The minimalist Christian

So, necessary, but not sufficient. Any thoughts on what additional is needed?

Getting more specific requires more knowledge of the particular branch. For example, Roman Catholics must believe in the inerrancy of the Pope when speaking Ex Cathedra (that is, officially on matters of faith and morals). That, of course, is not part of any other Christian sect's faith. Since that's the case, and such a statement was issued concerning the Immaculate Conception, then Catholics have to believe that, too, and so on. I dare say that most Christians of any stripe don't know all the things that they've signed up for. I also had a good friend that was (inaugurated? inducted? they "laid hands" on him, anyway) in the Swedish Baptist church, and the things he had to defend would curl the average agnostic's toes, including "inerrancy of the Bible in its original texts", whatever those were.

Many protestants believe that being saved is a matter of faith alone, (as opposed to the Roma Catholic requirement of "charity") which ties into the doctrine of predestination. And so it goes.
 
Last edited:
I don't think it's a question of stopping at the minimum. Regardless of what actions should or would follow the onset of belief, I am left with two questions:

1) At the moment one first believes, are they then a Christian?

My opinion is Yes - as far as other people (and themselves) are concerned. God probably sees it differently. He doesn't see you as a Christian or non-Christian, but as a child who is moving away from him or a child coming back to him, and finally children who have come home. (Sorry - I just for some reason can't give simple Yes or No answers to these things.)

2) And if they continue to believe, but fail to take the expected actions which should grow out of their belief, do they cease to be a Christian?

No - many Christians do this. There is an analogy of them being infants or immature or being a seedling. Those analogies use words that may seem insulting to adults, but I know you get the point. Christians use the terminology and symbolism (and these have become loaded phrases too these days) that you are "born again", "reborn", "awakened", "recreated", etc. It literally is seen as a spiritual beginning.

I have too big of a plank in my eye to judge them on how far in their growth they should be versus how far they actually are though.
 
Lets be serious now (he said trying not to insult anyone's mum), a master's degree in theology. Wouldn't that be exactly the same as a master's degree in Big Foot or Dragons?

There is just as much real proof out there for all three.

:)

Ummm.... Inasmuch as any degree requires study of allied fields and certain learning abilities at a minimum, I'd say that a degree in theology probably qualifies the owner to, perhaps, 90% of an equivalent degree in philosophy, or even 70% of a law degree, and likely more than a history degree. Even learning bunk takes something out of a person besides the time and money spent.
 
A while back I read this article on infidels.org regarding the criteria for determining who is a True ChristianTM. Although you might think it slanted against Christianity, I think it's one of the most fair assessments I've come across. It avoids the pitfalls of an exclusive view of Christianity by allowing people to define themselves as they choose.

http://www.infidels.org/library/modern/mathew/intro.html

What makes a real believer? There are so many One True Religions it's hard to tell. Look at Christianity: there are many competing groups, all convinced that they are the only true Christians. Sometimes they even fight and kill each other. How is an atheist supposed to decide who's a real Christian and who isn't, when even the major Christian churches like the Catholic Church and the Church of England can't decide amongst themselves?

In the end, most atheists take a pragmatic view, and decide that anyone who calls himself a Christian, and uses Christian belief or dogma to justify his actions, should be considered a Christian. Maybe some of those Christians are just perverting Christian teaching for their own ends--but surely if the Bible can be so readily used to support un-Christian acts it can't be much of a moral code? If the Bible is the word of God, why couldn't he have made it less easy to misinterpret? And how do you know that your beliefs aren't a perversion of what your God intended?

If there is no single unambiguous interpretation of the Bible, then why should an atheist take one interpretation over another just on your say-so? Sorry, but if someone claims that he believes in Jesus and that he murdered others because Jesus and the Bible told him to do so, we must call him a Christian.

I remember the following explanation from a Buddhist on another forum. Suppose a Buddhist dictator were responsible for atrocities that took thousands of lives. Buddhists would not try to disown or disassociate from this person by saying that he was not a "true Buddhist," in order to keep their ranks pure. Rather, they would say that this person was a "really bad Buddhist" which is the truth. When a member of the human race does something bad, you can't claim that he or she is "sub-human" or not a "true human." You would say describe this person as a "really bad human being."
 
My opinion is Yes - as far as other people (and themselves) are concerned. God probably sees it differently. He doesn't see you as a Christian or non-Christian, but as a child who is moving away from him or a child coming back to him, and finally children who have come home. (Sorry - I just for some reason can't give simple Yes or No answers to these things.)



No - many Christians do this. There is an analogy of them being infants or immature or being a seedling. Those analogies use words that may seem insulting to adults, but I know you get the point. Christians use the terminology and symbolism (and these have become loaded phrases too these days) that you are "born again", "reborn", "awakened", "recreated", etc. It literally is seen as a spiritual beginning.

I have too big of a plank in my eye to judge them on how far in their growth they should be versus how far they actually are though.


Thanks, I actually think these are pretty good answers. But it does still come back to the minimum being believing in the divinity of Jesus, it seems to me.

Personally, I'll go with Silentknight's approach. If you call yourself a Christian, I'll consider you a Christian.
 
Last edited:
So what is your interpretation of this statement?

I mean, prostitutes, sure, but tax collectors?:yikes:

The way it was explained to me, back when I was a child in Sunday School and asking the same question (as well as a lot of other questions that tended to make my teachers uncomfortable :) ) is that in that time and place, there were no laws or regulations about how taxes could be collected. What resulted was that tax collectors were basically thugs who took whatever they could get away with - and the weak and the poor, as always, would have been easier pickin's than the strong or the rich who could guard thier possessions. The tax collectors paid the Romans off, who didn't care how they collected the taxes or from whom, and then kept whatever was leftover. It was an occupation that was percieved then as we see extortion or thievery today.

I can't say if this is true, but it was one of the few answers I ever got from them that made sense to me.

No, I see your point, I just don't think its correct. One can reasonably say "I don't think this is going to work", or "I don't think Buddha knew what he was talking about", and still follow the eight fold path to prove it to oneself one way or the other. There is no prerequisite that you actually think its going to work. In fact, you can think its NOT going to work, the practice of the actions is what is required, not any prior belief about their efficacy.

I don't think this is true. Many things that people attempt, and I suspect the eight fold path is one of them, require belief in order to be successful. It's the idea behind a 'self-fullfilling prophecy'. Even if belief is not strictly required, those who believe they can accomplish some task are far more likely to succeed than those who don't.
 
Can anyone think of a moral or spiritual belief (other than than the religious framework - i.e. a belief in the supernatural particulars) that is not tied to an action towards someone or something or yourself?

Absolutely. "Love thy neighbor," which makes no demands of action whatsoever.
 
You mean my inaction towards someone is love? That is absurd...

...in your opinion.

In other opinions, and in other situations, it can be seen as the best possible action; if you are afraid of hurting someone by a more explicit expression of your love, for example. Heck, there are people who go so far as to commit suicide in order to make sure that their unrequited love is not bothered by their unwanted presence in their lives.

A literary example of "love expressed via inaction" would very easily be Dante for Beatrice --- had Dante not bothered to write about how he felt for Beatrice (after she was dead), the world would never have know the feelings that he had for her. But as far as she -- and the world during her lifetime -- knew, he didn't particularly care for her. Which given that she and he were both married to other people, is probably for the better.
 
...in your opinion.

In other opinions, and in other situations, it can be seen as the best possible action;
The best possible action at times is love? You don't see that you just called it an action?
there are people who go so far as to commit suicide in order to make sure that their unrequited love is not bothered by their unwanted presence in their lives.
Suicide isn't an action?
 
Leaving someone alone is not an action. Suicide itself is, but that's just an extreme case.
 
Last edited:
The best possible action at times is love?

No, the best possible thing to do in certain circumstances regarding your loved one is nothing. And, no, "nothing" is not "a thing," the limitations of English grammar aside.

And while suicide is indeed an action, it's not an action that necessarily affects the loved one. (If you commit suicide in a garret and your loved one never hears about it, it's hardly an action "towards" that person.)
 
No, the best possible thing to do in certain circumstances regarding your loved one is nothing. And, no, "nothing" is not "a thing," the limitations of English grammar aside.

And while suicide is indeed an action, it's not an action that necessarily affects the loved one. (If you commit suicide in a garret and your loved one never hears about it, it's hardly an action "towards" that person.)
Get back to me when you stop contradicting yourself...
 
Ummm.... Inasmuch as any degree requires study of allied fields and certain learning abilities at a minimum, I'd say that a degree in theology probably qualifies the owner to, perhaps, 90% of an equivalent degree in philosophy, or even 70% of a law degree, and likely more than a history degree. Even learning bunk takes something out of a person besides the time and money spent.

Good point. I agree that a master's degree in 'anything' is probably very hard work, even bunk.

But it does sound ludicrous when you consider they are learning about people and events etc that are made up.

It would be ridiculous to tell someone that you are Doctor Smith, based purely on your study of mythical red dragons. The same must be said about theological based studies.
 
Good point. I agree that a master's degree in 'anything' is probably very hard work, even bunk.

But it does sound ludicrous when you consider they are learning about people and events etc that are made up.

It would be ridiculous to tell someone that you are Doctor Smith, based purely on your study of mythical red dragons. The same must be said about theological based studies.

Lots of degrees are based on less, I'm here to tell you. My wife wrote her mother's doctoral thesis in cultural anthropology, and she doesn't have a bachelor's degree. I have an MSEE, but I do computer programming, and haven't worked in circuitry since I left the school. But I agree with you about the dragons. :)

Theology isn't made up, though. As a study, its probably 80% about people (maybe 40% sales and marketing!) and only 20% about god and his stuff. It has a very high correlation with philosophy and history. Divinity students delve a lot into the history and pedigree of the Bible, which a lot of fundamentalist preachers have to actually hide and not disclose to their parishioners, who would be scandalized. Talk about compartmentaization.

Anyway, whatever flicks their Bics.
 
To my perspective, a Christian is someone who applies the transcendent idea of "Christ" to the person of the human "Jesus". That in turn becomes a kind of 'ground' that ethical and moral struggles are referenced.

It is quite possible to believe that other great figures are 'Christlike', having this transcendent idea applied to other humans. Think of "Christ" as an idea that represents a connection with God that recurs through history in different ways. You could believe Jesus was the Christ, but also believe in the same sense that Mohamed or the Buddha was. We would not typically call this person a Christian unless, Jesus linked with Christ was the primary foundation or ground of the person. So I find myself in agreement with the Infidels justification, which was well stated earlier.

As it turns out, I have little argument with the kind of Christians who can simply and honestly struggle with their own beliefs and faith. There are some broad viewpoints within Christianity, some more or less superstitious, and some not.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom