The Mentality of Skeptics

ok, so here's the meat.

Are you content that people that you would agree are "true" skeptics in your view, can be correct in their skeptical rationalization of the non existence of BigFoot (or Squatch or whatever it is called).

Because IMHO being skeptical of BigFoot in a way that fits in with your definition of what a good and true skeptic should be, would be justified completely.

It's not possible to know that things like sasquatch, sea monsters, aliens ect. don't exist, so they'd be taking that stance without anything reasonable to support their belief. It has nothing to do with real skepticism.

For them to claim that they're correct in their belief means that they're either lying, seriously misinformed or that skepticism/uncertainty makes them uncomfortable to the point that they would want to believe in its non-existence anyway.

As much as I hate bigfoot as an example, this should point out the difference in style and tone:

1) There is no bigfoot - faux skeptic.

2) I haven't seen any evidence that convinces me there is a bigfoot - better skeptic.

For a bonus, #1 may go after the claimant (idiot, scammer, woo-meister, and so on), refuse to consider evidences offered up, or make unreasonable demands on the claimant - "Show me the body," "Where's the DNA?" and so on.

That is my understanding of the criticism being offered. How prevalent it is is open to debate.

That seems accurate.
 
The title is lacking accuracy, not honesty. I don't have anything against real skeptics.

Since you admit that you've mis-titled your thread, then, honesty would require that you ask the moderation team to rename it "The Mentality of Denialists." Do you plan to do so, or are you happy to continue to mislead even though you've admitted the title is inaccurate?

Dave
 
It's not possible to know that things like sasquatch, sea monsters, aliens ect. don't exist, so they'd be taking that stance without anything reasonable to support their belief. It has nothing to do with real skepticism.
It's possible to know that all the evidence that could reasonably be expected to exist if sasquatch existed is absent. Assuming that sasquatch does not exist until and unless such evidence is presented is therefore an entirely reasonable position for a real sceptic to take - indeed, the only reasonable position.
 
It's not possible to know that things like sasquatch, sea monsters, aliens ect. don't exist, so they'd be taking that stance without anything reasonable to support their belief. It has nothing to do with real skepticism.

For them to claim that they're correct in their belief means that they're either lying, seriously misinformed or that skepticism/uncertainty makes them uncomfortable to the point that they would want to believe in its non-existence anyway.



That seems accurate.

It's possible to prove that something which exists, exists. That is why Bigfoot hasn't been proven, because it doesn't exist. Ironically, out of all of the tear-jerkers on Team: Bignuthin', you're the only one not out there in the park field collecting "data." Funny, eh? Why is that?

But I digress, you vent that frustration, champ! :thumbsup:
 
Last edited:
It's possible to know that all the evidence that could reasonably be expected to exist if sasquatch existed is absent.

By doing that, you'd be creating an hypothetical version of the entity in your mind that has exactly all of the limitations that you place on it. In reality, it's not possible to know about something that you don't about.

"Argument from ignorance also known as appeal to ignorance, is a fallacy in informal logic. It asserts that a proposition is true because it has not yet been proven false (or vice versa)."

It's possible to prove that something which exists, exists.That is why Bigfoot hasn't been proven, because it doesn't exist.
Fallacy highlighted
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_ignorance
 
Last edited:
By doing that, you'd be creating an hypothetical version of the entity in your mind that has exactly all of the limitations that you place on it. In reality, it's not possible to know about something that you don't about.
We do know about large animals, and the kind of evidence they leave of their existence.
 
As much as I hate bigfoot as an example, this should point out the difference in style and tone:

1) There is no bigfoot - faux skeptic.

2) I haven't seen any evidence that convinces me there is a bigfoot - better skeptic.

For a bonus, #1 may go after the claimant (idiot, scammer, woo-meister, and so on), refuse to consider evidences offered up, or make unreasonable demands on the claimant - "Show me the body," "Where's the DNA?" and so on.

That is my understanding of the criticism being offered. How prevalent it is is open to debate.

Speaking for myself, I didn't come here to be a better sceptic, and nor am I bothered about trying to abide by the Grand Rules of Scepticism.

For me, Bigfoot is an interestingly hilarious pastime which I originally thought was about some nonsensical giant ape-man, but what I discovered was so much more.

Bigfoot isn't a giant ape-man at all. He's not even an alien-hybrid, or a relic hominid. He ain't even a bear.

No. Bigfoot is an attitude. A way of life. Like punk-rock, Bigfoot gave people hope, he taught them that they, too, could be Fortean-intellectuals. That they, too, could seek adventures, and you didn't need smarts or ability to do it. Anyone could get off his or her couch and pick up a thermal-imager, or a simple stick to beat the nearest tree with.

And if Bigfoot is punk-rock, then the entire cast of Finding Bigfoot are the equivalent of the Ramones, or probably the Stooges (how apt).

Bigfoot, like punk-rock, is about sticking it to the man, bro. You feel me?

Todd Disotell knows what I'm talkin' about, am I right?
 
Last edited:
We do know about large animals, and the kind of evidence they leave of their existence.

You would have to assume that Sasquatch is like any other large animal. How do you know that they're not burying their dead or that there isn't a cover-up of physical evidence?
 
You would have to assume that Sasquatch is like any other large animal.


Yeah, y'know, just from space and cross-bred with humans... According to you, the guy who's never seen one and isn't even out looking for one.
 
Last edited:
It's not possible to know that things like sasquatch, sea monsters, aliens ect. don't exist, so they'd be taking that stance without anything reasonable to support their belief. It has nothing to do with real skepticism.
First you are side stepping my question. I asked if a skeptic was a "true" skeptic that meets your criteria as a reasonable, rational skeptic, would you expect them to think that bigfoot exists or not?

Second point is where you are making your mistake about what a true skeptic is. It's not rational to believe something exists without good evidence. You don't understand what being skeptical means. Oh well.

For them to claim that they're correct in their belief means that they're either lying, seriously misinformed or that skepticism/uncertainty makes them uncomfortable to the point that they would want to believe in its non-existence anyway.
Not sure what to say here. You are obviously having a good laugh, or are completely delusional.
 
You would have to assume that Sasquatch is like any other large animal. How do you know that they're not burying their dead or that there isn't a cover-up of physical evidence?

Given 2 possibilities: (a) that all physical evidence of a large primate could successfully be buried or covered up or (b) that sasquatch is a product of well known and well understood cognitive biases plus overactive imaginations, a real sceptic assumes the most reasonable and likely one. Which is (b) by a factor of millions.
 
BTW, where is BigFoot supposed to live? Does OntarioSquatch imply it lives in Canada?

Are there sightings all over North America?
 

You are mistaken.

An argument from ignorance is: "I don't know if anybody looked for evidence of Bigfoot, therefore there is no evidence, and thus no bigfoot."

What was actually stated was the null:
"There would be a considerable evidence left by a race of large hominids, given what we know of their relatives in nature. Until the bigfoot research community produces such evidence, that meets a minimum threshold, the best reason for that lack of evidence, is that bigfoot is just a story."

Your argument that we can not describe what qualities a bigfoot might have is based on a false understanding we shall call the Rhino Problem:

In antiquity a man was writing about the strange beasts that people glimpsed while travelling distant shores. He listened to the description of sailors and merchants gave of creatures and wrote about the beasts he thought they had described. One such description was of a Unicorn. A horse with a horn, seen in the distance.

Over time stories of the unicorn grew, and drawings were produced of a mighty stallion with a long horn and white fur. So popular were these stories that even today, we know exactly what is meant when somebody describes a Unicorn.

Here is the problem: There is a beast that lives around the towns that the Merchants and traders visited with a horn. A rhino. It could crudely be described as being on all fours (like a horse) of a size (like a horse) and with a horn (like a horse).

And yet when the rhino was described by science, it was not named as a unicorn. It would not even occur to later scholars that what they were looking at was, by any means, a unicorn.

Thus we have the rhino problem: Stories of the bigfoot are well known. Like it or not, those who advocate the existence of bigfoot describe a creature with certain qualities. That is of a size, that it lives in a habitat, that it has habits and qualities. If it were a real creature, we would reasonably expect it to follow the rules of nature. (we know for example there is a wide variety of feline creatures, and yet there are commonalities between your tabby cat and a lion. We would expect new feline species to leave evidence of at least some of these traits).

By stating we do not know what qualities a bigfoot would have, by treating it as a complete unknown, then we are open to a paradox. If the creature behaved outside of our expectations, and outside of the behaviours and descriptions attributed to bigfoot by bigfoot advocates, would we ever know it was bigfoot?

Suppose we found a new species of bear, or sloth, or other large, would we call it bigfoot? No. Almost certainly the bigfoot community would state it did not match what they "know" of bigfoot and continue their search. It would be as different from Bigfoot as a unicorn is from a rhino.

What you may however find is that sceptics will consider if this new creature was the root cause of the bigfoot myth.
 
We do know about large animals, and the kind of evidence they leave of their existence.

You would have to assume that Sasquatch is like any other large animal. How do you know that they're not burying their dead or that there isn't a cover-up of physical evidence?

Even if they buried their dead, there would still be traces- bones, for a start, not to mention the fact the carrion-eaters would be trying to get at the bodies. Erosion, landslides, floods, clearing of forests for building etc. would all uncover these graves. Yet not one has been found.
This alleged cover-up of evidence is another extraordinary claim. Bigfoot eats bark ("stripping it from trees like cotton candy", if I recall correctly), but these (presumably numerous) stripped trees are then covered up again by a government team? If Bigfoot eats, then it is reasonable to assume that it also excretes- and again, this is carefully scooped up by another super-duper pooper posse?
Furthermore, how is it that all these teams have never been spotted by the Bigfoot hunters? Is another team going round busily concealing the first team? Where does it end? :eye-poppi
 
Last edited:
An argument from ignorance is: "I don't know if anybody looked for evidence of Bigfoot, therefore there is no evidence, and thus no bigfoot."

In its simplest form its: "X hasn't been proven yet, therefore X doesn't exist". One can add details to it, but it'll always be that same basic assumption.

Also, looking for X and not finding it isn't proof of the non-existence of X if you don't even know what X is and factors that are involved.

Your argument that we can not describe what qualities a bigfoot might have is based on a false understanding we shall call the Rhino Problem:

You can assume that you know all the factors involved, but in the end you'd just be assuming you know them based on the existence of other large mammals.
 
In its simplest form its: "X hasn't been proven yet, therefore X doesn't exist". One can add details to it, but it'll always be that same basic assumption.

Which is still a null hypothesis, and not an argument from ignorance. You were wrong.

Also, looking for X and not finding it isn't proof of the non-existence of X if you don't even know what X is and factors that are involved.

We know what X is. X is "Bigfoot as described by research groups who advocate it's existence". X is the creature described by those who believe it is out there to be found.

You can assume that you know all the factors involved, but in the end you'd just be assuming you know them based on the existence of other large mammals.

Again, nobody claimed to know all the factors. But there are many that bigfoot would have to share by virtue of being a mammal (and at this point we have to wonder why you think animals are classed as mammal without sharing traits). A large number, of which at least some would leave traces. More than this the descriptions of bigfoot go into specifics. Specifics can be tested, because specifics leave evidence. Their diet, their habits, etc.

Again we have the rhino problem. If we don't look for the factors in descriptions of "Bigfoot", if we find something that is not a large hominid mammal, then can we claim we have found "Bigfoot"?

If you are arguing that we can not look for evidence, because we know nothing of bigfoot, then you are entering the realms of religion. An unknowable and untestable entity has to be believed to exist, by daint that it can not be shown not to exist. As this is patently ridiculous, we will stick to the traditional methodology: Testing the claims as made by those who advocate the belief in bigfoot.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom