The Mentality of Skeptics

Good one, Ontario!

What about me? Can I be one of your former believers who's anxious about bigfoot and uncomfortable with uncertainty too? And don't forget folks like Drewbot or Skeptical Greg!

Can I join the club too please?
Is there a membership fee?

Me three!
I wanna be in the anxious uncomfortable uncertain Bigfoot skeptic denialist club!
I have earned it.
:D
 
There's skeptics and then there's denialists who hide behind the label of skeptic. The common traits of a denialist:

- dislikes uncertainty
- clings to the most common belief
- highly critical of opposing views
- doesn't like the idea of possibilities
- believes that all woo is false
- will debunk "woo" using explanations that only sound reasonable
- can't stand criticism




Their belief only appears to be unshakable. If you post something that challenges their belief, they'll often react in a way that reveals how insecure they are of their position. It's usually with great anger. The best place to observe this on this forum is in the Bigfoot threads.

And then there's believers

and then...

there's BLAARG'ers.

Once again, OS, the only person who's ever claimed to be uncertain at any point about this, is you.

;)
 
I was never a Bigfoot believer, so I'm not a "switcher" as OS may have implied.

Yeah, I didn't think so, tbh. I didn't think many, if any, here would be.

It just highlights the fact that OS is a bit of a spinner of yarns, and ironically very ignorant in his assertions. Funny that, considering this entire thread is supposed to be a smearing campaign against ignorant thinking and all.
 
.... "They all are secretly and strongly convinced that there is a Bigfoot. They are just too argumentative to admit it publicly. Of sure, they will go on and on with their face-saving silly arguments, but they all know that Bigfoot exists. And the more they deny this the more they are only hiding the truth- they all strongly believe in the reality of Bigfoot!"

If one is going to invent a mental state for the opposite side of the debate, and to persist despite their denials and in the total lack of evidence, then why not go all the way? Don't take any half measures.

Aye, we've seen certain christians try the same thing. Us atheists all secretly believe there is a god and we are scared of that so we...........blah blah
 
Just pointing out that if Bigfooters spent as much time in the woods looking for their creature as they do whining on the internet they could have found him by now.

Just sayin'...
 
Yeah, I didn't think so, tbh. I didn't think many, if any, here would be.

I think RayG and Kitakaze have both described themselves in that category, i.e. starting out believing but then realizing it was all bollocks upon further examination. I don't see either of those guys suffering for the lack of bigfoot in the world; both seem quite okay with currently aligning with the position that's supported by the preponderance of evidence.
 
I think RayG and Kitakaze have both described themselves in that category, i.e. starting out believing but then realizing it was all bollocks upon further examination. I don't see either of those guys suffering for the lack of bigfoot in the world; both seem quite okay with currently aligning with the position that's supported by the preponderance of evidence.

Now that you mention it, I recall hearing something similar from Kitakaze, and maybe Ray, actually. It just never crossed my mind as I've not seen either of them post in a long while.

So, out of "almost everyone who posts regularly in the Bigfoot threads," only two of them actually meet that criteria?

The BLAARG runs deep within OS.
 
How dishonest of you, then, to discuss what you now admit to be the mentality of denialists in a thread you entitled "The Mentality of Skeptics".

Dave

The title is lacking accuracy, not honesty. I don't have anything against real skeptics.
 
The title is lacking accuracy, not honesty. I don't have anything against real skeptics.

There are no word games that can make your fantasies real. All you can do is make your ridiculous assertions, then bash skeptics when they call you on them.
 
Actually, I'm analyzing their assertions and behaviour in this thread. Only a pseudo would think that it's somehow bashing skeptics.
 
Last edited:
Actually, I'm analyzing their assertions and behaviour in this thread. Only a pseudo would think that it's somehow bashing skeptics.

Translation: "I'm tired of being called a BLAARG'er, despite constantly acting like one and operating as such, and to be honest, the fact that Bigfoot isn't out there is really starting to drive me round the bloody bend. I've started this thread to vent some of that rage and generally try to smear people using lies and underhanded insinuations. I shan't be doing anything credible, like offering evidence for this creature I've admittedly never seen. Please don't take offense, this is all in the name of fun/depression."

No worries, OS. I don't take offense. I get it. Hate the game, not the player.

I'm glad we've cleared all of that up. Now carry on with your tantrum experiment.
 
Actually, I'm analyzing their assertions and behaviour in this thread. Only a pseudo would think that it's somehow bashing skeptics.

You're big on name-calling, but like I said, at the end of the day it doesn't matter. Your fantasies will as usual come to nothing. Your analysis likewise.
 
The title is lacking accuracy, not honesty. I don't have anything against real skeptics.
ok, so here's the meat.

Are you content that people that you would agree are "true" skeptics in your view, can be correct in their skeptical rationalization of the non existence of BigFoot (or Squatch or whatever it is called).

Because IMHO being skeptical of BigFoot in a way that fits in with your definition of what a good and true skeptic should be, would be justified completely.
 
ok, so here's the meat.

Are you content that people that you would agree are "true" skeptics in your view, can be correct in their skeptical rationalization of the non existence of BigFoot (or Squatch or whatever it is called).

Because IMHO being skeptical of BigFoot in a way that fits in with your definition of what a good and true skeptic should be, would be justified completely.

As much as I hate bigfoot as an example, this should point out the difference in style and tone:

1) There is no bigfoot - faux skeptic.

2) I haven't seen any evidence that convinces me there is a bigfoot - better skeptic.

For a bonus, #1 may go after the claimant (idiot, scammer, woo-meister, and so on), refuse to consider evidences offered up, or make unreasonable demands on the claimant - "Show me the body," "Where's the DNA?" and so on.

That is my understanding of the criticism being offered. How prevalent it is is open to debate.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom