The Mentality of Skeptics

Ah- the default (neutral) presumption is that she is not there, not that one should simply say, "One shouldn't assume whether she is or isn't until one actually looks! Any assumption that she is not indicates that you are biased and not than a true skeptic!"

This is a bias. It may be useful, but a bias nonetheless. One could start anywhere and allow evidence to change your mind to accomplish the same thing.

The default position with Bigfoot, or the existence of anything, is the same: that they do not exist.

If this were adopted as rationally sound, we would have no reason to look for anything - we already assume there's nothing to be found. Instead, our default may very well be "something" rather than "nothing," since we have much more experience with the former than the latter.

It's this principle (something rather than nothing) which leads us to offer explanations for the smooshy evidence presented for bigfoot - the blurry image shows a bear, or is an artifact of the lighting conditions, but still "something" rather than "nothing." We present alternative explanations to demonstrate the evidence cannot distinguish between different interpretations.

Existence questions are tricky. Does the tallest person in the world exist? I can't show him/her to you, since any person I show you is only an example of a tall person - there may be someone taller somewhere. Yet, I believe there is a tallest person, that they actually exist. Have the default of non-existence doesn't work well in this case because I extrapolate the concept of ranking by height (which I have evidence for) into this new realm, where I do not have such evidence.
 
There's no need to check your closet unless you think there's a good chance she's in there.

Are you sure? I think you're just afraid to check whether Natalie Portman is in your closet because you can't cope with the ambiguity of the situation. You really ought to try to overcome your fears by checking, at least daily, whether Natalie Portman is in your closet.

Dave
 
Are you sure? I think you're just afraid to check whether Natalie Portman is in your closet because you can't cope with the ambiguity of the situation. You really ought to try to overcome your fears by checking, at least daily, whether Natalie Portman is in your closet.



Dave


Just be wary if Good N Plentys start getting tossed out of your closet.
Nat's well known for liking them.
 
This is a bias. It may be useful, but a bias nonetheless. One could start anywhere and allow evidence to change your mind to accomplish the same thing.



If this were adopted as rationally sound, we would have no reason to look for anything - we already assume there's nothing to be found. Instead, our default may very well be "something" rather than "nothing," since we have much more experience with the former than the latter.
It's this principle (something rather than nothing) which leads us to offer explanations for the smooshy evidence presented for bigfoot - the blurry image shows a bear, or is an artifact of the lighting conditions, but still "something" rather than "nothing." We present alternative explanations to demonstrate the evidence cannot distinguish between different interpretations.

Existence questions are tricky. Does the tallest person in the world exist? I can't show him/her to you, since any person I show you is only an example of a tall person - there may be someone taller somewhere. Yet, I believe there is a tallest person, that they actually exist. Have the default of non-existence doesn't work well in this case because I extrapolate the concept of ranking by height (which I have evidence for) into this new realm, where I do not have such evidence.

You seem to very much want to make this point- but your point is actually very different from what we are discussing: the formal default assumption is always lack of existence. This assumption is a logical construct, not a block to all inquiry. One can logically assume that something does not exist until sufficient evidence indicates otherwise, but that does not mean that one is not permitted to look for that evidence. Seeking to test the default is valid and is different from stating that at the onset we have no evidence to contradict the default and what is proper to believe in the absence of any evidence.

And if you think about it, people almost always seek to prove the existence of something not yet proven because there is some evidence, if weak, of its existence. The logical default assumption is that there is no life on Mars. To show that there is, one must obtain sufficient convincing evidence to negate this default. Such convincing evidence has yet to be obtained. But that doesn't mean that it is wrong to want to look (and in fact there is some reason to think that is worth looking in that some of the information that we do have indicates that it is possible that the default is wrong and there might be life on Mars}. In contrast people are not actively looking for a 4 star restaurant on Mars because the evidence we do have gives us no reason to question the default, that there is no 4 star restaurant on Mars.

As to the second highlighted quotation- I think you mis-stated it: logic very much demands that there must be a tallest man on the planet, even if they are only 5 feet. This is the logic inherent to superlatives. It just doesn't allow you to say that you have located the actual, specific, tallest man until you measured every man on the planet. But a tallest man must exist (if there are at least three men)! Perhaps a better analogy is if you stated that the tallest man on the planet is 10 feet high. The logical default in this case is that they do not exist, and you would need to provide evidence that they do exist to make such a statement accurate. But you are free to look for such evidence. The logic of what to assume does not limit one's ability to test that assumption.

In fact, the same is true if you stated that there are men as much as 6 feet tall on the planet: the logical default is that there are not, but there is a lot of convincing pre-existing evidence that such people exist, so we have good reason to know that the default is wrong. It doesn't make the logic wrong- the logic is a pathway to follow to discover the truth and simply states that the initial assumption is non-existence and that one needs to prove existence. In the case of all the things we currently accept as existing, it is because the evidence is indeed convincing.
 
Last edited:
That sounds exactly like a negative claim, not a neutral position

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophic_burden_of_proof#Proving_a_negative

1. As discussed before, it states the overwhelming probability that she is not there.
2. For such extraordinarily unlikely events the typical language shortcut is to state it as "She is not there." The formal statement, which I am certain that you always use in your own speech about everything in your life is that "These is no evidence to suggest that she is there, and given that the default under these circumstances is the lack of her existence in my closet, it is a logical assumption that she is not in my closet unless and until I obtain solid evidence to the contrary." Or should I even expect that if someone asks you if you own a cheetah, you don't just say no, but instead state, "Well I have no evidence that I own a cheetah. But I don't want to make a negative claim, so I am only willing to state that I don't know if I own a cheetah."

Well, maybe you didn't get it after all.
 
Last edited:
One can logically assume that something does not exist until sufficient evidence indicates otherwise,

Argument from ignorance, also known as appeal to ignorance (in which ignorance stands for "lack of evidence to the contrary"), is a fallacy in informal logic. It asserts that a proposition is true because it has not yet been proven false (or vice versa).

Examples:

X is true because it hasn't been proven to be false.
X is false because it hasn't been proven to be true.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_ignorance
 
This is a bias. It may be useful, but a bias nonetheless. One could start anywhere and allow evidence to change your mind to accomplish the same thing.



If this were adopted as rationally sound, we would have no reason to look for anything - we already assume there's nothing to be found. Instead, our default may very well be "something" rather than "nothing," since we have much more experience with the former than the latter.

It's this principle (something rather than nothing) which leads us to offer explanations for the smooshy evidence presented for bigfoot - the blurry image shows a bear, or is an artifact of the lighting conditions, but still "something" rather than "nothing." We present alternative explanations to demonstrate the evidence cannot distinguish between different interpretations.

Existence questions are tricky. Does the tallest person in the world exist? I can't show him/her to you, since any person I show you is only an example of a tall person - there may be someone taller somewhere. Yet, I believe there is a tallest person, that they actually exist. Have the default of non-existence doesn't work well in this case because I extrapolate the concept of ranking by height (which I have evidence for) into this new realm, where I do not have such evidence.
Why is the certainty that Natalie Portman is not in my closet applicable to anything else that is suggested to be in my closet. Knowing without any rational doubt a list of things that are not in my closet does not consign the more likely contents to nothing. I know there is something in my closet. I do not even know all the somethings that are in there, though I know some. What I also know is that Natalie Portman is not there, and I do not have to check the closet to know. External evidence abounds.

Does a tallest person exist? Sure, there must be a tallest person in the world. It does not follow that I, or anyone else, could ever discover reliably who that is. The fact that there is such a thing is true by definition, as you note. It would be true no matter how many people there are in the world, no matter where they may be, and no matter even whether they are all the same height, since this is a championship that can easily be shared. Because of that, it can be presumed true without actually finding it. There is a deepest spot in the ocean too, but I do not have to dive into the ocean to find it. If I define what "deepest" means, then every body of water must by definition have a deepest point, and I can confidently say that this is true even of bodies of water that are themselves unknown.

I don't see how that issue relates to the question of knowing what is not in my closet.

There is also not an elephant in my closet. I do not have to look inside to know this, because my closet is demonstrably smaller than an elephant. I do not think this is substantially different from the evidence that some things that one might squeeze into my closet are also not in it. A sufficient abundance of surmises, while it may not constitute the legal definition of certainty, is, for all intents and purposes, certainty. I know that I have not given Natalie Portman a key to my front door, and surmise that she has not had one made. I surmise that she has no knowledge of where I live and has not chosen my house as a place to hide. I surmise that she would not have broken in in my absence, and that she does not know the way to the one closet in the house into which she might fit, and that she did not hide the contents of the closet that she would have to take out to do so, and that she did not sneak into rural Vermont unnoticed by anyone, and so on and so on. I REALLY REALLY REALLY don't have to look in my closet to know, not what is in my closet, nor where Natalie Portman is at any moment, but the utterly certain fact that whatever is in my closet and wherever she may be, she's NOT THERE!

Knowing what is in a place may overlap, but is not the same thing as knowing what is not.
 
Last edited:
Argument from ignorance, also known as appeal to ignorance (in which ignorance stands for "lack of evidence to the contrary"), is a fallacy in informal logic. It asserts that a proposition is true because it has not yet been proven false (or vice versa).

Examples:

X is true because it hasn't been proven to be false.
X is false because it hasn't been proven to be true.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_ignorance

You can quote it, but you don't really understand it. It is not an appeal to ignorance at all. In the absence of evidence to the contrary one must make an assumption. The default assumption is the null hypothesis. This is not an appeal to ignorance: it is where one starts the chain of logic; an appeal to ignorance is where one ends the chain of logic.

My god this whole discussion has gotten too silly for me. If you believe this, then you must accept the possible existence of everything and anything, especially because one can't disprove anything to a certainty, only to a very very very high precision. How can you know if your house wasn't destroyed today when you were at work to create a galactic bypass until you go home and look? How do you know that your wife hasn't magically turned into Natalie Portman until you actually look? Is this really how you live your life?

But again, this is just the established way statistics looks at things: it starts with the default assumption of lack of effect or existence. Look it up. This is absolutely the prevailing concept and has been very useful in establishing if something is true or not. But what makes the entire discussion especially silly is that the question with Bigfoot is not only if non-existence is the proper logical default in the total absence of evidence, but even more importantly if the existing evidence for outweighs the existing evidence against. And most of us vote the latter, by far. This is just in terms of existence vs non-existence, let alone your bizarre and completely unsupported take on what Bigfofot is. And your statements as to what I, or the other posters here, are thinking and why.
 
You seem to very much want to make this point- but your point is actually very different from what we are discussing: the formal default assumption is always lack of existence. This assumption is a logical construct, not a block to all inquiry. One can logically assume that something does not exist until sufficient evidence indicates otherwise, but that does not mean that one is not permitted to look for that evidence. Seeking to test the default is valid and is different from stating that at the onset we have no evidence to contradict the default and what is proper to believe in the absence of any evidence.

It's a counterfactual, which is why it starts with "if." I do not believe this is the actual default position used. What actually happens is we imagine some state of affairs that interests us or appeals to us, and check to see if our imagining matches up with reality. We aren't merely taking anything that comes along, but actively seeking evidence for a thing we previously think might be so.

We don't spend much time searching for life on the moon because we can't imagine how the moon could support life. Logically however, Mars and the moon occupy the same state of ignorance (or would as a default).

I don't know, but I assume the people who search for bigfoot think bigfoot is a possibility, in the same way that people who search for evidence of life on Mars think there might be life to find. But in both cases, the default isn't "no life/bigfoot," but "might be life/bigfoot."

This is why I presented it as a counterfactual. For all the insistence in this thread, I don't think we actually operate with non-existence as the default (in the interesting cases). The same motivation toward discovery motivates the guy who spends his vacations in the deep woods with camera ready as it motivates me to vote to increase NASA's budget. We both hope to discover something amazing.
 
Last edited:
My God- I looked in my closet and there was Natalie Portman! I was wrong!
Sorry, but I might be gone for a while from this thread- Natalie would like a bit of brunch, and then we are going for a walk around town. Evening plans may get complicated because of my wife, but I don't want to make a claim as to her feelings about Natalie until I find out.
As to you other guys expecting Ms. Portman in their closets- she is running behind schedule but keep looking.
 
It's a counterfactual, which is why it starts with "if." I do not believe this is the actual default position used. What actually happens is we imagine some state of affairs that interests us or appeals to us, and check to see if our imagining matches up with reality. We aren't merely taking anything that comes along, but actively seeking evidence for a thing we previously think might be so.

We don't spend much time searching for life on the moon because we can't imagine how the moon could support life. Logically however, Mars and the moon occupy the same state of ignorance (or would as a default).

I don't know, but I assume the people who search for bigfoot think bigfoot is a possibility, in the same way that people who search for evidence of life on Mars think there might be life to find. But in both cases, the default isn't "no life/bigfoot," but "might be life/bigfoot."

This is why I presented it as a counterfactual. For all the insistence in this thread, I don't think we actually operate with non-existence as the default (in the interesting cases). The same motivation toward discovery motivates the guy who spends his vacations in the deep woods with camera ready as it motivates me to vote to increase NASA's budget. We both hope to discover something amazing.

Highlight- certainly not. We have quite a bit of evidence as to the conditions on the Moon versus Mars, and are far from ignorant as to either. My point is exactly what you imply: the logical default is that there is no life on either. But we already have evidence about each that indicates that the logical default may not be true for Mars (certain enough to look, if not enough to convincingly falsify the default), but no reason to believe that the default is wrong for the Moon. It would be wrong to assume that the chances of finding life (as we know it) are equally uncertain for each.

You appear to be discussing some sort of "emotional" default of humans, whereas I see this thread relating to the proper formal logic default. Humans often imagine many things, seek out evidence for some of these, and are sometimes correct. But the logical assumption in the absence of convincing evidence is that an entity or an event doesn't exist, such that it would be wrong to conclude the existence of such things in the absence of convincing evidence. Again, not that it is wrong to imagine the possibility, or even to suspect it enough to look for this type of convincing evidence. But the logical presumption is that until such evidence is obtained, the correct assumption is that it does not exist.

As I stated again and again above, the issue with Bigfoot in particular is not even the logical default in the absence of evidence, because there is evidence available already. For some, this evidence convinces them that Bigfoot is an alien engineered superhuman. For others the balance of evidence convinces them that Bigfoot does not exist at all. So the OP is inherently wrong and we are discussing an entirely different question: what the evidence would lead one to conclude, not the default in the absence of any evidence. And this discussion should therefore be in one of the other threads.

In any case- Natalie is getting bored and I have to go.
 
Last edited:
Argument from ignorance, also known as appeal to ignorance (in which ignorance stands for "lack of evidence to the contrary"), is a fallacy in informal logic.

1. Despite how you are trying to spin it the "Argument from Ignorance Fallacy" does not allow you to make up random baseless assertions and demand people disprove them to your satisfaction.

2. There's still no Bigfoot.

3. If you believed in your... unique interpretation of the "Argument from Ignorance Fallacy" you wouldn't just be cheerleading for the giant magical alien monkey man, but all manner of unsupported assertions.

4. There's still no Bigfoot.

5. There is mountains of evidence that disproves Bigfoot to an amazingly high probability, you just choose to ignore it or special plead it away.

6. There's still no Bigfoot.
 
That sounds exactly like a negative claim, not a neutral position

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophic_burden_of_proof#Proving_a_negative
I admit I've probably made a mistake in giving you too much intellectual 'credit' in your career here. So let's dumb it down a bit. If "the beast doesn't exist" isn't the neutral position at present given the wholesale lack of evidence, what is the neutral position? And please explain in an intelligent way how YOU not having proper "Bigfoot evidence" is somehow OUR fault and that in fact such deficiency actually proves Bigfoot lives.

Argument from ignorance, also known as appeal to ignorance (in which ignorance stands for "lack of evidence to the contrary"), is a fallacy in informal logic. It asserts that a proposition is true because it has not yet been proven false (or vice versa).

Examples:

X is true because it hasn't been proven to be false.
X is false because it hasn't been proven to be true.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_ignorance
I'm getting the distinct impression you don't really understand this fallacy. You, the rocket scientist known as OntarioSquatch, are the one asserting that something is true (Bigfoot) because it has not yet been proven false. It gets more hilarious. In just the second paragraph of the Wikipedia™ article you linked to it says explicitly "In debates, appeals to ignorance are sometimes used in an attempt to shift the burden of proof." Which is precisely what you've been trying to do.

So what exactly is our supposed NEGATIVE CLAIM that bumps us into logical fallacy anyway? Is it our claim that you don't have any Bigfoot evidence that proves the beast's existence? That's not a negative claim (despite your pretending) AND we don't have to prove it to boot. It is a natural fact until YOU PROVE otherwise. It's that simple. YOU have to prove YOUR CLAIM independent of anything we need to do. Otherwise it's just your wet dreams and didn't happen.

Seems ever since you discovered Wikipedia™ you've completely discarded the notion that to prove Bigfoot you need evidence. Now it's just a constant barrage of Wikipedia™ inspired Straw from you trying to throw the entire discussion into lame confusion about why you are not supplying the proper proof for your Bigfoot claim.

That is, do you realize your 'in need of counseling' position is: There is a Bigfoot and until you wannabe amateur skeptics prove there isn't one, there is one. :boggled:
 
That sounds exactly like a negative claim, not a neutral position

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophic_burden_of_proof#Proving_a_negative

Ever since your mate Less Than Jake showed up, you've begun a whirlwind-romance with the technicalities of scepticism. How funny. You're the last person to bother trying to think logically, and the first person to attempt to use the language of scepticism against scepticism itself.

You couldn't be more of a mental-gymnast even if your frontal-lobe was wearing a sweat-band.
 
Which is the pretend mentality of a person who starts a thread about the mentality of someone else who doesn't appear to think like he/she does.

He certainly knows that there's bugger-all out there to find, which is why he admittedly doesn't bother to "look" for it, and nor has he ever seen one.

Apparently, it's not even in his best interests to converse about Bigfoot with like-minded gamers believers, he'd sooner participate on a sceptical forum where he can begin bait-threads and generally have a whinge about how everyone is bashing his fantasy.
 
He certainly knows that there's bugger-all out there to find, which is why he admittedly doesn't bother to "look" for it, and nor has he ever seen one.
Nobody appears to bother looking for it very seriously (if at all): Northern Lites (and his intrepid tracker Jim), OS, Patterson.

The folks who seem most involved are those goofs on Not Finding Bigfoot and they (and we) know they're not gonna find it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom