The minimalist Christian

Hokulele - I think you missed my point on that one. (And possibly the above statement too. :) )


Whoops, I did. On a reread, I finally figured it out. Sorry! :o

(I need more tea, it is too early for subtlety.)

Yes - everyone points that out - sorry - it's just how it comes out that way when I type. Since it bugs so many I'll try to stop it. I capitilize when a general word "atheists" is in regards to a specific group "Atheists" here on this forum. It might be breaking some grammer rules, but it visually works to emphasize who I'm talking about.


No worries, I wasn't sure if it was a mistake, or not knowing how the word is spelled. So, for this specific group of yours called "Atheists", what is the minimum criteria for belonging to that group? :p
 
I'm willing to bet that there are some self-proclaimed Buddhists who data-fit their actions to rationalize that they are following the eight-fold path, much the way there are some self-proclaimed Christians who data-fit their actions to rationalize that they are following the teachings of Jesus.

I remember going to AA meetings with my Dad (who led a lot of the meetings) and there was occasionally one of those fervent types who was all full of newly-sobered righteousness. Quite often they knocked out the first eight of the twelve steps in one day.
 
This is exactly where I didn't want to go, but....

Actually, no, it's not. Buddha said (supposedly):

“Believe nothing, no matter where you read it, or who said it, no matter if I have said it, unless it agrees with your own reason and your own common sense.”

You're missing the point I made. In order to even consider anything (including the above quote) you have to believe something else before hand about him. It's the same, by the way, with any person - not just religious leaders. If you believe Buddha is a liar and still want to try follow his teachings including the above quote then you'll have an awfully interesting time with it. :)

From my understanding, and I am not a Buddhist so I only know what I have read, the most important component of Buddhism is the _practice_, not the belief. You don't have to believe anything about Buddhism to test the practice of Buddhism to see if it "works", however one chooses to define this.

The practice of what? The beliefs put in action?


The question is not about judging, the question is about the criteria for being a Christian. If the criterion is simply a belief, then yes, I agree one could never know what someone actually believes. My question is if it is universally agreed that all that is required is belief. That has been my understanding, I am trying to confirm this.

There is no "simply". Belief is the beginning.

I understand. The question is whether the belief is all that is minimally required. It seems that it is.

Then you've got your answer. Good luck with your journey.
 
(I need more tea, it is too early for subtlety.)

And I need less Mt. Dew! It's affecting my typing.


No worries, I wasn't sure if it was a mistake, or not knowing how the word is spelled.

Actually until a month ago I didn't know how to spell it. I learned spelling phonetically so I've got lots of strange spellings. They often tend to agree with British spellings though. :)

So, for this specific group of yours called "Atheists", what is the minimum criteria for belonging to that group? :p

There doesn't seem to be a consensus amongst you - I'm not even going there. Just tell an athiests that they're really agnostics and see what happens. :boxedin:
 
You see, this is a sticking point for me, and I suspect, many atheists. I simply cannot get the knack of believing something I don't believe. How do you turn off the "I don't believe" parts of your brain in order to do this?

What don't I believe? Or rather what do I believe that I don't believe?
 
You're missing the point I made. In order to even consider anything (including the above quote) you have to believe something else before hand about him. It's the same, by the way, with any person - not just religious leaders. If you believe Buddha is a liar and still want to try follow his teachings including the above quote then you'll have an awfully interesting time with it. :)

No, I see your point, I just don't think its correct. One can reasonably say "I don't think this is going to work", or "I don't think Buddha knew what he was talking about", and still follow the eight fold path to prove it to oneself one way or the other. There is no prerequisite that you actually think its going to work. In fact, you can think its NOT going to work, the practice of the actions is what is required, not any prior belief about their efficacy.

Of course, if one followed the path, found that it did not work for them, and then CONTINUED to follow it, that would be a conflict. But there is no conflict to try something you doubt to see if you're right.

The practice of what? The beliefs put in action?

Again, it is not about beliefs. As I understand it, the practice of following the eight fold path is irrelevant to whether one actually thinks it is a worthwhile path in the first place. I don't see how it is inconsistent for someone to have serious doubts about whether the practice is correct or will work, but having an open mind and trying it for themselves to see if it does.

Of course, one has to know what the eight fold path IS, but that doesn't mean one has to believe it is CORRECT to try it. See my point?
 
One can reasonably say "I don't think this is going to work",

a belief

or "I don't think Buddha knew what he was talking about",

a belief

In fact, you can think its NOT going to work,

a belief

Of course, one has to know what the eight fold path IS, but that doesn't mean one has to believe it is CORRECT to try it. See my point?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noble_Eightfold_Path

If you have time to spend on spiritual things you think are not correct, then I'm envious of you having that much time.
 
Last edited:
I don't even have to be an Empress, I just need to wander down to Town Hall, fill in some rather minor paperwork, and I will be as Empress Josephiney as I wish. Transferring the bank accounts would be more tedious than changing my reality. This demonstrates the challenges of self-labeling.
There's still an objective standard. If you have your name changed legally to Empress Josephine, then you are Empress Josephine. Hell, I'll go further. If you convince enough people to call you Empress Josephine, then you are Empress Josephine, or at least that is your name. I will accept "the name I am known by" as objective evidence of its really being your name, barring any detected motive for deceit, of course. All you've done is switched standards.

So what is the standard by which we should measure one's Christianhood? There simply isn't one. Since the question of whether one is really a Christian is only a concern if there is a God separating the wheat from the chaff, there is no way to determine who really is one lacking a divine edict.

In the absence of a Christian god, why not use local authorities? I am sure there are dictates from various popes and whatever other denominations use as figureheads that would define "Christian".
Yes, and there are various figureheads who would define each other right out of the group. In such cases, whom should we believe? What standard should their conflicts of labelling be judged against? Again, there isn't one.

Actually, determining who was a "true Christian" could be quite easy, if there were explicit actions that were required.
Right. But the only one with the authority to require those actions with any real meaning behind them would be a Christian God. I could compose a list of actions and say all who adhere to it or Christians; everyone else isn't. So effing what? Anyone who wishes to call himself a Christian is one in my book. If any God wants to, he can sort out which ones were wrong later.
 
a belief

a belief

a belief

We are talking past each other.

The point is not that one doesn't have ANY beliefs, the point is that having _particular_ beliefs about the practice is not required to follow the practice. Again, it is the practice that is important for Buddhism, not any _particular_ belief about whether it is correct/incorrect, at least not to begin the practice.

If one is following the eight fold path, for the time one is following it they would be considered a Buddhist, regardless of their preconceptions.

This is in contrast to Christianity, which as I understand it requires a particular set of beliefs, the lack of which means someone is not a Christian no matter what particular actions they perform.

This is as clear as I can put it. If you still don't see my point I don't think I can put it any differently.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noble_Eightfold_Path

If you have time to spend on spiritual things you think are not correct, then I'm envious of you having that much time.

There is such a thing as a person who is willing to try things that they do not initially believe may be correct, because they are willing to accept that they might be wrong or that they don't have everything figured out.

"It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it" - Aristotle
 
So, I'll stop. If the Minimum were good enough, that would have been the Message. I don't find "just do the minimum" to have been anywhere in the message, in spirit nor letter. Others may have read the words differently than I. (Uh, I am sure of that. :) )

But if doing the minimum is not good enough, then it's not really the minimum is it?
 
What don't I believe? Or rather what do I believe that I don't believe?

Just pick something. Anything that you don't believe in. It could be Santa or WMDs in Iraq. Now focus on that thing and decide to believe it. Can you do it? If not, you may begin to realize why having "belief" as a beginning point for Christianity can't really work for atheists.
 
The point is not that one doesn't have ANY beliefs, the point is that having _particular_ beliefs about the practice is not required to follow the practice.

Can you describe an example where someone can put a belief or practice in action without a belief of any sort about that practice or belief?

This is in contrast to Christianity, which as I understand it requires a particular set of beliefs, the lack of which means someone is not a Christian no matter what particular actions they perform.

Maybe you should start with a belief in Jesus and see if that's all it becomes or is? That might answer your question the quickest (or longest). :D

There is such a thing as a person who is willing to try things that they do not initially believe may be correct, because they are willing to accept that they might be wrong or that they don't have everything figured out.

"It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it" - Aristotle

A belief something might be correct is different then a belief it is not correct. If you can believe something is not correct rather than might be correct and still want to devote siginificant time to it then go right ahead. You're free to.
 
Last edited:
Just pick something. Anything that you don't believe in. It could be Santa or WMDs in Iraq. Now focus on that thing and decide to believe it. Can you do it? If not, you may begin to realize why having "belief" as a beginning point for Christianity can't really work for atheists.

You worded it a bit odd so I didn't honestly understand what you were saying. Thanks for clarifying.
 
You worded it a bit odd so I didn't honestly understand what you were saying. Thanks for clarifying.
Sorry I was unclear.

Okay, so can you do this thing? Can you force yourself to believe something? I suspect you cannot (and I'd be a little worried about you if you could.) So you must either have always believed Christianity (or since earliest indoctrination) or something must have convinced you to believe in Christ the Savior.

So I disagree with you when you said "Belief is the beginning". Convincing is the beginning. And convincing is often a difficult thing here on the skeptics boards. We have more demanding criteria for being convinced than they do in Sunday School.
 
Can you describe an example where someone can put a belief or practice in action without a belief of any sort about that practice or belief?

Sigh. Again, your focusing on the wrong question. I'll try one more time.

Person A believes that the eight fold path is correct, and starts following it to try the practice. Person B believes that the eight fold path is probably not correct, but starts following the practice to prove it to themselves one way or the other. Both person A and person B would be considered Buddhists, despite their differing beliefs about the efficacy of the practice because they are both practicing the path.

So again, the point is not that they don't have _any_ beliefs about it, they do. The point is they don't have to have a specific belief that it will work in order to engage in the practice to be considered to be following Buddhism.

Is this not clear?

Maybe you should start with a belief in Jesus and see if that's all it becomes or is? That might answer your question the quickest (or longest). :D

Besides my opinion that convincing oneself to believe something just because you want to believe it is not a skeptical approach and intellectually dishonest to boot, it is also irrelevant to my question. My question is simply whether anything more than belief is _required_, and so far as I can see it is not.

A belief something might be correct is different then a belief it is not correct. If you can believe something is not correct rather than might be correct and still want to devote siginificant time to it then go right ahead. You're free to.

If someone is completely certain that something is not correct without examining it, well, that seems rather shallow and self limiting.

You seem to be confusing my discussing Buddhism with arguing for it. I am not a Buddhist, nor do I claim to follow the eight fold path. You brought up the topic of Buddhism, I am simply trying to correct your misunderstanding of it.

And for the record, I am not really concerned with devoting time to anything other than the intellectual discussion, at least as far as the topics of this thread are concerned.
 
Sorry I was unclear.

Okay, so can you do this thing? Can you force yourself to believe something? I suspect you cannot (and I'd be a little worried about you if you could.) So you must either have always believed Christianity (or since earliest indoctrination) or something must have convinced you to believe in Christ the Savior.

I have no disagreement on your point. See below for an explanation of my statement:

So I disagree with you when you said "Belief is the beginning". Convincing is the beginning. And convincing is often a difficult thing here on the skeptics boards. We have more demanding criteria for being convinced than they do in Sunday School.

My response was in how I interpretted Skepticals statement. It seemed to me he was saying Christianity was "simply a belief". The very nature of Christianity (and in my opinion all spiritual and moral beliefs) is that there is always more than belief - there is action. So that's why I was saying the belief is the beginning.

I'm trying not to read to much into what Skeptical is saying and asking, but he seems to want to know if you can only stop at the minimum belief. Each person will have to decide that on their own I suppose, but as I stated above, action won't be simply done by you because it's required, but it will be done because you want to do it and because it's a natural outgrowth of your belief. And these may lead to other beliefs and on and on.

Of course, ALL that is my opinion.

Added:

Can anyone think of a moral or spiritual belief (other than than the religious framework - i.e. a belief in the supernatural particulars) that is not tied to an action towards someone or something or yourself? (This last sentence isn't coming out how I intend regardless of how I reword it. Sorry if the meaning or intent isn't clear. This isn't a rhetorical question, by the way.)
 
Last edited:
I'm trying not to read to much into what Skeptical is saying and asking, but he seems to want to know if you can only stop at the minimum belief. Each person will have to decide that on their own I suppose, but as I stated above, action won't be simply done by you because it's required, but it will be done because you want to do it and because it's a natural outgrowth of your belief. And these may lead to other beliefs and on and on.


I don't think it's a question of stopping at the minimum. Regardless of what actions should or would follow the onset of belief, I am left with two questions:

1) At the moment one first believes, are they then a Christian?

2) And if they continue to believe, but fail to take the expected actions which should grow out of their belief, do they cease to be a Christian?
 
Last edited:
I don't think it's a question of stopping at the minimum. Regardless of what actions should or would follow the onset of belief, I am left with two questions:

1) At the moment one first believes, are they then a Christian?

2) And if they continue to believe, but fail to take the expected actions which should grow out of their belief, do they cease to be a Christian?

Yes, me too.

As far as I can tell the answer seems to be 1) yes and 2) no. Then there is the follow on question:

3) And if you stop believing, but you did in fact believe at one time, are you still saved? i.e. once saved always saved?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom