares. Take Amanda Knox off your google alert and stop worrying about what some random woman from Seattle has to say. Christ.
 
Incorrect: Linda Kuhlman ghostwrote the book by the UW 'graduate'.

You have absolutely no evidence of that. Yes. Linda assisted in writing the book. How much assistance is not known. Not known by me. Not known by you. So why do you insist that Amanda did not write the book? Oh, I forgot for a moment. A sick obsession to demonize Amanda Knox.
 
You have absolutely no evidence of that. Yes. Linda assisted in writing the book. How much assistance is not known. Not known by me. Not known by you. So why do you insist that Amanda did not write the book? Oh, I forgot for a moment. A sick obsession to demonize Amanda Knox.

It is ghostwritten in the same way Raff's book is ghostwritten by Andrew Gumbel. (You note both have been sued for defamation, not just Raff.)


Getting a third party to write it enabled the pair to put a human spin into their tale as Kulman and Gumbel set their imaginations to work on how they would feel if 'falsely charged' and 'wrongfully convicted'. As normal people no doubt they knew the correct emotions to describe.

It's interesting, the only explanation Knox can offer for her prosecution, and permanent conviction for Calunnia (=obstruction of justice US equivalent), is that the prosecutor Mignini has a personal interest in her.

ROFLMAO.
 
It is ghostwritten in the same way Raff's book is ghostwritten by Andrew Gumbel. (You note both have been sued for defamation, not just Raff.)


Getting a third party to write it enabled the pair to put a human spin into their tale as Kulman and Gumbel set their imaginations to work on how they would feel if 'falsely charged' and 'wrongfully convicted'. As normal people no doubt they knew the correct emotions to describe.

It's interesting, the only explanation Knox can offer for her prosecution, and permanent conviction for Calunnia (=obstruction of justice US equivalent), is that the prosecutor Mignini has a personal interest in her.

ROFLMAO.

How can a post be obsessed?

You're on to something. That should be "posts", plural. The continual citationless claims banged out by the dozen demonstrate a bizarre obsession. The advice upthread is sound, delete the term "Amanda Knox" from your google alerts "and stop worrying about what some random woman from Seattle has to say", and quit with the creepy use of the familiar term for the victim of this now decade-old, albeit still horrible crime.

Quit obsessively accusing someone of a crime they did not commit.

The creepy references to Knox actually creates her noteworthiness, the very thing you say she does not deserve. So quit with the multiple, creepy references and the whole thing will disappear.

ETA - you barely ever mention Rudy Guede and he's now virtually forgotten. See how it works?
 
Last edited:
Her ghostwritten book was only written by dint of her being a convicted murderer/sex criminal ATT as an attempt to influence public opinion and the courts.
As has been pointed out. The book was released after Amanda was acquitted and exonerated. And again, you only know that Amanda had help writing the book. Not that it was ghost written. Amanda is as innocent of murder and a sex crime as you are.
IOW her claim to fame is not through any talent, but because of the vicious slaying of her roommate, a lovely popular intelligent young woman with her life ahead of her.
So? Some of our lives are thrust upon us.

It is sickening that the media now see Amanda and Raff as expert crime commentators. It sends the wrong message.
What message is that? That 2 people who were wrongfully incarcerated and ground up by the legal system might have a perspective worth hearing?

I think it is a great message and am glad some feel sick by it. I love that it bothers the disgusting obscene morons who feel the need to continue to post their vile lies on the Internet. I love that Amanda and Raffaele are paid for their opinions by the LA Times, Salon, the New York Times etc while the unpaid sickos whine on social media.

I wrote many posts that Amanda and Raffaele had no choice but to do this. People were not going to leave them alone so they might as well use their fame to help others and make a living from it. You have only yourself to blame. If it wasn't the interest from fangirls like yourself that click on every article this wouldn't have happened.
 
I wrote many posts that Amanda and Raffaele had no choice but to do this. People were not going to leave them alone so they might as well use their fame to help others and make a living from it. You have only yourself to blame. If it wasn't the interest from fangirls like yourself that click on every article this wouldn't have happened.

Proof is how Rudy Guede - the killer - has fallen off social media radar.
 
It is ghostwritten in the same way Raff's book is ghostwritten by Andrew Gumbel. (You note both have been sued for defamation, not just Raff.)

Getting a third party to write it enabled the pair to put a human spin into their tale as Kulman and Gumbel set their imaginations to work on how they would feel if 'falsely charged' and 'wrongfully convicted'. As normal people no doubt they knew the correct emotions to describe.

It's interesting, the only explanation Knox can offer for her prosecution, and permanent conviction for Calunnia (=obstruction of justice US equivalent), is that the prosecutor Mignini has a personal interest in her.

ROFLMAO.
And another post which you have absolutely zero evidence for. No question Amanda had help writing the book never having penned one.

But you have absolutely no idea whatsoever how much was written by Linda and how much was written by Amanda. It only fits your sick and twisted narrative that Amanda couldn't have wrote it.

Here's a riddle for you. What do you call someone who doesn't have clue about what is true and what is false, but nevertheless says it anyway?




President
 
You have absolutely no evidence of that. Yes. Linda assisted in writing the book. How much assistance is not known. Not known by me. Not known by you. So why do you insist that Amanda did not write the book? Oh, I forgot for a moment. A sick obsession to demonize Amanda Knox.
Harper Collins would have been nuts NOT to assign someone to a first time author. My guess - only a guess - is that this Linda helped in layout and pacing, and offered advice on whether or not any one episode contributed to the larger narrative.

What we're witnessing on this thread are the elements of what wrongful convictions are. One of them is the incessant trash-talking towards the accused, regardless of what the courts eventually found.

Ironically the Italian Supreme Court included this element in its 2015 reasons for annulling the lower court conviction.

But no mistake - we're witnessing in real time with Vixen's posts the softening up of the narrative through trashing the accused at every turn.

Even to the point of calling that long list of experts who eventually supported the defence case "morons". At some point trash talk is all they have....

...... esp. when they cannot name one forensic-DNA expert who's ever supported the prosecution's DNA claims.

So it's to Plan B. Trash talk.
 
That's just it: they are bloody morons who want to impose their own personal opinions over those as statuted by legislation.

PGP posters who have difficulty understanding even the simplest concepts and display gross stupidity in their posts have the cheek to call people morons. Yet another example hypocrisy by PGP.
 
Why do I not find it surprising that you provide a link that you think supports your claim when, in fact, it doesn't?

Please quote where Dempsey says or even implies that

1) Vecchiotti even commissioned a DVD for the defence eyes' only

or that Vecchiotti

2) was almost arrested by the carabonieri carabinieri.
Hint: she doesn't.

"She appealed to Hellmann, the judge in the relevant case, and even he ordered her to make a copy for the court and for the prosecution, " is a misleading spin on what Dempsey actually wrote. Vecchiotti didn't "appeal" to Hellmann; she called him to find out if she should or could give the cops a copy as they had no warrant. What the police were attempting was illegal as they tried to seize property they had no legal right to. Your use of "even he ordered her to make a copy implies that a copy had already been ordered made for the police and Vecchiotti had not complied. That is false. Hellmann ordered a copy made because the prosecution requested it.



You have failed to provide any evidence that the DVD was ever made "for the defense's eyes only" or that the defense had even seen the DVD before it was played by Vecchiotti in court the previous day...when everyone else saw it. Your claim of collusion is thereby totally unsupported by any evidence.

Perhaps if you spent less time calling people, including highly respected experts, "morons", claiming that Knox had little to do with the writing of her book when you have no idea whatsoever how much Knox actually wrote, and penning incessant personal attacks on Knox....perhaps....just perhaps....you could address the issues I presented above.
 
Perhaps if you spent less time calling people, including highly respected experts, "morons", claiming that Knox had little to do with the writing of her book when you have no idea whatsoever how much Knox actually wrote, and penning incessant personal attacks on Knox....perhaps....just perhaps....you could address the issues I presented above.
I've been asking her to provide the name of a forensic-DNA expert who she doesn't regard as a moron, to no avail. Perhaps the incessant name-calling is a way of avoiding the issue.

One correction is that she has offered two people in place of this - one expert, an Italian professor with credentials who testified (obstensively to buttress the prosecution case) that Stefanoni had NOT followed international protocols regarding multiple amplifications..... and the other an astrologer.

Then she said that i.d.'ing the guy as an astrologer was an ad hominem!
 
It is ghostwritten in the same way Raff's book is ghostwritten by Andrew Gumbel. (You note both have been sued for defamation, not just Raff.)


Getting a third party to write it enabled the pair to put a human spin into their tale as Kulman and Gumbel set their imaginations to work on how they would feel if 'falsely charged' and 'wrongfully convicted'. As normal people no doubt they knew the correct emotions to describe.

It's interesting, the only explanation Knox can offer for her prosecution, and permanent conviction for Calunnia (=obstruction of justice US equivalent), is that the prosecutor Mignini has a personal interest in her.

ROFLMAO.

Once again you resort to telling us things you cannot possibly know. But that's pretty much par for the course now.

"The only explanation Knox can offer for her prosecution"? Really? You really wrote that? Knox has given many reasons as to why she was prosecuted: tunnel vision by the police and prosecution, media sensationalism,
pressure to find and arrest the killer, suspect-centered investigation, etc. I suggest you read the Supreme Court's criticism again as they saw many of the same reasons.

Please stop falsely claiming calunnia equals obstruction of justice in the US. It does not. There is NO equivalent to Italy's calunnia in the US. The closest equivalent is defamation (slander and libel). We've been over this before and you could never provide any evidence of your claim so please, just stop.

Calumny:
•a false and malicious statement meant to hurt someone's reputation
• the uttering of such a statement; slander

(Webster Legal Law Dictionary)

Lying/making false statements can ONLY be prosecuted as obstruction in the US if it is done UNDER OATH. Amanda was never under oath.

What about obstruction of justice? You're guilty of obstruction if you do anything that hampers an ongoing case—destroying documents, intimidating witnesses, or lying under oath, for example. (Some courts have ruled that lying under oath is not sufficient for conviction on its own, though.) As with the other charges, prosecutors must show that an act of obstruction has significant bearing on the proceeding. According to the Supreme Court, it must have the "natural and probable effect" of interfering with the case.
http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/recycled/2007/03/how_many_ways_can_you_say_lie.html



It is a class example of confirmation bias when someone continues to make a claim that has been repeatedly proved false but cannot provide any evidence of that claim being true.
 
Last edited:
It is a class example of confirmation bias when someone continues to make a claim that has been repeatedly proved false but cannot provide any evidence of that claim being true.

This thread is treated to the factors which go into wrongful convictions. One is making claims which have not been demonstrated.

Another is continual character assassination, which is justified by assuming the conclusion to begin with.
 
Regarding Maori's "wining and dining" (according to Vixen) of Conti and Vecchiotti from Mignini's deposition:

..had been seen by Dr MIGNINI (and, according to what has
been said to him, also by the biologist at Scientific Police
headquarters Dr Patrizia Stefanoni), to be having a long
conversation and in a “private” manner, with the defence
lawyers of the accused, in particular with Advocate Maori,
before the hearing in which the experts were to be examined
and cross-examined had started. This had happened in
particular on two occasions, both in Piazza Matteotti, in front
of the law courts building, one time in front of the main
entrance and a second time, further back, in the direction of
Via Oberdan, while Dr Stefanoni and Dr Comodi had seen them
together, amongst the various defence lawyers for the accused,
in a bar..

So, they were being "wined and dined" standing in front of the courthouse and in a bar in full public view and where anyone nearby could have heard what was being said. This is absolute evidence of collusion in the PGP version of reality. Sheesh.
 
Harper Collins would have been nuts NOT to assign someone to a first time author. My guess - only a guess - is that this Linda helped in layout and pacing, and offered advice on whether or not any one episode contributed to the larger narrative.
Of course this is true. Linda says that Amanda wrote the book and she did very little. But who's to say?

I KNOW that I don't know. What makes Vixen so sure of something she has ABSOLUTELY no way of knowing? Did Linda call her personally and tell her Amanda wrote none of it? Somehow, I doubt it.

But guess what Vixen? Amanda has written countless columns and more and more of them have been picked up by major publications. Seems as if she is making a living as a writer.
 
Oh, my! I've found the smoking gun regarding Maori colluding with the (not so) independent forensics experts! A frequent contributor to TJMK, whose credibility is unassailable, gave this as evidence citing PMF as the source:
1.Barbie Nadeau in Angel Face:
'Concern that the independent experts weren’t so independent after all spread quickly after several journalists saw Vecchiotti with Raffaele’s lawyer Luca Maori in the courthouse halls and coffee bars of Perugia. Curious, too, was the fact that the Vecchiotti-Conti report cited more American forensic standards than Italian ones, and that many of these had also been quoted by the Friends of Amanda.'


The curious thing is, when I search for this quote, including several short phrases from it, in Nadeau's book via Amazon's "Look inside" feature, nothing comes up except for "0 results". Nothing.

Even in this alleged (but unfound) quote from Nadeau's book, journalists were hardly seeing Maori "wining and dining" Conti and Vecchiotti.

It's in the updated post-Hellmann edition with the "Sex, Murder and the inside Story of Amanda Knox" (instead of the "The True Story of Student Killer Amanda Knox") subtitle at kindle position 2211.
 
Do read the deposition filed against Raff's attorney Maori.
[...]

This one? The one that has the lie about Matteini-Chiari being the president of the criminal appeals court in it?
The one that the prosecution in Florence asked to be dismissed in May last year?
Chiesta l’archiviazione La querela per diffamazione, firmata dal sostituto procuratore generale Mignini e da due poliziotte che quando prestavano servizio alla squadra mobile hanno svolto indagini sull’omicidio di Meredith, ha ricevuto una richiesta d’archiviazione da parte del pm di Firenze contro la quale è stata avanzata opposizione.
I still love to re-read that one, because it makes clear that for Mignini it's not about justice, but his very own "bella figura"... :(
 
It's in the updated post-Hellmann edition with the "Sex, Murder and the inside Story of Amanda Knox" (instead of the "The True Story of Student Killer Amanda Knox") subtitle at kindle position 2211.

Ah. Thank you, Methos. Poor Barbie having to retitle her book, removing "True" and "Student Killer Amanda Knox".:D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom