My point is that it doesn't make sense to accept something if there isn't evidence for it.
So why do you have a problem with somebody who does not accept Bigfoot, when there is no evidence for Bigfoot?
That seems to be the exact opposite for your claim that they were making an argument from ignorance.
Will you now apologise for your error?
Here's another way to look at it:
Belief that something exists ---- Neutrality --- Belief that something doesn't exist
The consensus in science is on neither side if there isn't proof for either side.[/quote]
I am sorry, but you misunderstand the scientific method. The consensus of science is not neutral on the existence of flying giant squids. The consensus of science is that the idea of giant flying squids should only be considered when I offer suitable evidence.
Your view is void, because it never allows for a conclusion to be drawn until it is the one you are happy with. It does not allow for evidence to be gathered and found wanting.
You can come up with a hypothesis to test against, but the null isn't necessarily the accepted view.
By definition, the Null is the accepted view, when comparing to an extraordinary claim. If the claim is giant flying squids, the null is: "There are no large aerial cephlopods that have remained undetected in the sky."
When comparing to Bigfoot, the Null is "misidentification of known species". As no evidence has been produced, that could not have come from a known species, such as human, it is unreasonable to expect people to believe in Bigfoot. The evidence has been tested, and found wanting. The lack of bigfoot is a reasonable conclusion
based on the evidence at hand.
And there is the rub. You ignore that the sceptics will reconsider, when evidence is produced. You argue that we can not know what factors to test for, and make excuses for lack of evidence.
But the simple truth is, people did not decide bigfoot does not exist without evidence. They decided based upon the evidence gathered. Their conclusion is sound, until you supply evidence otherwise.
At some point science must allow that something does not exist, unless evidence otherwise can be given. Otherwise we would still be searching for the ether through which light travels, and we would surely still believe in the tooth fairy.