The Mentality of Skeptics

As much as I hate bigfoot as an example, this should point out the difference in style and tone:

1) There is no bigfoot - faux skeptic.

2) I haven't seen any evidence that convinces me there is a bigfoot - better skeptic.

For a bonus, #1 may go after the claimant (idiot, scammer, woo-meister, and so on), refuse to consider evidences offered up, or make unreasonable demands on the claimant - "Show me the body," "Where's the DNA?" and so on.

That is my understanding of the criticism being offered. How prevalent it is is open to debate.

What is so unreasonable about testable evidence?
 
And that's why Bigfootery remains a pointless exercise, except to display the mind of a believer.

All this contradictory blurble about Obama in a closet, and still no monkey. There's never a monkey. Not even a picture of one.

No scat, no hair, no lair, in fact noting at all to show it even exists.

Clearly footie never poops, never sheds and never sleeps./BF believer.
 
Maybe, maybe not.

While I am fully onboard with the BLAARGing hypothesis, and do think it's probably the case in most of these threads, truth be told I'm not as overly concerned as some with how deep this rabbit hole goes because at the end of the day it doesn't matter, my responses are gonna be the same.

Whether OS (or anyone else) honestly believes there is a logically improbable to the point of practical level impossibility giant magical monkey man trouncing around or this is all some silly dog wagging the tail trolling is not a distinction I need to make for myself.

Don't get me wrong....just as with Bigfoot, my minds made up until something comes along (real evidence) to change my position.
There's no doubt in my mind the only reason a proponent would come here is to troll the fourm, and they reap what they sow ;)
 
Me three!
I wanna be in the anxious uncomfortable uncertain Bigfoot skeptic denialist club!
I have earned it.
:D

I want to be a member of whatever someone with that avatar is a member of.:)

Are there rituals? Will they be uncomfortable? Are clothes mandatory?:eye-poppi
 
As much as I hate bigfoot as an example, this should point out the difference in style and tone:

1) There is no bigfoot - faux skeptic.

2) I haven't seen any evidence that convinces me there is a bigfoot - better skeptic.

You missed the straw-free example:

3) Despite extensive searches for evidence which would have been expected to find it, no plausible evidence of a bigfoot has been found, so my current conclusion is that there is no bigfoot - actual skeptic.

Dave
 
A Skeptic encountering evidence of the paranormal is like the stereotypical woman in a movie farce who discovers a spider in her hair. Does she pause to calmly assess the situation? No, she starts batting wildly at her head, screaming, "Get it off me!"

Actually, there's nothing "anti-skeptical" about freaking out when you see a very strange phenomena. If I see a man levitate in front of my eyes, of course I'm going to freak the hell out and scream.

Being a skeptic doesn't mean you're a robot with no emotions who "stops to calmly asses the situation". You still get freaked out by weird stuff. Heck, we still get freaked out by stuff that we know do have an explanation (A good Illusionist performing a cool trick, a scary movie, a realistic Virtual Reality game) The initial emotional reaction is still there. It's what you do after the event has passed, and you are asked to provide your opinion on what the explanation for the phenomena is. That's where you differentiate a skeptic from someone who just wants to believe something weird without any evidence.
 
If we needed a tell that OS is just playing a happy troll game, it's hard to beat this old chestnut!

Please share with your 'footer buddies OS: The best way to ensure that physical evidence of real living bigfoots would already have been found would be if said bigfoots were burying their dead. Of course you know this.

If bigfoot had been around all this time burying their dead, we'd find a new skeleton every day.
 
My point is that it doesn't make sense to accept something if there isn't evidence for it.

Here's another way to look at it:

Belief that something exists ---- Neutrality --- Belief that something doesn't exist

The consensus in science is on neither side if there isn't proof for either side.

You can come up with a hypothesis to test against, but the null isn't necessarily the accepted view in science.


Your claim, your burden.
 
I want to be a member of whatever someone with that avatar is a member of.:)

Are there rituals? Will they be uncomfortable? Are clothes mandatory?:eye-poppi

:D

Seasonal hats are optional. We must be festive.

Rituals are excellent!
Uncomfortable?
Nah, only enough to build team spirit and the blackmail membership portfolio.

Pork and beans with the screwdriver will be your entrance fee.
I will bring the Good n Plentys.

I must go Mindfully Meditate on My Mentality, bringing skeptical anxiety
to the forefront my pre-frontal cortex.
Or, go eat some oatmeal.

Blue Booby usually chooses oatmeal.
:p
 
Maybe, maybe not.

While I am fully onboard with the BLAARGing hypothesis, and do think it's probably the case in most of these threads, truth be told I'm not as overly concerned as some with how deep this rabbit hole goes because at the end of the day it doesn't matter, my responses are gonna be the same.

Whether OS (or anyone else) honestly believes there is a logically improbable to the point of practical level impossibility giant magical monkey man trouncing around or this is all some silly dog wagging the tail trolling is not a distinction I need to make for myself.

I'm only here for the fear.:eek:
 
That's what begs the mentality question, maybe he does truly believe.

I suspect he's honest.

While he repeats the absurd claims of others ("Bigfoot is too frightening to photograph") I've never seen him make a preposterous claim of his own.

He's never been in the field and he never claims to have been. And there's nothing wrong with that; hell, for all I know he can't even walk.

He certainly believes liars, but I personally haven't seen any indication he is one himself.
 
Basically this whole thing is a forced, false distinction between "evidence" and "effects."

Bigfoot is hypothetically is an animal. Animals live in an environment. When animals live in an environment they interact with that environment. And when they interact with that environment they leave effect the environment.

"Evidence" is just a term used for "effects" that are collected to support a conclusion.

To argue that Bigfoot leaves no evidence would require one to argue that their existence has no effect, which is patently absurd.

The Footers (or their character sheets) are trying to have their cake and eat it to. A creature which has effects but leaves no evidence.
 
Basically this whole thing is a forced, false distinction between "evidence" and "effects."

Bigfoot is hypothetically is an animal. Animals live in an environment. When animals live in an environment they interact with that environment. And when they interact with that environment they leave effect the environment.

"Evidence" is just a term used for "effects" that are collected to support a conclusion.

To argue that Bigfoot leaves no evidence would require one to argue that their existence has no effect, which is patently absurd.

The Footers (or their character sheets) are trying to have their cake and eat it to. A creature which has effects but leaves no evidence.

And thus we are forced to conclude the possibility of flying giant squids to be undeniable.
 
Basically this whole thing is a forced, false distinction between "evidence" and "effects."

Bigfoot is hypothetically is an animal. Animals live in an environment. When animals live in an environment they interact with that environment. And when they interact with that environment they leave effect the environment.

"Evidence" is just a term used for "effects" that are collected to support a conclusion.

To argue that Bigfoot leaves no evidence would require one to argue that their existence has no effect, which is patently absurd.

The Footers (or their character sheets) are trying to have their cake and eat it to. A creature which has effects but leaves no evidence.
They wish to specially plead and conspiracy theorize these effects into a non-demonstrable corner, then whine about "denialists" when it's pointed out that won't do.
 
Honestly I do not know why I am in this thread. And the uncertainty of that gives me some anxiety.

On the other hand, based on what I already do know, I have concluded that Bigfoot does not exist, and have thought the same for many decades. Nonetheless, I would welcome any new evidence to the contrary. This view does not make me anxious at all.

Apparently the thylacine (Tasmanian Tiger) is thought to be extinct, but there are reported sightings from time to time. I am therefore uncertain if this quite strange creature still exists or not. But even this ambiguity does not leave me anxious or prone to force myself to decide that they are truly extinct just so that I can sleep at night. In fact, I rather hope that they still exist. But I am happy to say that I do not know.
 
:D
Seasonal hats are optional. We must be festive.
Rituals are excellent!
Uncomfortable?
Nah, only enough to build team spirit and the blackmail membership portfolio.
Pork and beans with the screwdriver will be your entrance fee.
I will bring the Good n Plentys.
I must go Mindfully Meditate on My Mentality, bringing skeptical anxiety
to the forefront my pre-frontal cortex.

Or, go eat some oatmeal.
Blue Booby usually chooses oatmeal.
:p
Is there a special corner to sit in if we feel anxious or in denial?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom