The minimalist Christian

And I see no reason we should take either group at all seriously. Especially since I've seen that pattern among many other groups, where sub-group A-1 calls subgroup A-2 a "false A." (Exempli gratia among many, Rush's criticism of McCain.) It's almost always a rhetorical power play, not an actual correct statement.


I agree, but the OP seems to be asking if there is any way to draw some kind of line where we can state that sub-group A-1 are a bunch of idiots for claiming that. Maybe the OP will come back to clarify, as I have been making a bunch of assumptions on his/her part.
 
Splitter!


A True LadyTM never spits, but s...

Oh, never mind.

To more cleanly answer that, Hok, Christians aren't standardized enough to call one another any one thing for a given category, other than perhaps "saved."


So would you personally consider anyone that isn't "saved" Christian or not? (Not that it means anything in a larger context, just curious.)

And that I doubt, given the distinctive squabble over doctrine endemic to Christian belief and practice.

Skeptical is on the right track, I think, in that faith in salvation via Jesus is a standard requirement.

Beyond that, it seems that "wherever two or more of you are gathered in His name" is all that is minimally required, given that Christianity involves behaviors vis a vis one's fellow human beings. I would argue that giving a sincere effort to apply "as you treat the least of these, so have you treated Me" and "love thy neighbor as thyself" would be necessary, but we are already in trouble here with any number of True Christians who demand that I buy only their kilts.

So, I'll stop.

DR


Heh, it gets even more fun when you examine how Christianity is practiced in non-Western countries.

ETA: Oopsie, DR was editing while I was composing. I think my response still relates to his added comments.
 
Last edited:
I agree, but the OP seems to be asking if there is any way to draw some kind of line where we can state that sub-group A-1 are a bunch of idiots for claiming that. Maybe the OP will come back to clarify, as I have been making a bunch of assumptions on his/her part.

A Comparative study of the common beliefs among different Christian denominations might be enlightening. For all their differences on many specifics, there is usually an overall commonality among them.

I'd say common beliefs overall: (Note: Not common beliefs on what makes a Christian)

1) A belief in a creator God
2) A belief that Jesus was divine (while not necessarily agreeing on how or even how much)
3) A belief that his life and death (and ressurection ;) )mattered and in fact, impacted the world. (Again - the particulars might be disagreed on)
4) A belief that if you believe the above you will be moved to actions both in regards to your relationship with God and your relationship with others.

Darth - you have any others or reasons to nix any of these?
 
Last edited:
A Comparative study of the common beliefs among different Christian denominations might be enlightening. For all their differences on many specifics, there is usually an overall commonality among them.

I'd say common beliefs overall: (Note: Not common beliefs on what makes a Christian)

1) A belief in a creator God
2) A belief that Jesus was divine (while not necessarily agreeing on how or even how much)
3) A belief that his life and death (and resurrection ;) )mattered and in fact, impacted the world. (Again - the particulars might be disagreed on)
4) A belief that if you believe the above you will be moved to actions both in regards to your relationship with God and your relationship with others.

Darth - you have any others or reasons to nix any of these?



My mother is Christian. She has a masters degree in theology, and is pursuing studies in divinity. She is a minister in the United Church of Canada.
Courtesy of many years of studies in religion, she is a best described as a deist, views the concept of "God" as mankind's attempts at realizing higher truths, but thinks there might be something indefinable that put the universe into motion. She will readily admit that the bible and religion is a creation of man, and products of the society that made them. She believes Jesus existed as a purely human individual (an old (30-something was old, back then) Essene teacher who happened to be a popular speaker) who wound up being deified by the early Christians. She believes he was crucified for being something of a troublemaker for the Romans and Pharisees (i.e. sedition-type things), but does not believe in the resurrection or any of the much-beloved birth stories.

I enjoy my discussions with her on theology, as it's an area I find fascinating. She knows I'm atheist, but since she realizes my atheism is the result of learning and understanding the history of god instead of just being pissed off at god for a screwed-up world, doesn't care. In fact, there was recently a debate at my university on "Does God Exist", with the theist side presented by kirk Durston (whose arguments were from incredulity at life's existence (i.e. Kalam) and that atheist can't be moral), and the atheist side defended by Tim Schroeder (who I fell did a poor job, focusing mostly on "the world is unpleasant, therefore no god)". I told her of the basic arguments, and she wishes she'd known about it in time to attend. She would have had some very difficult questions for the evangelical Durston.

By any literalist/fundamentalist definition, she is not Christian. But she believes in this "higher truth" and in Jesus the human. She is about as liberal as you get in Christianity, but she'd still call herself a Christian. I'd be inclined to agree.

Your list, as applied to her, would not fit. In her case:

1) God might be a creator who can't be bothered with us, or just might be "higher truth".
2) Jesus was fully human.
3) Jesus lived, died, and stayed dead. His impact was helped by early Christians who were, shall we say, fishermen.
4) God is not necessary for morality, and religion is a bad thing to use as moral source.

In my opinion, all you need to do to fit in to some sect of Christianity somewhere is believe in some higher state of being or truth, and follow Jesus' moral teachings. Well, the good ones, anyway. Regardless of whether they are authentic to the man or not. There will be a sect somewhere to fit you.

In short, I don't think any Christian would be able to reasonable defend the claim that someone else "isn't a true Christian". Perceptions and beliefs differ massively from person to person. Somebody might not be a true Christian by one person's standard, but would be by someone else's. Who is right? All and none.
 
Last edited:
Another noteworthy Christian who would not fit the terms in the list above would be this Episcopal bishop:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Shelby_Spong

A prominent theme in Spong's writing is that the popular, alleged "literal" interpretation of Christian scripture does not speak honestly to the situation of modern Christian communities, and that a more nuanced approach to scripture, informed by scholarship and compassion, can be consistent with both Christian Tradition and a contemporary understanding of the universe. He believes, as did his theological predecessor, Bishop John A.T. Robinson, that theism has lost credibility as a valid conception of God's nature. He explains that he is a Christian because he believes that Jesus Christ fully expressed the presence of a God of compassion and selfless love, and that this is the meaning of the early Christian proclamation, "Jesus is Lord" (Spong, 1994 and Spong, 1991). He rejects the historical truth claims of some Christian doctrines, such as the virgin birth (Spong, 1992) and the bodily resurrection of Jesus (Spong, 1994).

I read his book "Jesus for the Non-Religious" last year, and went on to read a couple of his past books "The Sins of Scripture" and "Rescuing the Bible from Fundamentalism." As an atheist, I found myself agreeing with just about everything he said, with the only differences being the directions from which we arrived at the same conclusions. Naturally, the fundamentalists hate his guts.
 
My mother is Christian. She has a masters degree in theology, and is

<snip>

Your list, as applied to her, would not fit. In her case:

That was a list of basic common Christian beliefs among denominations - not individuals.

What is the United Church of Canada's official teachings / beliefs on these?

Added:

Found here:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Church_of_Canada

Official doctrine
The Basis of Union sets out the doctrines concurred in by the uniting denominations; it

"affirms" "belief in the Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments as the primary source and ultimate standard of Christian faith and life";
"acknowledges" "the teaching of the great creeds of the ancient Church" — that is, the Apostles' Creed, the Nicene Creed and the Athanasian Creed; and
"maintains" "allegiance to the evangelical doctrines of the Reformation, as set forth in common in the doctrinal standards adopted by the Presbyterian Church in Canada, by the Congregational Union of Ontario and Quebec, and by the Methodist Church."
Weekly recitation of the Apostles Creed was a routine feature of Sunday worship until 1968 when the Church promulgated an additional specifically United Church Creed, entitled A New Creed. It should be noted that the United Church emphasises its participation in the universal small-C catholic church, and that the ancient creeds are not displaced but only supplemented; that being said, it is the new United Church Creed that rather than the ancient creeds is most often recited during Sunday worship.
 
Last edited:
That was a list of basic common Christian beliefs among denominations - not individuals.

What is the United Church of Canada's official teachings / beliefs on these?

Ah. I misinterpreted you.

[url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Church_of_Canada]Wikipedia[/url] said:
Official doctrine

The Basis of Union sets out the doctrines concurred in by the uniting denominations; it

* "affirms" "belief in the Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments as the primary source and ultimate standard of Christian faith and life";
* "acknowledges" "the teaching of the great creeds of the ancient Church" — that is, the Apostles' Creed, the Nicene Creed and the Athanasian Creed; and
* "maintains" "allegiance to the evangelical doctrines of the Reformation, as set forth in common in the doctrinal standards adopted by the Presbyterian Church in Canada, by the Congregational Union of Ontario and Quebec, and by the Methodist Church."


From my experience in the church, it seldom teaches anything above the grade-school level in terms of Christianities history and background.


However, it is the people who form the church, not the doctrine. At least, that's the standpoint of most members of the UCoC that I've known.


ETA: Foul! You had a head-start! I demand a re-race! :p
 
Last edited:
ETA: Foul! You had a head-start! I demand a re-race! :p

haha. I asked the questions and then thought ... hmmmm .... Google and Wikipedia.

We really are lucky with how easy it is these days to get basic information on things.
 
After reading all that non-sense........I am Truly glad, that I don't call myself a "Christian" anymore.

I once did, and I could never figure out if I met the "minimum" requirements.......;)

Just sayin'.

ETA: and by the way, I am an Author, Writer, and Musical Creator...
 
Last edited:
There is a big difference between self-labeling and how other people would categorize him. I can call myself Empress Josephine, but that does not make it so.
There is indeed a big difference, but I don't think you can gain anything more than a statistical definition of "Christian" that way. You might find that this statatistical definition leaves out Mormons or Branch Davidians or some other groups which adamantly call themselves Christians. So in the interest of fairness, I say a Christian is anyone who identifies himself as one. Since we all agree that there are many many kinds of Christian, then it seems fair to say that a person who follows the teachings of the Myth of Jesus but doesn't believe the myth itself is just as legitimately a Christian as a Seventh Day Adventist. He is just very different from other Christians.

Now of course this leads to labelling problems, but that's okay with me. I'm not too fond of labels anyway. I find it is better to find out what a person actually believes rather than make assumptions based on their label.

"But wait," I can hear you say in your island language that includes hip movements and spam consumption, "What if an atheist says, 'I am an atheist, but I believe in a God'?" Same deal. They are just an atheist that is far different from most atheists. In fact, the popular joke goes, "We are both athiests, I'm just atheist about one more god than you." Spot on, Mr. God-believing athiest. You and I can argue until the Monk Seals come home about what our brand of atheism is like, but I won't ever use No True Scotsman against you.

I think for the purposes of the OP, skeptical is looking for a definition that Christians apply to each other. I would tentatively agree with Sefarst (but can be convinced otherwise).
As I mention, this would be, at best, a statistical definition. Each Christian might define it differently. I say they have the right to do so.
 
Last edited:
IRL, I tend to be more of a lumper than a splitter, but I can see an argument being made that having some kind of definition is useful for those involved in discussions, particularly of the on-line variety, where one can call BS on someone using the No True AlabamianTM line.

And the proper phrase is "Try wait", not "But wait", as in "Try wait, there's more!"
 
IRL, I tend to be more of a lumper than a splitter, but I can see an argument being made that having some kind of definition is useful for those involved in discussions, particularly of the on-line variety, where one can call BS on someone using the No True AlabamianTM line.
Sure its useful for general and fuzzy distinctions, sort of like race is useful for classifying people's appearance, but under the microscope, it has no power to identify. So I don't care if you're covered with cilia and have a tough outer pellicle, if you want to call yourself an amoeba, I'm not going to call you a liar.

As for Alabamians, I was disowned by the majority of the cline years ago.

And the proper phrase is "Try wait", not "But wait", as in "Try wait, there's more!"
I can see why. Those big Polynesians might not like anything that sounded too much like "Butt weight". (And it is true, I'm in no position to cast aspersions.)
 
Last edited:
I agree, but the OP seems to be asking if there is any way to draw some kind of line where we can state that sub-group A-1 are a bunch of idiots for claiming that. Maybe the OP will come back to clarify, as I have been making a bunch of assumptions on his/her part.

What I was really asking, I suppose, is what is the dividing line, if one exists, between where nearly every Christian would draw the line and say, if your on this side of the line, you're a Christian, and if you on the other side, you're not.

Of course, there is a prerequisite question which is "who gets to decide", assuming there is no universally accepted minimum.

There have been some interesting responses, but I didn't see anything that seemed fairly definitive, which would fit in with what I have seen that there is no agreed upon definition.

I will go back through the responses to make sure I didn't miss one, but that was my first read through.
 
Sure its useful for general and fuzzy distinctions, sort of like race is useful for classifying people's appearance, but under the microscope, it has no power to identify. So I don't care if you're covered with cilia and have a tough outer pellicle, if you want to call yourself an amoeba, I'm not going to call you a liar.


True, but (butt) if you go back to the OP, one of the reasons behind the original question was to counter the move by some Christians to disassociate themselves from others. For example, DOC claims that Mormons aren't Christians due to the fact that they place their god on planet Kolob. By coming up with a more general description of the main tenet(s) of Christianity, a claim such as DOC's can be examined more closely and accepted or rejected on its merits, rather than DOC's say-so.

As for Alabamians, I was disowned by the majority of the cline years ago.


They didn't want you either, huh?

I can see why. Those big Polynesians might not like anything that sounded too much like "Butt weight". (And it is true, I'm in no position to cast aspersions.)


A heavy build is considered an attractive feature to most Polynesians. Baby got back!
 
Last edited:
I actually think that the minimum requirement of being a Christian is to accept Jesus as your savior. Just believing in him is not enough, as Christians often say, "The devil believes in Jesus too." It requires a deliberate request for Jesus to forgive your sins, or so I'm led to believe.

Ok, I can see that.

So, then my follow on is, if that is the minimum, then it seems to mean that there is no particular moral code or other beliefs that one has to have. So, someone could lead a completely "anti Christian" life, and still be "saved" as long as they continually ask Jesus to forgive them. Is that correct?
 
For me personally the minimum (without any elaboration) is:

Believe in Jesus.

So, if you believe "in" Jesus, whatever one chooses to mean by that, does that imply one has to at least attempt to follow a certain moral code, or does it not?

For example, if someone says they believe in Jesus, but they don't think you should treat your neighbor as yourself, nor that you should turn the other cheek, nor any of the other supposed sayings of Jesus, would you say this means they are not a Christian?
 
Ok, I can see that.

So, then my follow on is, if that is the minimum, then it seems to mean that there is no particular moral code or other beliefs that one has to have. So, someone could lead a completely "anti Christian" life, and still be "saved" as long as they continually ask Jesus to forgive them. Is that correct?

This might depend on whether you think "believe in" means simply "believes exists" or means "something more", and then whether that "something more" would lead to any sort of changed behavior and / or a closer look at his (Jesus') moral, spiritual and philisophical teachings.
 
So, if you believe "in" Jesus, whatever one chooses to mean by that, does that imply one has to at least attempt to follow a certain moral code, or does it not?

For example, if someone says they believe in Jesus, but they don't think you should treat your neighbor as yourself, nor that you should turn the other cheek, nor any of the other supposed sayings of Jesus, would you say this means they are not a Christian?

What, in this scenario, would believing in Jesus mean?
 
The only way there could be objective evidence of who among us is a true Christian would be if some version of the Christian God did exist. True Christians would then be whomever he deemed them to be, regardless of what we thought about it. Since any such God that might exist has not laid down the definitive criteria, I am content to allow that anyone that claims to be a Christian is one, saving any cases in which I can detect a motive for deceit.

Actually, determining who was a "true Christian" could be quite easy, if there were explicit actions that were required. For example, if you said someone had to attend church a certain number of times, give a certain amount of money, follow certain moral codes (even if one didn't believe in them), etc.

It is only because the criteria seems to require a certain _belief_, which is obviously beyond another's ability to know, that this problem arises.

So, my question still is, is the belief all that is required. If someone says "I believe that", but there are no other actions at all, including not attempting to follow a certain moral code, is that person still a Christian?
 
This might depend on whether you think "believe in" means simply "believes exists" or means "something more", and then whether that "something more" would lead to any sort of changed behavior and / or a closer look at his (Jesus') moral, spiritual and philisophical teachings.
Why is it when reading your posts I am strongly reminded of television ads for the LDS?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom