The Mentality of Skeptics

How is that a dodge?

OntarioSquatch said:
You, William Parcher and dmaker come to mind. Also maybe JoeBentley. I'm not sure about him though.
This reply was to me, not John Jones. It was in response to my questions in posts#249 and 253 which were clearly made in response to this assertion of yours.
There's people who are troubled by the fact that they don't know if Sasquatch exist or not. I've seen them both here and on the Bigfoot forums. Some of them switch back and forth between believing that they do exist and believing that they don't, but one thing that they never do is accept the fact that they don't know.
Now, one more time, I have never believed in footie, nor do I have any doubts as to its non-existence. Please refrain from any claims, assertions or implications otherwise.

Thanks.
 
Last edited:
Context: People who have doubts about the existence or non-existence of Sasquatch.

Nobody has doubts, mate. You're the only person in these threads who has professed to having doubts. I've certainly not had any, so your general sweeping of posters, including me, is not only pathetically underhanded, but it's also blatantly untrue, and thus, borne of ignorance. Isn't this thread about supposedly ignorant thinking?

You've got little to no credibility with me, OS.
 
Based on first-hand accounts of two different people I have an open mind about the existence of Bigfoot. I would just like my mind filled with evidence, not cool stories.
 
=Cosmic Yak;11023463]I thought this part of your post deserved its own answer. I read three pages of the thread you linked to, looking for the kind of behaviour you described. This is what I found:
Firstly, you hijacked a thread about Jenny McCarthy with a post making allegations against 'Big Pharma'.
The first reply (Post 2) asks for evidence. No insults, no shrillness, no arrogance or condescension.

You said in regards to what you think is my hijacking of the JM thread:
post 2 ‘asks for evidence’ no insults
Like to be a little more specific? Or does your argument lose traction if you're forced to discuss the facts?
Athon

My reply – I didn’t intentionally hijack the thread. I got into computers late in life and started my forum education on Sherdog.com, which is an MMA site. I was not up on forum protocols in general the protocols specifically on this site.

I came here hoping for better. At first I was very pleased and I was impressed with science/math, etc. but then I came to Gen. Skept/CT forums and was amazed at the disconnect between rationality and emotionality exhibited between safe forums and hot button forums.

Also, if you want to talk about hijacked threads, check out the one entitled ‘Mentality of Skeptics’. That’s a humdinger of a thread jack, isn’t it? It starts out as one topic and the segues into attacks about OntarioSasquatch about Bigfoot. #27-Like I already said, you're totally missing the point. This thread isn't even about Bigfoot. I re-jacked the thread and got it back on track.

I don’t if we are reading the same post #2, but the one above, right out of the gate, is sarcastic, snarky, condescending, insulting, etc.. It set the mood and the tone of the back and forth right out of the gate.

Post 4: Looks at both sides, no unquestioning defence of Big Pharma, no insults.
Post 6 asks you to move this to a separate thread, a request you ignore. No insults, no " shrill, irrational, arrogant, condescending, insulting psuedoskepticism ".

I didn’t intentionally hijack the thread. I got into computers late in life and started my forum education on Sherdog.com, which is an MMA site. I was not up on forum protocols in general the protocols specifically on this site. Also, this was my first major thread of involvement on this forum. If you bother to read past the first 100 posts, my point about "Outraged Hounds of Hell" is self evident...at least it is to most people but not on this site, unfortunately.

In post 8, you ask people to 'follow the money'.
First response: No insult, no arrogance, simply a statement of fact. Chris Haynes, in Post 14, produces a series of links showing how following the money refutes your idea (This is an assumption, based on his comments: the links don't work any more). No insult, no shrillness, no arrogance. Just research.
Your response?

And my post said:
Yes, people do care about saving the lives of their kids. They don't want them having unnecessary surgeries, unnecessary psych meds, etc. The greatest evil there is is narrow minded bigotry like the Salem Witch trials.

There's an old saying, "Follow the money"


And paximperium's response: And that continues to be irrelevant to vaccinations and the harm that woo-mongerers are pushing.

Why don't you start your own thread on this and bring things called "evidence" before making a fool of yourself?


First paragraph my first take was/is WTF? He's making up his own rule and taking it totally out of context to the point I was making. He is totally overlooking the obvious which is that Big Pharma does all kinds of nefarious things like off-label marketing, which is illegal, and all of the drug recalls because of ill effects, some of which is unavoidable, but certainly not all.

You didn't bother to read, apparently, past post 100 and you cherry picked certain ones that you think make a case. Right off the bat you say post #2 was not arrogant, snarky, etc., which is totally different from my take. If you read further you will find the Law of Ratpacking™, which if you don't agree to that, then we are apparently in two different concurrent realities a gagillion multi-verses apart and neither one of us has an intermulti-verse transportation devise.

4
‘haven’t been total angels’ saved at least once by big pharma
no insults…produces series of links refutes my idea(assumption on my part based on his comments: links don’t work any more) no insults, no arrogance… your response

Law of Intentionally Ignoring the Obvious™ – he brushes the whole point of my ‘thread hijacker’ by not even addressing the issue of the bad that Big Pharma does, which is even more egregious than a Dem/Rep saying, “Hah, you’re guy got caught with his pants down around his ankles and his hand in the till? And the Dem/Rep replying, “Yeah, yeah, but look at what your guy did, he…” Which is the Law of Diminishing, minimizing and down playing the point made”

If you take him at face value with ‘links don’t work anymore’ then you have to take me at face value on the ‘Joe Nickell-flying friar’ vid, if not, then it is the Law of Double Standards™- What’s good for the goose ain’t necessarily good for the Gander. Your response? Both the Joe Nickell vid and the Phil Plait vid are classical examples of the Law of the Implausible Plausible™

That, to me, is arrogant and insulting. But maybe that's just me.
Snark begets snark, sarcasm begets sarcasm

Moving on....
Finally the first insult, albeit not one on your list.
In post 30, we get this : These epithets are aimed at your links, not at you, so I'm afraid we can't count this as insulting. whale.to and Natural News (Skopie's Law) are truly deserving of scorn, and I would hope you agree.

I can see how y’all would see it as such, but I, personally, would choose a different term such as definitely ‘conspiracy oriented’ or even paranoid. but the question I would ask of Skeptibunkers™ in general would be, “Are all of the links and data on that site totally wrong, exaggerated, blown out of proportion or what?” I don’t know and I don’t think y’all do either.

At the time of my join date and the date of that Big Pharma split those links were early in my career posting on this type of thread. Also, if you read the whole thread you will notice that I adapted quickly and came up with many links that were, for the most point, right on the money.

Later, in Post 37, you say
More of your pseudo-psychological analysis, which is clearly not based on anything posted so far.
Chris Haynes comes back in Post 42 with another series of links (evidence, research, what we do here), and this request:

No insults, no arrogance, no condescension, no shrillness. Just a request for evidence.

And the rest of my post says, “I don’t care whether vaccinations are good or bad. My point is that if you are going on a crusade against, as one poster said, “evil”, then start with the big boys first where you can do the most good for the most people. After you have cleaned up that mess, then go for the smallfries and more power to you in all cases. What you do is good, it just needs to be refocused to where the “true evil” lies.

Remember, this started out as ‘The JM body count’ which was inflammable and misleading slander that showed no direct causal link between JM and any deaths. As I said, she would be in jail for negligent homicide.

I could go on, but I think everyone has by now got my point. The questionable (i.e. insulting or otherwise potentially objectionable) posts are few and far between. Posts either asking for you to back up your claims with evidence, or refuting, with evidence, what claims you have made, constitute the overwhelming majority of responses, along with requests for you to stop hijacking a thread and start a new one. Nowhere in what I read (which was up to Page 3, over 100 posts) did I see any of the epithets you claimed posters had levelled at you. In fact, you were more insulting than anyone else. You hijacked a thread, refused to respond to multiple questions and threw accusations of shilling, obsessive-compulsive disorder, irrationality, illogicality and non-objectivity at everyone who attempted to debate with you.
Once again, you have utterly failed to show any real evidence for your claims. If the (mostly) polite, reasonable and communicative posts you cite here are what you call 'hounds of hell', then I would surmise that you have led a very sheltered existence, where everything you have said is greeted with uncritical acceptance and adulation, because the amount and tone of debate and disagreement shown in that thread is what I said before: normal human behaviour. Your unwillingness and/or inability to deal with it is not a defect of the members of this forum. As the old adage goes, look within.

You obviously didn't read the entire thread or a rational skeptic wouldn't be saying what you are saying. I presented good link after good link of solid facts to back up my stand, but for the most part they were ignored, brushed aside or twisted in their interpretation.

I'll give you the benefit of the doubt and not accuse you of hijacking this thread, that's already been done and I re-jacked the thread and got it back on point. I p.m.ed OntarioSasquatch and here's what I asked him:
My first pm asked him if he thought I had overstepped my bounds and here was his response:
Re: possible derailing of thread
Your posts were all on topic. It was the discussion on the existence of Sasquatch that derailed it.


However, I would say you are sidetracking the thread by making such a lengthy response to it. I proved my point on several issues already. And they are:

Law of Ratpacking™ the Jenny M. Body/Big Pharma split and this thread here with me and Ontario.

Law of the Implausible Plausible™ Joe Nickell vid and Phil Plait vid

Derailing of thread from Ontario's first post to woo bashing-stated above.

You will notice that I haven't responded to many of the ratpackers because my strategy, after the JM thread is to only respond to the first couple three posters or one that makes detailed responses like you did. To try to answer all of the posts responding to me, aside from time and energy, is that the more people you respond to, the more diffuse and complex it gets and many of the respondents will reframe, twist and distort my responses until it becomes tattered and frayed than is possible to keep up with.



Now, the Jenny. M. thread is a different thread for a different time. Also, the more down the rabbit hole we go the more complex, time consuming and draining it becomes. I grow weary of this because it is obvious that neither one of us is going to convince the other and so it becomes a matter of endurance. I will not respond to anymore JM stuff. If you want to start a thread called JM Body Count/Big Pharma, by all means do so and I will probably jump in on that.

We've been playing the Skeptibunker™ game, now it's time to play my game. I'm going to try to explain to you some things that hopefully will give a better insight to this whole irrationality that goes on in these 'hot button' threads(politics, social stuff aside).

I am a guy by the side of a lake trying to tell a fish about the meaning of 'wet' and the fish is saying, "I don't get what you are saying." Now I grab the fish and throw him on the bank and let him flop and gasp in panic and then I throw him back in the lake and say, "Now do you get it?" And the fish says, "Yeah, now I understand the concept of 'wet'. The best way for you to get it is to go to SGU and look at the discourse there. It is much more civil, polite and well thought out without all the shrill hysteria. Also, this site: http://www.rationalskepticism.org/general-debunking/ The differences between this site and those is not black and white, but more like the differences between dusk before the night and dawn before the day. Shared similarities, but much different regarding mood, tone, temperment, etc.. If you can't see the difference between here and there, then I would consider you to be incorrigible, and, as I've already said, "You can't see the wood for the b(sn)ark.

Also, at my own time and expense I'm going to give you a bunch of links so you can see what other people think of the Skeptibunker™ scene in general:

http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/releases/261561.php

http://www.skepticalaboutskeptics.org/

http://freethoughtblogs.com/pharyng...lly-divorce-myself-from-the-skeptic-movement/

http://www.dailygrail.com/news/psychology-of-the-skeptic

http://thomassheridanarts.com/articles.php?article_id=82

http://monkeywah.typepad.com/paranormalia/2008/11/spr-study-day---the-psychology-of-the-sceptic.html

http://www.skeptic.com/about_us/manifesto/

http://weekinweird.com/2012/08/09/solve-coagula-debunkers-response/

http://weekinweird.com/2013/03/05/letter-editor-strawmen-james-randi-skeptic-religion/

http://disinfo.com/2013/06/stephen-bond-why-i-am-no-longer-a-skeptic/

http://vigilantcitizen.com/forums/Thread-Re-discovering-the-Mind

You have a couple of choices to make in regards to the links posted above. One choice is to set aside your Skeptibunker™ hat and put on an openminded, objective hat and see what others see about you. Your other choice is to apply the

Law of Contemptio Prepositus Inquiro™ - (contempt prior to investigation)

or the Law of Broad Brushstrokes™

You can call them all cranks, nutters, woos, etc., if you are so inclined and be done with it.

You are seeing yourself from the inside out, but others see you from the outside in. There's a big difference.

Also, you said, "look within", that's what Ontario and I have been saying to y'all all along.
 
Speaking only for myself, though I am sure OS counts me as a member of the pseudos, I would absolutely LOVE IT if Sasquatch were real. Think how amazing that would be! "Skeptics are afraid of uncertainty." What ********.

Count me in with that. Were Squatch real. it would be a discovery once in a lifetime. Relict hominid found? That would be fascinating.

The problem is that OS thinks you and I are shivering in our boots at the concept of a squatch for reasons even he cannot describe. Got a problem with that idea? Take it up with him. He is the one claiming that skeptics fart in their panties at the mere thought of uncertainty.
 
Also, you said, "look within", that's what Ontario and I have been saying to y'all all along.

:D

You might as well have just said "that's what the blue-haired man who lives in my cupboard and I have been saying to y'all all along," because the fictional man in the cupboard would have about as much credibility in telling anyone anything. You both make me chuckle, lol.
 
I like Obama as an example rather than a dragon, because we might be pre-agreed that dragons don't exist.

So, here are two statements about my closet:
1) President Obama is in my closet.
2) President Obama is not in my closet.

Are you saying that only one of those claims requires evidence? That, lacking any direct evidence, I should accept one as true and reject the other?

Both are claims about the as-yet-unknown contents of a closet, one positive, one negative. Both are possible. I think either would require evidence for verification.
Sorry to get back to Obama in the Closet thing from way back. But I have a couple of points:

First:

1) President Obama is in my closet.
2) President Obama is not in my closet.

Are both positive claims IMO. Am I correct. A negative claim is a claim made against a positive claim. So:

1+) President Obama is in my closet.
1-) No, nope. I don't believe you. Seems unlikely to me, you need to prove it.

2+) President Obama is not in my closet
2-) I think you could be wrong here, he was in this area, and it wouldn't be the first time after all. I know he likes you, and you like him...

The positive claim has the burden of proof.

Secondly:

Did you go home and check last night (just to make sure)
 
Sorry to get back to Obama in the Closet thing from way back. But I have a couple of points:

First:

1) President Obama is in my closet.
2) President Obama is not in my closet.

Are both positive claims IMO. Am I correct. A negative claim is a claim made against a positive claim. So:

1+) President Obama is in my closet.
1-) No, nope. I don't believe you. Seems unlikely to me, you need to prove it.

2+) President Obama is not in my closet
2-) I think you could be wrong here, he was in this area, and it wouldn't be the first time after all. I know he likes you, and you like him...

The positive claim has the burden of proof.

Secondly:

Did you go home and check last night (just to make sure)

I didn't check. The hypothetical does sound like a recipe for OCD though.

As to your breakdown of what constitutes a positive and negative claim, I don't read the second ones in those pairs as being claims at all.

So, while I disagree with how you labeled them, I do think a statement about my beliefs is the better way to go as a skeptic.
"Obama is/isn't in my closet." - claim
"I don't believe you." - good skeptical response, without making a negative/counter claim.
 
I was going to check my closet tonight to make sure that President Obama is not in it, and maybe offer him some cheese and crackers, but then when I started thinking about it, I figured I dare not open the door. Equal to that possibility is, after all, that there is a hungry tiger in my closet that would eat me, or that the corpse of Lenin is in my closet and that would be gross. Of course there could also be four hundred pounds of parmesan cheese in my closet, and that would be very tasty, and also would keep Mr. Obama from starving, so perhaps I'd better just check. Of course it could also be peanut butter, which I don't like, so maybe I'd be better off leaving it there. All these things, after all, are known to exist, and I have not actually looked in my closet, so how can I be sure they are not there? Oh dear, it's getting very confusing. Every time I stop to think about it, I think of something else that could theoretically be there. What if there's an alligator or a black mamba? Do I dare to look? Egad! I haven't checked the basement and the barn either. Every night I check under the bed for monsters, but my sleep is fitful. Did I lock the closet door?

 
I was going to check my closet tonight to make sure that President Obama is not in it, and maybe offer him some cheese and crackers, but then when I started thinking about it, I figured I dare not open the door. Equal to that possibility is, after all, that there is a hungry tiger in my closet that would eat me, or that the corpse of Lenin is in my closet and that would be gross. Of course there could also be four hundred pounds of parmesan cheese in my closet, and that would be very tasty, and also would keep Mr. Obama from starving, so perhaps I'd better just check. Of course it could also be peanut butter, which I don't like, so maybe I'd be better off leaving it there. All these things, after all, are known to exist, and I have not actually looked in my closet, so how can I be sure they are not there? Oh dear, it's getting very confusing. Every time I stop to think about it, I think of something else that could theoretically be there. What if there's an alligator or a black mamba? Do I dare to look? Egad! I haven't checked the basement and the barn either. Every night I check under the bed for monsters, but my sleep is fitful. Did I lock the closet door?

How like the future that sounds. For when I dare to predict what will happen, yet I remain suspicious that, despite my honest intent and strong yearning, something will have slipped by me and the future which comes will surprise rather than satisfy.

I shall then attempt to choose my uncertainties wisely, for the vast set is too large to see entire and so must be ignored. I shall choose a few to puzzle over and agonize about, but just a few. The rest may fly where they will, and I shall wait until the future fixes itself, glued down and labeled past, and then I shall say, "Oh, but I knew all along what would be."

Do not ask more of me, nor of any man. For even when I create a world, as when spinning a fancy tale of pretend heroes, even then, as God Almighty of this little world, the characters - when true and worth writing - still manage to betray my desires and surprise their own author. There is no certainty to be had. Perhaps the horse will sing. But do not bet on it. Do not bet on uncertain things, for as soon as you take uncertainty to be sure, you find out even uncertainty cannot be relied upon.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom