The minimalist Christian

I tend to agree with that in theory, but that doesn't seem to be required by any denomination, Protestant or Catholic. So, if no Christian group requires it, then that cannot be the criteria, can it?

I agree with you you are implying.

I guess in that case the more pertinent question becomes, is what is supposedly required of you by modern denominations truly what christ intended? (assuming he really was the son of god)

And if you follow the modern cherry picked faith, will you be able to get into heaven, or will god send you to hell for blatantly disregarding his instructions in his manual the bible?
 
Last edited:
After reading all that non-sense........I am Truly glad, that I don't call myself a "Christian" anymore.

I once did, and I could never figure out if I met the "minimum" requirements.......;)
When I was young, the term was much more easily understood. You were generally classified as a Christian if you went to church, even if only at Christmas. Otherwise there were Jewish people and that's about it really, and the Salvation Army of course, but they came under the first group anyway.

ETA: and by the way, I am an Author, Writer, and Musical Creator...
What I think is: the world needs a couple of new books in the Bluffer's Guide series - one '..to Atheism' and another '..to Christianity'. Does the idea interest you?! (I wish I could write because I'd do one in connection with my avatar!)

What I was really asking, I suppose, is what is the dividing line, if one exists, between where nearly every Christian would draw the line and say, if your on this side of the line, you're a Christian, and if you on the other side, you're not.
This question has certainly become more and more complicated. One friend, who has know me for very many years during which time I have come down firmly on the side of atheism, said, 'But you're not a Christian.' However, when I asked her how my morals, behaviour etc etc were different from hers, she could not answer and said she didn't want to talk about that. Pity, really.


Of course, there is a prerequisite question which is "who gets to decide", assuming there is no universally accepted minimum.

There have been some interesting responses, but I didn't see anything that seemed fairly definitive, which would fit in with what I have seen that there is no agreed upon definition.
Well, it was a very interesting question.
 
Since you are a Christian, one of the few around here, can you answer the question? In your opinion, is just believing Jesus was divine and can forgive your sins, all by itself, enough? If more is required, what is the "more"?

What does "believing Jesus was divine and can forgive your sins" mean?

What does being a disciple mean?

What does following Jesus mean?


Never mind - let's ask Jesus whether more is required with belief:

The Parable of the Two Sons
28"What do you think? There was a man who had two sons. He went to the first and said, 'Son, go and work today in the vineyard.'
29" 'I will not,' he answered, but later he changed his mind and went.

30"Then the father went to the other son and said the same thing. He answered, 'I will, sir,' but he did not go.

31"Which of the two did what his father wanted?"
"The first," they answered.

Jesus said to them, "I tell you the truth, the tax collectors and the prostitutes are entering the kingdom of God ahead of you. 32For John came to you to show you the way of righteousness, and you did not believe him, but the tax collectors and the prostitutes did. And even after you saw this, you did not repent and believe him.
 
A friend of mine from college was the most minimalist Christian I've ever met. His position was that you need not believe in Jesus or God or salvation, so long as you abide by the moral principles set down by the possibly-mythological Jesus. Bob argued that the moral code was worth it, even if the whole thing was one big parable.

And if you said he was not a Real Christian, then you had better step back.

Why? Did he turn the other cheek really quickly?
 
What does "believing Jesus was divine and can forgive your sins" mean?
It means that you can go ahead and sin, so long as you ask forgiveness.

What does being a disciple mean?
It means whatever you want it to mean.

What does following Jesus mean?
It means whatever you want it to mean.

Never mind - let's ask Jesus whether more is required with belief:
And Jesus gives an answer that could be interpreted any number of ways, i.e. whatever you want it to mean.

So what is your interpretation of this statement?
Jesus said to them, "I tell you the truth, the tax collectors and the prostitutes are entering the kingdom of God ahead of you.
32 For John came to you to show you the way of righteousness, and you did not believe him, but the tax collectors and the prostitutes did. And even after you saw this, you did not repent and believe him.
I mean, prostitutes, sure, but tax collectors?:yikes:
 
I guess in that case the more pertinent question becomes, is what is supposedly required of you by modern denominations truly what christ intended? (assuming he really was the son of god)

And if you follow the modern cherry picked faith, will you be able to get into heaven, or will god send you to hell for blatantly disregarding his instructions in his manual the bible?

I think this thread amply demonstrates that those are unanswerable questions.

The first simply does not admit of a unique answer, any more than you can ask what the weather is like in the Western Hemisphere. Aside from obvious and useless generalizations (it's daytime? It's too warm for the oxygen to freeze?), there is simply too much variance; the weather in New York is not like the weather in LA, which in turn is different from the weather in Santiago Chile.

The second requires access to information that we do not have and have no expectation of getting. That's like asking what the weather is like on the Klingon homeworld.
 
No - the church says that to be a Christian you have to believe at least this.

So, necessary, but not sufficient. Any thoughts on what additional is needed?

Personally, I don't believe in much of it at all, but I got the full treatment on the way up, so I can blurt it out here. Since I don't, I can hardly tell others what to think, I think. BTW, there is no "RCC" part in the creed, as there was no other church at the time to differentiate from. The word "catholic" in it has the meaning of "universal":

Ah, right. I always forget the actual definition of "catholic", thanks for that. I don't really think its telling others what to think, I was just looking for some opinions and discussion.
 
What does "believing Jesus was divine and can forgive your sins" mean?

What does being a disciple mean?

What does following Jesus mean?


Never mind - let's ask Jesus whether more is required with belief:


Actually, that's what I'm asking. I appreciate the quotes, and that is sort of the issue. There seem to be a lot of people who say they are Christians, but follow very little, if any, of the teachings that Jesus is reported to have said.

It is confusing to me how one can claim to be a Christian and not even attempt to follow any teachings of Jesus.

I would be interested to hear your own answers to the questions you posed above.

ETA: I read your Jesus quote 3 times, but its still not clear what the "more" is, and its also not clear that the "more" is actually required, only that it is a good thing, so I'd like to hear your thoughts on that as well
 
Last edited:
It means that you can go ahead and sin, so long as you ask forgiveness.

But in Sceptical's scenario - the person saying they believe this discounts everything Jesus teaches - which would include forgiveness of sins. To add that into your belief statement means either you believe he can forgive your sins or not - if you don't it's meaningless to have in your statement. If you ask for the forgiveness (an action) then you are accepting his teachings (at least on this) - but Sceptical is saying the Christian doesn't accept Jesus' teachings - so they wouldn't ask for forgiveness. Sceptical is asking a question which he already seems to know the answer to in order to accomplish something - I'm not really sure.

In fact, in his most recent post he wrote this:
sceptical said:
It is confusing to me how one can claim to be a Christian and not even attempt to follow any teachings of Jesus.

Tricky said:
It means whatever you want it to mean.

It means whatever you want it to mean.

You're right - those are questions each person needs to answer for themself.

And Jesus gives an answer that could be interpreted any number of ways, i.e. whatever you want it to mean.

This parable doesn't even need to be interpreted as he answers it himself. Which son did do what his father asked?

So what is your interpretation of this statement?
Jesus said to them, "I tell you the truth, the tax collectors and the prostitutes are entering the kingdom of God ahead of you. 32For John came to you to show you the way of righteousness, and you did not believe him, but the tax collectors and the prostitutes did. And even after you saw this, you did not repent and believe him.

In this section of Matthew Jesus is comparing the Chief Priests and Elders beliefs with the beliefs of the tax collectors and prostitutes. Both groups verbally say they believe - but Jesus says only the tax collectors and prostitutes really do. How do you know they do? Because what the Chief Priests and Elders did not do the tax collectors and prostitutes do do.

I mean, prostitutes, sure, but tax collectors?:yikes:

I think that in Jesus times Tax Collectors were not well liked by the religious people. Prostitutes and Tax Collectors are being contrasted with the righteously religious of the times.
 
Actually, that's what I'm asking. I appreciate the quotes, and that is sort of the issue. There seem to be a lot of people who say they are Christians, but follow very little, if any, of the teachings that Jesus is reported to have said.

Religious people saying one thing and doing another is not a new trait in humanity. So let me ask you - what do you care if Christians (or anyone for that matter) say one thing but don't do it? How does that affect your beliefs? What do you care if a Christian (or anyone for that matter) says something and actually does it? How does that affect your beliefs?

It is confusing to me how one can claim to be a Christian and not even attempt to follow any teachings of Jesus.

Can a person be a Buhddist and not follow or believe a single Buddhist teaching or have ever learned of his teachings? They might be Buddha-like if some of their actions match up with his teachings (in spite of their ignorance of his teachings), but not a Buddhist in the sense of a follower of him.

Can someone still call themselves a Buddhist regardless? - of course. But if they are not even believing what Buddha taught or putting his wisdom into action I'm not going to take any advice from that person about Buddhsm that seriously. Or at least I won't judge what they say by what they do.

I may hear what they say and possibly do what they say (in regards to Buhddist teaching) but I won't do what they do since it is in contradiction to what they say which is the Buhddist teaching. (Hmm .... that sounds familiar)
 
Last edited:
Actually, that's what I'm asking. I appreciate the quotes, and that is sort of the issue. There seem to be a lot of people who say they are Christians, but follow very little, if any, of the teachings that Jesus is reported to have said.

There are several issues here.

The first is simply that Christianity is not internally consistent about what it demands.

The second is that many of the most famous demands -- especially the most famous of the "minimalist" demands -- are of a state of mind, not of a specific visible action, so you will not be in a position to judge whether or not such demands are met.

Case in point (Matthew 22:35-40)

35 Then one of them, which was a lawyer, asked him a question, tempting him, and saying,
36 Master, which is the great commandment in the law?
37 Jesus said unto him, Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind.
38 This is the first and great commandment.
39 And the second is like unto it, Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself.
40 On these two commandments hang all the law and the prophets.

That's not a demand that I actually complete any specific task, merely that I "love" someone, which of course is a state of mind. Ask any lonely housewife about whether or not her husband "loves" her, then ask him, and see how different people feel about the necessity for demonstrativeness. Heck, ask any abused housewife about whether or not her husband "loves" her and see what she says.... "Love" is a tricky word indeed.

It is confusing to me how one can claim to be a Christian and not even attempt to follow any teachings of Jesus.

Which teachings? The one about "love thy neighbor as thyself" or the one about "whosoever will come after me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow me." The "neither do I condemn the: go, and sin no more" bit, or the "if thy right hand offend thee, cut it off, and cast it from thee" bit? The "he that loveth father or mother more than me is not worthy of me" or the "honor thy father and mother" bit? The "it is lawful to do well on the sabbath days" bit, the "The sabbath was made for man, and not man for the sabbath" bit, or the "till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law" bit?
 
Religious people saying one thing and doing another is not a new trait in humanity. So let me ask you - what do you care if Christians (or anyone for that matter) say one thing but don't do it? How does that affect your beliefs? What do you care if a Christian (or anyone for that matter) says something and actually does it? How does that affect your beliefs?

I only care in the sense that I find it interesting how people act on belief systems. It doesn't affect me one way or the other per se. However, if someone makes claims that, for example, Christians are more moral than non-Christians and points to the teachings of Jesus, it would seem fair for the non-Christian to say that apparently the teachings of Jesus are irrelevant to being a Christian (or nearly so). (NOTE: not saying you were making any such arguments, but I have heard this from many others who call themselves Christians)

So, what I was trying to figure out was if this was a legitimate objection or not. As far as I can tell, it is, because there doesn't seem to be any minimum requirements of behavior to be able to call oneself a Christian.


Can a person be a Buhddist and not follow or believe a single Buddhist teaching or have ever learned of his teachings? They might be Buddha-like if some of their actions match up with his teachings (in spite of their ignorance of his teachings), but not a Buddhist in the sense of a follower of him.

Actually, Buddhism, at least in its original form, specifically does NOT require any particular belief system. It is required that your follow certain principles such as the eight fold path. True, there are the four noble truths, but Buddha specifically said (supposedly) that what is required is not belief in the system, but the practice of it to prove it for yourself. I am not familiar with how it is practiced today, but the foundational principles as I understand them do not require any particular beliefs, only actions.

Can someone still call themselves a Buddhist regardless? - of course. But if they are not even believing what Buddha taught or putting his wisdom into action I'm not going to take any advice from that person about Buddhsm that seriously. Or at least I won't judge what they say by what they do.

Well of course anyone can call themselves anything. The question is if that claim is respected despite actions. As far as I can tell, there are no specific actions required by any denomination of Christianity to call oneself a Christian. All that is required is a belief. I understand perfectly that one is _supposed_ to follow certain actions, but if you don't, there doesn't seem to be any grounds for saying a person is not a Christian provided they genuinely have certain beliefs.

But, I'm prepared to be wrong about that, that's why I'm asking.

I may hear what they say and possibly do what they say (in regards to Buhddist teaching) but I won't do what they do since it is in contradiction to what they say which is the Buhddist teaching. (Hmm .... that sounds familiar)

But in Buddhism, if you don't follow the eight fold path, your not a Buddhist. That seems pretty clear from the foundational texts. It's not at all clear, at least to me, that if you don't follow Jesus' teachings (or at least some of them), that you are not a Christian. Is this conception of Christianity wrong?

I don't want to turn this into a "Buddhism is better than Christianity" thread, I am just pointing out that Buddhism does appear to have minimum requirements of action for someone to call themselves a Buddhist, so the question is whether the same exists in Christianity.
 
There are several issues here.

The first is simply that Christianity is not internally consistent about what it demands.

Yes, I think you're right, at least insofar as the texts are concerned. I think the same is true for the practice of the religion itself, as far as I can tell.

The second is that many of the most famous demands -- especially the most famous of the "minimalist" demands -- are of a state of mind, not of a specific visible action, so you will not be in a position to judge whether or not such demands are met.

Yes, that's the issue. The minimum seems to be a certain state of mind, and not any external actions. That's what I thought, but wanted to see if I was wrong about that.

Which teachings? The one about "love thy neighbor as thyself" or the one about "whosoever will come after me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow me." The "neither do I condemn the: go, and sin no more" bit, or the "if thy right hand offend thee, cut it off, and cast it from thee" bit? The "he that loveth father or mother more than me is not worthy of me" or the "honor thy father and mother" bit? The "it is lawful to do well on the sabbath days" bit, the "The sabbath was made for man, and not man for the sabbath" bit, or the "till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law" bit?

Yes, those. :)
 
Lets be serious now (he said trying not to insult anyone's mum), a master's degree in theology. Wouldn't that be exactly the same as a master's degree in Big Foot or Dragons?

There is just as much real proof out there for all three.

:)

Well, 'tis possible, I suppose.
In practice, it means she knows more about the Judeo-Christian religions than your average church-goer. Considerably more.

Think of it more as a study of the history, development and teachings (doctrinal and non-doctrinal) of religion. Primarily Christianity.

So yes, I suppose you could equate it to a degree in Bigfoot or Dragons, if that degree discussed the history of the phenomenon and the reciprocal effects between society and the belief.

At least, I think that's what you're saying...


I want to say more about defining a Christian, but it isn't going to flow smoothly from the comment above. For the poor segue, I apologize.

The trouble with defining Christianity off of a given doctrine or creed is that is denies the aly forms of Christianity that did not follow the same beliefs.
Take the Nicene creed, which was used to set the basis of an "acceptable" Christianity and standardize the Bible.
What of the texts that were rejected, for whatever reason?
Does this mean the early Christian sects which used these texts, later cast away, were not Christians?
Does it mean that now, Christians are limited only to the Biblical texts, and further reading (Nag Hammadi Library, Gospel of Judas, etc) is not part of Christianity?
 
Last edited:
Actually, Buddhism, at least in its original form, specifically does NOT require any particular belief system.

The first fundamental belief in Buddhasm is a belief in Buddha - specifically a belief he was telling you the Truth.

It is required that your follow certain principles such as the eight fold path.

Can you follow the eight fold path because you are reqired to without believing in the eight fold path or believing it's required of you?

I am not familiar with how it is practiced today, but the foundational principles as I understand them do not require any particular beliefs, only actions.

A belief is an action (a mental one - see Dr. Kitten's well written post above on why it's basically impossible apart from any outward actions to completely judge another person). Can you have an religious action without a religious belief or without the religious belief is it simply an action?

Well of course anyone can call themselves anything. The question is if that claim is respected despite actions. As far as I can tell, there are no specific actions required by any denomination of Christianity to call oneself a Christian. All that is required is a belief.

As long as you think belief is simply a mental statement or agreement with someone elses statement and not a mental action that leads to other actions you are going to be stuck in one spot. Belief in Jesus and Belief in God isn't simply a belief they exist. Me believing you exist isn't the same as me believing in you.

Sorry - I can't help any farther. I'd probably ask these questions to your local churches or Christians instead of to Athiests if you're really interested in getting better answers and a better sample of answers. People on this forum are probably a bit biased against Christianity. :)

Unless of course you just want Athiests to confirm what you already believe.
 
Last edited:
The first fundamental belief in Buddhasm is a belief in Buddha - specifically a belief he was telling you the Truth.

This is exactly where I didn't want to go, but....

Actually, no, it's not. Buddha said (supposedly):

“Believe nothing, no matter where you read it, or who said it, no matter if I have said it, unless it agrees with your own reason and your own common sense.”

http://thinkexist.com/quotation/believe_nothing-no_matter_where_you_read_it-or/143661.html

From my understanding, and I am not a Buddhist so I only know what I have read, the most important component of Buddhism is the _practice_, not the belief. You don't have to believe anything about Buddhism to test the practice of Buddhism to see if it "works", however one chooses to define this.

Can you follow the eight fold path because you are reqired to without believing in the eight fold path or believing it's required of you?

The eight fold path is about actions and not belief. One could reasonably not believe its going to work, and yet try it and see if it does. (again, however one defines that) If you are living the eight fold path, regardless of ones beliefs about it, then by my understanding you are a Buddhist.

A belief is an action (a mental one - see Dr. Kitten's well written post above on why it's basically impossible apart from any outward actions to completely judge another person). Can you have an religious action without a religious belief or without the religious belief is it simply an action?

The question is not about judging, the question is about the criteria for being a Christian. If the criterion is simply a belief, then yes, I agree one could never know what someone actually believes. My question is if it is universally agreed that all that is required is belief. That has been my understanding, I am trying to confirm this.

In some systems, the actions are what is important, and not the beliefs. In others, it is the beliefs. Christianity as I understand it focuses on the belief, so in Christianity I think the answer would be "no". Buddhism, as I understand it, focuses on the actions, so in Buddhism the answer would be "yes".

As long as you think belief is simply a mental statement or agreement with someone elses statement and not a mental action that leads to other actions you are going to be stuck in one spot. Belief in Jesus and Belief in God isn't simply a belief they exist. Me believing you exist isn't the same as me believing in you.

I understand. The question is whether the belief is all that is minimally required. It seems that it is.

Sorry - I can't help any farther. I'd probably ask these questions to your local churches or Christians instead of to Athiests if you're really interested in getting better answers and a better sample of answers. People on this forum are probably a bit biased against Christianity. :)

I don't normally go to churches, and if I did I doubt I would ask people these questions. I don't think people go to church to get asked things like this, so I respect that. And, I have asked this on other boards more congenial to Christians, and honestly the answers were not any better.

I am always interested in a diversity of opinion, but on this point there seems to be consensus that what is critical is the belief itself, and not any actions, even if certain actions are highly encouraged.

Unless of course you just want Athiests to confirm what you already believe.

I would hope that I have never given that impression. I am interested in diverse opinions, not just those I already agree with. But that doesn't mean that those who I already agree with don't have good opinions. :)
 
The first fundamental belief in Buddhasm is a belief in Buddha - specifically a belief he was telling you the Truth.


Nope.

Can you follow the eight fold path because you are reqired to without believing in the eight fold path or believing it's required of you?


Yup, you can follow the eight fold path even if you have never heard of it before.

And just a nitpick, the word is spelled "atheist", and it does not need capitalization as it is not a proper name.
 

True - I suppose if you thought he was lieing you could still follow his teachings - even if you think they are all false.


Yup, you can follow the eight fold path even if you have never heard of it before.

Hokulele - I think you missed my point on that one. (And possibly the above statement too. :) )

And just a nitpick, the word is spelled "atheist", and it does not need capitalization as it is not a proper name.

Yes - everyone points that out - sorry - it's just how it comes out that way when I type. Since it bugs so many I'll try to stop it. I capitilize when a general word "atheists" is in regards to a specific group "Atheists" here on this forum. It might be breaking some grammer rules, but it visually works to emphasize who I'm talking about.
 
Last edited:
The trouble with defining Christianity off of a given doctrine or creed is that is denies the aly forms of Christianity that did not follow the same beliefs.
Take the Nicene creed, which was used to set the basis of an "acceptable" Christianity and standardize the Bible.
What of the texts that were rejected, for whatever reason?
Does this mean the early Christian sects which used these texts, later cast away, were not Christians?
Does it mean that now, Christians are limited only to the Biblical texts, and further reading (Nag Hammadi Library, Gospel of Judas, etc) is not part of Christianity?

That is a problem, and it seems to boil down to 2 basic issues:

1) The focus on beliefs means that there is no objective measurement of who is/who is not a Christian, because you cannot know what someone actually believes

2) The set of beliefs does not appear to be capable of minimum specification, because even if you believe the minimum creeds, if you believe ADDITIONAL things that are not "catholic", then that seems to also eliminate you. What the "catholic" beliefs are, appears to be depend on which branch of Christianity you are attached to, so again no objective measurement is possible.

I think I understand why the RCC is so pissy about this. :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom