The Mentality of Skeptics

You can assume that you know all the factors involved, but in the end you'd just be assuming you know them based on the existence of other large mammals.

You keep using that word . . .

Not assumptions but accurate predictions made through cross-disciplined scientific observations of animal behavior/characteristics in their natural state. You claim footie to be a natural creature inhabiting a finite environment, but offer nothing but special pleading and conspiracy theory when asked for scientific evidence of bigfoot occupying that finite environment.
 
=Cosmic Yak;11031128]I read, as I said, 100 posts of the thread that you linked to, the thread you claimed displayed the kind of behaviour you keep complaining about. Is there anything in the rest of the thread that refutes or invalidates what I said about the first three pages? If there is, why did you not link to that in the first place? Or are you simply trying to claim, as with so many woo-mongers, that "the proof is just around the corner, it's really really there, but I can't quite point you to it"?

As I said, you didn't read the rest of the post. If you had, then you would have seen what I called ratpacking. That should have been obvious in the first 100 posts. Woo monger? Isn't that some of what you wanted to see?
It's not right around the corner, it's in the first 100 posts and 'further on down the road'.

Moving on to your analogy: this isn't a fist fight. It's a forum. If you want a private conversation with just two participants, do that instead. Don't post on a public forum with numerous members and then whine that more than one of those members is participating in a discussion with you.

#425 Cosmic Yak
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=301143&page=11

I am well aware that you are talking about the psychology of debunkers. However, that psychology will still be manifested in real-world behaviour, which in the case of this forum will be actual posts. My question stands unanswered: Can you quote someone actually displaying this kind of mindset? Somehow I doubt it.....

As I said, fist fight with one, 2 or more guys jump in, ratpacking.

Once again: I spent a considerable amount of time dissecting your reply to me, in the expectation you would respond in an honest, equally detailed and courteous manner. I was clearly wrong. Your dismissive, curt answers are woefully short of adequate, lacking in substance and largely ignore most of the points I made.
If this is the way you operate, how can you expect posters here to treat you in any other way than the way you treat them?

See my re-address of this post 'further on down the line'>
 
The phrase "no evidence" keeps coming up in this thread. It is an example of what the OP sees as denialism vs. skepticism.

I have to mention again that bigfootery isn't my thing - the only "case" I followed was the guy hauling the doll around in a trailer - so my examples are only drawn from supposition.

Someone posts blurred images. They mention tales of seeing bigfoot. They offer up various physical evidences (casts of footprints, torn tree bark or hair).

This is not "no evidence." It may be poor quality evidence and fail to convince me, but it isn't "no evidence." From the footer's point of view, he only has the evidence available to work with and can reasonably say the consilience of evidence has convinced him. I may disagree, deciding that the evidence is not compelling and more likely to be mistaken or fraudulent.
 
Someone posts blurred images. They mention tales of seeing bigfoot. They offer up various physical evidences (casts of footprints, torn tree bark or hair).

This is not "no evidence." It may be poor quality evidence and fail to convince me, but it isn't "no evidence." From the footer's point of view, he only has the evidence available to work with and can reasonably say the consilience of evidence has convinced him. I may disagree, deciding that the evidence is not compelling and more likely to be mistaken or fraudulent.

The hair between "no evidence" and "no meaningful or reasonable evidence" has already been split to Planck Length level in countless Bigfoot threads.

If you want to mentally amend any mention of "No evidence" to "No (meaningful) evidence" just tidy up the books, knock yourself out.
 
As I said, you didn't read the rest of the post. If you had, then you would have seen what I called ratpacking. That should have been obvious in the first 100 posts. Woo monger? Isn't that some of what you wanted to see?
It's not right around the corner, it's in the first 100 posts and 'further on down the road'.



#425 Cosmic Yak
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=301143&page=11

I am well aware that you are talking about the psychology of debunkers. However, that psychology will still be manifested in real-world behaviour, which in the case of this forum will be actual posts. My question stands unanswered: Can you quote someone actually displaying this kind of mindset? Somehow I doubt it.....

As I said, fist fight with one, 2 or more guys jump in, ratpacking.



See my re-address of this post 'further on down the line'>
So ratpacking on a forum is when many people generally agree with a given position and post appropriately? In my mind, that simply indicates general agreement with a given concept. Of course popularity does not equal truth, but conversely a lot of people agreeing with a particular view is one thing that would is often found with correct views.

If someone were to post that force = mass times acceleration^2, would it be ratpacking if other posters noted that force = mass times acceleration? What if the first person persisted in their belief that the first equation is correct? Would it be ratpacking if multiple posters then expressed their view that the first equation is wrong?

A forum is not a fist fight, but even consider a fist fight: It is often considered "unfair" if in a fistfight between two individuals a bunch of people pile on to help one side. But what if one side has it correct and the other side is doing something obviously wrong? Is is ratpacking if someone at a movie pulls out a knife and tries to stab an innocent man, and a bunch of other people all step in to disarm the knife wielder?
 
The phrase "no evidence" keeps coming up in this thread. It is an example of what the OP sees as denialism vs. skepticism.

I have to mention again that bigfootery isn't my thing - the only "case" I followed was the guy hauling the doll around in a trailer - so my examples are only drawn from supposition.

Someone posts blurred images. They mention tales of seeing bigfoot. They offer up various physical evidences (casts of footprints, torn tree bark or hair).

This is not "no evidence." It may be poor quality evidence and fail to convince me, but it isn't "no evidence." From the footer's point of view, he only has the evidence available to work with and can reasonably say the consilience of evidence has convinced him. I may disagree, deciding that the evidence is not compelling and more likely to be mistaken or fraudulent.
The poor quality of bigfoot evidence has been discussed ad nauseum.
 
1) There is no Bigfoot.

Were I to base that assertion on nothing more than my own hubris and catching a few minutes of Moneymaker & Friends on television then, sure, I would agree that my position was based on some pretty flimsy information.

The reality, of course, is that I decided to take a seriously deep dive on the subject many years ago. I really took the time to familiarize myself with the claims and the claimants, and hypothesize all manner of ways in which there might be a kernel of truth to the legend. My experience is quite similar to that of other skeptics with whom Ontario engages here frequently. In my case and with the benefit of about 15 years of actively seeking out the purported evidence for Bigfoot, I have concluded that there is no Bigfoot, and never has been.

Therefore, if OS would characterize me as a denialist or some other label of a poor skeptic, I would like him to tell how much longer I need to keep at this before, as a GOOD skeptic I can make the assertion that there's no Bigfoot.
This is where his game runs seriously short of strategy. There is absolutely nothing intelligent he can say in response to that except "Yeah it has been long enough". Cause "Keep on truckin" doesn't work. Whatever the case it's vivid proof he's BLAARGing.

Basically OS is hiding behind a poor understanding of "The Null Hypothesis" in order to hide the fact that he has presented zero evidence for Bigfoot. Because there is no Bigfoot. Because he knows perfectly well there is no Bigfoot.
I've been saying that all along including frank but true assertions now in AAH. He's just BLAARGing/trolling/gaming the board.

You would have to assume that Sasquatch is like any other large animal. How do you know that they're not burying their dead or that there isn't a cover-up of physical evidence?
<playing along> Wanna know how we know a "mythical" animal doesn't bury their dead? No "mythical" tools with which to dig holes. Even some random Bigfooter of The Year from Mississippi would agree there's no evidence (in the stories) that Bigfoot uses tools in any way. As such they can't dig holes the size of a small Buick with their bare hands, can they? And if they can, how come we've never once come across any semblance of such a dig before, during or after?

Yeah I forgot, reality and you hate each other. I'd tell you to GROW UP but I'm sure you'd just whine to the mods like other times so I won't tell you to GROW UP. In fact I will tell you I want you to stay the perfectly innocent misunderstood CHILD you are. :eye-poppi
 
Here's another way to look at it:

Belief that something exists ---- Neutrality --- Belief that something doesn't exist
Matt Dillahunty described this best. In a court case the prosecution has the burden of proof and has to prove beyond reasonable doubt that "Bigfoot exists". If the jury is not convinced then they vote not guilty. A "not guilty" verdict does not mean "Bigfoot does not exist", it means "we don't think you have proven beyond reasonable doubt that he does", there is a big difference saying "not guilty" and "innocent".
 
I've got no problem whatsoever with claiming that Bigfoot does not exist, anywhere in the world. That makes me a rational, fully-functioning adult human. Only in the world of the insanely butthurt and imaginatively-inclined does that make me a denialist.

What's there to be sceptical about? All of the mental-gymnastics being offered to try and explain why calling a spade a spade is somehow unfair and non-sceptical, lol.

Meanwhile, it's hard to ignore the sheer raging lack of Bigfoot.

...and the beat goes on.
 
I read, as I said, 100 posts of the thread that you linked to, the thread you claimed displayed the kind of behaviour you keep complaining about. Is there anything in the rest of the thread that refutes or invalidates what I said about the first three pages? If there is, why did you not link to that in the first place? Or are you simply trying to claim, as with so many woo-mongers, that "the proof is just around the corner, it's really really there, but I can't quite point you to it"?
As I said, you didn't read the rest of the post. If you had, then you would have seen what I called ratpacking. That should have been obvious in the first 100 posts. Woo monger? Isn't that some of what you wanted to see?
It's not right around the corner, it's in the first 100 posts and 'further on down the road'.

Once again, this does not in any way answer my questions. Read the above exchange again. You have answered as if you had not read my post at all, and neither had you read my original reply, in which I detailed the responses in the thread you linked to, demonstrating that I obviously had read it, and that the content was nothing like what you claimed it was.
As is your wont, your post is totally lacking in detail or evidence for your claims. Instead, you have contented yourself with repeating your earlier points, which I have already examined and, in my eyes at least, disproved. This does nothing to move the discussion on, and again I'm wondering what you think you will achieve by this approach.
 
(snip)
<playing along> Wanna know how we know a "mythical" animal doesn't bury their dead? No "mythical" tools with which to dig holes. Even some random Bigfooter of The Year from Mississippi would agree there's no evidence (in the stories) that Bigfoot uses tools in any way.

There was Creekfreak who, iirc, witnessed a bigfoot using a screwdriver to open a can of beans. Don't recall if he also saw one using a can opener to set screws....;)
 
There was Creekfreak who, iirc, witnessed a bigfoot using a screwdriver to open a can of beans. Don't recall if he also saw one using a can opener to set screws....;)


I don't think CF actually claimed to have witnessed this. IIRC, he pieced together the scenario from the "evidence" after the fact. A can of pork n beans was opened and eaten, plus screwdriver on the table, or something. It was totally Bigfoot in his kitchen, eating his pork n beans. It's the only logical explanation.
 
Can We Accept the Null Hypothesis?​

Some researchers say that a hypothesis test can have one of two outcomes: you accept the null hypothesis or you reject the null hypothesis. Many statisticians, however, take issue with the notion of "accepting the null hypothesis." Instead, they say: you reject the null hypothesis or you fail to reject the null hypothesis.

Why the distinction between "acceptance" and "failure to reject?" Acceptance implies that the null hypothesis is true. Failure to reject implies that the data are not sufficiently persuasive for us to prefer the alternative hypothesis over the null hypothesis.

http://stattrek.com/hypothesis-test/hypothesis-testing.aspx
This is something I deal with in my work everyday and I think you mis-understand the concept. The idea is that one tests one's observations statistically to determine if they likely demonstrate something ("reject the null hypothesis") or don't (i.e. are consistent with the null hypothesis and one's "evidence" is indistinguishable from the observations that would be expected from purely random events). But here again the standard default is the null hypothesis- if one's observations are not sufficient to reject the null hypothesis, statistical analysis states that therefore there is no reason to reject the null hypothesis as examining the observations. Stating it as a failure to reject the null hypothesis doesn't change anything- that was always understood no matter the precise wording.

One cannot prove the null hypothesis 100% (which is sort of what you are demanding). But as one obtains increasingly accurate or numerous observations one can continue to reduce the possibility of rejecting the null state. Thus one can state that the probability of there being a Bigfoot is 10%, then 1%, then 0.1%, then 0.01%. etc.

Your quote actually argues against your point: the null state is considered to be the absence of an effect and thus to be neutral. Neutrality is not somewhere between believing in Bigfoot (or unicorns) and not; statistical neutrality starts with the assumption that neither exist and any observations that appear to support their existence have to be statistically distinct from those expected at random to support rejecting the null hypothesis and believing in these creatures..
 
Last edited:
Your quote actually argues against your point: the null state is considered to be the absence of an effect and thus to be neutral.

Neutral would mean that you're not claiming anything. Claiming that something is absent is still a claim and it's a negative one.
 
Cool story, bro. You'll always be behind me.

Please, do elaborate on how I intentionally ignore the obvious, bro, the obvious in this case being the lack of Bigfoot.

Can you do that, bro?

Probably not, bro.

:boggled:

The obvious was The Mentality of Skeptics, which was the thread's title. It got hijacked from psychology, which seems to make SkeptiBunkers uneasy and into something SkeptiBunkers feel much more comfortable talking about. Get back on track.
 
Neutral would mean that you're not claiming anything. Claiming that something is absent is still a claim and it's a negative one.
I suppose one could make a case that claiming the world is what it is is a negative claim to the contention that the world is a concoction of utter nonsense that it isn't, but I think to suggest that rejection of the supernatural involves the same kind of faith as acceptance of it is inherently chaotic and leads to a constant stream of nonsense.
 
Neutral would mean that you're not claiming anything. Claiming that something is absent is still a claim and it's a negative one.

And this is not even close to being reasonable.

So basically that your new angle? You have zero evidence for the giant magical alien monkey man, we have zero evidence against him, so it's a draw?

You still haven't answered the question as to how that makes Bigfoot any different from invisible garage dragons.

How about this. You owe me... 5,000 dollars. Until such time as you offer proof to my standards that you don't owe me 5,000 dollars the fair thing would be to split the difference and send me 2,500 dollars.

I'll refund the 2,500 dollars at such time you prove to my standards that you owe me no money, and you will send me the remaining 2,500 dollars at such time as I prove to your standards that you do in fact owe me the 5,000 dollars.

I will accept the payment in US Dollars, Euros, Gold Doubloons, certified check, Amazon Gift Cards, Fallout 4 Caps, or equivalent value in Cuban Cigars, bottles of 20 year Scotch, rare books, or a new set of tires for a 2013 Dodge Dart.
 
And this is not even close to being reasonable.

So basically that your new angle? You have zero evidence for the giant magical alien monkey man, we have zero evidence against him, so it's a draw?

Yes, but why do you look at it like its a competition? Are you desperate to have some sort of closure?

You still haven't answered the question as to how that makes Bigfoot any different from invisible garage dragons.

Invisible garage dragons could be real for all I know, but I haven't seen any evidence of it that convinces me it's real.

How about this. You owe me... 5,000 dollars. Until such time as you offer proof to my standards that you don't owe me 5,000 dollars the fair thing would be to split the difference and send me 2,500 dollars.

It's your claim, so you have a burden of proof.
 
Neutral would mean that you're not claiming anything. Claiming that something is absent is still a claim and it's a negative one.
Claiming that something is absent is a positive claim. It is an assertion. When a paleontologist claims that Tyrannosaurs are extinct they are making a positive assertion. In order to properly make that claim they need evidence. There is evidence for the absence of Tyrannosaurs because there is no confirmatory evidence when it should be expected. The same is true for Bigfoot. We say that Bigfoot does not exist because there is no confirmatory evidence when it should be expected. The absence of confirmatory evidence when it is expected informs us that Bigfoot doesn't exist and also that T-Rex no longer exists.

Bigfoot denialists hold the strongest evidence. A Bigfoot denialist recognizes the absence of Bigfoot in the same way that a scientist recognizes the extinction of T-Rex.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom