The Mentality of Skeptics

Which is still a null hypothesis, and not an argument from ignorance.

"Argument from ignorance also known as appeal to ignorance, is a fallacy in informal logic. It asserts that a proposition is true because it has not yet been proven false (or vice versa)."

Error of the Default Null

/philosophy : pseudoscience : incorrect hypothesis testing/ : a variation of argument from ignorance. The practice of assigning a favored or untestable/unfalsifiable hypothesis unmerited status as the null hypothesis. Further then proclaiming the Default Null to be the prevailing conclusion of science until such testing is conducted which could prove it to be false or until such time as it can be defeated by new competing science.

http://theethicalskeptic.com/2015/08/17/the-four-types-of-null-hypothesis-fallacy/
 
It's worth pointing out that a hypothesis is something that one uses to test against. It's not something that you accept as a conclusion.
 
"Argument from ignorance also known as appeal to ignorance, is a fallacy in informal logic. It asserts that a proposition is true because it has not yet been proven false (or vice versa)."

Error of the Default Null

/philosophy : pseudoscience : incorrect hypothesis testing/ : a variation of argument from ignorance. The practice of assigning a favored or untestable/unfalsifiable hypothesis unmerited status as the null hypothesis. Further then proclaiming the Default Null to be the prevailing conclusion of science until such testing is conducted which could prove it to be false or until such time as it can be defeated by new competing science.

http://theethicalskeptic.com/2015/08/17/the-four-types-of-null-hypothesis-fallacy/

Neither of which represent the quotes you claimed were arguments from ignorance.

I am sorry. I can see the difference is obviously subtle. But the null hypothesis is being applied correctly. You are suggesting they are assuming a lack of evidence proves something can not exist.

They have studied the evidence that would be required for such an animal to exist, and have found no signs of existence.

The "Bigfoot" has been described in some detail.
That detail offers evidence we would expect to see for the presence of a bigfoot.
The evidence has yet to be produced.
The evidence that has been produced does not overcome the null.

The posters you claimed to be making arguments from ignorance, which would appear to Gilbert and Pixie, are doing no such thing.

By your reckoning, we must accept the existence of the giant flying squids I just made up. Why? Because to do otherwise would be an argument of ignorance.

It seems to matter not, that I can offer no description of how giant squids fly, or why we have found no trace of flying giant squids. After all, how can you tell me the attributes of a creature nobody has seen? Perhaps there are billions of giant flying squids... It doesn't even matter if you are offered no reason to consider their existence to be more than a story.

Do you see the difference?
 
It's worth pointing out that a hypothesis is something that one uses to test against. It's not something that you accept as a conclusion.

Sorry, but no.
A hypothesis is not even what you test against. The hypothesis is the starting point, from which the concept to be tested is derived.

For instance, the hypothesis is that there is a large hominid is called Bigfoot.
The Null hypothesis, is that there is no large unknown hominid.
The concept to be tested is derived from discerning what evidence we would need to prove the presence of a large hominid.

In this case we would need to consider: That the hominid is an animal with a physical presence, and that it would need to fulfil the basic functions of life.

We would then look at other large hominids and consider a list of possible forms of evidence, and proofs, to indicate the possibility of a bigfoot.

Evidence would then be gathered.

The Theory would be that which best explains the evidence.

Proof would be evidence that makes the evidence the only reasonable truth, until new evidence is produced.

At the moment there is no evidence for the possibility of bigfoot. Far from being an argument from ignorance, this is a statement that no viable reason has been given for us to consider the presence.

In short: Is not an argument of ignorance to consider Bigfoot to be the solution to a question that has no reason to be asked.
 
By your reckoning, we must accept the existence of the giant flying squids I just made up. Why? Because to do otherwise would be an argument of ignorance.

My point is that it doesn't make sense to accept something if there isn't evidence for it.

Here's another way to look at it:

Belief that something exists ---- Neutrality --- Belief that something doesn't exist

The consensus in science is on neither side if there isn't proof for either side.

You can come up with a hypothesis to test against, but the null isn't necessarily the accepted view in science.
 
Last edited:
That just not how reality works.

You didn't answer the question. How is your Bigfoot any different from the colony of giant flying invisible squids I just made up?
 
Can We Accept the Null Hypothesis?​

Some researchers say that a hypothesis test can have one of two outcomes: you accept the null hypothesis or you reject the null hypothesis. Many statisticians, however, take issue with the notion of "accepting the null hypothesis." Instead, they say: you reject the null hypothesis or you fail to reject the null hypothesis.

Why the distinction between "acceptance" and "failure to reject?" Acceptance implies that the null hypothesis is true. Failure to reject implies that the data are not sufficiently persuasive for us to prefer the alternative hypothesis over the null hypothesis.

http://stattrek.com/hypothesis-test/hypothesis-testing.aspx
 
My point is that it doesn't make sense to accept something if there isn't evidence for it.

Yet that is exactly what you want the skeptics here to do. No-one on the skeptical side of the fence will accept the existence of Bigfoot, because there is no evidence for it.
Your response is to assert that the evidence is being concealed, either by the Bigfoots themselves, or some secret government agency. Not only is there no evidence, in this scenario, but there is no evidence of evidence concealment either.
Why then do you expect anyone to accept the existence of Bigfoot, as by your own argument, you yourself would not?
 
My point is that it doesn't make sense to accept something if there isn't evidence for it.

So why do you have a problem with somebody who does not accept Bigfoot, when there is no evidence for Bigfoot?

That seems to be the exact opposite for your claim that they were making an argument from ignorance.

Will you now apologise for your error?

Here's another way to look at it:

Belief that something exists ---- Neutrality --- Belief that something doesn't exist

The consensus in science is on neither side if there isn't proof for either side.[/quote]

I am sorry, but you misunderstand the scientific method. The consensus of science is not neutral on the existence of flying giant squids. The consensus of science is that the idea of giant flying squids should only be considered when I offer suitable evidence.

Your view is void, because it never allows for a conclusion to be drawn until it is the one you are happy with. It does not allow for evidence to be gathered and found wanting.
You can come up with a hypothesis to test against, but the null isn't necessarily the accepted view.

By definition, the Null is the accepted view, when comparing to an extraordinary claim. If the claim is giant flying squids, the null is: "There are no large aerial cephlopods that have remained undetected in the sky."

When comparing to Bigfoot, the Null is "misidentification of known species". As no evidence has been produced, that could not have come from a known species, such as human, it is unreasonable to expect people to believe in Bigfoot. The evidence has been tested, and found wanting. The lack of bigfoot is a reasonable conclusion based on the evidence at hand.

And there is the rub. You ignore that the sceptics will reconsider, when evidence is produced. You argue that we can not know what factors to test for, and make excuses for lack of evidence.

But the simple truth is, people did not decide bigfoot does not exist without evidence. They decided based upon the evidence gathered. Their conclusion is sound, until you supply evidence otherwise.

At some point science must allow that something does not exist, unless evidence otherwise can be given. Otherwise we would still be searching for the ether through which light travels, and we would surely still believe in the tooth fairy.
 
Why the distinction between "acceptance" and "failure to reject?" Acceptance implies that the null hypothesis is true. Failure to reject implies that the data are not sufficiently persuasive for us to prefer the alternative hypothesis over the null hypothesis.

Yes, failure to reject the null tells us that the data is not yet strong enough to prefer another alternative.

The next step is to create a theory.

That is to say, we now look for an explanation that best fits the evidence.

So let's apply that to the Bigfoot.
We have null hypothesis: That bigfoot sightings are misidentified known species.
We have no evidence of a bigfoot body.
We have no bigfoot in captivity.
We have no repeatable evidence of the presence of a bigfoot.
We have failed to reject the null.
Now for the important step: What theory best fits the evidence?


Obviously that the bgfoot sightings are misidentified known species.

This remains true until you can supply evidence that overcomes the null.

Just because the null allows for you to state "unproven", it also allows a very reasonable conclusion to be drawn. It allows for us to state that bigfoot does not exist.

Which science will be happy with, because science and scepticism allow us to reconsider with new evidence.

On the other hand, a bigfoot believer offers himself no such luxury. Bigfoot must exist, regardless of what the evidence says.
 
1) There is no Bigfoot.

Were I to base that assertion on nothing more than my own hubris and catching a few minutes of Moneymaker & Friends on television then, sure, I would agree that my position was based on some pretty flimsy information.

The reality, of course, is that I decided to take a seriously deep dive on the subject many years ago. I really took the time to familiarize myself with the claims and the claimants, and hypothesize all manner of ways in which there might be a kernel of truth to the legend. My experience is quite similar to that of other skeptics with whom Ontario engages here frequently. In my case and with the benefit of about 15 years of actively seeking out the purported evidence for Bigfoot, I have concluded that there is no Bigfoot, and never has been.

Therefore, if OS would characterize me as a denialist or some other label of a poor skeptic, I would like him to tell how much longer I need to keep at this before, as a GOOD skeptic I can make the assertion that there's no Bigfoot.
 
OS also seems to ignore that gathered evidence can indicate the Null, to the point of confirmation.

He also does not allow for gathered evidence pointing against the possibility of bigfoot.


Lets use my local forteana as an example. Lots of people think there are Alien Big Cats in the Medway valley. More specifically they state at least one is a Puma.

If we look at early reports we can conclude the evidence is incapable of rejecting the null: The blurred camcorder footage is not clear enough to show a puma, or to discern that the cat is puma sized.

But we can look at some of the investigations and find that sheep are not being killed in enough numbers to support the existence of a puma. The dietry requirements of a puma are not being met.

We can draw a reasonable conclusion. Not only was the null not rejected, the claim was found to be untrue. We can concede that perhaps some wild cats are out there, but the specific claim of the puma was the product of psychology, not a beast stalking the old quarries.

Now let's consider bigfoot. It is all very well to say we have yet to reject the null, but what if evidence supports the null?

If we were to go searching for the trees that bigfoot apparently rips bark from to eat like candy, would we find any? Would we find enough bark to sustain a diet? If we studied the trees, that were claimed to be bigfoots snacking ground, and found the bark peeled away because of a fungus, or was chewed away by deer, how would that alter our conclusions?

If we looked at the bigger picture, and found no relatives to bigfoot from which he could of evolved, and no signs of the foraging required to sustain even a small community of large hominids, no signs at all of a unaccounted population in the food chain, how would we then alter our conclusions?

Lack of evidence is cited, but my understanding is that there are good arguments for the "evidence of a lack".
 
As much as I hate bigfoot as an example, this should point out the difference in style and tone:

1) There is no bigfoot - faux skeptic.

2) I haven't seen any evidence that convinces me there is a bigfoot - better skeptic.

For a bonus, #1 may go after the claimant (idiot, scammer, woo-meister, and so on), refuse to consider evidences offered up, or make unreasonable demands on the claimant - "Show me the body," "Where's the DNA?" and so on.

That is my understanding of the criticism being offered. How prevalent it is is open to debate.

In its simplest form its: "X hasn't been proven yet, therefore X doesn't exist". One can add details to it, but it'll always be that same basic assumption.

Also, looking for X and not finding it isn't proof of the non-existence of X if you don't even know what X is and factors that are involved.



You can assume that you know all the factors involved, but in the end you'd just be assuming you know them based on the existence of other large mammals.

"Argument from ignorance also known as appeal to ignorance, is a fallacy in informal logic. It asserts that a proposition is true because it has not yet been proven false (or vice versa)."

Error of the Default Null

/philosophy : pseudoscience : incorrect hypothesis testing/ : a variation of argument from ignorance. The practice of assigning a favored or untestable/unfalsifiable hypothesis unmerited status as the null hypothesis. Further then proclaiming the Default Null to be the prevailing conclusion of science until such testing is conducted which could prove it to be false or until such time as it can be defeated by new competing science.

http://theethicalskeptic.com/2015/08/17/the-four-types-of-null-hypothesis-fallacy/

Can We Accept the Null Hypothesis?​

Some researchers say that a hypothesis test can have one of two outcomes: you accept the null hypothesis or you reject the null hypothesis. Many statisticians, however, take issue with the notion of "accepting the null hypothesis." Instead, they say: you reject the null hypothesis or you fail to reject the null hypothesis.

Why the distinction between "acceptance" and "failure to reject?" Acceptance implies that the null hypothesis is true. Failure to reject implies that the data are not sufficiently persuasive for us to prefer the alternative hypothesis over the null hypothesis.

http://stattrek.com/hypothesis-test/hypothesis-testing.aspx
These posts share at least one underlying problem: They insist on a clinically sterile scientific discussion on the part of those who dismiss Bigfoot while allowing for a pub-level discussion of pub-level evidence on the part of those who claim Bigfoot exists (in any of its speculative forms).

They also share the flaw of assuming that such discussion happens in a vacuum and that anyone who says positively that there is no Bigfoot is an emotional denialist unless in every comment there is a full discussion of the history of claims, their dissection and subsequent refutation, and the full extent of the absence of expected evidence.

OntarioSquatch is particularly guilty of the first problem. There is not one single post of his in support of Bigfoot that extends beyond anything that my drunken friend would say in a night of friendly argument over hot wings and beer, yet every post by those who rightly state there is no Bigfoot is met with some version of misapplied sciencey-sounding nitpickery.
 
^^^^
What's good for the gander is good for the goose.

There's not one shred of scientifically verifiable evidence that anything like Bigfoot exist or ever existed.

So lets turn the mentality question around....what's the mentality of someone who believes not only Bigfoot exist but is an alien hybrid?

Is it stuff like this?



Care to explain OS?
 
Last edited:
Basically OS is hiding behind a poor understanding of "The Null Hypothesis" in order to hide the fact that he has presented zero evidence for Bigfoot. Because there is no Bigfoot. Because he knows perfectly well there is no Bigfoot.
 
^^^^
What's good for the gander is good for the goose.

There's not one shred of scientifically verifiable evidence that anything like Bigfoot exist or ever existed.
So lets turn the mentality question around....what's the mentality of someone who believes not only Bigfoot exist but is an alien hybrid?

Is it stuff like this?

[qimg]http://i796.photobucket.com/albums/yy242/RCM944/4BFC829E-6CAE-42DB-A9F5-B19D027AEF6C.jpg[/qimg]

Care to explain OS?
And there is a near-conclusive absence of the evidence that would be reasonably expected if even a small portion of the claims were true.

In regard to the photo, the real explanation is simple: Drunken Pub Friend pontificating over hot wings and beer.
 
Basically OS is hiding behind a poor understanding of "The Null Hypothesis" in order to hide the fact that he has presented zero evidence for Bigfoot. Because there is no Bigfoot. Because he knows perfectly well there is no Bigfoot.

That's what begs the mentality question, maybe he does truly believe.

Is the presence of proponents on this fourm a result of their belief system being "attacked", and the response is a pile of absurd threads, smear campaigns and disingenuous discussions playing word games. It would seem to be a pretty hysterical response with an almost fanatical reaction.

Why wouldn't a proponent just happily bask in the delusional world of BFF(Bigfoot Fantasy w/Friends)?
 
Last edited:
That's what begs the mentality question, maybe he does truly believe.

Maybe, maybe not.

While I am fully onboard with the BLAARGing hypothesis, and do think it's probably the case in most of these threads, truth be told I'm not as overly concerned as some with how deep this rabbit hole goes because at the end of the day it doesn't matter, my responses are gonna be the same.

Whether OS (or anyone else) honestly believes there is a logically improbable to the point of practical level impossibility giant magical monkey man trouncing around or this is all some silly dog wagging the tail trolling is not a distinction I need to make for myself.
 
How do you know that they're not burying their dead . . . ?

If we needed a tell that OS is just playing a happy troll game, it's hard to beat this old chestnut!

Please share with your 'footer buddies OS: The best way to ensure that physical evidence of real living bigfoots would already have been found would be if said bigfoots were burying their dead. Of course you know this.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom