The minimalist Christian

skeptical

Muse
Joined
Mar 4, 2007
Messages
957
Some thoughts in another thread rekindled a question I have had for some time: What is the _minimum_ requirement to be a Christian?

I often hear Christians say things like "that person was not a true Christian" when something is brought up as evidence against the supposed morality of Christians. But this statement is completely meaningless unless there is an agree upon definition of what it takes, at a minimum, to be a Christian.

Bertrand Russell started with the proposition that the minimum is that one has to think Jesus was the best moral person who ever lived. But I'm not convinced that is right. In fact, I think there is no scriptural basis for this idea.

As far as I can tell, the _minimum_ has nothing to do with actions at all, but with belief. According to the NT, it would seem that if you believe the Jesus was the son of God (or God, which is apparently the same thing), the this, standing alone, is enough. And, if you don't, then no amount of good deeds or beliefs about morality is. In other words, belief in Jesus alone is both necessary and sufficient.

As I read it, if you belief Jesus is God, then nothing else is required. You can perform whatever acts you want, however immoral, and you are still a "true Christian". Likewise, you can perform as many good acts as you want, but if you don't believe Jesus is God, your not a "true Christian", and by the way, your hell bound.

Is this interpretation correct? Thoughts?
 
I actually think that the minimum requirement of being a Christian is to accept Jesus as your savior. Just believing in him is not enough, as Christians often say, "The devil believes in Jesus too." It requires a deliberate request for Jesus to forgive your sins, or so I'm led to believe.
 
As I read it, if you belief Jesus is God, then nothing else is required. You can perform whatever acts you want, however immoral, and you are still a "true Christian".

If you believe one thing, but do another what does that make you?
 
If you believe one thing, but do another what does that make you?

Human.

I believe I should lose weight. I believe I should exercise more. I believe I should spend more time writing books and less time on the Randi forums. Does this make me not a "true author"?
 
Human.

I believe I should lose weight. I believe I should exercise more. I believe I should spend more time writing books and less time on the Randi forums. Does this make me not a "true author"?

Are you still writing books?

And am I an "true book author" if I've never written a book, never tried to write a book, and am currently not writing a book?
 
Last edited:
Human.

I believe I should lose weight. I believe I should exercise more. I believe I should spend more time writing books and less time on the Randi forums. Does this make me not a "true author"?


No just an interesting poster.
 
Last edited:
A friend of mine from college was the most minimalist Christian I've ever met. His position was that you need not believe in Jesus or God or salvation, so long as you abide by the moral principles set down by the possibly-mythological Jesus. Bob argued that the moral code was worth it, even if the whole thing was one big parable.

And if you said he was not a Real Christian, then you had better step back.
 
A friend of mine from college was the most minimalist Christian I've ever met. His position was that you need not believe in Jesus or God or salvation, so long as you abide by the moral principles set down by the possibly-mythological Jesus. Bob argued that the moral code was worth it, even if the whole thing was one big parable.

And if you said he was not a Real Christian, then you had better step back.

I was about to post a similar observation. One can be a Buddhist without thinking that Gautama was "the savior". If someone wants to say that he/she suspects that Jesus may have been mythical but that many of the teachings attributed to him have value and are worth following, and said person wishes to be identified as a Christian then who am I to argue?
 
Ummm....hello.....religion is an invention of man, not God. God just want recognition and fellowship of man. The problem is that the church tries to get to specific about it and tell you how you should act in every facade of your life. Forget being a technical christian, forget the church and it's impossible rules, just live your life trying to make this world better then you found it and keep searching for God until you find Him.
 
A friend of mine from college was the most minimalist Christian I've ever met. His position was that you need not believe in Jesus or God or salvation, so long as you abide by the moral principles set down by the possibly-mythological Jesus. Bob argued that the moral code was worth it, even if the whole thing was one big parable.

And if you said he was not a Real Christian, then you had better step back.


There is a big difference between self-labeling and how other people would categorize him. I can call myself Empress Josephine, but that does not make it so. I think for the purposes of the OP, skeptical is looking for a definition that Christians apply to each other. I would tentatively agree with Sefarst (but can be convinced otherwise).
 
Last edited:
There is a big difference between self-labeling and how other people would categorize him. I can call myself Empress Josephine, but that does not make it so. I think for the purposes of the OP, skeptical is looking for a definition that Christians apply to each other. I would tentatively agree with Seafarst (but can be convinced otherwise).

I agree that the vast majority of Christians are of the "personal savior" variety, but even among them there are a great many "false Christians".
 
Last edited:
And am I an "true book author" if I've never written a book, never tried to write a book, and am currently not writing a book?

I have no problem disbelieving in the existence of anyone who believes in the divinity of Christ but has never in any way acted in accordance with the dictates of Christianity.
This is a straw man, and a rather silly one at that.

But I have no problem characterizing someone who has only gotten as far as putting paper in the typewriter and tapping out "It was a dark and stormy night..." as an author. A bad one, perhaps, but still an author.
 
There is a big difference between self-labeling and how other people would categorize him. I can call myself Empress Josephine, but that does not make it so.
The difference is we could ask you to present evidence that you were an empress and that your name was Josephine. We have an objective standard by which to measure your Empress Josephineness against. The only way there could be objective evidence of who among us is a true Christian would be if some version of the Christian God did exist. True Christians would then be whomever he deemed them to be, regardless of what we thought about it. Since any such God that might exist has not laid down the definitive criteria, I am content to allow that anyone that claims to be a Christian is one, saving any cases in which I can detect a motive for deceit.
 
Last edited:
Actually, the answer is found to contradict itself in the new testament. Jesus said take what you have and sell it, give to the poor then follow me.

Paul (the parasee-convert-roman citizen) said "believe in the name of jesus."

If the christians can't figure it out why ask non-christians?
 
Last edited:
I agree that the vast majority of Christians are of the "personal savior" variety, but even among them there are a great many "false Christians".


The main problem is, some Christians call each other "false" due to actions, others due to beliefs. This is where it gets tricky, as the NT makes it clear that both are required. That opens up the can of worms as to picking out which actions are necessary to be considered a "true" Christian. The beliefs seem to be a lot easier.
 
The main problem is, some Christians call each other "false" due to actions, others due to beliefs.

And I see no reason we should take either group at all seriously. Especially since I've seen that pattern among many other groups, where sub-group A-1 calls subgroup A-2 a "false A." (Exempli gratia among many, Rush's criticism of McCain.) It's almost always a rhetorical power play, not an actual correct statement.
 
The difference is we could ask you to present evidence that you were an empress and that your name was Josephine. We have an objective standard by which to measure your Empress Josephineness against.


I don't even have to be an Empress, I just need to wander down to Town Hall, fill in some rather minor paperwork, and I will be as Empress Josephiney as I wish. Transferring the bank accounts would be more tedious than changing my reality. This demonstrates the challenges of self-labeling.

The only way there could be objective evidence of who among us is a true Christian would be if some version of the Christian God did exist. True Christians would then be whomever he deemed them to be, regardless of what we thought about it. Since any such God that might exist has not laid down the definitive criteria, I am content to allow that anyone that claims to be a Christian is one, saving any cases in which I can detect a motive for deceit.


In the absence of a Christian god, why not use local authorities? I am sure there are dictates from various popes and whatever other denominations use as figureheads that would define "Christian".
 
I think for the purposes of the OP, skeptical is looking for a definition that Christians apply to each other.
What appears to be the agreed upon convention reagrding each others variations in practice and dogma is to apply this definition to the other:

Splitter!

:)

To more cleanly answer that, Hok, Christians aren't standardized enough to call one another any one thing for a given category, other than perhaps "saved."

And that I doubt, given the squabbles over doctrine endemic to Christian belief and practice.

Skeptical is on the right track, I think, in that faith in salvation via Jesus is a standard requirement.

Beyond that, it seems that "wherever two or more of you are gathered in His name" is all that is minimally required, given that Christianity involves behaviors vis a vis one's fellow human beings. I would argue that giving a sincere effort to apply "as you treat the least of these, so have you treated Me" and "love thy neighbor as thyself" would be necessary, but we are already in trouble here with any number of True Christians who demand that I buy only their kilts.

So, I'll stop. If the Minimum were good enough, that would have been the Message. I don't find "just do the minimum" to have been anywhere in the message, in spirit nor letter. Others may have read the words differently than I. (Uh, I am sure of that. :) )

DR
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom