To put it simply, you can't know what's inside a closet if you've never looked into it. You can guess what is and isn't in there, but you'd just be guessing.
No matter how you look at it, it's very different from this
I agree with Dave Rogers- I very much doubt that this is really how you operate in your real life. I do know pretty well what to expect in
my closet from what I have seen and not seen, and Obama is not one of those things. What I have seen and not seen are FACTS, and I have formed an operative conclusion based on them. So I do know to a very high degree what is in my closet. That is not the same as stating that Obama absolutely cannot be in my closet, but when I opened it to take out my pants this morning, I did not think, "Oh, what if the POTUS in in there and will see me in my underwear?!?" The tiny tiny chance that he was in my closet was not the way that I, or you, actually run our lives. And it would be silly, even impossible, to run our lives based on the assumption that virtually anything was of sufficiently high enough probability that we should consider it equally with the much higher expectations of other things, with the relative probabilities determined from our prior experiences and knowledge of what is likely to be in a closet.
More generally although I know less certainly what might be in a closet that I have never opened, the probably of some items is nonetheless much, much higher than others. An unopened closet in someone else's house may be empty, or have clothes, or even a vacuum cleaner or golf clubs. But it is much less likely to have Obama in it, unless it is a closet in the Whitehouse, Camp David, or a hotel in which we know Obama is staying.
Many people, including myself, have agree that almost anything has at least some tiny, tiny probability, including Obama in my closet or the existence of Bigfoot. In fact quantum mechanics indicates that there is a very, very tiny chance that the next time you lie down to sleep on your bed you will tunnel through and land on the floor. But we run our lives based on the prevailing, reasonable probabilities, and only function by discarding as a matter of practice such incredibly low probabilities as Obama in My Closet. And you do too in your life; arguing otherwise is not enhancing the credibility of your position on Bigfoot.
If you wish to state that the existence of Bigfoot is on the same order of probability as Obama in My Closet, I might be willing to agree just to be polite, even though I think the former probability is much higher than the latter. Even though both are so very close to zero as to not change my working conclusions or how I run my life.