A Comparative study of the common beliefs among different Christian denominations might be enlightening. For all their differences on many specifics, there is usually an overall commonality among them.
I'd say common beliefs overall: (Note: Not common beliefs on what makes a Christian)
1) A belief in a creator God
2) A belief that Jesus was divine (while not necessarily agreeing on how or even how much)
3) A belief that his life and death (and resurrection

)mattered and in fact, impacted the world. (Again - the particulars might be disagreed on)
4) A belief that if you believe the above you will be moved to actions both in regards to your relationship with God and your relationship with others.
Darth - you have any others or reasons to nix any of these?
My mother is Christian. She has a masters degree in theology, and is pursuing studies in divinity. She is a minister in the United Church of Canada.
Courtesy of many years of studies in religion, she is a best described as a deist, views the concept of "God" as mankind's attempts at realizing higher truths, but thinks there might be something indefinable that put the universe into motion. She will readily admit that the bible and religion is a creation of man, and products of the society that made them. She believes Jesus existed as a purely human individual (an old (30-something was old, back then) Essene teacher who happened to be a popular speaker) who wound up being deified by the early Christians. She believes he was crucified for being something of a troublemaker for the Romans and Pharisees (i.e. sedition-type things), but does not believe in the resurrection or any of the much-beloved birth stories.
I enjoy my discussions with her on theology, as it's an area I find fascinating. She knows I'm atheist, but since she realizes my atheism is the result of learning and understanding the history of god instead of just being pissed off at god for a screwed-up world, doesn't care. In fact, there was recently a debate at my university on "Does God Exist", with the theist side presented by kirk Durston (whose arguments were from incredulity at life's existence (i.e. Kalam) and that atheist can't be moral), and the atheist side defended by Tim Schroeder (who I fell did a poor job, focusing mostly on "the world is unpleasant, therefore no god)". I told her of the basic arguments, and she wishes she'd known about it in time to attend. She would have had some very difficult questions for the evangelical Durston.
By any literalist/fundamentalist definition, she is not Christian. But she believes in this "higher truth" and in Jesus the human. She is about as liberal as you get in Christianity, but she'd still call herself a Christian. I'd be inclined to agree.
Your list, as applied to her, would not fit. In her case:
1) God might be a creator who can't be bothered with us, or just might be "higher truth".
2) Jesus was fully human.
3) Jesus lived, died, and stayed dead. His impact was helped by early Christians who were, shall we say, fishermen.
4) God is not necessary for morality, and religion is a bad thing to use as moral source.
In my opinion, all you need to do to fit in to some sect of Christianity somewhere is believe in some higher state of being or truth, and follow Jesus' moral teachings. Well, the good ones, anyway. Regardless of whether they are authentic to the man or not. There will be a sect somewhere to fit you.
In short, I don't think any Christian would be able to reasonable defend the claim that someone else "isn't a true Christian". Perceptions and beliefs differ massively from person to person. Somebody might not be a true Christian by one person's standard, but would be by someone else's. Who is right? All and none.