The Mentality of Skeptics

I feel that we all owe it to ourselves, as "SkeptiBunkers," to check our closets for Natalie Portman on an hourly basis. Just to make sure. Don't forget to check behind Barrack Obama.

Because you never really know 'til you really know, y'know?

Hey- she's due in mine first! Prove otherwise, or else get in line.

Frankly, although I like Obama, if he is in my closet instead when I check later I will be somewhat disappointed. Funny how things work...
 
Frankly, although I like Obama, if he is in my closet instead when I check later I will be somewhat disappointed. Funny how things work...

The fact that Obama could be in your closet is something that worries you, as a denialist, you're threatened by the idea that Obama might be in your closest.
 
The fact that Obama could be in your closet is something that worries you, as a denialist, you're threatened by the idea that Obama might be in your closest.

Except for the ears, he is a pretty good looking guy. So I am threatened by the possibility that my wife is secretly seeing Obama during the day when I am at work, so I am forced to deny the likelihood that he is in my closet. I do this even though I often find Obama 2012 campaign buttons in my closet. But one must delude one's self to get by. And I do feel that it is a little unfair for me to imagine Portman being in my closet and yet being unwilling to allow my wife a similar relationship with Obama. My biggest concern is with Michelle finding out- she looks in pretty good shape and could really hurt us if my wife and I get her angry.
 
Hey- she's due in mine first! Prove otherwise, or else get in line.

Frankly, although I like Obama, if he is in my closet instead when I check later I will be somewhat disappointed. Funny how things work...

I watched Nat, as she likes me to call her, in Black Swan the other night.

Good film.

I closed my eyes and wished but, alas, my cupboard remained bare.
So as long as it's empty I mustn't dismiss the possibility that she might be there but is hiding behind the Monopoly set.
 
Last edited:
I kind of like the idea of a "skeptibunker©," but picture it more as a safe haven from woo and its wild potshots. I am working on plans for a mass produced model. And though I think it's probably best to leave the furnishing of skeptibunkers© to individual purchasers, the idea of finding Natalie Portman in my skeptibunker© seems rather attractive.
 
I watched Nat, as she likes me to call her, in Black Swan the other night.

Good film.

I closed my eyes and wished but, alas, my cupboard remained bare.
So as long as it's empty I must dismiss the possibility that she might be there but was hiding behind the Monopoly set.

Frankly I don't think she and I would be compatible for many reasons- age, interests, looks, etc. But anything is possible!
 
The fact that Obama could be in your closet is something that worries you, as a denialist, you're threatened by the idea that Obama might be in your closest.

I want to find a real live SkeptiBunker in my closet*!

As a close second, any Bigfoot Denialist will do.



*The closet is the best place to keep my anxiety too.
It could be crowded in there. :p

OntarioSquatch,

Am I one of the skeptics who suffers from this existential angst?

I actually came to this forum many years after an experience I had in
Georgia during a training exercise.
After much reading and thinking, I came to realize there were
many more likely explanations for my "sighting" than a random
Bigfoot studying me from behind a scrub pine.

I do not label myself a skeptic, I like to think I am honing my critical
thinking skills. :)

Pixel 42 said:
People have cognitive biases, fallible perceptions and malleable memories. The way that these can cause people to think they have seen something that wasn't really there are well known and well understood. Pointing this out is not "explaining away with some random explanation". Only if plausible mundane explanations do not suffice is it necessary to seriously consider more exotic ones.

Yes, very much this. Thank you Pixel42.
 
I feel that we all owe it to ourselves, as "SkeptiBunkers," to check our closets for Natalie Portman on an hourly basis. Just to make sure. Don't forget to check behind Barrack Obama.

Because you never really know 'til you really know, y'know?
Nope, she only appears when your not looking. You need some expensive equipment to detect her in he closet without disturbing her, preferably from out in the street.

BTW, we may run into problems if two independent researchers detect her in two different closets at the same time. Best if you guys get your ducks in a row first ;)
 
Nope, she only appears when your not looking. You need some expensive equipment to detect her in he closet without disturbing her, preferably from out in the street.

BTW, we may run into problems if two independent researchers detect her in two different closets at the same time. Best if you guys get your ducks in a row first ;)

My spelling checker is having a problem with that last line.

I'm reminded of an old joke about a lady who hosted a dinner party, and a person asked her where she'd been the day before. She said she'd gone to Boston to get scrod, to which the person replied, "Oh, that's how you pronouce it?"
 
My spelling checker is having a problem with that last line.

I'm reminded of an old joke about a lady who hosted a dinner party, and a person asked her where she'd been the day before. She said she'd gone to Boston to get scrod, to which the person replied, "Oh, that's how you pronouce it?"
hu? What's wrong with it... ?
 
Is it possible that Natalie Portman is in your closet?

Yes --- I don't know --- No

If yes, what are the odds?

_:_ --- I don't know


There's no need to check your closet unless you think there's a good chance she's in there.
 
Last edited:
I'm selling plaster casts of Natalie Portman's foot print.
I had a sighting earlier but the camera battery had died.
We should set up a database of sightings.
 
Is it possible that Natalie Portman is in your closet?

Yes --- I don't know --- No

If yes, what are the odds?

_:_ --- I don't know


There's no need to check your closet unless you think there's a good chance she's in there.
By George I think he's got it.
 
Is it possible that Natalie Portman is in your closet?

Yes --- I don't know --- No

If yes, what are the odds?

_:_ --- I don't know


There's no need to check your closet unless you think there's a good chance she's in there.

Oh you want to bring probability back into the argument now despite completely ignoring it when it comes to Figboot?

At this point it would be more intellectually honest if you just invoked Bigfoot as a religious style faith based belief instead of jumping through hoops trying to pretend there is any logic or reason behind it.
 
Is it possible that Natalie Portman is in your closet?

Yes --- I don't know --- No

If yes, what are the odds?

_:_ --- I don't know


There's no need to check your closet unless you think there's a good chance she's in there.

Ah- the default (neutral) presumption is that she is not there, not that one should simply say, "One shouldn't assume whether she is or isn't until one actually looks! Any assumption that she is not indicates that you are biased and not than a true skeptic!"

I do think you got it!

The default position with Bigfoot, or the existence of anything, is the same: that they do not exist.

The question then becomes if the available evidence is sufficient to negate the default position so as to indicate existence. You apparently think that there is enough adequate evidence to do so, allowing you to reach your own conclusion that Bigfoot is an alien-created, genetically engineered superman. I and many other people here think not, and that the available evidence is far too insufficient to negate the default position, that of Bigfoot not existing.

That is a very different question than the one in the OP and which you have been proposing in this thread. Once more: the default assumption for anything is that it doesn't exist or doesn't happen unless there is reasonable evidence that it does (or even might). The proper default position for gorillas was originally that they did not exist. Then evidence began to accumulate, first that there was a reasonable chance that they exist, then strong confirmation that they do. As a result we now accept that gorillas exist. Same for anything- cars, chairs, rain, etc., although for these we obtained a lot of evidence for their existence very early in our lives, so we never had to invoke the default position.

The difference between you and most of the skeptics in this thread is in evaluating the strength of the evidence for Bigfoot to move the assumption from the standard default, no reason to think it exists, to the "Hmmm-possible" and all the way to "Oh yes, certainly." I, in fact, once fell into the might exist category, but the discussion on this forum convinced me to slide back to the default: no reason at all to think that it might exist. This is relevant to the other threads about Bigfoot; not the topic of this thread.
 
Last edited:
Let your brain sort this out for you ;) Its good at statistics. This exercise is exercise of imagination and probabilities beyond what brains need to keep you alive.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom