The first fundamental belief in Buddhasm is a belief in Buddha - specifically a belief he was telling you the Truth.
This is exactly where I didn't want to go, but....
Actually, no, it's not. Buddha said (supposedly):
“Believe nothing, no matter where you read it, or who said it, no matter if I have said it, unless it agrees with your own reason and your own common sense.”
http://thinkexist.com/quotation/believe_nothing-no_matter_where_you_read_it-or/143661.html
From my understanding, and I am not a Buddhist so I only know what I have read, the most important component of Buddhism is the _practice_, not the belief. You don't have to believe anything about Buddhism to test the practice of Buddhism to see if it "works", however one chooses to define this.
Can you follow the eight fold path because you are reqired to without believing in the eight fold path or believing it's required of you?
The eight fold path is about actions and not belief. One could reasonably not believe its going to work, and yet try it and see if it does. (again, however one defines that) If you are living the eight fold path, regardless of ones beliefs about it, then by my understanding you are a Buddhist.
A belief is an action (a mental one - see Dr. Kitten's well written post above on why it's basically impossible apart from any outward actions to completely judge another person). Can you have an religious action without a religious belief or without the religious belief is it simply an action?
The question is not about judging, the question is about the criteria for being a Christian. If the criterion is simply a belief, then yes, I agree one could never know what someone actually believes. My question is if it is universally agreed that all that is required is belief. That has been my understanding, I am trying to confirm this.
In some systems, the actions are what is important, and not the beliefs. In others, it is the beliefs. Christianity as I understand it focuses on the belief, so in Christianity I think the answer would be "no". Buddhism, as I understand it, focuses on the actions, so in Buddhism the answer would be "yes".
As long as you think belief is simply a mental statement or agreement with someone elses statement and not a mental action that leads to other actions you are going to be stuck in one spot. Belief in Jesus and Belief in God isn't simply a belief they exist. Me believing you exist isn't the same as me believing in you.
I understand. The question is whether the belief is all that is minimally required. It seems that it is.
Sorry - I can't help any farther. I'd probably ask these questions to your local churches or Christians instead of to Athiests if you're really interested in getting better answers and a better sample of answers. People on this forum are probably a bit biased
against Christianity.
I don't normally go to churches, and if I did I doubt I would ask people these questions. I don't think people go to church to get asked things like this, so I respect that. And, I have asked this on other boards more congenial to Christians, and honestly the answers were not any better.
I am always interested in a diversity of opinion, but on this point there seems to be consensus that what is critical is the belief itself, and not any actions, even if certain actions are highly encouraged.
Unless of course you just want Athiests to confirm what you already believe.
I would hope that I have never given that impression. I am interested in diverse opinions, not just those I already agree with. But that doesn't mean that those who I already agree with don't have good opinions.
