The Mentality of Skeptics

That's not the same as being taken by surprise by an 8 foot gorilla-looking humanoid. Even if you're not scared or shocked and are ready to take a picture, the time it takes to pull out an iPhone and switch it to camera is often enough for it to get away.

Another issue is that they look like people. All someone needs is a fur coat to look like one from a distance, so even if you get a picture or video of what you believe is a Sasquatch, you can bet that people on the internet will call fake.

But you've admittedly never seen a Bigfoot, so how can you be sure of the likely reaction to seeing one? Did Patterson display any of what you've mentioned? He got his camera out fine, depending on who you ask and/or which account you choose to believe.

Patterson not only didn't have a problem filming it, but he also opted to run after it, before "tracking" it for several miles. No shock, no surprise, nothing.
 
But you've admittedly never seen a Bigfoot, so how can you be sure of the likely reaction to seeing one?

Just reading people's reports makes it obvious. From what I've read, up close encounters with Sasquatch often scare the hell out of people. Even long distance sightings can scare someone. The usual thoughts are:

"what am I looking at?"
"Is it going to attack me?"

"Wow, I better get a picture!" isn't a common reaction

Patterson not only didn't have a problem filming it, but he also opted to run after it, before "tracking" it for several miles. No shock, no surprise, nothing.

He did have some problems filming it, but he did manage to get a clear shot. In his case, luck met with preparation.
 
That's not the same as being taken by surprise by an 8 foot gorilla-looking humanoid. Even if you're not scared or shocked and are ready to take a picture, the time it takes to pull out an iPhone and switch it to camera is often enough for it to get away.
People were taken by surprise by griz, saber-tooths, big hairy efalants for eons; didn't stop them from reducing these to possession.

Who says you can't surprise footie? That would be the most reliable way to harvest one if they were real.

Another issue is that they look like people.
Patty doesn't look like people, nor Standing's muppets, nor Erikson's Wookie.

Bald assertion.

All someone needs is a fur coat to look like one from a distance, so even if you get a picture or video of what you believe is a Sasquatch, you can bet that people on the internet will call fake.

So what? If you think you've videoed a footie, go back to that spot and look for confirming evidence. I understand that's not standard footer procedure, but it should be.
 
Last edited:
That's not the same as being taken by surprise by an 8 foot gorilla-looking humanoid.

As Gilbert asked, how would you know?

Horror movies aren't reality.

Even if you're not scared or shocked and are ready to take a picture, the time it takes to pull out an iPhone and switch it to camera is often enough for it to get away.

Why is it so much easier to get a picture of a chinstrap penguin in the Weddell Sea than Bigfoot in North America? Are there more photographers in Antarctica? Or is it because penguins are real?

Another issue is that they look like people. All someone needs is a fur coat to look like one from a distance, so even if you get a picture or video of what you believe is a Sasquatch, you can bet that people on the internet will call fake.

How could a story with a photo be more ridiculous than the same story without a photo?
 
Just reading people's reports makes it obvious. From what I've read, up close encounters with Sasquatch often scare the hell out of people. Even long distance sightings can scare someone. The usual thoughts are:

"what am I looking at?"
"Is it going to attack me?"

"Wow, I better get a picture!" isn't a common reaction

That's how you can tell they're lying. In real life, people have photographed bears attacking them.
 
Just reading people's reports makes it obvious. From what I've read, up close encounters with Sasquatch often scare the hell out of people. Even long distance sightings can scare someone. The usual thoughts are:

"what am I looking at?"
"Is it going to attack me?"

"Wow, I better get a picture!" isn't a common reaction



He did have some problems filming it, but he did manage to get a clear shot. In his case, luck met with preparation.


So, reading reports, which you neither can confirm nor deny, has given you information, regarding how people react to Bigfoot, that you can now conclude to be deemed as being obvious?

Ironically, everything you've said here goes against the PGF "encounter" and quite a few others.

"What am I looking at?" - Didn't seem to enter Roger's mind.

"Is it going to attack me?" - Didn't seem to even cross Roger's mind for a second.

"Wow, I better get a picture!" isn't a common reaction," - ironically, it was a reaction that Roger Patterson had, and acted upon.

He had no problems filming it, unless you count him being thrown from the horse, but again, this only happened in one of the accounts, lol. He even bent the stirrup in one account.

It's amazing that such a rare chance-encounter could be punctuated with so many differing versions of accounts from the "only" people there.
 
So, reading reports, which you neither can confirm nor deny, has given you information, regarding how people react to Bigfoot, that you can now conclude to be deemed as being obvious?

Ironically, everything you've said here goes against the PGF "encounter" and quite a few others.

"What am I looking at?" - Didn't seem to enter Roger's mind.

"Is it going to attack me?" - Didn't seem to even cross Roger's mind for a second.

"Wow, I better get a picture!" isn't a common reaction," - ironically, it was a reaction that Roger Patterson had, and acted upon.

He had no problems filming it, unless you count him being thrown from the horse, but again, this only happened in one of the accounts, lol. He even bent the stirrup in one account.

It's amazing that such a rare chance-encounter could be punctuated with so many differing versions of accounts from the "only" people there.

Roger was mentally prepared for it. It was what he was supposedly searching for.

"Is it going to attack me?" - Didn't seem to even cross Roger's mind for a second.

It actually did if you've listened to Bob Gimlin talk about Patterson's feelings about the encounter. It's why he didn't want Gimlin to leave him there without a horse.
 
Last edited:
Roger was mentally prepared for it. It was what he was supposedly searching for.



It actually did if you've listened to Bob Gimlin talk about Patterson's feelings about the encounter. It's why he didn't want Gimlin to leave him there without a horse.

LOL. So, on one hand, seeing an 8-foot Gorilla-looking humanoid is apparently enough to render most people into a state of dumbfounded shock, but if you mentally prepare for such a sight, you're immune to the surprise?

How can you take Gimlin's word about whether Roger did or did not genuinely feel some type of fearful emotion? It's been pointed out several times that neither man could even agree on basic things, such as whether or not Roger was thrown from the horse, and/or whether the horses showed any fear.

From what we can tell, Roger ran after Patty, and Gimlin was a bit of the way away, with a gun, that they'd both agreed not to use... I'll let that sink in for a moment.
 
The point I'm trying to make here is there isn't any need to make presumptions. You could make a presumption about something you don't know about and you might be right, but doing so is neither evidence-based or skeptical thinking; it's guesswork.

Better look in your closet for Barack Obama then. Have you checked yet today? He could be spying on you.

Dave
 
To put it simply, you can't know what's inside a closet if you've never looked into it. You can guess what is and isn't in there, but you'd just be guessing.

No matter how you look at it, it's very different from this
I disagree, to this extent. It is true you cannot know what is inside the closet without looking inside. It is not true you therefore cannot know what is NOT inside the closet without looking inside. Evidence for what is not inside is found outside. If, for example, I have good, sound, reasonable evidence that President Obama was in Washington, DC a couple of hours ago, and if I know that nobody has opened the closet since before that time, I do not have to know what is in that closet to know that President Obama is not. I can open my closet, and be, not just reasonably confident, but utterly sure, completely and absolutely, that President Obama will not jump out. Neither will Donald Trump nor a tiger nor a taxicab.

Do you really think that as I stand outside the closet contemplating, I need to know what is inside it in order to know that i am not?

Being unsure of exactly what is in my closet does not mean that I must consider the possibility that it contains the entire universe.
 
Last edited:
Roger was mentally prepared for it. It was what he was supposedly searching for.

...And the thousands of people combing the forests with cameras ready are not "prepared" to take a picture of an animal. Gotcha.

That's another clue there is no bigfoot: birders would be the first to get pictures, not bigfooters.
 
Yes, but that's not the same as trying to debunk the very existence of certain entities. The motivation for it might be the same though.



The burden of proof lies with anyone making a claim. It doesn't matter if it's a positive or negative claim.

All that there is to BF is claims of evidence, there is nothing else...
 
I fear that we are departing from the theme of this thread and now fully into ideas best explored, indeed already explored, in the multiple Bigfoot threads.

If you wish, you can find my views of the "too surprised to photograph" concept on the Bigfoot Follies: part deux thread.
 
There's less than ten thousand reports published in databases and a good portion of them aren't even visual sightings. Compare that to the number of people who use forests every year.



It's difficult to be sure if someone's telling the truth or not but when you study the phenomenon long enough, you eventually get some idea of which reports are likely to have happened.

By what criteria?
 
Seeing a large mythological creature like Bigfoot for the first time is much scarier than seeing any known animal that you previously knew about. A lot of Sasquatch eyewitnesses end up with symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder like not wanting to go out into the woods alone and fearing that there might be a Sasquatch in every shadow of the woods. I think Cervelo might have experienced something like this.

By what criteria?

Usually location, time of year, behaviour observed by the witness, behaviour of the witness and physical description.
 
Last edited:
Seeing a large mythological creature like Bigfoot for the first time is much scarier than seeing any known animal that you previously knew about. A lot of Sasquatch eyewitnesses end up with symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder like not wanting to go out into the woods alone and fearing that there might be a Sasquatch in every shadow of the woods. I think Cervelo might have experienced something like this.



Usually location, time of year, behaviour observed by the witness, behaviour of the witness and physical description.


Again, if you've not seen one, then how can you be so sure?

And again, Roger was perfectly fine when stumbling across this supposedly large, scary, mythical creature. They'd even anticipated their lack of fear and agreed to not bother shooting one if they saw one.

Roger, Freeman, and most other hoaxers witnesses that I can think of, all displayed about as much post-traumatic stress syndrome as I displayed when I ate a bacon-sandwich for lunch today.
 
Seeing a large mythological creature like Bigfoot for the first time is much scarier than seeing any known animal that you previously knew about. A lot of Sasquatch eyewitnesses end up with symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder like not wanting to go out into the woods alone and fearing that there might be a Sasquatch in every shadow of the woods. I think Cervelo might have experienced something like this.



Usually location, time of year, behaviour observed by the witness, behaviour of the witness and physical description.

I've been trying to move this to a more appropriate thread. So far without result. So I will just point out that I have never seen either a Bigfoot or a mountain lion in the woods. I have "heard" of both, and I have heard that mountain lions can kill and eat me, but Bigfoot will not. Why on earth would seeing a Bigfoot scare me more than seeing a mountain lion? Many people who have photographed mountain lions never expected to see one when they went hiking- how are they more prepared than seeing another creature that they did not expect; Bigfoot?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom