The Mentality of Skeptics

What OS has proposed is the common childhood boogie monster under the bed.

The point I'm trying to make here is there isn't any need to make presumptions. You could make a presumption about something you don't know about and you might be right, but doing so is neither evidence-based or skeptical thinking; it's guesswork.
 
May I suggest that everyone take a step back.

What OS has proposed is the common childhood boogie monster under the bed.

Risible, I know. Yet all of you have risen to the bait, all of you. Me included.

We have all of us burned countless hours fielding all manner of squatchcranks, but that is their goal. As long as the plethora of squatchkranks can sustain any conversation they get the cosy warm feeling of validation.

I'm happy to play along with the BLAARG, tbh. There's always the slight chance that OS actually believes all of what he's saying here, and if that's the case, then that's just brilliant.
 
How many tourists visit this closet in a year? Most of whom carry cameras?

There could be an infinite number of visitors and none of them will get anything if they're all either too shocked to remember their camera or if the sightings last only several seconds. Couple that with the rarity of sightings and you'll get a pretty good idea of what's going on.
 
There could be an infinite number of visitors and none of them will get anything if they're all either too shocked to remember their camera or if the sightings last only several seconds.
There have been millions upon millions of interested parties spending billions of hours afield across the depth and breadth of the continent for thousands of years. Mammoth nor mastodon, smilodon nor grizzly were too shocking for these hunters; as a matter of fact, they exterminated these creatures. Footie would have been a footnote

Couple that with the rarity of sightings . . .
According to many in the bigfoot clique, sightings are hardly rare.
. . . and you'll get a pretty good idea of what's going on.
I think we've a pretty good idea about what's going on.
 
According to many in the bigfoot clique, sightings are hardly rare.

I've never heard anyone say that. If someone did say that, they're obviously wrong.

eta - Or perhaps they have a very different idea of "rare".
 
Last edited:
I've never heard anyone say that. If someone did say that, they're obviously wrong.

How do you know that?
That would imply that at least some of those many sightings are fabrications. How do you tell the difference between a fabricated sighting and an actual sighting?
 
Last edited:
There could be an infinite number of visitors and none of them will get anything if they're all either too shocked to remember their camera or if the sightings last only several seconds. Couple that with the rarity of sightings and you'll get a pretty good idea of what's going on.

I'll remind everyone at this point that OS has admittedly never had a sighting, nor has he ever obtained any evidence.
 
I've never heard anyone say that. If someone did say that, they're obviously wrong.

eta - Or perhaps they have a very different idea of "rare".
Many of your co-horts over at that other place claim thousands up thousands of modern sightings, (I've seen one estimate at 100k) and many more that go unreported.

This of course ignores the fact that if footie were as ubiquitous as claimed, there'd be many, many more that just these. Plus, of course, a full body mount in the Field Museum of Natural History.
 
There's less than ten thousand reports published in databases and a good portion of them aren't even visual sightings. Compare that to the number of people who use forests every year.

How do you know that?
That would imply that at least some of those many sightings are fabrications. How do you tell the difference between a fabricated sighting and an actual sighting?

It's difficult to be sure if someone's telling the truth or not but when you study the phenomenon long enough, you eventually get some idea of which reports are likely to have happened.
 
snip



It's difficult to be sure if someone's telling the truth or not but when you study the phenomenon long enough, you eventually get some idea of which reports are likely to have happened.
...and which conclusions are likely to be accurate or even intended to be believed.

This is true.
 
There's less than ten thousand reports published in databases and a good portion of them aren't even visual sightings. Compare that to the number of people who use forests every year.
Once again you'd have to consult with your fellow enthusiasts about this. I believe even you have posited that a great proportion of sightings go unreported, though I have no idea how you (or anyone) would know that.

Clearly this great congruency or consilience of evidence bigfoot enthusiasts claim is as much a chimera as the object of that enthusiasm.
 
It's difficult to be sure if someone's telling the truth or not but when you study the phenomenon long enough, you eventually get some idea of which reports are likely to have happened.

When you say "study the phenomenon," what exactly do you mean? What've you been studying?

None of the reports are likely to have actually happened, apart from in genuine cases of misidentification, and/or the "non-visual" sightings.

You seem to make a lot of assumptions, despite expecting us to believe that you make conclusions based entirely on sound logic.
 
There could be an infinite number of visitors and none of them will get anything if they're all either too shocked to remember their camera or if the sightings last only several seconds.

You've never actually used a camera, have you?

"Several seconds?" I've taken pictures of breaching orca. I'd love to have several seconds to line up a shot.

20070221%20142015-L.jpg


No, I did not get the penguin to pose.
 
Last edited:
You've never actually used a camera, have you?

"Several seconds?" I've taken pictures of breaching orca. I'd love to have several seconds to line up a shot.

The other thing about the "several seconds" line of evidence is that so many reports are "witnesses watched the UFOs hover for several hours".

Check out the database:

[National UFO Reporting Center]
 
You've never actually used a camera, have you?

"Several seconds?" I've taken pictures of breaching orca. I'd love to have several seconds to line up a shot.

That's not the same as being taken by surprise by an 8 foot gorilla-looking humanoid. Even if you're not scared or shocked and are ready to take a picture, the time it takes to pull out an iPhone and switch it to camera is often enough for it to get away.

Another issue is that they look like people. All someone needs is a fur coat to look like one from a distance, so even if you get a picture or video of what you believe is a Sasquatch, you can bet that people on the internet will call fake.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom