The Mentality of Skeptics

I've been trying to move this to a more appropriate thread. So far without result.
OS posts nearly exclusively on bigfoot threads; this is where his misunderstandings with skeptics arise. I don't think it's possible to have an honest discussion without this context.
 
More appropriate to this thread is the question of the mentality of the people who demand very high standards for "skeptics." First, they don't seem to apply those same standards to themselves; instead I see the willingness to believe in things with virtually no evidence, with a clear bias of wanting to believe that does not allow them to judge the evidence fairly and reach an unbiased conclusion.

Second, rather than call the kettle black, I also note that I have not until now really bought into the concept that pro-Bigfoot advocates know that they are making it all up. I usually think that they are true believers. But the past few days in this thread have resulted in me being much more willing to accept that no one could really believe some of what has been posted here. That would now be my preferred conclusion, because if some of the arguments as to closets, Obama, and what would be a reasonable conclusion were meant to reflect actual logic... Come on- pull my other leg.
 
Seeing a large mythological creature like Bigfoot for the first time is much scarier than seeing any known animal that you previously knew about.
Bare assertion.

A lot of Sasquatch eyewitnesses end up with symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder like not wanting to go out into the woods alone and fearing that there might be a Sasquatch in every shadow of the woods.
Unevidenced anecdote

I think Cervelo might have experienced something like this.
Bare assertion.
 
Roger was mentally prepared for it...


Sort of. Roger Patterson was actually immune to Bigfoot's special mind powers. You should consider the possibility that Roger was an alien. It's not as stupid as it sounds. How did Roger get the film developed so quickly? He had a flying saucer. Or, teleportation. Or, a teleporting flying saucer. You and I know about Bigfoot's outer space connection. What about Roger Patterson?

It makes sense if you think about it, OS.
 
Obama being the codename for Bigfoot, in this scenario. It's always about the Big Guy, or the lack thereof.

Not for me. It serves to address the criticisms offered in the OP without having to argue existence questions. Bigfoot is tainted by a substantial disagreement in the underlying beliefs about its existence, short circuiting any discussion about how skeptics react to claims generally, and where the burden of proof lies.

(excellent post snipped some to save space.)

It is interesting that you define knowledge of pre-existing evidence as bias. Bias usually means the inability to interpret new evidence fairly, not forming a conclusion based on prior evidence in the absence of new evidence.

I've tried to explain this before, but I will be very explicit here. And I will use your own example of Obama in My Closet, a silly proposal for you to defend, but which is nonetheless strangely appropriate to the Bigfoot concept and to the idea of skeptics having a pre-existing "bias."

Bias isn't necessarily a negative attribute, at least not how I'm using it. Rather, it's something we bring with us to the analysis. The important bit is to recognize it exists, which, I think, forms the basis for the criticism levied in this thread.

Here are the facts that I am using to calculate the likelihood that Obama is in my closet. Feel free to point out if any of these are not facts (trust that I am not lying to you just for purposes of the argument) and therefore do not represent authentic evidence:

1. Neither I nor anyone I know has observed Obama in their closet. Ever.
2. I have never previously observed anyone unexpectedly in my closet, nor has anyone I have ever met revealed such a thing as to their own closets.
3. Obama does not even know of my existence as far as I can tell, does not know of my address, and has no known reason to sneak into my closet.
4. Neither I nor my wife has heard anything moving in my closed closet. Ever, let alone this morning.
5. The Whitehouse website states that Obama is in Washington DC this morning.
6. There are reports from established news agencies that Obama is in Washington DC as of this morning.
7. For Obama to be in my closet he would have to have snuck out of Washington with no one seeing him, gotten on a commerical plane to California wearing a convincing disguise, changed planes, gotten off at my local airport, secretly taken a cab to my home, somehow have gotten the key, and snuck into my closet without me, by neighbors, my wife, or I seeing him do so.

5, 6, and 7 are new information/evidence you have introduced to the thought problem. I'll suggest another: there's a website where people post their experiences of finding, guess who? Obama in their closets!

Let's face it: the origin of this thread is that any opinion that does not accept the existence of Bigfoot is biased. That is silly. The huge preponderance of evidence indicates that there virtually no chance that there is a Bigfoot. Does that mean that I am saying that there is no Bigfoot, and that I will ignore any future evidence of the existence of a Bigfoot? Of course not! I will consider any evidence along with the entire set of evidence to date and honestly consider if the likely conclusion is now different. An appropriate DNA sequence of some Bigfoot scat would probably do it.

To suggest that working conclusions based on pre-existing facts must represent bias is just plain wrong. Bias is selectively rejecting information, old or new (in fact all new information becomes old information in an instant) unfairly, often for emotional rather than factual reasons. From what I have seen in this thread, I see little or no evidence of bias on the "no reason to believe Bigfoot exists" side but lots of evidence of bias on the "there is a Bigfoot" side.

When you use the word "unfairly" you are expressing the function of bias. It is the prejudgement done to filter out certain types of evidence based on our previous experiences and ideas about what indicates truth.

One could reasonably ask how a person who has seen bigfoot, is surrounded by people who've also seen bigfoot, and who spends time trying to convince others about bigfoot would perceive the same situation. They too have a bias, driven by the same method you outline. One could say they would be unreasonable to reject the notion, based on their own experiences and background facts.
 
Last edited:
Not for me. It serves to address the criticisms offered in the OP without having to argue existence questions. Bigfoot is tainted by a substantial disagreement in the underlying beliefs about its existence, short circuiting any discussion about how skeptics react to claims generally, and where the burden of proof lies.

You should've stopped at bigfoot is tainted.

This is a thread that was borne of Bigfoot, and OS isn't thinking about anything else when he makes his tired claims about the "pseudo-scepticism" of the non-believers.

If we didn't argue the toss about Sasquatch here as we do, this thread would not exist. OS isn't disgruntled about scepticism, but merely the fact that we're sceptical of his favourite Universal Monster that never was. I prefer the Creature, of Black Lagoon fame, and the monsters that Boris and Lon brought to life. They at least existed in some sense, I've had the ice-lollies to prove it!
 
You should've stopped at bigfoot is tainted.

This is a thread that was borne of Bigfoot, and OS isn't thinking about anything else when he makes his tired claims about the "pseudo-scepticism" of the non-believers.

So what? Ignore going ad hom and address the criticisms instead. The history you cite is an example of the very front-loading being questioned.

I don't care about bigfoot, other than it's a completely polluted, hot-button here.
 
So what? Ignore going ad hom and address the criticisms instead. The history you cite is an example of the very front-loading being questioned.

I don't care about bigfoot, other than it's a completely polluted, hot-button here.

I've no idea what you're chatting about, but if you don't like the Bigfoot-talk, don't get involved. I've addressed enough of the criticisms, and will do as I please, cheers.

The history I cite is relevant. Maybe you're confused about what this thread was started for, for that, I'm sorry, but I can't help you. The fact that you seem to think that there's an actual point to what OS says is baffling.

Bait-Thread. No more, no less. So if you'd like to sit down and have a proper chat about the merits of scepticism, be my guest, but you're in the wrong thread. This here is Bigfoot country, always has been, and forever it shall remain.

Btw, you took my initial post concerning the word "tainted" way too seriously, lol.
 
Last edited:
...If so, then everything is "guessing" by this type of definition...
He's using a similar premise to political correctness, if you can change the definitions you can change the effect (and not in a good way). In truth it's his poor attempt at trying to use semantics to not not-prove Bigfoot, i.e. he's playing not to lose. The bottom line though is he doesn't actually believe there is a Bigfoot. He's just BLAARGing.

And you would deny them that at this Christmasy time of year? You fiend.

Plus, you're suggesting that brilliant bulbs like OntarioSquatch are merely playing games when they post insights like these:

"When it comes to Sasquatch, most people just don't understand the phenomenon and some claim that they don't exist because there is lack of a lack a body or a certain quantity of evidence. The error in that sort of thinking should be pretty obvious if you're not looking at it through denialist lenses."

Shame on you.
:thumbsup: And without a hint of conscience he's more than happy to have numerous generous and helpful forum members wasting valuable time writing virtual essays to him on the benefits of looking at things intelligently and seeing the error of his ways. Sadly for those members, he's fully aware of that 'error' and is just gaming the board because the rules allow him to. It's either that or he's the absolute dumbest piece of mutha ******* stupidity we've ever come across. I wonder if he is willing to cop to that? Or maybe he's willing to actually prove it by saying he "still believes" despite the plethora of logic, reason and sanity this board has bombarded him with these last 3+ years? :biggrin:
 
Seeing a large mythological creature like Bigfoot for the first time is much scarier than seeing any known animal that you previously knew about. A lot of Sasquatch eyewitnesses end up with symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder like not wanting to go out into the woods alone and fearing that there might be a Sasquatch in every shadow of the woods. I think Cervelo might have experienced something like this.



Usually location, time of year, behaviour observed by the witness, behaviour of the witness and physical description.

Where do you come up with this stuff LOL?

I've never seen a Bigfoot or claimed to have seen a Bigfoot.

I do the majority of my camping, hunting, fishing and hiking alone...so you might need to do some rethinking ;)
 
The only people who focus on trying to debunk something like this are the pseudos. It's fun for them because it helps remove their uncertainty.
Again with this. You keep repeating this as if it is true.

To know this you would have to (as judge Judy says) know the operations of their mind. You would have to know:
a) skeptics have uncertainty about an issue
b) skeptics are uncomfortable with this uncertainty
c) skeptics are motivated to remove this uncertainty by trying to prove to themselves one side of the issue.

You can establish and prove none of this about any specific individual, never mind an entire group.
 
Again with this. You keep repeating this as if it is true.

To know this you would have to (as judge Judy says) know the operations of their mind. You would have to know:
a) skeptics have uncertainty about an issue
b) skeptics are uncomfortable with this uncertainty
c) skeptics are motivated to remove this uncertainty by trying to prove to themselves one side of the issue.

You can establish and prove none of this about any specific individual, never mind an entire group.

This seems reasonable until I realize that "knowing the operations of their mind" is something I do all the time. It's a common human skill, essential in social beings.

I've seen Judge Judy in action. I can hazard a guess as to the operation of her mind. She's a bitch.
 
Last edited:
This seems reasonable until I realize that "knowing the operations of their mind" is something I do all the time. It's a common human skill, essential in social beings.
You don't 'know'. You can guess, but you have no way of actually knowing.

I've seen Judge Judy in action. I can hazard a guess as to the operation of her mind. She's a bitch.
um.......so.........what?
 
You don't 'know'. You can guess, but you have no way of actually knowing.

Unless you mean to go full on solipsism, I disagree. It's the same observational methodology that I use to "know" a pot contains boiling water. I observe the characteristics of boiling water, perhaps test my conclusion but perhaps not.

"Aha!," the challenger cries, "But the pot really contained dry ice. That's where the bubbles came from. The "steam" you saw was just cool fog."

And, I have to admit to being fooled. My "knowing" was false. Strangely though, the next pot of boiling water I observe will, once again, rekindle my belief that I know how to recognize boiling water. Just as the next angry person I meet will reinforce my belief that I can recognize anger.

It may be described as guesswork, but this harms nothing. For there are good guesses and bad, accurate and inaccurate. I'd go so far as to state we know each others' minds on par with knowing our own. Perhaps not perfectly reliable, but quite a sufficient measure nonetheless.

After all, what is "knowing" other than a sufficient degree of accuracy? Do I really have to describe the movement of every molecule to "know" the water is boiling? Am I required to be always error free to trust the mechanism? In a world where omniscient is off the table, I think I'll stick with the softer, and more useful meaning of the word.
 
A mood is not a mind. Someone can be both angry and deceitful at the same time. Someone can be both happy and deceitful at the same time. You be able to gauge their outward emotional state, but you cannot know their mind.
 
Last edited:
A mood is not a mind. Someone can be both angry and deceitful at the same time. Someone can be both happy and deceitful at the same time. You be able to gauge their outward emotional state, but you cannot know their mind.

Do I know your mind by reading that? Do I know more after reading it than before?

Surely, the situation isn't hopeless.
 
There is an interesting paradox here. To know I have been fooled and mistaken (at least sometimes), I must at times believe I am not fooled or mistaken. Errors are only caught with correction, mistakes only recognized in contrast with the accurate.
 
But look what the op is stating.
He claims to know the inner core motivation of 'most skeptics' or 'pseudo' skeptics as he calls them.
He is claiming they are uncomfortable with uncertainty about a particular issue, and their discomfort with that uncertainty motivates them to attempt to debunk the hypothesis with the goal to remove uncertainty.

How can he possibly know, for example, my innermost motivating factor in dismissing, for example, the sasquatch hypothesis? How can he KNOW I am FRIGHTENED of the possibility sasquatch may exist?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom