The Mentality of Skeptics

*claims* of evidence can be debunked.

Yes, but that's not the same as trying to debunk the very existence of certain entities. The motivation for it might be the same though.

We do not have and have never had any burden whatsoever to "prove" in any way Bigfoot doesn't exist, and in fact it is you who carries 100% of the burden of proving it does, otherwise it doesn't.

The burden of proof lies with anyone making a claim. It doesn't matter if it's a positive or negative claim.
 
This is from the book, Attacking Faulty Reasoning by T. Edward Damer


The Burden of Proof Principle

"Just as a person is held accountable for his or her own actions, one who makes a positive OR negative claim about something has what's called the burden of proof. In many cases, of course, one does not have to supply such proof, for we are not always always challenged to defend our claims.

To ask others to accept your claim without any support, or to shift the burden of proof to them by suggesting that your position is true unless they can prove otherwise, is to commit the fallacy of "arguing from ignorance", for you are, in this way, making a claim based on no evidence at all.

Moreover, since negative claims are notoriously difficult to establish, you are setting yourself up for a win by default. But in the argument game, there are no wins by default, for the merit of any position is only as good as the argument that's given in support of it."
 
This is from the book, Attacking Faulty Reasoning by T. Edward Damer


The Burden of Proof Principle

"Just as a person is held accountable for his or her own actions, one who makes a positive OR negative claim about something has what's called the burden of proof. In many cases, of course, one does not have to supply such proof, for we are not always always challenged to defend our claims.

To ask others to accept your claim without any support, or to shift the burden of proof to them by suggesting that your position is true unless they can prove otherwise, is to commit the fallacy of "arguing from ignorance", for you are, in this way, making a claim based on no evidence at all.

Moreover, since negative claims are notoriously difficult to establish, you are setting yourself up for a win by default. But in the argument game, there are no wins by default, for the merit of any position is only as good as the argument that's given in support of it."

Gee, unfortunately the author of the book is simply dead wrong. The default is the presumption that something does not exist if there is no evidence for its existence. In fact you yourself realize this because you use that logic all the time in your day to day life. Is President Obama in your closet? Do you need to go look because otherwise it is a 50:50 chance that he is? Might there be unicorns in your car trunk? Better go look before you assume you can put your groceries there. Is there a dragon in your garage? If you were a true skeptic you wouldn't assume that there wasn't until you looked, and even if you didn't see one it might be invisible, right?

Just because it is in a book doesn't mean you can assume that it is correct. I thought a true skeptic doesn't make assumptions.
 
Last edited:
And again I must point out that even the absence of evidence can be evidence of absence if the existence of something would inevitably generate the evidence under discussion. If one proposes that a dragon breathes long flames of fire, then the absence of scorch marks in one's garage is pretty good reason to think that no dragon lives there.
 
Last edited:
I thought this part of your post deserved its own answer. I read three pages of the thread you linked to, looking for the kind of behaviour you described. This is what I found:
Firstly, you hijacked a thread about Jenny McCarthy with a post making allegations against 'Big Pharma'.
The first reply (Post 2) asks for evidence. No insults, no shrillness, no arrogance or condescension.
Post 4: Looks at both sides, no unquestioning defence of Big Pharma, no insults.
Post 6 asks you to move this to a separate thread, a request you ignore. No insults, no " shrill, irrational, arrogant, condescending, insulting psuedoskepticism ".
In post 8, you ask people to 'follow the money'.
First response: No insult, no arrogance, simply a statement of fact. Chris Haynes, in Post 14, produces a series of links showing how following the money refutes your idea (This is an assumption, based on his comments: the links don't work any more). No insult, no shrillness, no arrogance. Just research.
Your response?
That, to me, is arrogant and insulting. But maybe that's just me.
Moving on....
Finally the first insult, albeit not one on your list.
In post 30, we get this : These epithets are aimed at your links, not at you, so I'm afraid we can't count this as insulting. whale.to and Natural News (Skopie's Law) are truly deserving of scorn, and I would hope you agree.
Later, in Post 37, you say
More of your pseudo-psychological analysis, which is clearly not based on anything posted so far.
Chris Haynes comes back in Post 42 with another series of links (evidence, research, what we do here), and this request:

No insults, no arrogance, no condescension, no shrillness. Just a request for evidence.
I could go on, but I think everyone has by now got my point. The questionable (i.e. insulting or otherwise potentially objectionable) posts are few and far between. Posts either asking for you to back up your claims with evidence, or refuting, with evidence, what claims you have made, constitute the overwhelming majority of responses, along with requests for you to stop hijacking a thread and start a new one. Nowhere in what I read (which was up to Page 3, over 100 posts) did I see any of the epithets you claimed posters had levelled at you. In fact, you were more insulting than anyone else. You hijacked a thread, refused to respond to multiple questions and threw accusations of shilling, obsessive-compulsive disorder, irrationality, illogicality and non-objectivity at everyone who attempted to debate with you.
Once again, you have utterly failed to show any real evidence for your claims. If the (mostly) polite, reasonable and communicative posts you cite here are what you call 'hounds of hell', then I would surmise that you have led a very sheltered existence, where everything you have said is greeted with uncritical acceptance and adulation, because the amount and tone of debate and disagreement shown in that thread is what I said before: normal human behaviour. Your unwillingness and/or inability to deal with it is not a defect of the members of this forum. As the old adage goes, look within.

You obviously didn’t read the entire thread or you wouldn’t be saying most of what you’re saying. You’re blending two different threads to make what point? My point about rat packing still stands as you can see already on this thread.

I don’t know what you consider rat packing, but if you’re in a fist fight with someone and 2 or more of his buddies jumps into the fray, that’s rat packing. If you don’t think so, talk to me later when you wake up in the hospital in traction with broken bones and more black and blue on you than your natural skin tones.
 
Yes, but that's not the same as trying to debunk the very existence of certain entities. The motivation for it might be the same though.

The burden of proof lies with anyone making a claim. It doesn't matter if it's a positive or negative claim.
:biggrin: Like I said, a pretend misunderstanding of reality. I say pretend because you can't possibly believe that my recitation of reality "doesn't prove anything". Which really means you're just LYING! And that's what I CLAIM you've been doing all along. PROVE ME WRONG Mr. Wizard! :thumbsup:
 
Gee, unfortunately the author of the book is simply dead wrong. The default is the presumption that something does not exist if there is no evidence for its existence. In fact you yourself realize this because you use that logic all the time in your day to day life. Is President Obama in your closet? Do you need to go look because otherwise it is a 50:50 chance that he is?

I think you are confusing how we approach our daily lives with the rather more formal process of logic and debate.

I have no idea what is in your closet. No evidence. Am I then justified in believing your closet is empty? That can't be right, since in my experience, other closets have stuff in them (and some crammed full of stuff). Yet, by the reasoning you give, I should insist there is nothing in there unless shown.

If we are just assuming things, it all works out. But if I make a claim - that Obama is not in my closet - then logically, I would have to produce evidence to support that claim, or you can reject it. For the case of imaginary beings, one can reject such claims if the object in question doesn't exist. There may be many things in my closet, but things that do not exist cannot be.

So yes, negative claims can generate a burden of proof, just as positive claims can. The fact that such burdens may be impossible to overcome doesn't change anything - it just limits the force of the claims we can usefully make and find evidence for.
 
Yes, but that's not the same as trying to debunk the very existence of certain entities. The motivation for it might be the same though.



The burden of proof lies with anyone making a claim. It doesn't matter if it's a positive or negative claim.
Whoa, here we go again. So even if no good evidence exists for a claim, the burden of proof shifts to the person denying it? Does "show me the evidence" suddenly now require evidence as some sort of bizarre quid pro quo? At what point does the denial of something become the assertion of something? Is no a supspecies of yes now?
 
Refusing to believe a positive claim is different from making a negative claim. One is neutral and one isn't. One requires proof and the other doesn't.
 
I think you are confusing how we approach our daily lives with the rather more formal process of logic and debate.

I have no idea what is in your closet. No evidence. Am I then justified in believing your closet is empty? That can't be right, since in my experience, other closets have stuff in them (and some crammed full of stuff). Yet, by the reasoning you give, I should insist there is nothing in there unless shown.

If we are just assuming things, it all works out. But if I make a claim - that Obama is not in my closet - then logically, I would have to produce evidence to support that claim, or you can reject it. For the case of imaginary beings, one can reject such claims if the object in question doesn't exist. There may be many things in my closet, but things that do not exist cannot be.

So yes, negative claims can generate a burden of proof, just as positive claims can. The fact that such burdens may be impossible to overcome doesn't change anything - it just limits the force of the claims we can usefully make and find evidence for.

First, a claim that my closet is empty is more logical given the facts and observations that we have already accumulated in our brains from our real life prior observations compared to a claim that I have a dragon in it. Also the proposal of an empty closet is not really a negative claim- in this context if we accept that I have a closet then empty is a type of contents just as having an umbrella in it. Our experience and prior observations indicate that a closet may be empty or to have an umbrella or clothes, but it is unlikely to have a dragon. Our experience and prior observations are therefore evidence, even in a formal logic setting, in favor of a set of certain plausible contents (e.g. empty or umbrella) and against other, much more implausible contents (e.g. dragon).

I still maintain that the default is that something does not exist in the absence of any evidence for this existence but prior observation are indeed a form of evidence.. "If closet- then often has clothes and umbrellas" is reasonable evidence that these are things that are likely to be in a closet. Also "If closet- then less frequently but also possible to be empty" is a conclusion based on legitimate evidence- I have observed empty closets in my own experience.

If you want to actually make a specific statement as to what is in the closet, including empty, then you would need more direct evidence. But this is the exact opposite of claiming that, in the absence of this specific evidence, one has not way of predicting whether the closet may have clothes, be empty, or have a dragon in it.

Do you really wish to maintain that if I make a claim that Obama is in my closet that this is equal in likelihood to the proposal that he is not, requiring me to open the door to check before I can reach any conclusion as to likelihood? Obama exists in either case. But one's experience and understanding of the world makes it much, much more likely that he is not in my closet. I am not stating that the likelihood of bigfoot or Obama in my closet in 0.000; just neither are very likely and I would want some positive proof of either before I would feel the urge to question the implications of my experience, based on prior observations of the evidence, and open the door to actually check.

I think this again relates to the proposal in the OP that for anyone to form a legitimate conclusion on a topic one must ignore all the prior observations that one has accumulated in one's life and pretend that none of this can be considered evidence. I disagree. In formal logic my prior observations that when I release a ball from my hand it has never fallen up are legitimate facts to weigh when answering the question. "if I now release this new ball from my hand, will it fall up?"
 
Last edited:
(much snipped)
If you want to actually make a specific statement as to what is in the closet, including empty, then you would need more direct evidence. But this is the exact opposite of claiming that, in the absence of this specific evidence, one has not way of predicting whether the closet may have clothes, be empty, or has a dragon in it.

I like Obama as an example rather than a dragon, because we might be pre-agreed that dragons don't exist.

So, here are two statements about my closet:
1) President Obama is in my closet.
2) President Obama is not in my closet.

Are you saying that only one of those claims requires evidence? That, lacking any direct evidence, I should accept one as true and reject the other?

Both are claims about the as-yet-unknown contents of a closet, one positive, one negative. Both are possible. I think either would require evidence for verification.
 
There's no reason to presume that Obama is or isn't in someone's closet if you don't know what's in it. It's only after you've actually looked into that closet that you can logically decide whether he is or isn't in there. The fact that you think it's unlikely that he would be in there doesn't justify a presumption.
 
There's no reason to presume that Obama is or isn't in someone's closet if you don't know what's in it. It's only after you've actually looked into that closet that you can logically decide whether he is or isn't in there. The fact that you think it's unlikely that he would be in there doesn't justify a presumption.

Yes, that's my take on it too. Disbelieving a positive claim is not the same thing as asserting the negative.
 
Refusing to believe a positive claim is different from making a negative claim. One is neutral and one isn't. One requires proof and the other doesn't.

As previously noted, virtually all the skeptical posts that you disparage in this thread have actually been of the first kind and not the second. You are the one making a positive claim. Most of the others here have been questioning whether there is any reason to believe this positive claim. The outright negative claims have been many fewer, and as I explained, even in this case have been almost always shorthand for the former (e.g. "there is no bigfoot" typically has been just a simplified version of "there is no reason to suggest that bigfoot exists and very good reasons to believe that he does not exist, so my working hypothesis is that he does not exist.").
 
There's no reason to presume that Obama is or isn't in someone's closet if you don't know what's in it. It's only after you've actually looked into that closet that you can logically decide whether he is or isn't in there. The fact that you think it's unlikely that he would be in there doesn't justify a presumption.

If you actually believe this "logic" it explains why you believe in bigfoot. But this makes for quite an amazing life for you, because who knows what might happen or who you might find in your closet the next time you open the dodor. Anyone or anything would be equally possible until you actually look. Schrodinger's cat may be alive, or dead, or a dog, or a cow, or an iPhone, or a green Martian when you open the box; how can one even narrow it down beforehand?
 
I like Obama as an example rather than a dragon, because we might be pre-agreed that dragons don't exist.

So, here are two statements about my closet:
1) President Obama is in my closet.
2) President Obama is not in my closet.

Are you saying that only one of those claims requires evidence? That, lacking any direct evidence, I should accept one as true and reject the other?

Both are claims about the as-yet-unknown contents of a closet, one positive, one negative. Both are possible. I think either would require evidence for verification.

It depends on the level of confidence one requires. Yes, in the absence of any new evidence, the prior evidence that I have observed and accumulated up to now makes #2 enormously more likely than #1. Therefore I would bet $10,000 to $1 that he is not in my closet without me having to open it first. But the remaining, tiny, tiny possibility that he is in my closet probably means that I would not bet $10,000,000 to $1.

Do they each require evidence? Yes, if we began with no evidence or knowledge of Obama or my closet. But that is not the case. Inside we have substantial evidence for #2 and against #1 based on our previous experiences and observations of facts. Evidence is not only what we discover after we ask the question; it can include the facts we already knew.
 
Last edited:
I like Obama as an example rather than a dragon, because we might be pre-agreed that dragons don't exist.

So, here are two statements about my closet:
1) President Obama is in my closet.
2) President Obama is not in my closet.

Are you saying that only one of those claims requires evidence? That, lacking any direct evidence, I should accept one as true and reject the other?

Both are claims about the as-yet-unknown contents of a closet, one positive, one negative. Both are possible. I think either would require evidence for verification.

Why should we pre-agree that there are no dragons? Do you have evidence that there are no dragons?
 
Why should we pre-agree that there are no dragons? Do you have evidence that there are no dragons?

No, which is why we pre-agree. It serves as an axiom so the conversation can be grounded somewhere. It doesn't have to be, we don't have to agree that dragons don't exist. If we don't, I'd ask you to suggest something else to serve as placeholder to fill the axiomatic role.

It's interesting that you bring up prior experience and consilience as a way to judge situations where evidence is sparse. Isn't that where bias is rooted as well? After all, the Obama-in-my-closet thought experiment is meant to propose something extraordinary, a one-off, amazing and remarkable happenstance. This places it firmly outside the realm of my experience.

In essence, you seem to be saying that things which you are unfamiliar with are less likely to be true, solely because you are unfamiliar with them. I don't find much power in this: "I have seen the inside of many closets in my life, and I have never seen Obama in any of them."

That's certainly true (although he might have been hiding behind the overcoats), but there are many, many more closets in the world than the subset I have peered into. And even for those I have looked in, the President may have just stepped out of, only to return the next day. But even worse, there's only one Barack Obama, so we'd probably expect his appearance in any random closet to be a pretty rare thing. On the other hand, if he dresses himself, he's likely in some closet, somewhere, at least once a day. (Maybe more if he has to get out his basketball duds.)

Finally, you have to wonder why someone would claim to have Obama in their closet. It's an odd thing to say, especially if you actually didn't have him in there. On the other hand, if I did have him in there, you can bet I'd whisper it to someone or other - the very extraordinariness of the event makes it worth mentioning.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom