This is a bias. It may be useful, but a bias nonetheless. One could start anywhere and allow evidence to change your mind to accomplish the same thing.
If this were adopted as rationally sound, we would have no reason to look for anything - we already assume there's nothing to be found. Instead, our default may very well be "something" rather than "nothing," since we have much more experience with the former than the latter.
It's this principle (something rather than nothing) which leads us to offer explanations for the smooshy evidence presented for bigfoot - the blurry image shows a bear, or is an artifact of the lighting conditions, but still "something" rather than "nothing." We present alternative explanations to demonstrate the evidence cannot distinguish between different interpretations.
Existence questions are tricky. Does the tallest person in the world exist? I can't show him/her to you, since any person I show you is only an example of a tall person - there may be someone taller somewhere. Yet, I believe there is a tallest person, that they actually exist. Have the default of non-existence doesn't work well in this case because I extrapolate the concept of ranking by height (which I have evidence for) into this new realm, where I do not have such evidence.
You seem to very much want to make this point- but your point is actually very different from what we are discussing: the formal default assumption is always
lack of existence. This assumption is a logical construct, not a block to all inquiry. One can logically assume that something does not exist until sufficient evidence indicates otherwise, but that does not mean that one is not permitted to look for that evidence. Seeking to test the default is valid and is different from stating that at the onset we have no evidence to contradict the default and what is proper to believe in the absence of any evidence.
And if you think about it,
people almost always seek to prove the existence of something not yet proven because there is some evidence, if weak, of its existence. The logical default assumption is that there is no life on Mars. To show that there is, one must obtain sufficient convincing evidence to negate this default. Such convincing evidence has yet to be obtained. But that doesn't mean that it is wrong to want to look (and in fact there is some reason to think that is worth looking in that some of the information that we do have indicates that it is possible that the default is wrong and there might be life on Mars}. In contrast people are not actively looking for a 4 star restaurant on Mars because the evidence we do have gives us no reason to question the default, that there is no 4 star restaurant on Mars.
As to the second highlighted quotation- I think you mis-stated it: logic very much demands that there
must be a tallest man on the planet, even if they are only 5 feet.
This is the logic inherent to superlatives. It just doesn't allow you to say that you have located the actual, specific, tallest man until you measured every man on the planet. But a tallest man must exist (if there are at least three men)! Perhaps a better analogy is if you stated that the tallest man on the planet is 10 feet high. The logical default in this case is that they do not exist, and you would need to provide evidence that they do exist to make such a statement accurate. But you are free to look for such evidence. The logic of what to assume does not limit one's ability to test that assumption.
In fact, the same is true if you stated that there are men as much as 6 feet tall on the planet: the logical default is that there are not, but there is a lot of convincing pre-existing evidence that such people exist, so we have good reason to know that the default is wrong. It doesn't make the
logic wrong- the logic is a pathway to follow to discover the truth and simply states that the initial assumption is non-existence and that one needs to prove existence. In the case of all the things we currently accept as existing, it is because the evidence is indeed convincing.