The Mentality of Skeptics

It's their uncertainty about the truth that makes them uneasy. In other words, they can't stand not knowing. It's not the existence of the entity that they're afraid of.

Sorry, don't agree. Science starts with questions like "Why does that happen?" followed by "I don't know." All scientific progress, all invention, discovery and exploration starts on the boundaries of the known and ventures hopefully, inquisitively and eagerly into the unknown.
Admitting that you don't know something also serves as a counter-balance to hubris. It teaches humility, and also a respect for greater expertise than one's own.
Nowhere on this forum have I seen anyone saying "I know everything!" (with the possible exception of Clayton Moore!), and denying unexplainable phenomena because they are outside our boundaries of knowledge, not because they lack concrete evidence.
Of course you know this. This last part has been said many times, and I and others have repeatedly asked you to back up your pseudo-psychological flim-flam with some actual quotes.
Just in time for Christmas would make a great present. Go on- you know you want to!
 
Sorry, don't agree. Science starts with questions like "Why does that happen?" followed by "I don't know." All scientific progress, all invention, discovery and exploration starts on the boundaries of the known and ventures hopefully, inquisitively and eagerly into the unknown.

Indeed. The most exciting words a Sceptic can say is "I don't know".

It is somewhat strange to claim "It's their uncertainty about the truth that makes them uneasy". It is the uncertainty, the possibility of a multitude of explanations, that I find interesting (and that others seem to share).

In my experience those who do not like uncertainty would rather fill the blank with an unshakable belief. Rarely is there any uncertainty that the unidentified object they saw in the sky was an alien vessel. Rarely is there an uncertainty that the large shadow they saw in the woods was a Bigfoot. Or the experience they had in an old building was the ghost of a dead person.

As a sceptic I am often astounded by how much certainty some people have in the "unknown".
 
There's skeptics and then there's denialists who hide behind the label of skeptic. The common traits of a denialist:

- dislikes uncertainty
- clings to the most common belief
- highly critical of opposing views
- doesn't like the idea of possibilities
- believes that all woo is false
- will debunk "woo" using explanations that only sound reasonable
- can't stand criticism


In my experience those who do not like uncertainty would rather fill the blank with an unshakable belief.

Their belief only appears to be unshakable. If you post something that challenges their belief, they'll often react in a way that reveals how insecure they are of their position. It's usually with great anger. The best place to observe this on this forum is in the Bigfoot threads.
 
Indeed. The most exciting words a Sceptic can say is "I don't know".
Indeed.


Fast Times at Ridgemont High - I Don't Know

Good stuff starts at 1:40.

Of course there is stuff we can know, that is demonstrable.
 
I can see one advantage to a psychology forum. Every post that includes a reference to "pseudo skeptics" could automatically be sent there. As a special bonus for those who might occasionally stray into the psychology forum, threads that include reference to "pseudo skeptics" could be noted with an asterisk denoting that they can be safely ignored.

You forgot to include kook, nutter, CTer, Troofers, etc..
 
=Metullus;11018498]As near as I can tell the reasoning goes like this:

1. All skeptics are poopy heads, and,
2. There is no Psychology sub-forum, therefore,
3. All skeptics are poopy heads.

Not poopy heads, Skeptibunkers, many, but not all.
 
You know, just because you put "Law of" in front of something doesn't actually make it a law, or even a reasonable correlation.

Consider that Emily's Cat's Law of Bad Laws.

There you go, you're getting the point. You should put a trade mark symbol on that because I might steal it.
 
Bored of jakesteele early on, I've not kept up with his position. Is it true he thinks we don't give "Bigfoot believers" enough attention? It's perfectly clear he's not talking about us 'cause we give far too much. He probably just got his forums mixed up. He's confused us with That's The Stupidest Thing I Ever Heard™ forum over there ~~~>.

Where did you get that? That has to be some kind of fallacy, doesn't it?
 
There's skeptics and then there's denialists who hide behind the label of skeptic. The common traits of a denialist:

- dislikes uncertainty
- clings to the most common belief
- highly critical of opposing views
- doesn't like the idea of possibilities
- believes that all woo is false
- will debunk "woo" using explanations that only sound reasonable
- can't stand criticism




Their belief only appears to be unshakable. If you post something that challenges their belief, they'll often react in a way that reveals how insecure they are of their position. It's usually with great anger. The best place to observe this on this forum is in the Bigfoot threads.

I have seen many bigfoot believers who match my description. They believe in bigfoot despite the evidence, make a big speech about how the world is mysterious and only sceptics are silly enough to believe that science knows everything... Before talking at length about Bigfoot being real.

So much for the mystery.

And the people who tend to present sceptics, as denialist are the ones who want to misrepresent scepticism as denial. They normally make a "if you are so sceptical why aren't you considering my view... Is science so precious?" Style argument.

Most often there will be petty arguments about why the sceptics refuse to be convinced, instead of listening to the minimum evidence a sceptic requires to be convinced.

ETA: Error corrected to avoid unintentionally misrepresenting the post I was replying to. My bad. Sorry.
 
Last edited:
Most often there will be petty arguments about why the sceptics refuse to be convinced, instead of listening to the minimum evidence a sceptic requires to be convinced.

And that's why Bigfootery remains a pointless exercise, except to display the mind of a believer.

All this contradictory blurble about Obama in a closet, and still no monkey. There's never a monkey. Not even a picture of one.
 
There's skeptics and then there's denialists who hide behind the label of skeptic. The common traits of a denialist:

- dislikes uncertainty
- clings to the most common belief
- highly critical of opposing views
- doesn't like the idea of possibilities
- believes that all woo is false
- will debunk "woo" using explanations that only sound reasonable
- can't stand criticism




Their belief only appears to be unshakable. If you post something that challenges their belief, they'll often react in a way that reveals how insecure they are of their position. It's usually with great anger. The best place to observe this on this forum is in the Bigfoot threads.

OT to the OP...
 
It's just a little confusing, because he names barely a handful of people, and yet he also states in the same post that it's almost everyone who posts in the Bigfoot threads. So I was after a little more clarification, however, clarity isn't a feature among BLAARG'ers.
I was never a Bigfoot believer, so I'm not a "switcher" as OS may have implied.
 
Saying you have your mind made up doesn't mean you're truly convinced. None of the Bigfoot-devoted skeptics here are convinced that it doesn't exist, even if they say they are. They can't stand not knowing so they cling to the position/belief that they think is most likely true. A few of them even switch back and forth bewteen being a skeptic and a proponent, but one thing they never do is come to terms with the fact that they don't know the truth.

Let that freak flag fly!

Endless repetition of a baseless assertion does not make it valid.

SQUAWK for Bigfoot!
 
Last edited:
There's skeptics and then there's denialists who hide behind the label of skeptic. The common traits of a denialist:

- dislikes uncertainty
- clings to the most common belief
- highly critical of opposing views
- doesn't like the idea of possibilities
- believes that all woo is false
- will debunk "woo" using explanations that only sound reasonable
- can't stand criticism




Their belief only appears to be unshakable. If you post something that challenges their belief, they'll often react in a way that reveals how insecure they are of their position. It's usually with great anger. The best place to observe this on this forum is in the Bigfoot threads.

SQUAWK for Bigfoot!
 
Why stop with stating that "None of the Bigfoot-devoted skeptics here are convinced that it doesn't exist, even if they say they are. They can't stand not knowing..." Why not just take the position that none of the Bigfoot-devoted skeptic here even suspect that he doesn't exist! "They all are secretly and strongly convinced that there is a Bigfoot. They are just too argumentative to admit it publicly. Of sure, they will go on and on with their face-saving silly arguments, but they all know that Bigfoot exists. And the more they deny this the more they are only hiding the truth- they all strongly believe in the reality of Bigfoot!"

If one is going to invent a mental state for the opposite side of the debate, and to persist despite their denials and in the total lack of evidence, then why not go all the way? Don't take any half measures.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom