OntarioSquatch
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- Jun 10, 2012
- Messages
- 1,783
ok, so here's the meat.
Are you content that people that you would agree are "true" skeptics in your view, can be correct in their skeptical rationalization of the non existence of BigFoot (or Squatch or whatever it is called).
Because IMHO being skeptical of BigFoot in a way that fits in with your definition of what a good and true skeptic should be, would be justified completely.
It's not possible to know that things like sasquatch, sea monsters, aliens ect. don't exist, so they'd be taking that stance without anything reasonable to support their belief. It has nothing to do with real skepticism.
For them to claim that they're correct in their belief means that they're either lying, seriously misinformed or that skepticism/uncertainty makes them uncomfortable to the point that they would want to believe in its non-existence anyway.
As much as I hate bigfoot as an example, this should point out the difference in style and tone:
1) There is no bigfoot - faux skeptic.
2) I haven't seen any evidence that convinces me there is a bigfoot - better skeptic.
For a bonus, #1 may go after the claimant (idiot, scammer, woo-meister, and so on), refuse to consider evidences offered up, or make unreasonable demands on the claimant - "Show me the body," "Where's the DNA?" and so on.
That is my understanding of the criticism being offered. How prevalent it is is open to debate.
That seems accurate.
