The Mentality of Skeptics

OntarioSquatch,

Am I one of the skeptics who suffers from this existential angst?

I actually came to this forum many years after an experience I had in
Georgia during a training exercise.
After much reading and thinking, I came to realize there were
many more likely explanations for my "sighting" than a random
Bigfoot studying me from behind a scrub pine.

I do not label myself a skeptic, I like to think I am honing my critical
thinking skills. :)


According to Major League Gaming Member 3,043: OS, everyone is a denialist, but they also secretly worry about not being certain, which implies that they're actually believers, it's all very confusing.
 
According to Major League Gaming Member 3,043: OS, everyone is a denialist, but they also secretly worry about not being certain, which implies that they're actually believers, it's all very confusing.


Oh what a tangled web we weave, When the aim of BLAARGing is to deceive.
 
Nobody appears to bother looking for it very seriously (if at all): Northern Lites (and his intrepid tracker Jim), OS, Patterson.

The folks who seem most involved are those goofs on Not Finding Bigfoot and they (and we) know they're not gonna find it.

That was literally the only reason why I offered to bet with NL, or any believer, for that matter. I just wanted to see how confident they actually were. Apparently, they're about as confident of finding Bigfoot as I am of finding Natalie Portman behind a crouching Barrack Obama in my wardrobe.
 
Oh what a tangled web we weave, When the aim of BLAARGing is to deceive.

I guess it mean's that we're all believers who're trapped in the closet...behind either Natalie Portman, or Barrack Obama, and possibly R-Kelly, depending on which scenario you find to be more likely. Remember now: you don't know until you know, bro.
 
I guess it mean's that we're all believers who're trapped in the closet...behind either Natalie Portman, or Barrack Obama, and possibly R-Kelly, depending on which scenario you find to be more likely. Remember now: you don't know until you know, bro.


Erm... Are we now "trapped in the closet?" Oh dear.
I truly hope that Tom Cruise and John Travolta aren't trapped in my closet Also.
They can stay in their own stinkin' closets. I only have space for Natalie.
 
The fact that Obama could be in your closet is something that worries you, as a denialist, you're threatened by the idea that Obama might be in your closest.

Bang! There goes my worldview blowing up, if you need me I'll be under the bed.
 
I've never said that.

But you blatantly did say that almost everyone who posts regularly in the Bigfoot threads flips from believing to not believing, which, of course, was a load of unsubstantiated bollocks, which you never once bothered to correct. Underhanded behaviour.

You really ought to start being more specific.
 
Last edited:
Is it possible that Natalie Portman is in your closet?

Yes --- I don't know --- No

If yes, what are the odds?

_:_ --- I don't know


There's no need to check your closet unless you think there's a good chance she's in there.

But you check your closet anyway because:

1. She might be in there. (Robert Downey Jr once stumbled into the wrong house while stoned and passed out in someone's bedroom).
2. I really want to find Natalie Portman in my closet, and the only way to confirm that she is or is not there is get off my lazy backside and look...seriously, ten seconds out of my day.
3. Once you've confirmed that she's not in there you have to reevaluate your thesis.

Most skeptics have no need to check their closet for Ms. Portman, but some might because checking your closet is sometimes a good thing as it might be time to clean it out. The main reason they would not check is because Ms. Portman has no behavioral pattern of hiding in stranger's closets.

But, we know Natalie Portman exists. Should we wish to see her in person all we have to do is wait for one of her six up-coming movies to premier and make the journey to Hollywood - with our cameras - and hang out near the red carpet.

If we were to apply the Natalie Portman model (I'm inventing this) to Bigfoot we'd have definitive evidence one way or the other.

But if we applied to Bigfoot "research" Model to Ms. Portman nobody would bother going to a premier with a quality camera, there would be specualtion that she has been in movies that nobody knows about, or has had uncredited cameos in thousands of movies.

Worst of all we would be subjected to grainy, out of focus, and blurry pictures of her (which would be the biggest crime).
 
if you need me I'll be under the bed.

Ah, rookie mistake! There may or may not possibly be monsters lurking under there, chances are that there isn't, but you never really, truly know. Better to check under there at least once every few hours, just work it into the closet-check routine. Better to be safe than in denial, in your SkeptiBunker.
 
Gee- why should I look in my closet? If Ms. Portman was there she would already probably be in a relationship with President Obama. And I can't compete with him- my ears are a little smaller but I don't even have my own airplane and I have less interesting stories to tell.
 
Bang! There goes my worldview blowing up, if you need me I'll be under the bed.

Can you even fit there with the horrible monster that's been living under the bed since I was 5 years old? It is true that at that age I was too scared to look. But I was fairly convinced, even without any evidence, and quite willing to tell my mom and dad that there was probably a monster under my bed. Once it actually came out late at night to frighten me; it turned out to be my older brother. Once I recognized him, I still tried to kill him!
 
But you blatantly did say that almost everyone who posts regularly in the Bigfoot threads flips from believing to not believing [is a denialist]

Context corrected. I don't know what percentage of denialists have switched beliefs in the past, but it doesn't really matter. The driving force behind every one of them is their inability to handle uncertainty and that's what was supposed to be the main topic here.
 
Context corrected. I don't know what percentage of denialists have switched beliefs in the past, but it doesn't really matter. The driving force behind every one of them is their inability to handle uncertainty and that's what was supposed to be the main topic here.

:sdl::sdl::dl::sdl::sdl::dl::sdl::sdl:
 
Context corrected. I don't know what percentage of denialists have switched beliefs in the past, but it doesn't really matter. The driving force behind every one of them is their inability to handle uncertainty and that's what was supposed to be the main topic here.

Actually it is plumbing that fills me with uncertainty, leaving me unwilling to do repairs to my bathroom. It is the vision of a geyser spouting from my toilet that I can't handle. Bigfoot? Not a problem.
 
Context corrected. I don't know what percentage of denialists have switched beliefs in the past, but it doesn't really matter. The driving force behind every one of them is their inability to handle uncertainty and that's what was supposed to be the main topic here.

How do you know the second if you don't know the first?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom