The Mentality of Skeptics

Neutral would mean that you're not claiming anything. Claiming that something is absent is still a claim and it's a negative one.

Nop, you still don't get even the example you gave. In terms of existence, the neutral is that there is no reason to believe it exists.. Saying it doesn't exist is shorthand for saying that there is no convincing evidence in support of the claim that it does exist.

Now this is even more silly because you claim all sorts of things with no real evidence, including things as to the mental state of the skeptics here. No your whole thread is not based at all on your fervent view of true skepticism, which you violate wholesale. It is only a distraction from your own totally unsubstantiated views on Bigfoot, which lack any real evidence. This is not even an issue of what neutral would be, which you have wrong anyway. Even if true neutral would be no belief in the absence of evidence, there is a slew of evidence against the belief that Bigfoot exists.
 
Last edited:
Let me give you a scientific example. You wish to find out if a new drug lowers blood sugar. You feed it to 100 mice and measure their blood sugar against 100 placebo treated mice.The null hypothesis is that it has no effect. You perform the statistics to find out if the drug treated mice have a lower blood sugar than the placebo, more so than would be observed by just random variation. If the treated mice are statistically no different from the placebo mice, you reach the conclusion that there is no reason to believe the drug has an effect different front the null hypothesis, and by most criteria, you can state that the drug has no observable effect on blood sugar in mice. You can also state that if it does have a tiny effect not of the magnitude that would be observed in your study, the effect must be less than a certain statistical value determined by your experimental statistics.

The neutral conclusion is not that you still don't know.
 
Last edited:
And this is not even close to being reasonable.

So basically that your new angle? You have zero evidence for the giant magical alien monkey man, we have zero evidence against him, so it's a draw?...
Yes, but why do you look at it like its a competition? Are you desperate to have some sort of closure?
:biggrin: So funny! He's equating clear evidence against with not-absolute-proof by pretending that if skeptics can't prove all of it then they can't prove any of it. Which is psychotic. There is in fact vivid no-body "evidence against him" back here in pesky no-body reality, and umm that's no body. Also, there's no body. Wait, did he ever come up with a body? No, right, he didn't so yep, no body. :wink:

It's your claim, so you have a burden of proof.
Once again you're sorely confused. His claim-our claim-all Bigfoot skeptics claim is simply that there is no "scientifically acceptable" evidence that proves there is Bigfoot. Do you have some? Until you cough some up and/or otherwise prove we are in error, we have in fact proven our claim. And yes it's a competition. Between fantasy and reality. We won.
 
Let me give you a scientific example. You wish to find out if a new drug lowers blood sugar. You feed it to 100 mice and measure their blood sugar against 100 placebo treated mice.The null hypothesis is that it has no effect. You perform the statistics to find out if the drug treated mice have a lower blood sugar than the placebo, more so than would be observed by just random variation. If the treated mice are statistically no different from the placebo mice, you reach the conclusion that there is no reason to believe the drug has an effect different front the null hypothesis, and by most criteria, you can state that the drug has no observable effect on blood sugar in mice. You can also state that if it does have a tiny effect not of the magnitude that would be observed in your study, the effect must be less than a certain statistical value determined by your experimental statistics.

The neutral conclusion is not that you still don't know.

The highlighted terms have different meanings and indicate part of the OP's objection. It is one thing to say the the drug does not have the effect you have tested for, quite another to claim the drug is completely inert (the no effect at all state).

For existence questions, a claim of non-existence combines all the attributes you have tested for and attributes you have not tested for. It is one thing to test a specific claim - Obama (or bigfoot) is not in my closet right now - and another to expand that into: Obama (bigfoot) has never been, nor never will be, in my closet, nor any other, ever. All you can ever do is delineate what you have tested, report it, and go on from there.

What actually happens is we get tired of such testing and just say, "Well, OK, ya got me on philosophical grounds. Congrats. Now, call me up when you find Obama in your closet, 'cause I have other things to do."

This is why I only dipped into the bigfoot stuff when that guy was hauling around what he claimed was a dead bigfoot. "Ah, now that's a claim worth examining." It didn't hold up. But at least a claim that big had a chance of altering the landscape.

I'll pay attention when a claim of that magnitude comes up again. But meanwhile, why bother?
 
There aren't thousands of reports of the T-Rex. The Patterson film doesn't show a T-Rex and casts of T-Rex footprints aren't being found in great numbers. In addition to all of that, we have evidence of a mass extinction. That's the difference in my opinion...


Unlike that annoying showoff, Bigfoot, T-rex doesn't prance around like a total dick, looking for attention. T-rex has class.
 
The obvious was The Mentality of Skeptics, which was the thread's title. It got hijacked from psychology, which seems to make SkeptiBunkers uneasy and into something SkeptiBunkers feel much more comfortable talking about. Get back on track.

I love that you think I'm attempting to be a SkeptiBunker, I also love the fact that you're a grown man who typed the word SkeptiBunker with a straight face and thought it was cutting-edge, or that anything about this conversation makes me uncomfortable. Maybe more projection, perhaps?

At any rate, you said I was intentionally ignoring the obvious, and this thread is obviously about Bigfoot. It's not about sceptics, it's about people who don't believe in Bigfoot.

Now, please explain how I've been intentionally ignoring the lack of Bigfoot, and try and do it without all of your back-flipping, somersaulting mental-gymnastics, bro.
 
The obvious was The Mentality of Skeptics, which was the thread's title.

And which the thread's originator has admitted was a misleading title, and claims he's asked the mods to correct. So we have a typical bait-and-switch argument, where the proponents have two incompatible positions so that every time one of them gets shown to be untenable they immediately pretend they were always taking the other; reverse, rinse and repeat as desired.

Dave
 
There aren't thousands of reports of the T-Rex. The Patterson film doesn't show a T-Rex and casts of T-Rex footprints aren't being found in great numbers. In addition to all of that, we have evidence of a mass extinction. That's the difference in my opinion.

Info on what a negative claim is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophic_burden_of_proof#Proving_a_negative

LOL....yeah the increasing number of reports and the lack of alien-monkey man, should clue you into something ;)

Here's something I posted in response to your re-appearance on this forum...

You've relapsed my friend apparently a year away from all things Bigfoot wasn't enough....your inner footer is starting to take over again with the opening statement of your post.
I don't know the depth of your time spent in the woods and I really hate to pull the woodsmen resume card because its not really necessary in truth.

But anyone who wants to attempt to answer the question of the Bigfoot phenomenon (Sharon Hill) needs to do is get on the Internet and start researching a few things, like how and why most NP, NF were established, focus on the timber industry during the late 1800s to early 1900s especially the east coast, as well as animal populations over the past couple of hundred years. Finally how much work is being done currently and by who is keeping tabs on the numerous species that populate NA.

Spend sometime talking to someone like The Shrike his field of study is birds, so he and/or his students are going in the field and studying birds on a regular basis.....now stay with me here.... Theres a Shrike for reptiles, mammals, bugs, fish, plants and on and on in the field on a regular basis counting, observing and leaving traps of all types, cameras, plate traps, ect ect
There are govt entities doing the exact same thing from a resource management perspective.
Not to mention the amateurs...we all know about birders, well guess what it's the same for every other group of animals, I've got a friend who's idea of a hot date is him and his girlfriend spending untold hours in the mountains of Va turning over rocks in stream beds looking for salamanders.
Then there the hunters, hikers, campers, join a site called White Blaze it's for AT thru hikers ask them about Bigfoot a few stories but for the most part meh nothing.

My point is start at the beginning if there's any undocumented large animal in NA how would it get missed and what is currently being done to keep track of the known fauna. Just a cursory look will yield your answer, there's no way any animal over 50lbs has gone undiscovered in NA.

Or using established scientific protocol or just common sense here's my unscientific breakdown
1) locals report creature
2) evidence of creature is gathered
3) new creature discovered

Bigfoot has never gotten beyond #1, but proponents like yourself want to fill in the blanks for why that hasn't happened giving Bigfoot all sorts of extraordinary abilities that may exist in some species in almost exclusivity of all others.
Bigfoots got it all night vision, super stealthy, invisibility, super stinky not super stinky, super strength, sub-sonic zapping, hibernation, lives in caves, hangs out in trees, great swimmer, leaps tall brush piles in a single bound, mind reader, speaks english but hollers alot for no reason, knows what a camera is but keeps getting shot at and of course plenty of freetime to play cat n mouse with the NAWACKYs during spring beak/summer vacation.

Sure lets talk about the food issue there's only a couple of apex omnivores in NA one hibernates the other builds its own homes to survive the winter sorry I see no evidence that a third made it to current times....in fact if Bigfoot ever existed as described by proponents today they would be at the top of the heap.

I know, I know, they are the at one with nature super being sorry don't buy the Avatar malarkey the native Americans held that spot and we took care of that in a horrible example of how things have always worked out between hominids...subjugation, assimilation and/or extinction.

So in conclusion Bigfoot must be a social construct evident by the complete lack of verifiable evidence but to this day gets reported on a regular basis.
Pretty sciencey sounding huh?

But in all seriousness OS spend enough time outdoors just observing and you will see almost every species out there or real evidence of their existence.
I have and while I've had some weird stuff happen none of it points to anything like Bigfoot.
 
Last edited:
Note to mods: There seems to be some disagreement about the topic of this thread. While it is still called "The Mentality of Skeptics", I will continue to post about claims about this subject. If and when the title is changed, I will of course cease and desist.
Now, getting back to jakesteele:
As I said, you didn't read the rest of the post. If you had, then you would have seen what I called ratpacking. That should have been obvious in the first 100 posts.

Actually, no you didn't. You seem to have forgotten your original post. This is what you claimed this thread displayed:

I got your ‘outraged hounds of hell’ right here:
This was my first real taste of shrill, irrational, arrogant, condescending, insulting psuedoskepticism when I started coming to this site. This is mine, but I have seen this many times on the Gen.Skept/CT forums. Don’t bother asking me for links when you’ve got two forums full of them.

http://www.internationalskeptics.co...50&highlight=Jenny+McCarthy+Body+Count+Online


I’ll just repeat the slurs and insults I’ve heard so many times; kook, nutter, CTer, woo, Xian, tin foil hatter, Troofer.

Nice dodge, but I'm afraid yaks are noted for their good memories.
I spent a lot of time showing how this thread demonstrated none of the points you claimed it did.
Moving the goalposts won't help you, old bean. You were, I'm afraid, shot down in flames. Have the decency to admit it.
 
The highlighted terms have different meanings and indicate part of the OP's objection. It is one thing to say the the drug does not have the effect you have tested for, quite another to claim the drug is completely inert (the no effect at all state).

For existence questions, a claim of non-existence combines all the attributes you have tested for and attributes you have not tested for. It is one thing to test a specific claim - Obama (or bigfoot) is not in my closet right now - and another to expand that into: Obama (bigfoot) has never been, nor never will be, in my closet, nor any other, ever. All you can ever do is delineate what you have tested, report it, and go on from there.

What actually happens is we get tired of such testing and just say, "Well, OK, ya got me on philosophical grounds. Congrats. Now, call me up when you find Obama in your closet, 'cause I have other things to do."

This is why I only dipped into the bigfoot stuff when that guy was hauling around what he claimed was a dead bigfoot. "Ah, now that's a claim worth examining." It didn't hold up. But at least a claim that big had a chance of altering the landscape.

I'll pay attention when a claim of that magnitude comes up again. But meanwhile, why bother?
We can differ in how we view the details of the language, but I think that the highlighted portion of your own quote is a sufficient and a point on which we can agree. There is no current reason to believe that Bigfoot exists.

Of course no one can eliminate every possibility that some version of Bigfoot exists in some narrow fashion in some very specific manner that would explain the lack of convincing evidence. Just like the mouse drug study, however, we can state with a high precision that there is no evidence and therefore no reason to believe that Bigfoot exists in the form as is often claimed by his advocates. The null hypothesis in my mouse example is that the drug has no measurable effect on blood glucose, not that it might have some other effect. But the same null hypothesis applies to these other effects as well" there is no reason to think that the drug has any effect until sufficient evidence is accumulated that it does.

With Bigfoot, multiple forms of evidence for his existence are absent, so multiple potential forms of Bigfoot existence have been found to be indistinguishable from the null (non-existence) hypothesis. Of course Bigfoot might exist only in vast underground cities powered by nuclear fusion with his poop recycled, his dead incinerated, and he goes out only in an invisibility cloak. But here too there is no evidence in favor of this explanation, so the null hypothesis is still appropriate until we find evidence in its favor.

Am I willing to boldly state that there is no Bigfoot? No, not if we are dealing with formal language, just as I would not formally claim "all dinosaurs are extinct" (in fact some people few birds as surviving "dinosaurs"). But I am willing to state that the chances of Bigfoot existing are so very very small that it is not worth bothering about until more convincing evidence is obtained in the future. I am happy to state that there is no significant evidence that Bigfoot exists in any fashion that has been proposed, and that the default/neutral is that therefore there is no reason to believe that he exists. Nonetheless I would be pleased and excited if new information is obtained in the future that causes me to re-evaluate my current view.
 
I'm amazed that the concept of why "You can't provide enough counter evidence to disprove the thing which I am going out of my neither provide any evidence for nor define clearly exists... therefore it exists" is not an intellectually solid position is even up for debate.
 
Somebody bring me up to speed. Have we been properly chastised for not believing every damn fool thing that hits the 'net?

No, because we're skeptics, and this thread is about denialists. Except that all of the denialists are also skeptics, so all skeptics are denialists, though there isn't actually any evidence that any specific skeptics are denialists. And except that the thread isn't actually about denialists, it's about skeptics, until it isn't.

That clear?

Dave
 
No. It almost happens and then someone imagines another damn fool thing and we have to start all over.

In order not to be classified as a poor skeptic by anonymous posters on the internet I'm buying into Bigfoot, UFO's, Kirilian Photography, Ouija boards. homeopathy ect. ect. cet. We all Jake now?
 
I have imagined things involving Natalie Portman which initially appeared to me to be implausible, but thankfully I now understand that they are as possible as impossible given the lack of information to the contrary. She may even be in my closet (I intend to look after I complete this post). The existence of Ms. Portman in my closet may create problems with my wife, but then again they may not (I am trying to maintain a neutral perspective here). Wish me luck!
 
I feel that we all owe it to ourselves, as "SkeptiBunkers," to check our closets for Natalie Portman on an hourly basis. Just to make sure. Don't forget to check behind Barrack Obama.

Because you never really know 'til you really know, y'know?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom