The Mentality of Skeptics

But look what the op is stating.
He claims to know the inner core motivation of 'most skeptics' or 'pseudo' skeptics as he calls them.
He is claiming they are uncomfortable with uncertainty about a particular issue, and their discomfort with that uncertainty motivates them to attempt to debunk the hypothesis with the goal to remove uncertainty.

How can he possibly know, for example, my innermost motivating factor in dismissing, for example, the sasquatch hypothesis? How can he KNOW I am FRIGHTENED of the possibility sasquatch may exist?

I understood the claim to be a kind of stereotyping based on interactions on the forum, not a specific diagnosis of particular member.

The value isn't in a direct criticism targeted at me, but as an outsider's perspective on how this forum reacts. Like most sweeping generalizations, I don't think it applies to many here, but insofar that it does, it interests me.

I would like to think I evaluate claims fairly and without a rush to judgement. I'd like to think that, but if it isn't accurate, I'd like to know that as well.
 
How can he possibly know, for example, my innermost motivating factor in dismissing, for example, the sasquatch hypothesis? How can he KNOW I am FRIGHTENED of the possibility sasquatch may exist?

He can't, of course; but he needs that so he can pretend he isn't wrong.
 
Unless you mean to go full on solipsism, I disagree. It's the same observational methodology that I use to "know" a pot contains boiling water. I observe the characteristics of boiling water, perhaps test my conclusion but perhaps not.

"Aha!," the challenger cries, "But the pot really contained dry ice. That's where the bubbles came from. The "steam" you saw was just cool fog."
And, I have to admit to being fooled. My "knowing" was false. Strangely though, the next pot of boiling water I observe will, once again, rekindle my belief that I know how to recognize boiling water. Just as the next angry person I meet will reinforce my belief that I can recognize anger.

It may be described as guesswork, but this harms nothing. For there are good guesses and bad, accurate and inaccurate. I'd go so far as to state we know each others' minds on par with knowing our own. Perhaps not perfectly reliable, but quite a sufficient measure nonetheless.

After all, what is "knowing" other than a sufficient degree of accuracy? Do I really have to describe the movement of every molecule to "know" the water is boiling? Am I required to be always error free to trust the mechanism? In a world where omniscient is off the table, I think I'll stick with the softer, and more useful meaning of the word.
I'm not sure I agree with the ability to know mental states, but highlight the above because it points up one of the problems with the believer's "you can't know for sure" idea. The pot could contain dry ice only if we have no external knowledge of the environment it is in. If the pot is on the stove in my kitchen, since I know that there has never been any dry ice introduced into my kitchen, then even if I ignore the fact that I poured cold water into it a few minutes ago and turned on the burner, which is now red hot under it, even then, I can be entirely and completely sure that the pot does not contain dry ice. To consider that it might would require a panoply of other ridiculous circumstances - perhaps I blacked out and space aliens replaced the contents of the pot, because isn't that the kind of things that space aliens do? There are plenty of times when you really really do not have to look into the pot to eliminate the possibility that its contents are utterly absurd and impossible.
 
Last edited:
It's theoretically possible that Obama could be in your closet, but the point I'm trying to make here is that there's no need to make any presumptions or do any guesswork. The closet is there for you to look inside.

If we assume that everything is a negative until it's proven otherwise, then we'd be assuming that every closet in this world that we don't know about is in fact empty. A more logical approach would be to not assume anything.

You make a very strange argument, experience would show that certain items are 'frequently' found in closets, while the POTUS, who is highly mobile, highly visible and has a busy schedule would be a remarkable thing to find in a closet.

Generally it would be quite safe to think it highly unlikely that president Obama was in a given closet. While theoretically possible, the probability would be very very very low.

And that is the purpose of the null hypothesis, in general you assume a thing isn't so (Obama in the closet), which is the null hypothesis.

Now again objects which would frequently be found in the closet or infrequently might adjust the null hypothesis, a towel or a pot farm are not infrequent.

But you are just stretching this whole bad analogy to get away from the fact that the evidence for BigFoot is sadly lacking.
 
Your closet could be empty for all I know or there could be a ghost in it. The point is that I don't know, so it's more logical for me to not assume anything at all.

When it comes to Sasquatch, most people just don't understand the phenomenon and some claim that they don't exist because there is lack of a lack a body or a certain quantity of evidence. The error in that sort of thinking should be pretty obvious if you're not looking at it through denialist lenses.

Nice category error and false dichotomy, there are many reasons people may hold a belief that bigfootie exists, many of which do not lead to the reasonable conclusion that such a physical organic creature exists.

I have experienced many a strange phenomena, a dancing star for one. (Great explanation)

As well as wonderful things in a forest after sunset, I could have sworn that a beaver appeared huge to my late twilight perception, and in fact that it was the size of a bear.
It was not however a bear, it was a beaver, despite my misperception.

So I am bear denialist?

:D
 
But you are just stretching this whole bad analogy to get away from the fact that the evidence for BigFoot is sadly lacking.

Exactamundo! This thread isn't about the "mentality of sceptics," it's about the supposed "mentality of Bigfoot-denialists."

OS could care less if we poke fun at Ogo Pogo, or Nessie.
 
Unless you mean to go full on solipsism, I disagree. It's the same observational methodology that I use to "know" a pot contains boiling water. I observe the characteristics of boiling water, perhaps test my conclusion but perhaps not.

"Aha!," the challenger cries, "But the pot really contained dry ice. That's where the bubbles came from. The "steam" you saw was just cool fog."

And, I have to admit to being fooled. My "knowing" was false. Strangely though, the next pot of boiling water I observe will, once again, rekindle my belief that I know how to recognize boiling water. Just as the next angry person I meet will reinforce my belief that I can recognize anger.

It may be described as guesswork, but this harms nothing. For there are good guesses and bad, accurate and inaccurate. I'd go so far as to state we know each others' minds on par with knowing our own. Perhaps not perfectly reliable, but quite a sufficient measure nonetheless.

After all, what is "knowing" other than a sufficient degree of accuracy? Do I really have to describe the movement of every molecule to "know" the water is boiling? Am I required to be always error free to trust the mechanism? In a world where omniscient is off the table, I think I'll stick with the softer, and more useful meaning of the word.
I generally agree with this particular post. I am not denying that based on incomplete information one can come to an inaccurate working conclusion. Based on the "steam" you concluded that the water was probably very hot. Perhaps an even more rigorous skeptic would have thought- "It looks like steam, but what it really is is some form of particulate translucent vapor. It could be smoke or very cold nitrogen gas causing water from the air to condense on it. Or something else along those general lines." Additional information, if available to you at the same time ("The container was hot to the touch, I looked at the container from filling with water to steaming and there was no chance that dry ice was put into it in my presence, it only started to steam once on a lit stove, etc") could have helped you narrow your interim conclusion even further.

But in either case the correct skeptic response is not "It could be anything until I learn more! It could be an airplane or President Obama or..."
Indeed, there are certainly many things, based on what you already knew, that it could not be.

So it is very reasonable for a skeptic to form an interim opinion that matches the facts that they do know. What is crucial for skeptics is to be willing to change their interim opinion in reaction to new information/evidence, just as you did.

My point again: a "true skeptic" is not one who has no prior view of what might be going on. Almost everyone does have some view or suspicion or opinion, and in fact this is necessary to get through life. We reach tentative conclusions based on the available facts all the time and make decisions based on those interim conclusions, if only to drive a car down the street without crashing. But true skeptics are willing to consider any new information with the same standards of significance and accuracy as they apply to their older information, and to be willing to change their conclusion based on this new sum of the evidence.
 
(much snipped)
So it is very reasonable for a skeptic to form an interim opinion that matches the facts that they do know. What is crucial for skeptics is to be willing to change their interim opinion in reaction to new information/evidence, just as you did.

If I understand the complaint from the OP, it's that we sometimes cut-off new evidence and prejudge it based on existing biases. Now, it may be that individuals have a good reason for the biases they hold, but subjectively, from the wooster's point of view, it's just dismissal without a hearing.

The Charlie Hebdo "investigation" thread is a good example. If we dismiss, the idea of a conspiracy, without even examining the evidence offered (to some degree), then I think the charge has some merit to it.

I'm not necessarily agreeing that things are quite as dire as the OP in this thread might think, and I'm certainly not going to allow the criticisms to morph into proof of something else, but it's worth thinking about.

In fact, after awhile, the Hebdo conspiracy thread did move in the direction of looking at the evidence offered up and challenging it directly, instead of categorically dismissing everything in one fell swoop.
 
There is no time, and energy, to verify everything. For that there are filters or peer-reviewed. Be it news agency or journal.

So maybe "true skeptic" indeed examines all evidence but "true skeptic" does not exist because we live like 100 years most. If you ask me, and I consider myself hardcore skeptic, that thread is complete waste of time and energy*, until I see otherwise - through filters.

edit:* from skeptical inquiry point of view
 
Last edited:
It's theoretically possible that Obama could be in your closet, but the point I'm trying to make here is that there's no need to make any presumptions or do any guesswork. The closet is there for you to look inside.

If we assume that everything is a negative until it's proven otherwise, then we'd be assuming that every closet in this world that we don't know about is in fact empty. A more logical approach would be to not assume anything.

Nonsense. The fact that we can assume certain things does not in any way mean that we must assume all things or nothing. I do not need to assume that Barack Obama is in my closet. I know as well as anything that we can call knowledge can qualify knowing, that Barack Obama is not in my closet. I do not need to make unwarranted assumptions about what actually is in it, or what is or is not in any other closet. The only possible way that Barack Obama could be in my closet would be if everything everyone knows about the way the world works is wrong, and this has nothing to do with any other closets or with what is in them or not. Sure, in some theoretical way, perhaps alien fairies warped the space within my closet, kidnapped Obama and transported him invisibly in their lightspeeders and folded him under the door. But I do not have to acknowledge the theoretical possibility that everything about everything is nonsense to know that certain things are not in my closet, and I can know this without ever opening the closet and knowing what is there.

I also know there is not a bigfoot in my closet.
 
But look what the op is stating.
He claims to know the inner core motivation of 'most skeptics' or 'pseudo' skeptics as he calls them.
He is claiming they are uncomfortable with uncertainty about a particular issue, and their discomfort with that uncertainty motivates them to attempt to debunk the hypothesis with the goal to remove uncertainty.

How can he possibly know, for example, my innermost motivating factor in dismissing, for example, the sasquatch hypothesis? How can he KNOW I am FRIGHTENED of the possibility sasquatch may exist?

Speaking only for myself, though I am sure OS counts me as a member of the pseudos, I would absolutely LOVE IT if Sasquatch were real. Think how amazing that would be! "Skeptics are afraid of uncertainty." What ********.
 
Last edited:
Speaking only for myself, though I am sure OS counts me as a member of the pseudos, I would absolutely LOVE IT if Sasquatch were real. Think how amazing that would be! "Skeptics are afraid of uncertainty." What ********.

I don't know if I'd love it or hate it. I might say 'neat, they discovered a new species.', and be interested in the biology for a while. Thats about it. Sorta like with that fish https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coelacanth
 
Speaking only for myself, though I am sure OS counts me as a member of the pseudos, I would absolutely LOVE IT if Sasquatch were real. Think how amazing that would be! "Skeptics are afraid of uncertainty." What ********.

The "Why we haven't had them in the Smithsonian since 1850" explanation would be even more interesting than the animal, but yeah, it would be pretty fantastic.
 
Why wouldn't anyone want Bigfoot to be real? To suggest that it's something that instils fear into people is about as hilariously nonsensical as one can get. It merely makes me laugh at how deluded the believers actually are, that is, the one's who actually believe.
 
If I understand the complaint from the OP, it's that we sometimes cut-off new evidence and prejudge it based on existing biases. Now, it may be that individuals have a good reason for the biases they hold, but subjectively, from the wooster's point of view, it's just dismissal without a hearing.

The Charlie Hebdo "investigation" thread is a good example. If we dismiss, the idea of a conspiracy, without even examining the evidence offered (to some degree), then I think the charge has some merit to it.

I'm not necessarily agreeing that things are quite as dire as the OP in this thread might think, and I'm certainly not going to allow the criticisms to morph into proof of something else, but it's worth thinking about.

In fact, after awhile, the Hebdo conspiracy thread did move in the direction of looking at the evidence offered up and challenging it directly, instead of categorically dismissing everything in one fell swoop.
Yes, it is almost like criticizing Motherhood. Dismissing something due solely to a pre-held viewpoint is not true skepticism. One should always be open to changing one's views based on new information. Of course one might legitimately demand very convincing new data to offset any pre-existing data that itself strongly supports the opposite conclusion. I have good reason to suppose that if I drop a bowling ball, it will fall down. If someone wants to convince me that it might float up instead, they should expect to present very clear and convincing evidence of their claim to balance out all the pre-existing data that I already have accumulated that indicates the ball will fall down. Even if I am being completely fair, and I objectively combine the new data with the old- the total sum would have to be enough to support the float concept, and to for a skeptic demand this is not proof of a pre-existing unfair prejudice. It would be the same if I had no opinion whatsoever of bowling balls at time zero: if one then suddenly presented me with all the facts about gravity and bowling balls, the idea that they might sometimes float would still have to be supported by the total balance of evidence that I am suddenly provided.

My problem with the OP is that I have not found true his claim of a pre-existing closed mindset on this forum that automatically rejects all Bigfoot evidence without a fair hearing. Sure, there may be a few people like that here as anywhere, but the majority have been willing to look at any new evidence that was supplied and they appear willing to change their minds if this new evidence is sufficient, when objectively added to the old evidence, to justify as much.

Unfortunately, from what I have seen, this new pro-Bigfoot evidence has been so weak and full of holes as to be insufficient to cause me to believe in Bigfoot even in the absence of any of the pre-existing data that opposes the likelihood of Bigfoot. Further, in the current thread, OS has more than once stated that one can not legitimately form any opinion about anything until all possible data is acquired. Well, of course there is never a time when all possible data is acquired, and one can certainly narrow down the possibilities and get a reasonable idea of the probability of different conclusions in the meantime. Further, if OS truly believed in his own views expressed in this thread, then why on Earth is he himself drawing such an elaborate and complex conclusion as to the existence and nature of Bigfoot in the total absence of evidence for virtually any of the attributes he assigns to Bigfoot?
 
To suggest that it's something that instils fear into people is about as hilariously nonsensical as one can get.

And even if it did, they'd be lining around the block for a chance to see it. Name any place rumored to have scary stuff happening, and you can probably buy tickets.

As I said earlier, it's the way people act in Scooby Doo. Not the real world,
 
And even if it did, they'd be lining around the block for a chance to see it. Name any place rumored to have scary stuff happening, and you can probably buy tickets.

As I said earlier, it's the way people act in Scooby Doo. Not the real world,

I guess a fair few people might be scared of them, the actual creatures, naturally, but to suggest that the idea of them being real is something that puts fear into people is about as silly as silly gets. We're aware that man-eating sharks exist, and yet we function just fine.

You're right about the love of the fear-factor, though, we've been scaring ourselves for entertainment's sake for centuries. The Ouija board being a good example.
 
It's their uncertainty about the truth that makes them uneasy. In other words, they can't stand not knowing. It's not the existence of the entity that they're afraid of.
 
It's their uncertainty about the truth that makes them uneasy. In other words, they can't stand not knowing. It's not the existence of the entity that they're afraid of.

Is this, then the part where you finally get around to providing support for your...odd...claims?

That would be a refreshing change.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom