The Mentality of Skeptics

To put it simply, you can't know what's inside a closet if you've never looked into it. You can guess what is and isn't in there, but you'd just be guessing.

No matter how you look at it, it's very different from this

Nonsense, you can formulate a pretty good "guess" of what may be inside a particular closet, Obama would be a rare-find, and that's putting it lightly.

It's the same deal with Bigfoot, you don't need to personally search each and every local park or woodland to understand that the chances of finding a non-existent alien-ape hybrid are slimmer than Victoria Beckham's legs.
 
To put it simply, you can't know what's inside a closet if you've never looked into it. You can guess what is and isn't in there, but you'd just be guessing.

Do you check all your closets for Barack Obama daily, or do you just live your life on the assumption that he's not in there? If (b), then you've formed a provisional conclusion in exactly the same way you're complaining everyone else has about Bigfoot. If (a), you're stark staring bonkers.

Dave
 
Do you check all your closets for Barack Obama daily, or do you just live your life on the assumption that he's not in there? If (b), then you've formed a provisional conclusion in exactly the same way you're complaining everyone else has about Bigfoot. If (a), you're stark staring bonkers.

Dave

:thumbsup:
 
To put it simply, you can't know what's inside a closet if you've never looked into it. You can guess what is and isn't in there, but you'd just be guessing.

No matter how you look at it, it's very different from this

You are actually persisting in this analogy? Amazing.

Okay, let me try this:

1. There are approximately 125 million houses in the USA (I think that this includes apartments, but the argument is the same if it does or doesn't).

2. Each house has at least one closet, probably more.

3. So at minimum, even if Obama was hiding in a closet in the USA right now, the chance of this being true for any one closet would be less than one in 125 million, assuming that he can only be one place at one time.

The statistics alone indicate that the chance of Obama being in my closet is less than one in 125 million even if we know that he is in a closet. Do you still think that we all need to look into each of our closets to be able to say, "Obama is almost surely not in my closet." Do you really believe that it is non-skeptical to reach this type of conclusion without actually looking, and that this is any more "guessing" than reaching the working conclusion that "It is extremely likely that the Sun will rise in the East tomorrow?"

If so, then everything is "guessing" by this type of definition. Yes, everything has a probability, often distinct from absolute zero, but it is more than fair, in common speech and common practice, to typically ignore this feeble likelihood, especially if one remains open to new evidence that, added to the previous evidence, would suggest a different conclusion.
 
3. So at minimum, even if Obama was hiding in a closet in the USA right now, the chance of this being true for any one closet would be less than one in 125 million, assuming that he can only be one place at one time.

Given that he was born in two different countries at the same time, that's a highly questionable assumption.

Dave
 
Do you check all your closets for Barack Obama daily, or do you just live your life on the assumption that he's not in there? If (b), then you've formed a provisional conclusion in exactly the same way you're complaining everyone else has about Bigfoot. If (a), you're stark staring bonkers.

Dave

It's theoretically possible that Obama could be in your closet, but the point I'm trying to make here is that there's no need to make any presumptions or do any guesswork. The closet is there for you to look inside.

If we assume that everything is a negative until it's proven otherwise, then we'd be assuming that every closet in this world that we don't know about is in fact empty. A more logical approach would be to not assume anything.
 
It's theoretically possible that Obama could be in your closet, but the point I'm trying to make here is that there's no need to make any presumptions or do any guesswork. The closet is there for you to look inside.

If we assume that everything is a negative until it's proven otherwise, then we'd be assuming that every closet in this world that we don't know about is in fact empty. A more logical approach would be to not assume anything.

No, you'd assume that most closets were full of clothes of some sort, or boxes, or bed-sheets etc. You wouldn't assume that all closets you didn't know of were empty. Why would you? Comparing something like a closet (which many people have) containing Obama (who certainly exists) to Bigfoot (which is still strangely absent in the year nearly-2016) makes very little sense.

It's very logical to make assumptions based on things we already know, and things we know not to be true.

Again, your mental-gymnastics are all over the place with this Bigfoot thing.

The logical approach, with regards to Bigfoot, is one that you seem against taking.
 
To add insult to quackery, this Obama in my closet analogy only works if we haven't actually looked in bigfoot's closet. We have, however, for centuries. There are thousands (millions?) of people in bigfoot's many North American closets right now, but when we wake up tomorrow morning there will be exactly as much worthwhile evidence for bigfoot as there is today.
 
It's theoretically possible that Obama could be in your closet, but the point I'm trying to make here is that there's no need to make any presumptions or do any guesswork. The closet is there for you to look inside.

If we assume that everything is a negative until it's proven otherwise, then we'd be assuming that every closet in this world that we don't know about is in fact empty. A more logical approach would be to not assume anything.
The one assumption we definitely need not make is the bigfoot assumption as there is no reliable scientific evidence (where there would be a plethora) for such a thing.

I do not assume extant T-Rexes, mermaids, or Elvis either.
 
Last edited:
To put it simply, you can't know what's inside a closet if you've never looked into it. You can guess what is and isn't in there, but you'd just be guessing.

No matter how you look at it, it's very different from this

I agree with Dave Rogers- I very much doubt that this is really how you operate in your real life. I do know pretty well what to expect in my closet from what I have seen and not seen, and Obama is not one of those things. What I have seen and not seen are FACTS, and I have formed an operative conclusion based on them. So I do know to a very high degree what is in my closet. That is not the same as stating that Obama absolutely cannot be in my closet, but when I opened it to take out my pants this morning, I did not think, "Oh, what if the POTUS in in there and will see me in my underwear?!?" The tiny tiny chance that he was in my closet was not the way that I, or you, actually run our lives. And it would be silly, even impossible, to run our lives based on the assumption that virtually anything was of sufficiently high enough probability that we should consider it equally with the much higher expectations of other things, with the relative probabilities determined from our prior experiences and knowledge of what is likely to be in a closet.

More generally although I know less certainly what might be in a closet that I have never opened, the probably of some items is nonetheless much, much higher than others. An unopened closet in someone else's house may be empty, or have clothes, or even a vacuum cleaner or golf clubs. But it is much less likely to have Obama in it, unless it is a closet in the Whitehouse, Camp David, or a hotel in which we know Obama is staying.

Many people, including myself, have agree that almost anything has at least some tiny, tiny probability, including Obama in my closet or the existence of Bigfoot. In fact quantum mechanics indicates that there is a very, very tiny chance that the next time you lie down to sleep on your bed you will tunnel through and land on the floor. But we run our lives based on the prevailing, reasonable probabilities, and only function by discarding as a matter of practice such incredibly low probabilities as Obama in My Closet. And you do too in your life; arguing otherwise is not enhancing the credibility of your position on Bigfoot.

If you wish to state that the existence of Bigfoot is on the same order of probability as Obama in My Closet, I might be willing to agree just to be polite, even though I think the former probability is much higher than the latter. Even though both are so very close to zero as to not change my working conclusions or how I run my life.
 
Last edited:
No, you'd assume that most closets were full of clothes of some sort, or boxes, or bed-sheets etc. You wouldn't assume that all closets you didn't know of were empty. Why would you?

Your closet could be empty for all I know or there could be a ghost in it. The point is that I don't know, so it's more logical for me to not assume anything at all.

When it comes to Sasquatch, most people just don't understand the phenomenon and some claim that they don't exist because there is lack of a lack a body or a certain quantity of evidence. The error in that sort of thinking should be pretty obvious if you're not looking at it through denialist lenses.
 
It's theoretically possible that Obama could be in your closet, but the point I'm trying to make here is that there's no need to make any presumptions or do any guesswork. The closet is there for you to look inside.

If we assume that everything is a negative until it's proven otherwise, then we'd be assuming that every closet in this world that we don't know about is in fact empty. A more logical approach would be to not assume anything.

Once again (do you read other posts) an "empty closet" is not the null, negative, or default position. First, an empty closet is not empty but has air in it, and this is certainly a known form of closet contents. Further people have looked and found closets with clothes and golf clubs and etc. in it. The assumption is that until we look, a closet is likely to contain the sort of things we know (based on known facts) are found in closets: clothes, or golf clubs, or "empty" air. or etc.

I would also add to the previous comments: if (as I strongly suspect) this is really a thread trying to disparage "skeptics" for not sharing your alledged belief in Bigfoot, then I would add that we have looked in the "closet." We have looked in the woods and found no convincing evidence of Bigfoot which should be there if he existed: no scat, no bodies, no clear photographs, etc. If no one had ever looked, then I would assign a higher possibility than I do now that Bigfoot exists (although the question of how a hairy unknown, non-human primate ended up in the woods in North America would still prevent me from assigning a 50:50 probability of existence). But people have looked, extensively and for a long time. And only found highly unconvincing evidence when they should have found highly convincing evidence if Bigfoot did exist. So in considering the available evidence, I assign Bigfoot very, very low probability of existence. But if someone comes up with strong evidence that outweighs this prior evidence, then I am certainly willing to change my mind.
 
Last edited:
May I suggest that everyone take a step back.

What OS has proposed is the common childhood boogie monster under the bed.

Risible, I know. Yet all of you have risen to the bait, all of you. Me included.

We have all of us burned countless hours fielding all manner of squatchcranks, but that is their goal. As long as the plethora of squatchkranks can sustain any conversation they get the cosy warm feeling of validation.
 
Your closet could be empty for all I know or there could be a ghost in it. The point is that I don't know, so it's more logical for me to not assume anything at all.

When it comes to Sasquatch, most people just don't understand the phenomenon and some claim that they don't exist because there is lack of a lack a body or a certain quantity of evidence. The error in that sort of thinking should be pretty obvious if you're not looking at it through denialist lenses.

Provisionally no closets contain ghosts, fairies, dryads, unicorns, psychics, hoards of working homeopathic medicine, philosophers stones or sasquatches.

If you had any Bigfoot evidence you wouldn't be tearfully casting aspersions on skeptics. And let's not forget that it's not just skeptics who dismiss this fantasy but experts in biology.
 
Your closet could be empty for all I know or there could be a ghost in it. The point is that I don't know, so it's more logical for me to not assume anything at all.

Your baseline assumption should be Random Closet contains "usual closet stuff." Anything outside that baseline (empty, skeletons, marijuana plants, POTUS) would be unusual, and would be exceptionally unexpected without some other information.

When it comes to Sasquatch, most people just don't understand the phenomenon and some claim that they don't exist because there is lack of a lack a body or a certain quantity of evidence. The error in that sort of thinking should be pretty obvious if you're not looking at it through denialist lenses.


There is no "phenomenon." There either is a large hairy biped for which zero reliable evidence exists or there isn't.

Assuming the existence of things for which there is zero evidence is not sensible, logical, or scientific. It's religious.
 
Your closet could be empty for all I know or there could be a ghost in it. The point is that I don't know, so it's more logical for me to not assume anything at all.

When it comes to Sasquatch, most people just don't understand the phenomenon and some claim that they don't exist because there is lack of a lack a body or a certain quantity of evidence. The error in that sort of thinking should be pretty obvious if you're not looking at it through denialist lenses.

Perhaps you are using your own definition of "assume" as you have been using your own definitions of "skeptic" and of "bias."

Assume as used here almost always implies that the individual's conclusion is that x most likely, but "assume" typically includes recognition of the possibility that the assumption is wrong. Otherwise one would use a much more definitive grammatical construct, such as "Obama is not in my closet!" (and even here most people are using this construction as a verbal short cut and recognize that there is some tiny change otherwise, just as if I stated "A bowling ball will drop to the floor if I let it go from my hand." Yes it might float into the air when released, but my statement is to just indicate that for our intents and purposes it is highly unlikely to do so based on the known facts about bowling balls.
 
As long as the plethora of squatchkranks can sustain any conversation they get the cosy warm feeling of validation.

And you would deny them that at this Christmasy time of year? You fiend.

Plus, you're suggesting that brilliant bulbs like OntarioSquatch are merely playing games when they post insights like these:

"When it comes to Sasquatch, most people just don't understand the phenomenon and some claim that they don't exist because there is lack of a lack a body or a certain quantity of evidence. The error in that sort of thinking should be pretty obvious if you're not looking at it through denialist lenses."

Shame on you.
 
May I suggest that everyone take a step back.

What OS has proposed is the common childhood boogie monster under the bed.

Risible, I know. Yet all of you have risen to the bait, all of you. Me included.

We have all of us burned countless hours fielding all manner of squatchcranks, but that is their goal. As long as the plethora of squatchkranks can sustain any conversation they get the cosy warm feeling of validation.

Agreed.
 
Your closet could be empty for all I know or there could be a ghost in it. The point is that I don't know, so it's more logical for me to not assume anything at all.

When it comes to Sasquatch, most people just don't understand the phenomenon and some claim that they don't exist because there is lack of a lack a body or a certain quantity of evidence. The error in that sort of thinking should be pretty obvious if you're not looking at it through denialist lenses.

It's not necessarily a matter of making the correct assumptions, it's about making a sensible assumption based on what you know. You know that my closet could very likely be full of clothes, or boxes, or bed-linen. You wouldn't naturally assume that I was hiding Barack bloody Obama in there, would you?

I actually think most people understand the Sasquatch phenomenon very well, hence why the programmes for such a creature are routinely made to entertain people, as opposed to educating them. There's a reason why Bigfoot shows are broadcast during the Nat Geo's fictional hour of the evening, along with Ancient Aliens and shows about CGI Megalodon.

I actually think that the vast majority of people understand the "phenomenon" better than you do.

Denialist this and pseudo-sceptic that. At the end of the day, mate, it's not like we're here preventing you from offering something that isn't extremely laughable. It's just that you're hard-pressed to find anything tangible with regards to actual evidence.

There's a reason why Bigfoot's existence is only ever "seriously" discussed in forums such as this, and that other one. There's also a reason why you've not found him, a reason why NL won't take a realistic bet based on its discovery, a reason why Chris wouldn't show his amazing HD footage from 15 feet away, and more importantly, there's a very good reason why the PGF remains the talking-point in Bigfootery, a film from 1967, made by a guy who was literally in possession of a stolen camera and who'd also stolen a bunch of other peoples work when he wrote his book about Bigfoot, which ironically contained a stolen picture of a female Bigfoot who looked suspiciously similar to the one in your avatar, y'know, the one with the block-foot and the unmoving buttocks? :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom