The Implosion of the BFF

Status
Not open for further replies.
When you find the real cause of Christianity, Islam, Mormonism, Judaism and all the others you will find the cause of Big foot.
I'm not sure it's that simple. One simple root cause of religion(s) in general is humans' innate egocentric fear of death being the actual end. Bigfoot might be a lot of things to a lot of people, but his being related to our mortality is likely really low on the list.

Myself alone have given far more than two paragraphs on the "causes" of Bigfootery. It's probably not a single essence. But how could you reject the following?...

There are some people who enjoy the fantasy of Bigfoot being real.
I don't reject that. Heck, maybe that's the exact reason. But how do you prove it? And I also agree that it's surely not just one single thing, but then how many is it? Two things? Eight? Twenty eight? My original point being, we haven't done enough 'investigation' as the supposed truth seekers to have any idea whatsoever as to what the proven cause(s) are or how many there may actually be.

There have been many ideas proferred as to Bogfoot's reality. Narcolepsy, hallucination, hoaxing, mood altering drugs, mis ID, all being part of the perpetuation of am American myth.
Yes, but we're talkin Bigfoot. Jokin. ;) Again, all those are fine examples of the possible reasons, but how can we here say, with unwavering confidence and scientific investigation behind us that they are the reasons, not just possible reasons?

In many cases I think mis-perception is a better term than mis-identification, because it implies a somewhat less rational process and one which is influenced by subtle factors or experience and expectation. People see (and hear) what they expect to see and hear.

I am struck by the number of current reports which date back to experiences many years ago... 'footers say these people were afraid to come forward. Contamination of memory can account for a number of these. Nowadays, their stories are welcomed around the campfire.
And again, I don't disagree, but the question becomes is there any way to decipher how any one 'witness', for example, came up with his/her 'story' short of some actual beast? Meaning, could it be horses or moose or walking bears or a few wolverines that can account for say 95% of Bigfoot reports? Or is it 5% and the rest are simply made up in somebody's head?

My point is we're apparently so fixated on 'getting the word out' there is no Bigfoot (the beast) we forget that there's still Bigfoot (the mystery) causing Bigfoot (the phenomenon) to live on. Are we not supposed to be interested in that aspect because it's just too complex? If so we need to tone down our rhetoric that we're in possession of some kind of cosmic truth. We're in possession of only a teensy tiny part of it.

Which brings us full circle back to the BFF. Going over there as 'skeptics' and telling them they need to wake up and smell the coffee is almost disingenuous in that we're not the actual 'truth holders', nor are we offering them much as to the alternative possibilities except to say things like 'there is no Bigfoot get over it'. And FTR, Kit is over there arguing one singular instance. What about the thirteen thousand others?
 
and maybe comment on why you talked to Tom Biscardi unless your motives have another color?

At the BFF I have had a minority of people be so desperate as to find anything to point at and scream that the fact I interviewed Tom Biscardi for his side on the Patricia Patterson attorney hoax admission rumour that was sourced to him is what they use against me. It is absurd and laughable that they do this. By this logic a reporter interviewing a known gangster for his take on a gangland rumour makes the reporter a gangster of some sort. Like as if I got hoaxer cooties on me from talking to a hoaxer. These people have the five year old boy logic to point and scream at another boy they think got girl germs on them.

If a substantial rumour was sourced to someone, and the person turns out to be Tom Biscardi, I am not going to be afraid to pick up the phone and hear what Tom has to say. Maybe every word that comes out of his mouth might be hooey, but I'll have done my job in getting his side on the record for whatever it is.

These people chastise me if I cite a source that was Greg Long's contact and then chastise me when I go to a source myself. I find such tactics to be the ravings of cultish fanatics. I'm damned if I do, damned if I don't. I will never be cowwed by such hysterical people. These people can carry on with the froth and bubble of their No Bigfoot Days-induced Mexican soap opera maneuvers and throw whatever goop they can at me. I have a HAZMAT suit on called "logic".
 
I just did, it came to my attention that kit has spoken to a known hoaxer, thus motives become suspect. Take the labcoat off and let him answer.

The brilliance of Bigfooter drama. Mike, by your nonsense reasoning, every reporter in this conference room has suspect motives...

 
I typically wear a Tyvex suit and two condoms whenever I'm posting, just in case.
 
Then I submit you have a highly skewed sense of reality affected by the perpetual No Bigfoot Days and endless back room backbiting of Bigfootery.

Tom Biscardi, in conjunction with Matt Whitton and Rick Dyer, made a hoax. They made a bold claim and did it for money. Reporters came to ask them inevitable questions.

So, Mikey, how am I suspect for getting Biscardi's words on a rumour attributed to him?
 
Kit, you are doing a documentary about a hoax, why do you even address such a silly line of questioning? It is fabricated to divert you from your target.
 
I think there is value in asking the irrational to try and walk through the steps of their irrationality. It's easy to plop out a dollop of unthinking goop. It is another to explain why they think the way they do. I think when they are asked to do so, they will inevitably fall apart in their own high strangeness.
 
I think Drew wants to sterilize the population!



ETA: Obscure reference explanation. Drew is Detroit. Kitakaze is Detroit-obsessed. Correa said labcoat. Kitakaze played science-obsessed labcoat-wearing Detroit music.
 
Last edited:
And again, I don't disagree, but the question becomes is there any way to decipher how any one 'witness', for example, came up with his/her 'story' short of some actual beast? . . .
Which brings us full circle back to the BFF. Going over there as 'skeptics' and telling them they need to wake up and smell the coffee . . . nor are we offering them much as to the alternative possibilities except to say things like 'there is no Bigfoot get over it'. And FTR, Kit is over there arguing one singular instance. What about the thirteen thousand others?

I'm with you, Harry. This is one of the reasons that I keep participating. There are encounters that defy explanation other than (1) completely bald-faced lying or (2) actually sat down to tea with a bigfoot. The hallucination explanation just feels contrived and unsatisfactory sometimes. It's not easy for people to sort these out when their frame of reference for truth is "I seen it with my own eyes."

Of course, every time I bring up "lying" folks start rocking back and forth in the corner and mumbling to themselves. They can't handle it. They're just detached from the reality that human behavior includes a certain number of folks who will simply make %^^& up for no apparent reason. Check out the "multiple encounters" thread for an illustration.

I'm hopeful that when I carefully explain the reasons why I'm not buying a particular story that there is a little crowbar being inserted into the minds of at least some of these people that will help them see the world as it really is as opposed to the view they've constructed for themselves. While it's fun to toss an occasional salvo with JREF swagger, such comments tend to alienate and are ultimately counterproductive.

Although Kit's approach has obviously drawn fire from the true believers, we shouldn't lose sight of the fact that a healthy proportion of the BFF readership (lurkers too) are undecided about the PGF. For these folks, Kit is knocking down preconceptions about the film, the storyline, the footprints. These things plant the seeds of doubt in people that can make them more skeptical of things they might assume to be well supported. If a passing interest in bigfoot helps someone progress as a good critical thinker, that's a good thing.
 
The Shrike said:

Although Kit's approach has obviously drawn fire from the true believers, we shouldn't lose sight of the fact that a healthy proportion of the BFF readership (lurkers too) are undecided about the PGF. For these folks, Kit is knocking down preconceptions about the film, the storyline, the footprints. These things plant the seeds of doubt in people that can make them more skeptical of things they might assume to be well supported. If a passing interest in bigfoot helps someone progress as a good critical thinker, that's a good thing.

Critical thinking is a good thing, but shouldnt the truth be important too? I think that is far more important than what side of the "bigfoot fence" your on.

Just my two cents.
 
There are encounters that defy explanation other than (1) completely bald-faced lying or (2) actually sat down to tea with a bigfoot....

Of course, every time I bring up "lying" folks start rocking back and forth in the corner and mumbling to themselves. They can't handle it. They're just detached from the reality that human behavior includes a certain number of folks who will simply make %^^& up for no apparent reason. Check out the "multiple encounters" thread for an illustration.

I'm at the point where I consider the framing and description of Bigfoot fabrication to be largely a false argument or a strawman. It isn't a lie any more than a fictional novel or fictional short story is a lie. It is odd to call a fictional writer or novelist a liar.

If Bigfoot is a folk concept, folktale, campfire story and myth... then false stories about encounters are not lies. They are artifacts of folk society and how it embraces its own culture. As such, credible and honest people may contribute to this without actually degrading their personal integrity.

The Bigfoot myth may be somewhat unique among other myths. This is because the folk description of Bigfoot includes the feature that it does live in our forests. This is different from say a dragon, unicorn or mermaid whose descriptions do not include the feature of actually living in the real world. When you tell a Bigfoot story you tell people that you really saw it. You tell people that it therefore exists. You talk about other people who saw it. By golly, it exists. What's ironic is that part of the telling of the myth is to insist that it isn't a myth.

The problem is that people engaged in the debate automatically equate Bigfoot fabrications with moral or social dysfunction. The people doing this are pegged as hoaxers and liars. Many Bigfooters and even Bigfoot skeptics portray them as human scum and express hatred for their deeds and their person. This sets the stage for the notion of great social harm and impropriety to be attached to the terms lie and liar. A proper inquiry and debate cannot be maintained when those terms are used. This is especially true when engaging one who claims to be a witness.

Everything changes when the phenomenon is addressed as folklore and social construct. The person who tells the fabricated sighting story or creates the fake footprints is not a liar or even a bad person. They are engaging in folk tradition that still exists in the United States and Canada and goes back for many decades if not centuries.

They're just detached from the reality that human behavior includes a certain number of folks who will simply make %^^& up for no apparent reason.

No, it is not for no apparent reason. It is for a very apparent and good reason. It keeps the enjoyable folk concept of Bigfoot alive and kicking.
 
Let's not oversimplify. There are parts of the bigfoot myth that are unlike the fairies and the leprechauns and Santa Claus. They began with the fakery, something not seen with fairies and leprecauns, which then was amplified by television and motion pictures, and now by the internet. Those who seek explanation of some dark or hairy thing or strange sound in the dark can easily find the misinformed and the profiteers online.

Fakery and film and the internet. That is why you have people in the US Fish and Wildlife Service actually discussing bigfoot.
 
Last edited:
Yes, Parnassus, the 1917 [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cottingley_fairies]Cottingley fairy hoax[/url] is a pretty famous/infamous case of fairy fakery. It's something of a touchstone for skeptics interested in how the hoaxing phenomenon works.

ETA: An instructive paragraph from the above link:

In a 1985 television interview on Arthur C. Clarke's World of Strange Powers, Elsie said that she and Frances were too embarrassed to admit the truth after fooling the author of Sherlock Holmes: "Two village kids and a brilliant man like Conan Doyle – well, we could only keep quiet." In the same interview Frances said: "I never even thought of it as being a fraud – it was just Elsie and I having a bit of fun and I can't understand to this day why they were taken in – they wanted to be taken in."​
 
Last edited:
Which brings us full circle back to the BFF. Going over there as 'skeptics' and telling them they need to wake up and smell the coffee is almost disingenuous in that we're not the actual 'truth holders', nor are we offering them much as to the alternative possibilities except to say things like 'there is no Bigfoot get over it'.


Wanna bet? Wanna bet that "we" aren't the actual truth holders? Wanna bet on the existence of Bigfoot?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom