No, which is why we pre-agree. It serves as an axiom so the conversation can be grounded somewhere. It doesn't have to be, we don't have to agree that dragons don't exist. If we don't, I'd ask you to suggest something else to serve as placeholder to fill the axiomatic role.
It's interesting that you bring up prior experience and consilience as a way to judge situations where evidence is sparse. Isn't that where bias is rooted as well? After all, the Obama-in-my-closet thought experiment is meant to propose something extraordinary, a one-off, amazing and remarkable happenstance. This places it firmly outside the realm of my experience.
In essence, you seem to be saying that things which you are unfamiliar with are less likely to be true, solely because you are unfamiliar with them. I don't find much power in this: "I have seen the inside of many closets in my life, and I have never seen Obama in any of them."
That's certainly true (although he might have been hiding behind the overcoats), but there are many, many more closets in the world than the subset I have peered into. And even for those I have looked in, the President may have just stepped out of, only to return the next day. But even worse, there's only one Barack Obama, so we'd probably expect his appearance in any random closet to be a pretty rare thing. On the other hand, if he dresses himself, he's likely in some closet, somewhere, at least once a day. (Maybe more if he has to get out his basketball duds.)
Finally, you have to wonder why someone would claim to have Obama in their closet. It's an odd thing to say, especially if you actually didn't have him in there. On the other hand, if I did have him in there, you can bet I'd whisper it to someone or other - the very extraordinariness of the event makes it worth mentioning.
It is interesting that you define knowledge of pre-existing evidence as bias. Bias usually means the inability to interpret
new evidence fairly, not forming a conclusion based on prior evidence in the
absence of new evidence.
I've tried to explain this before, but I will be very explicit here. And I will use your own example of Obama in My Closet, a silly proposal for you to defend, but which is nonetheless strangely appropriate to the Bigfoot concept and to the idea of skeptics having a pre-existing "bias."
Here are the facts that I am using to calculate the likelihood that Obama is in my closet. Feel free to point out if any of these are not facts (trust that I am not lying to you just for purposes of the argument) and therefore do not represent authentic evidence:
1. Neither I nor anyone
I know has observed Obama in their closet. Ever.
2. I have never previously observed anyone unexpectedly in my closet, nor has anyone I have ever met revealed such a thing as to their own closets.
3. Obama does not even know of my existence as far as I can tell, does not know of my address, and has no known reason to sneak into my closet.
4. Neither I nor my wife has heard anything moving in my closed closet. Ever, let alone this morning.
5. The Whitehouse website states that Obama is in Washington DC this morning.
6. There are reports from established news agencies that Obama is in Washington DC as of this morning.
7. For Obama to be in my closet he would have to have snuck out of Washington with no one seeing him, gotten on a commerical plane to California wearing a convincing disguise, changed planes, gotten off at my local airport, secretly taken a cab to my home, somehow have gotten the key, and snuck into my closet without me, by neighbors, my wife, or I seeing him do so.
I am undoubtedly leaving out additional previously observed facts. But just on the basis of these, it is extremely reasonable for me to conclude that it is extraordinarily unlikely that Obama is in my closet. Do I state it is absolutely impossibility? No, of course not. The Whitehouse and the reporters might be lying as to his whereabouts. My wife may know but not tell be. Obama may have learned of my extraordinarily handsomeness and looked up my address to see my visage in person and hid in my closet to surprise me, misunderstanding it is my birthday.
But is it fair to note that, as a working hypothesis, that Obama is almost certainly not in my closet and therefore for me to run my life by that assumption? Of course it is, just like I went to work today assuming that a giant asteroid will not enter the atmosphere this morning and reduce my workplace to crushed tiny diamonds.
You appear to think that somehow I could not know "for certain" until I looked in my closet. But this would produce exactly the same type of pre-existing evidence as above: I look and I don't see Obama. Well, perhaps he has an invisibility cloak on (low probability, but who knows?) or is behind the clothes as you suggest. And even if I am certain that I did not see him, milliseconds after I look this evidence becomes historic,
just as the other evidence above which you incorrectly consider bias.
This is the approach we use all the time in day to day life. But it also applies to science (in the past momentum has equalled mass times velocity when measured, so it is very, very likely to be the same the next time we measure a moving object). And even formal logic uses an "If...then..." system and what I listed as evidence above is what one places after the "If..." The logical "then..." is that Obama is almost certainly not in my closet.
I would be biased if I looked in my closet,
see Obama, but refuse to acknowledge or accept this new evidence because of my prior experience. Bias is being unwilling to change one's mind
in light of new evidence. It is
not bias to form an opinion based on all the evidence one currently has. so long as one is willing to examine new evidence later in a fair manner.
The proposal was not "Is Obama in a closet at some point in the day?" as you included in your post. The proposal was "Is Obama in my closet?" Just as the question that inspired this thread was not "Are there large mammals in North America?" It was "Is there a Bigfoot in North America?"
Let's face it: the origin of this thread is that any opinion that does not accept the existence of Bigfoot is biased. That is silly. The huge preponderance of evidence indicates that there virtually no chance that there is a Bigfoot. Does that mean that I am saying that there is no Bigfoot, and that I will ignore any future evidence of the existence of a Bigfoot? Of course not! I will consider any evidence along with the entire set of evidence to date and honestly consider if the likely conclusion is now different. An appropriate DNA sequence of some Bigfoot scat would probably do it.
To suggest that working conclusions based on pre-existing facts must represent bias is just plain wrong. Bias is selectively rejecting information, old or new (in fact all new information becomes old information in an instant) unfairly, often for emotional rather than factual reasons. From what I have seen in this thread, I see little or no evidence of bias on the "no reason to believe Bigfoot exists" side but lots of evidence of bias on the "there is a Bigfoot" side.
Frankly I think you form these very sort of working conclusions based on pre-existing experiences and knowledge from other sources all the time- one cannot get through a day without doing so. You assume that you live at the same address as the one you left this morning. That the grocery store will be willing to sell you food today just like they did two days ago. That the clear liquid coming out of your kitchen tap will be water and not acetone, just like it was earlier today. And this is not just personal knowledge- you include your observations that these same things were experienced widely by others, are what is written in books and on the web, and that if something changed you would have seen some signs of it or heard about it from others. The alternative is to have no way of knowing what action to take because, being "unbiased" you have absolutely no way of knowing what the consequences might me.