The Implosion of the BFF

Status
Not open for further replies.
You can use all the semantic nuances you wish, but claiming to have seen a creature with no a type specimen is a lie, anyway you slice it.


QUOTE]

Sir/Ma'm or whatever you are,

You do not know me. I am not a liar. No, I cannot prove what I saw, but I am a honest person. I am working on getting that type specimen.
 
K.,

There's something which I believe is also a matter of concern and indicates the actual personalities of many a footer- the silent ones. It does not matter which side of the fence you are. Unethical behavior must be avoided and denounced.

Those who remain silent are conivent. Their silence, for all practical reasons, is equal to approval.

I have not been silent in my disgust of this unethical behavior. I just seem to be urinating into the wind.
 
Now, back on track and regarding hoaxing...

I think its safe to say hoaxing has been associated with beliefs for a long long time, stretching way back in the past. Example- how many "holy relics" there are around? Bones of saints and holy men, fragments of the Holy Cross, the shroud of Turin, you name it. How many "miracles reports" one can find being told and retold around to reinforce faith? Are they all real? How many "holy sites" there are around? The events supposed to have happened there, were they real? And in case of being real, have they actually happened there?

Its important to note that in a number of cases, a religious group, authority, whatever, is/was conivent with the hoax if not one of hoaxers. Why? Maybe its exclusively profit-motivated, maybe its the "ends justify the means" mentality, maybe its something in-between.

Now where does it leads us regarding bigfootery? I think we can see similar trends within bigfootery (as well as other fringe subjects). Many "top footers" probably are aware they are presenting their fellows and followers (and potential fellows and followers) hoaxed (or possibly hoaxed) material. A certain vocal pro-bigfoot poster once acknowledged that Freeman faked (some of his) material. The poster in question seemed not to see to too many problems in his act; Freeman was just trying to "heat things up" when interest on bigfoot was fading. Similar behaviors can be seen at sites like Cryptomundo, where lots of crappy material is presented and the owners' best possible attitude will be something like "I just present it, its up to the public to make their own minds" (not a real quote).

Hoaxes and the promotion of hoaxes are deeply entrenched within bigfootery and many subjects based on faith and/or belief.

The same is valid for experiences and/or phenomena wich are not actually related to the existence of the subject in the real world. Daydreams, hallucinations, false memories and misidentifications will also be used to compose an entangled mess of material supportive of the belief.

That's how, in my humble opinion and in a very simplified way, belief in bigfoot, fairies, dragons, sea monsters, UFOs, ghosts, spirits of all sorts, gods, floating islands, mythical lost cities, etc. are built and gain momentum by feedback. And just like fairies, every time someone says "I don't believe" one of them dies.
 
You can use all the semantic nuances you wish, but claiming to have seen a creature with no a type specimen is a lie, anyway you slice it.

That would mean everyone who claimed to see a creature that was later documented with a type specimen, was a liar, wouldn't it?

That doesn't sound right...
 
Don't get me wrong, I have been a lurker for a while and enjoy reading what you bring to the pattycake table, but diehard believers in bigfoot are mentally ill.

A lurker? You are a cicada.

You joined in 2007 and have 155 posts.

152 posts were in 2007 (none about Bigfoot).
1 post was in 2008 (about Bigfoot).
2 posts were yesterday (about Bigfoot).
 

Attachments

  • Magicicada.jpg
    Magicicada.jpg
    41.1 KB · Views: 3
You seem to be explaining something different than what was going on. First there was a BFF account named "alex". We knew that was the kid who was here on JREF as makaya325. Then later a new account showed up named "makaya". Alex and makaya were two different BFF accounts and both names could be found in the Members List simultaneously. It looked as if Alex decided to start another account and named it makaya. After several days the makaya account vanished. Did some other mod or admin delete it because it was a sockpuppet and not tell you about it?

Additionally, there was an account named "loyaljimite" which was there for at least a week then vanished. Did some other mod or admin delete it because it was a sockpuppet and not tell you about it?

If these things actually are happening and you are not informed it may be because the mod or admin is friends/allied with the offender and doesn't want them to get in trouble, so to speak.

All I can tell you is that when I looked, I could only find one 'alex' account, and no 'makaya' account.

Until a couple of days ago, I was the only person who had the ability to delete an account, so I can only think that either you are mistaken, or the Makaya account belongs to someone who has since changed the user and/or display name.

Either way, you appear to be suggesting that something sinister has happenned, which is simply not the case.

Why are you so obsessed with the usernames of members on another forum anyway? It seems just a little odd to me.



As for 'Jim' accounts? I haven't looked at any, I haven't looked for any, and frankly, I couldn't give two hoots how many Jims there are on BFF. It is of little importance.

I still find it amazing that *I* am referred to as a 'Jimite' when I am far from it. Jim F. is one of only two people who have ever 'de-friended' me on Facebook (the other being his wife) because I made a comment about MRP that he didn't like. And yet, here on JREF and elsewhere, there have been accusations for months about how *I* 'protected' the MRP guys!

Seriously people, do some research before you hurl accusations at people.
 
Kitakaze, I assume you know who's doing all this? Why not OUT them here? Are you willing to tell us? And just FYI, relying solely on LE (in either country) might be 'less than' the ideal approach. They mean well, but they're busy and they have to play by a bunch of (mostly) ineffective 'rules'. You would likely be surprised at the enormity of the resources hiding behind all these mere words of some of the folks here. ;)

At least when Harry posted his web page including the real names of all the BFF moderators he had the decency to remove it when I asked him to. http://www.thereisnobigfoot.com/Players.html (although my real name wasn't removed from the entire website, just the page where Harry made fun of everyone)

Are you suggesting that I should have outed your real name Harry just because you 'outed' the moderators? Two wrongs don't make a right, and I for one would never publish your real name or address regardless of the circumstances.



I am of the opinion that unless you are a published author or someone who otherwise makes a living out of bigfoot, that no-one should ever post the real name of a forum member without permission, regardless of whether it is someone involved in bigfoot, model trains or competitive ironing.

I know when I stupidly made reference on BFF to 'dfoot's real name (legitimately I thought since he was criticising another member's IMDB entry), I was jumped on by dozens of members who told me I was completely out of order, which of course in hindsight, I was.

As someone who has been stalked in the past by more than one person simply because I used to moderate BFF, I really feel for Kit in his current situation, but just as people seem to use my real name freely here and elsewhere, I think trying to stop people knowing and using your real name is a little 'Cnutish'*



*I'm really curious as to whether 'Cnut' will get past the bad word filter ;)
 
Last edited:
All I can tell you is that when I looked, I could only find one 'alex' account, and no 'makaya' account.

Until a couple of days ago, I was the only person who had the ability to delete an account, so I can only think that either you are mistaken, or the Makaya account belongs to someone who has since changed the user and/or display name.

Either way, you appear to be suggesting that something sinister has happenned, which is simply not the case.


Slow down there fella, you're getting goofy. I have evidence (a screen capture) that a "makaya" appeared on the BFF home page as "Newest Member" down near the bottom. It was by chance that I was looking at BFF when this name showed up. I immediately went into the Members list to look for Alex. That name was also listed. If Alex had changed his user name to makaya, I would expect that Alex would disappear from the Member list. I also would not expect that a name change would appear in the Newest Member spot on the home page as the user is not a new member.

I see that within each users profile is a "Display name history" button. I suspect that that will reveal any and all user name changes done by the user. Alex has no history of any name changes. That particular account was always called Alex. Paul, this boy has a well-known history of creating sockpuppets and being an annoying troll. Whether it was him or not... somebody chose to create a user account and named it for him. That is not necessarily sinister (your term) but it is odd and worthy of examination. Do you not agree? Are you not interested in funny business going on with new BFF users? Do you care?


Why are you so obsessed with the usernames of members on another forum anyway? It seems just a little odd to me.

There is no Bigfoot but there are bizarre Bigfoot believers. It's all there is to check out. Speaking of odd... you were the leader of the largest pro-Bigfoot forum in the universe. That is supremely odd.

As for 'Jim' accounts? I haven't looked at any, I haven't looked for any, and frankly, I couldn't give two hoots how many Jims there are on BFF. It is of little importance.

I have screen shot evidence of the "loyaljimite" new membership just the same as I do for makaya. Paul, you say you don't really care, but you actually seem to be rather clueless about what is going on in the new forum.

I still find it amazing that *I* am referred to as a 'Jimite' when I am far from it. Jim F. is one of only two people who have ever 'de-friended' me on Facebook (the other being his wife) because I made a comment about MRP that he didn't like. And yet, here on JREF and elsewhere, there have been accusations for months about how *I* 'protected' the MRP guys!

Seriously people, do some research before you hurl accusations at people.

That's probably Mikeyx/Ganglian calling you a Jimite. He isn't really a JREF Bigfoot skeptic. He mainly uses this forum to bash other Bigfoot believers.
 
...Pattycakes who claim to have seen bigfoot are knowingly lying, but more importantly maintain the lie. ...

You can use all the semantic nuances you wish, but claiming to have seen a creature with no a type specimen is a lie, anyway you slice it.

... They're liars.

... Call it whatever you like, but fabrications are fabrications. Faking evidence is faking evidence. In short, they're lying.

These accusations of intentional mendacity against every single bigfoot claimant are without foundation. Several known phenomena of the human mind -- regional expectation, unintentional misperception and/or misidentification, and hypnagogic hallucination -- can explain sightings without resorting to outright lying as an explanation.

Also, some claimants could be the victims of hoaxes with which they were not otherwise involved.

(This post is undoubtedly off-topic, but since the post to which I'm responding was made here without response from the Mods, I'm placing my response here as well.)
 
Slow down there fella, you're getting goofy. I have evidence (a screen capture)

I will take another look in case I missed something.


Are you not interested in funny business going on with new BFF users? Do you care?

Yes, I care, but I am not moderating the forum - I can't, since you made it perfectly clear that you would be 'watching me', and I wouldn't want to go back on my word and give you the satisfaction. ;)


There is no Bigfoot but there are bizarre Bigfoot believers. It's all there is to check out. Speaking of odd... you were the leader of the largest pro-Bigfoot forum in the universe. That is supremely odd.

You may well be right, there might well be no bigfoot - I've never said there was. I have said that there is sufficient anecdotal evidence to make it worthy of investigation, and I am interested in the subject, as are you obviously. I don't find that particularly odd at all. Not everyone on BFF shares my skepticsm (and I get more skeptical each year), I can't do much about that. The make up of the forum makes it generally speaking a 'pro' forum, I can't do much about that either except do as I've always done and ask for more skeptics to post there. Skepticism is good, every 'bigfooter' should think skeptically.


That's probably Mikeyx/Ganglian calling you a Jimite. He isn't really a JREF Bigfoot skeptic. He mainly uses this forum to bash other Bigfoot believers.

Actually, quite a few people here (and elsewhere) have referred to me as protecting the MRP guys, when in fact, it was me that re-opened the thread on BFF, and me that fell out with the MRP guys over it.
 
One thing I have noticed is that some folks over there really tend to take any sort of criticism quite personally. I think kitakaze really avoids making ad hom remarks. But that distinction is lost on many of them. Their identities are so wrapped up in the whole bf/Patterson/Gimlin thing that a criticism of any part of it... their ideas, their experiences, their activities, Bob Gimlin, etc,...becomes a personal "insult,' as one poster put it.

I'm glad the Victoria authorities are looking into it. It's too bad it has to come to that.
 
Here they are again, Paul.


e62a6c9c.gif
5a87593c.gif



If it is true that no accounts were ever deleted (I think you said this) then the people who opened these two accounts still have accounts on BFF. They must have switched their own names to something else. But then we should be able to find out who they are by looking at the "Display name history", right?
 
Here they are again, Paul.


[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/e62a6c9c.gif[/qimg] [qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/5a87593c.gif[/qimg]


If it is true that no accounts were ever deleted (I think you said this) then the people who opened these two accounts still have accounts on BFF. They must have switched their own names to something else. But then we should be able to find out who they are by looking at the "Display name history", right?


I'm not sure what your problem with the 'loyaljimite' user is - it isn't Jim F. after all. Would there be a problem with registering here as 'loyalwilliamite' if your friends had been nicknamed as such? Of course not, so I'm not going to start investigating users who select usernames declaring their friendship with Jim.


I agree, looking at 'Display Name History' would reveal that, but there are 400+ accounts, and I woudl have to look at each one in turn and view the display name history - I don't have that sort of time, I have a business to run and real work to do.

I have searched again - there is no makaya username or display name currently in the system, and yes, I have not deleted a user with such a name.

I wonder if that display you posted includes 'validating' members? If they don't 'email validate' correctly after a few days, the software automatically purges them from the system.*

I can't explain it, sorry.




*nope, that doesn't work, i've just tested it.
 
Last edited:
It looks like the name change reveal feature does work...

[qimg]http://i179.photobucket.com/albums/w310/william_parcher/79a0c47a.gif[/qimg]

I guess Teresa cannot decide who she wants to be? Can I change my name to Paul Vella? Then I would be really cool. :D
 
Here we go...

02868d94.gif


7b4e1595.gif



Some others you might be interested in. Keep in mind that Huntster created a sockpuppet on JREF and was banned here "twice". He might make a sock at the new BFF...


ad978268.gif


4d82e0e8.gif



Pay some attention to this one. I felt pretty confident that pnwskookum was a makaya325 sockpuppet on the old BFF. Odor of rat here.

5e815f8f.gif


9d160da3.gif


Now go back and look at the dates/times of the name changes. Mak to lightbright and pnwskookum to eddiemunster happen within one minute of each other. And look there are other changes made in a short timespan. Rats from a sinking ship?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom